狠狠撸

狠狠撸Share a Scribd company logo
3
Most read
What indicators do
The mediation of measures in the Walloon regional sustainable
development governance
Louis Florin
FASOS - ESST
March, 11th 2016
Outline
I. Background
II. Research question and objectives
III. Theoretical framework
IV. Methodology: data gathering and analysis
V. Possible obstacles and limitations
VI. Relevance of the proposal and positioning vis-à-vis existing research and
literature
I. Background
? Sustainable Development Indicators (SDI) as innovation in policy-instruments
? Grounded in the rise of the concept of sustainable development and New Public
Management
? New sources of official statistics: decentralization and globalization
? Initiative in Wallonia
? Regional Sustainable Development Strategy
? Plan Marshall 2.vert
? Mandate the IWEPS for the production of indicators for monitoring and guiding
II. Research question and objectives
? How is the concept of sustainable development materialized into indicators
and how is their authority constructed ?
? How are the indicators produced ?
? How is the product of this work staged ?
? Side-questions
? Is the “technological mediation” theoretical framework relevant to study policy
instruments and, more specifically, indicators ?
? How do statisticians perceive and “resolve” the paradox of scientific authority ?
III. Theoretical framework
? Peter-Paul Verbeek’s account on technological mediation as
the main source
? Dramaturgical perspective on scientific advise (Hilgartner)
? Backstage: Quantification procedures and conventions
? Frontstage: The statistical argument in public
? Paradox of scientific authority
? Governance through indicators (reflexive, informational, …)
What indicators do: thesis proposal
? Case study: trying to move from the local perspective to some generalization
? This can be done by comparing with some other projects (Limburg, Nord-Pas-De-
Calais)
? ANT approach
? Following the actors, the network and the translations around the project
? Studying the agency of indicators
? Same vocabulary for statisticians, lay people or civil servants
? Begin borderless and in a holistic perspective
? In the end all the data will be sorted to connect with the theoretical frame
IV. Methodology: Data gathering and
analysis
IV. Methodology: Data gathering and
analysis
? Sources
? Textual:
? IWEPS’ working papers
? Walloon Government policy documents
? IWEPS’ press release
? Press articles
? Interviews:
? IWEPS statisticians and researchers from the project
? Indicators user’s committee
? Administration and government representatives
? Other experts
V. Possible obstacles and limitations
? Only 2 indicators out of 5 already usable
? The regional sustainable development strategy was developed in the previous
legislature
? The theoretical framework might not be relevant
VI. Relevance and positioning
? Going beyond the managerial approach of “What gets measured gets done”…
? Overcoming the idea of new indicators as a technical fix (deterministic)
? Going beyond the focus on where to look that black-box the policy instrument
(indicator)
? … But also understanding the politics of such instruments
? Not only a technical account
? Applying the “technological mediation” framework to policy instruments and,
more specifically, indicators
? Adding an STS point of view to the literature on ISD and the specific case of
Wallonia
Ad

