際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
Lets play 
SPOT THE 
ACADEMIC 
RESOURCE! 
Are you ready? 
Then lets begin.
For each resource presented, review all the 
information available. 
Would you count this as an 
academic source 
for an assignment? 
Why or why not?
Article found in Discovery
Article found in Discovery 
Verdict: 
YES!
Article found in Discovery 
Abstract: Mainstream media images of female beauty disproportionately feature slim, White women. 
Although Black American women typically report higher self and body esteem, and lower internalization of 
media ideals than White women, the extent to which specific media affinities are implicated in Black 
women's body image concerns remain unclear. The present survey study (n = 141) examines how young 
women's views of self and of female media personae predict body consciousness. Black women reported 
lower body surveillance, concern with others' approval, and wishful identification with a favorite media 
persona than White women. However, results of regression analyses showed that increased wishful 
identification with and decreased perceived similarity to favorite female media personae predicted body 
surveillance for all women (controlling for body mass index and self-esteem). Others' approval concerns 
predicted body concerns after accounting for all other study variables. Key ethnic distinctions did emerge 
as a function of body type and ethnicity of media personae. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2013 APA, all 
rights reserved) (journal abstract)
Article found in Discovery 
Abstract: Mainstream media images of female beauty disproportionately feature slim, White women. 
Although Black American women typically report higher self and body esteem, and lower internalization of 
media ideals than White women, the extent to which specific media affinities are implicated in Black 
women's body image concerns remain unclear. The present survey study (n = 141) examines how young 
women's views of self and of female media personae predict body consciousness. Black women reported 
lower body surveillance, concern with others' approval, and wishful identification with a favorite media 
persona than White women. However, results of regression analyses showed that increased wishful 
identification with and decreased perceived similarity to favorite female media personae predicted body 
surveillance for all women (controlling for body mass index and self-esteem). Others' approval concerns 
predicted body concerns after accounting for all other study variables. Key ethnic distinctions did emerge 
as a function of body type and ethnicity of media personae. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2013 APA, all 
rights reserved) (journal abstract) 
Verdict: 
YES!
Article found in Discovery
Article found in Discovery 
Includes images. 
Verdict: 
NO!
Book found in Library catalogue
Book found in Library catalogue 
Verdict: 
YES!
Book found in Discovery
Book found in Discovery 
Boring 
cover, 
no images 
Verdict: 
Probably yescheck the 
language/intended 
audience/publisher.
Website found online (Google)
Website found online (Google) 
Not an academic or research institution 
Who wrote this? Uncertain authorship. 
Language seems 
written for a 
popular audience. 
Verdict: NO! 
But maybe find some of 
these references.
KEYS TO DETERMINING AN ACADEMIC SOURCE 
 Where did you find it? A Library database or the open 
web? 
 What is the source  a peer-reviewed journal, an 
academic journal, a newspaper, a magazine, or a 
website? 
 Does it have references (citations)? 
 Who is the author? What are their credentials? 
 What is the writing style? Does the writing read like it 
was written for a scholarly, popular or business 
audience? 
 What is the purpose of the article  to make an 
argument/propose a new theory or to give general 
background information about the topic? Can you find a 
thesis statement?

More Related Content

Similar to Academic or Not? (16)