Recommended

convergence of technologies
convergence of technologies
deepinder07
?
Collaborative ICT Development - Empowerment Technologies
Collaborative ICT Development - Empowerment Technologies
Mark Jhon Oxillo
?
History of ICt in the Philippines.ppt
History of ICt in the Philippines.ppt
YhanPuig
?
The World of ICT
The World of ICT
pbiappsuny2019
?
Information Assurance And Security - Chapter 1 - Lesson 2
Information Assurance And Security - Chapter 1 - Lesson 2
MLG College of Learning, Inc
?
Economics of Technology
Economics of Technology
OntarioEast
?
What is ICT?
What is ICT?
ranazhafiradewi
?
Technological convergence
Technological convergence
ShibZ95
?
The Role of IT for Social Change
The Role of IT for Social Change
Netcetera
?
Uses of ICT in daily lives.pptx
Uses of ICT in daily lives.pptx
DeanofInstructionCTU
?
Meaning and concept of ict
Meaning and concept of ict
Suresh Kumar
?
Internet Threats
Internet Threats
Leelet1121
?
Maker culture and education
Maker culture and education
Clifford Choy
?
History and Introduction to Information and Communication Technology
History and Introduction to Information and Communication Technology
Faraz Ahmed
?
Visual information-and-media
Visual information-and-media
KristinaMangila
?
Research Paper Technology
Research Paper Technology
Ximme Naranjo
?
EmpTech Lesson 13-Planning and Conceptualizing Social Advocacy.pdf
EmpTech Lesson 13-Planning and Conceptualizing Social Advocacy.pdf
liera silvan
?
Materials Generators Hand-outs
Materials Generators Hand-outs
Ada Marie Tayao
?
ICT IN EDUCATION PRESENTATION
ICT IN EDUCATION PRESENTATION
Lydia Folaranmi
?
Educational trends for 2020
Educational trends for 2020
SathyaRaj73
?
Ethics of technology
Ethics of technology
Arsalan Humayun
?
Presentation of the revised water governance indicator framework, OECD
Presentation of the revised water governance indicator framework, OECD
OECD Governance
?
IAOS 2018 - Science policy interface framework for SDGs implementation, A. Miola
IAOS 2018 - Science policy interface framework for SDGs implementation, A. Miola
StatsCommunications
?
Sustainability development indicators now and in the future, Jari Lyytim?ki, ...
Sustainability development indicators now and in the future, Jari Lyytim?ki, ...
Tilastokeskus
?
Environmental Progress in the EU
Environmental Progress in the EU
Iwl Pcu
?
Stakeholder consultation on water governance indicators oecd secretariat
Stakeholder consultation on water governance indicators oecd secretariat
OECD Governance
?
Measuring Progress: Indicators, Data Sources and Assessment | Laszlo Pinter, ...
Measuring Progress: Indicators, Data Sources and Assessment | Laszlo Pinter, ...
NAP Global Network
?
Water Governance Indicators
Water Governance Indicators
OECD Governance
?
Methods for measuring citizen-science impact
Methods for measuring citizen-science impact
Luigi Ceccaroni
?
Statistics and indicators for the post-2015 development agenda
Statistics and indicators for the post-2015 development agenda
Department of Economic and Social Affairs (UN DESA)
?

More Related Content

What's hot (13)

The Role of IT for Social Change
The Role of IT for Social Change
Netcetera
?
Uses of ICT in daily lives.pptx
Uses of ICT in daily lives.pptx
DeanofInstructionCTU
?
Meaning and concept of ict
Meaning and concept of ict
Suresh Kumar
?
Internet Threats
Internet Threats
Leelet1121
?
Maker culture and education
Maker culture and education
Clifford Choy
?
History and Introduction to Information and Communication Technology
History and Introduction to Information and Communication Technology
Faraz Ahmed
?
Visual information-and-media
Visual information-and-media
KristinaMangila
?
Research Paper Technology
Research Paper Technology
Ximme Naranjo
?
EmpTech Lesson 13-Planning and Conceptualizing Social Advocacy.pdf
EmpTech Lesson 13-Planning and Conceptualizing Social Advocacy.pdf
liera silvan
?
Materials Generators Hand-outs
Materials Generators Hand-outs
Ada Marie Tayao
?
ICT IN EDUCATION PRESENTATION
ICT IN EDUCATION PRESENTATION
Lydia Folaranmi
?
Educational trends for 2020
Educational trends for 2020
SathyaRaj73
?
Ethics of technology
Ethics of technology
Arsalan Humayun
?
The Role of IT for Social Change
The Role of IT for Social Change
Netcetera
?
Meaning and concept of ict
Meaning and concept of ict
Suresh Kumar
?
Maker culture and education
Maker culture and education
Clifford Choy
?
History and Introduction to Information and Communication Technology
History and Introduction to Information and Communication Technology
Faraz Ahmed
?
Visual information-and-media
Visual information-and-media
KristinaMangila
?
Research Paper Technology
Research Paper Technology
Ximme Naranjo
?
EmpTech Lesson 13-Planning and Conceptualizing Social Advocacy.pdf
EmpTech Lesson 13-Planning and Conceptualizing Social Advocacy.pdf
liera silvan
?
Materials Generators Hand-outs
Materials Generators Hand-outs
Ada Marie Tayao
?
ICT IN EDUCATION PRESENTATION
ICT IN EDUCATION PRESENTATION
Lydia Folaranmi
?
Educational trends for 2020
Educational trends for 2020
SathyaRaj73
?

Similar to What indicators do: thesis proposal (20)

Presentation of the revised water governance indicator framework, OECD
Presentation of the revised water governance indicator framework, OECD
OECD Governance
?
IAOS 2018 - Science policy interface framework for SDGs implementation, A. Miola
IAOS 2018 - Science policy interface framework for SDGs implementation, A. Miola
StatsCommunications
?
Sustainability development indicators now and in the future, Jari Lyytim?ki, ...
Sustainability development indicators now and in the future, Jari Lyytim?ki, ...
Tilastokeskus
?
Environmental Progress in the EU
Environmental Progress in the EU
Iwl Pcu
?
Stakeholder consultation on water governance indicators oecd secretariat
Stakeholder consultation on water governance indicators oecd secretariat
OECD Governance
?
Measuring Progress: Indicators, Data Sources and Assessment | Laszlo Pinter, ...
Measuring Progress: Indicators, Data Sources and Assessment | Laszlo Pinter, ...
NAP Global Network
?
Water Governance Indicators
Water Governance Indicators
OECD Governance
?
Methods for measuring citizen-science impact
Methods for measuring citizen-science impact
Luigi Ceccaroni
?
Statistics and indicators for the post-2015 development agenda
Statistics and indicators for the post-2015 development agenda
Department of Economic and Social Affairs (UN DESA)
?
Measuring Progress: Indicators, data sources and assessment | Laszlo Pinter, ...
Measuring Progress: Indicators, data sources and assessment | Laszlo Pinter, ...
NAP Global Network
?
International Organization for Standardization
International Organization for Standardization
roweenchico
?
Emcis 2015 - Policy Impact Evaluation Through Prosperity Metrics and Open Dat...
Emcis 2015 - Policy Impact Evaluation Through Prosperity Metrics and Open Dat...
PolicyCompass
?
Sustainable development indicators: food for thought or efficient tools for d...
Sustainable development indicators: food for thought or efficient tools for d...
Jari Lyytim?ki
?
M. Pratesi, Workshop of the advisory committee on statistical methods - Rome,...
M. Pratesi, Workshop of the advisory committee on statistical methods - Rome,...
Istituto nazionale di statistica
?
WS2011_libro degli abstract
WS2011_libro degli abstract
Gruppo Valorizzazione delle Statistiche Pubbliche
?
Sustainability indicator in the world
Sustainability indicator in the world
Silverio Jr. Magallon
?
Civil society indicators for the Sustainable Development Goals
Civil society indicators for the Sustainable Development Goals
Céline Charveriat
?
Statistics for-effective-regional-policy
Statistics for-effective-regional-policy
OECD Governance
?
02 laszlo singapore sdg_is
02 laszlo singapore sdg_is
Grazyna Pulawska
?
B08 A44s 59 Diapo Minguez En
B08 A44s 59 Diapo Minguez En
Territorial Intelligence
?
Presentation of the revised water governance indicator framework, OECD
Presentation of the revised water governance indicator framework, OECD
OECD Governance
?
IAOS 2018 - Science policy interface framework for SDGs implementation, A. Miola
IAOS 2018 - Science policy interface framework for SDGs implementation, A. Miola
StatsCommunications
?
Sustainability development indicators now and in the future, Jari Lyytim?ki, ...
Sustainability development indicators now and in the future, Jari Lyytim?ki, ...
Tilastokeskus
?
Environmental Progress in the EU
Environmental Progress in the EU
Iwl Pcu
?
Stakeholder consultation on water governance indicators oecd secretariat
Stakeholder consultation on water governance indicators oecd secretariat
OECD Governance
?
Measuring Progress: Indicators, Data Sources and Assessment | Laszlo Pinter, ...
Measuring Progress: Indicators, Data Sources and Assessment | Laszlo Pinter, ...
NAP Global Network
?
Water Governance Indicators
Water Governance Indicators
OECD Governance
?
Methods for measuring citizen-science impact
Methods for measuring citizen-science impact
Luigi Ceccaroni
?
Measuring Progress: Indicators, data sources and assessment | Laszlo Pinter, ...
Measuring Progress: Indicators, data sources and assessment | Laszlo Pinter, ...
NAP Global Network
?
International Organization for Standardization
International Organization for Standardization
roweenchico
?
Emcis 2015 - Policy Impact Evaluation Through Prosperity Metrics and Open Dat...
Emcis 2015 - Policy Impact Evaluation Through Prosperity Metrics and Open Dat...
PolicyCompass
?
Sustainable development indicators: food for thought or efficient tools for d...
Sustainable development indicators: food for thought or efficient tools for d...
Jari Lyytim?ki
?
M. Pratesi, Workshop of the advisory committee on statistical methods - Rome,...
M. Pratesi, Workshop of the advisory committee on statistical methods - Rome,...
Istituto nazionale di statistica
?
Civil society indicators for the Sustainable Development Goals
Civil society indicators for the Sustainable Development Goals
Céline Charveriat
?
Statistics for-effective-regional-policy
Statistics for-effective-regional-policy
OECD Governance
?
Ad