Participants
ParticipantsParticipants
Participants
Beth Sockman
Advanced Placement Psychology Research Methods PowerPoint Part 2
Advanced Placement Psychology Research Methods PowerPoint Part 2Advanced Placement Psychology Research Methods PowerPoint Part 2
Advanced Placement Psychology Research Methods PowerPoint Part 2
jasonsinning
Social identity theory & MLK
Social identity theory & MLKSocial identity theory & MLK
Social identity theory & MLK
abonica
Art 101 week 5 dq
Art 101 week 5 dqArt 101 week 5 dq
Art 101 week 5 dq
vibmorrtapink1987
Interviewing ethnic minorities
Interviewing ethnic minoritiesInterviewing ethnic minorities
Interviewing ethnic minorities
Mark Boukes (University of Amsterdam)
How to diversify science and why
How to diversify science and why How to diversify science and why
How to diversify science and why
JoanStrassmann
Critique Essay Example
Critique Essay ExampleCritique Essay Example
Critique Essay Example
Paper Writing Service College
SENIOR THESIS RMAS
SENIOR THESIS RMASSENIOR THESIS RMAS
SENIOR THESIS RMAS
Ashley Rodriguez Delgadillo
Speech 101 2016/17
Speech 101 2016/17Speech 101 2016/17
Speech 101 2016/17
elizabethfox
05chap ppt
05chap ppt05chap ppt
05chap ppt
stanbridge
Writing a Review of Related Literature.pptx
Writing a Review of Related Literature.pptxWriting a Review of Related Literature.pptx
Writing a Review of Related Literature.pptx
BarzZoreksky
RESEARCH IN THE WORKPLACE Research in the workplace solves a.docx
RESEARCH IN THE WORKPLACE Research in the workplace solves a.docxRESEARCH IN THE WORKPLACE Research in the workplace solves a.docx
RESEARCH IN THE WORKPLACE Research in the workplace solves a.docx
WilheminaRossi174
Research Methods Spring 2020 Research proposal Points 0.docx
Research Methods Spring 2020  Research proposal Points 0.docxResearch Methods Spring 2020  Research proposal Points 0.docx
Research Methods Spring 2020 Research proposal Points 0.docx
verad6
Research Methods Spring 2020 Research proposal Points 0.docx
Research Methods Spring 2020  Research proposal Points 0.docxResearch Methods Spring 2020  Research proposal Points 0.docx
Research Methods Spring 2020 Research proposal Points 0.docx
debishakespeare
Running head INFLUENCE OF THE MEDIA ON BODY IMAGE1INFLUENCE .docx
Running head INFLUENCE OF THE MEDIA ON BODY IMAGE1INFLUENCE .docxRunning head INFLUENCE OF THE MEDIA ON BODY IMAGE1INFLUENCE .docx
Running head INFLUENCE OF THE MEDIA ON BODY IMAGE1INFLUENCE .docx
charisellington63520
Persuasive Essay Topics For High School.pdf
Persuasive Essay Topics For High School.pdfPersuasive Essay Topics For High School.pdf
Persuasive Essay Topics For High School.pdf
Lynn Bennett
Advanced Placement Psychology Research Methods PowerPoint Part 2
Advanced Placement Psychology Research Methods PowerPoint Part 2Advanced Placement Psychology Research Methods PowerPoint Part 2
Advanced Placement Psychology Research Methods PowerPoint Part 2
jasonsinning
Social identity theory & MLK
Social identity theory & MLKSocial identity theory & MLK
Social identity theory & MLK
abonica
How to diversify science and why
How to diversify science and why How to diversify science and why
How to diversify science and why
JoanStrassmann
Speech 101 2016/17
Speech 101 2016/17Speech 101 2016/17
Speech 101 2016/17
elizabethfox
Writing a Review of Related Literature.pptx
Writing a Review of Related Literature.pptxWriting a Review of Related Literature.pptx
Writing a Review of Related Literature.pptx
BarzZoreksky
RESEARCH IN THE WORKPLACE Research in the workplace solves a.docx
RESEARCH IN THE WORKPLACE Research in the workplace solves a.docxRESEARCH IN THE WORKPLACE Research in the workplace solves a.docx
RESEARCH IN THE WORKPLACE Research in the workplace solves a.docx
WilheminaRossi174
Research Methods Spring 2020 Research proposal Points 0.docx
Research Methods Spring 2020  Research proposal Points 0.docxResearch Methods Spring 2020  Research proposal Points 0.docx
Research Methods Spring 2020 Research proposal Points 0.docx
verad6
Research Methods Spring 2020 Research proposal Points 0.docx
Research Methods Spring 2020  Research proposal Points 0.docxResearch Methods Spring 2020  Research proposal Points 0.docx
Research Methods Spring 2020 Research proposal Points 0.docx
debishakespeare
Running head INFLUENCE OF THE MEDIA ON BODY IMAGE1INFLUENCE .docx
Running head INFLUENCE OF THE MEDIA ON BODY IMAGE1INFLUENCE .docxRunning head INFLUENCE OF THE MEDIA ON BODY IMAGE1INFLUENCE .docx
Running head INFLUENCE OF THE MEDIA ON BODY IMAGE1INFLUENCE .docx
charisellington63520
Persuasive Essay Topics For High School.pdf
Persuasive Essay Topics For High School.pdfPersuasive Essay Topics For High School.pdf
Persuasive Essay Topics For High School.pdf
Lynn Bennett

Recently uploaded (20)