Recently uploaded (20)

Trusted Site To Buy Verified Payoneer Accounts In This Time.pdf
Trusted Site To Buy Verified Payoneer Accounts In This Time.pdf
https://top5starshop.com/product/buy-verified-cash-app-accounts/
?
复刻加拿大硕士毕业证温莎大学文凭证书鲍奥学生卡
复刻加拿大硕士毕业证温莎大学文凭证书鲍奥学生卡
taqyed
?
The Social Innovation Playbook: Foundation of Social & Behaviour change
The Social Innovation Playbook: Foundation of Social & Behaviour change
archana400846
?
combinepdf1-250218074557- cb23d7f4.pdf
combinepdf1-250218074557- cb23d7f4.pdf
bsarashka
?
voting by M. Salman khan (Wah Engineering college).ppt
voting by M. Salman khan (Wah Engineering college).ppt
mrsinankhan01
?
Government at a Glance 2025 Launch Presentation.pdf
Government at a Glance 2025 Launch Presentation.pdf
OECD Governance
?
加拿大爱德华王子岛大学成绩单范本调鲍笔贰滨毕业完成信鲍笔贰滨成绩单防伪皑100%复刻
加拿大爱德华王子岛大学成绩单范本调鲍笔贰滨毕业完成信鲍笔贰滨成绩单防伪皑100%复刻
Taqyea
?
一比一原版(贬诲惭毕业证)斯图加特媒体学院毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(贬诲惭毕业证)斯图加特媒体学院毕业证如何办理
taqyed
?
Competency of Interactive Diplomacy.pdf.pdf
Competency of Interactive Diplomacy.pdf.pdf
giselladarfian
?
Texas Water Association: 89th Legislative Recap
Texas Water Association: 89th Legislative Recap
Texas Water Association
?
When History Became Affordable: Abhay Bhutada Foundation and the Shivsrushti ...
When History Became Affordable: Abhay Bhutada Foundation and the Shivsrushti ...
Lokesh Agrawal
?
定制鲍奥翱蹿蹿别谤英国华威大学毕业证范本,鲍奥学历证书
定制鲍奥翱蹿蹿别谤英国华威大学毕业证范本,鲍奥学历证书
taqyed
?
Citizen Perception Survey (CPS) 2024 | Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics
Citizen Perception Survey (CPS) 2024 | Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics
Razin Mustafiz
?
2 Regulatory Landscape.pptxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
2 Regulatory Landscape.pptxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
MohamadIsmail57
?
Shivsrushti’s Special Summer Access Made Possible by Abhay Bhutada Foundation
Shivsrushti’s Special Summer Access Made Possible by Abhay Bhutada Foundation
Lokesh Agrawal
?
Abhay Bhutada Foundation Enables ?50 Entry to Shivsrushti
Abhay Bhutada Foundation Enables ?50 Entry to Shivsrushti
Swapnil Pednekar
?
Rs 50 Entry at Shivsrushti Ongoing Till July 15, Thanks to Abhay Bhutada Foun...
Rs 50 Entry at Shivsrushti Ongoing Till July 15, Thanks to Abhay Bhutada Foun...
Swapnil Pednekar
?
The Environmental Cost of Grand Celebrations
The Environmental Cost of Grand Celebrations
Harsh Mishra
?
Step 7_Investment Programming Invest.pptx
Step 7_Investment Programming Invest.pptx
danilynolinares
?
Individual presentation (HIT) MPH 09.pdf
Individual presentation (HIT) MPH 09.pdf
AhmedAbdirizak3
?
复刻加拿大硕士毕业证温莎大学文凭证书鲍奥学生卡
复刻加拿大硕士毕业证温莎大学文凭证书鲍奥学生卡
taqyed
?
The Social Innovation Playbook: Foundation of Social & Behaviour change
The Social Innovation Playbook: Foundation of Social & Behaviour change
archana400846
?
combinepdf1-250218074557- cb23d7f4.pdf
combinepdf1-250218074557- cb23d7f4.pdf
bsarashka
?
voting by M. Salman khan (Wah Engineering college).ppt
voting by M. Salman khan (Wah Engineering college).ppt
mrsinankhan01
?
Government at a Glance 2025 Launch Presentation.pdf
Government at a Glance 2025 Launch Presentation.pdf
OECD Governance
?
加拿大爱德华王子岛大学成绩单范本调鲍笔贰滨毕业完成信鲍笔贰滨成绩单防伪皑100%复刻
加拿大爱德华王子岛大学成绩单范本调鲍笔贰滨毕业完成信鲍笔贰滨成绩单防伪皑100%复刻
Taqyea
?
一比一原版(贬诲惭毕业证)斯图加特媒体学院毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(贬诲惭毕业证)斯图加特媒体学院毕业证如何办理
taqyed
?
Competency of Interactive Diplomacy.pdf.pdf
Competency of Interactive Diplomacy.pdf.pdf
giselladarfian
?
Texas Water Association: 89th Legislative Recap
Texas Water Association: 89th Legislative Recap
Texas Water Association
?
When History Became Affordable: Abhay Bhutada Foundation and the Shivsrushti ...
When History Became Affordable: Abhay Bhutada Foundation and the Shivsrushti ...
Lokesh Agrawal
?
定制鲍奥翱蹿蹿别谤英国华威大学毕业证范本,鲍奥学历证书
定制鲍奥翱蹿蹿别谤英国华威大学毕业证范本,鲍奥学历证书
taqyed
?
Citizen Perception Survey (CPS) 2024 | Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics
Citizen Perception Survey (CPS) 2024 | Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics
Razin Mustafiz
?
2 Regulatory Landscape.pptxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
2 Regulatory Landscape.pptxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
MohamadIsmail57
?
Shivsrushti’s Special Summer Access Made Possible by Abhay Bhutada Foundation
Shivsrushti’s Special Summer Access Made Possible by Abhay Bhutada Foundation
Lokesh Agrawal
?
Abhay Bhutada Foundation Enables ?50 Entry to Shivsrushti
Abhay Bhutada Foundation Enables ?50 Entry to Shivsrushti
Swapnil Pednekar
?
Rs 50 Entry at Shivsrushti Ongoing Till July 15, Thanks to Abhay Bhutada Foun...
Rs 50 Entry at Shivsrushti Ongoing Till July 15, Thanks to Abhay Bhutada Foun...
Swapnil Pednekar
?
The Environmental Cost of Grand Celebrations
The Environmental Cost of Grand Celebrations
Harsh Mishra
?
Step 7_Investment Programming Invest.pptx
Step 7_Investment Programming Invest.pptx
danilynolinares
?
Individual presentation (HIT) MPH 09.pdf
Individual presentation (HIT) MPH 09.pdf
AhmedAbdirizak3
?
Ad

What indicators do: thesis proposal

  • 1. What indicators do The mediation of measures in the Walloon regional sustainable development governance Louis Florin FASOS - ESST March, 11th 2016
  • 2. Outline I. Background II. Research question and objectives III. Theoretical framework IV. Methodology: data gathering and analysis V. Possible obstacles and limitations VI. Relevance of the proposal and positioning vis-à-vis existing research and literature
  • 3. I. Background ? Sustainable Development Indicators (SDI) as innovation in policy-instruments ? Grounded in the rise of the concept of sustainable development and New Public Management ? New sources of official statistics: decentralization and globalization ? Initiative in Wallonia ? Regional Sustainable Development Strategy ? Plan Marshall 2.vert ? Mandate the IWEPS for the production of indicators for monitoring and guiding
  • 4. II. Research question and objectives ? How is the concept of sustainable development materialized into indicators and how is their authority constructed ? ? How are the indicators produced ? ? How is the product of this work staged ? ? Side-questions ? Is the “technological mediation” theoretical framework relevant to study policy instruments and, more specifically, indicators ? ? How do statisticians perceive and “resolve” the paradox of scientific authority ?
  • 5. III. Theoretical framework ? Peter-Paul Verbeek’s account on technological mediation as the main source ? Dramaturgical perspective on scientific advise (Hilgartner) ? Backstage: Quantification procedures and conventions ? Frontstage: The statistical argument in public ? Paradox of scientific authority ? Governance through indicators (reflexive, informational, …)
  • 7. ? Case study: trying to move from the local perspective to some generalization ? This can be done by comparing with some other projects (Limburg, Nord-Pas-De- Calais) ? ANT approach ? Following the actors, the network and the translations around the project ? Studying the agency of indicators ? Same vocabulary for statisticians, lay people or civil servants ? Begin borderless and in a holistic perspective ? In the end all the data will be sorted to connect with the theoretical frame IV. Methodology: Data gathering and analysis
  • 8. IV. Methodology: Data gathering and analysis ? Sources ? Textual: ? IWEPS’ working papers ? Walloon Government policy documents ? IWEPS’ press release ? Press articles ? Interviews: ? IWEPS statisticians and researchers from the project ? Indicators user’s committee ? Administration and government representatives ? Other experts
  • 9. V. Possible obstacles and limitations ? Only 2 indicators out of 5 already usable ? The regional sustainable development strategy was developed in the previous legislature ? The theoretical framework might not be relevant
  • 10. VI. Relevance and positioning ? Going beyond the managerial approach of “What gets measured gets done”… ? Overcoming the idea of new indicators as a technical fix (deterministic) ? Going beyond the focus on where to look that black-box the policy instrument (indicator) ? … But also understanding the politics of such instruments ? Not only a technical account ? Applying the “technological mediation” framework to policy instruments and, more specifically, indicators ? Adding an STS point of view to the literature on ISD and the specific case of Wallonia