A PPT Presentation on The Princess and the God: A tale of ancient India by A...
A PPT Presentation on The Princess and the God: A tale of ancient India  by A...A PPT Presentation on The Princess and the God: A tale of ancient India  by A...
A PPT Presentation on The Princess and the God: A tale of ancient India by A...
Beena E S
How to Manage Putaway Rule in Odoo 17 Inventory
How to Manage Putaway Rule in Odoo 17 InventoryHow to Manage Putaway Rule in Odoo 17 Inventory
How to Manage Putaway Rule in Odoo 17 Inventory
Celine George
FESTIVAL: SINULOG & THINGYAN-LESSON 4.pptx
FESTIVAL: SINULOG & THINGYAN-LESSON 4.pptxFESTIVAL: SINULOG & THINGYAN-LESSON 4.pptx
FESTIVAL: SINULOG & THINGYAN-LESSON 4.pptx
DanmarieMuli1
The basics of sentences session 6pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 6pptx.pptxThe basics of sentences session 6pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 6pptx.pptx
heathfieldcps1
The Story Behind the Abney Park Restoration Project by Tom Walker
The Story Behind the Abney Park Restoration Project by Tom WalkerThe Story Behind the Abney Park Restoration Project by Tom Walker
The Story Behind the Abney Park Restoration Project by Tom Walker
History of Stoke Newington
How to attach file using upload button Odoo 18
How to attach file using upload button Odoo 18How to attach file using upload button Odoo 18
How to attach file using upload button Odoo 18
Celine George
Reordering Rules in Odoo 17 Inventory - Odoo 際際滷s
Reordering Rules in Odoo 17 Inventory - Odoo 際際滷sReordering Rules in Odoo 17 Inventory - Odoo 際際滷s
Reordering Rules in Odoo 17 Inventory - Odoo 際際滷s
Celine George
CBSE Arabic Grammar - Class 10 ppt.pptx
CBSE Arabic Grammar - Class 10   ppt.pptxCBSE Arabic Grammar - Class 10   ppt.pptx
CBSE Arabic Grammar - Class 10 ppt.pptx
suhail849886
APM People Interest Network Conference - Tim Lyons - The neurological levels ...
APM People Interest Network Conference - Tim Lyons - The neurological levels ...APM People Interest Network Conference - Tim Lyons - The neurological levels ...
APM People Interest Network Conference - Tim Lyons - The neurological levels ...
Association for Project Management
Modeling-Simple-Equation-Using-Bar-Models.pptx
Modeling-Simple-Equation-Using-Bar-Models.pptxModeling-Simple-Equation-Using-Bar-Models.pptx
Modeling-Simple-Equation-Using-Bar-Models.pptx
maribethlacno2
How to Setup WhatsApp in Odoo 17 - Odoo 際際滷s
How to Setup WhatsApp in Odoo 17 - Odoo 際際滷sHow to Setup WhatsApp in Odoo 17 - Odoo 際際滷s
How to Setup WhatsApp in Odoo 17 - Odoo 際際滷s
Celine George
Essentials of a Good PMO, presented by Aalok Sonawala
Essentials of a Good PMO, presented by Aalok SonawalaEssentials of a Good PMO, presented by Aalok Sonawala
Essentials of a Good PMO, presented by Aalok Sonawala
Association for Project Management
EDL 290F Week 3 - Mountaintop Views (2025).pdf
EDL 290F Week 3  - Mountaintop Views (2025).pdfEDL 290F Week 3  - Mountaintop Views (2025).pdf
EDL 290F Week 3 - Mountaintop Views (2025).pdf
Liz Walsh-Trevino
PUBH1000 Module 3: Public Health Systems
PUBH1000 Module 3: Public Health SystemsPUBH1000 Module 3: Public Health Systems
PUBH1000 Module 3: Public Health Systems
Jonathan Hallett
QuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online How to Make the Move
QuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online  How to Make the MoveQuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online  How to Make the Move
QuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online How to Make the Move
TechSoup
APM People Interest Network Conference - Oliver Randall & David Bovis - Own Y...
APM People Interest Network Conference - Oliver Randall & David Bovis - Own Y...APM People Interest Network Conference - Oliver Randall & David Bovis - Own Y...
APM People Interest Network Conference - Oliver Randall & David Bovis - Own Y...
Association for Project Management
TLE 7 - 3rd Topic - Hand Tools, Power Tools, Instruments, and Equipment Used ...
TLE 7 - 3rd Topic - Hand Tools, Power Tools, Instruments, and Equipment Used ...TLE 7 - 3rd Topic - Hand Tools, Power Tools, Instruments, and Equipment Used ...
TLE 7 - 3rd Topic - Hand Tools, Power Tools, Instruments, and Equipment Used ...
RizaBedayo
Rass MELAI : an Internet MELA Quiz Prelims - El Dorado 2025
Rass MELAI : an Internet MELA Quiz Prelims - El Dorado 2025Rass MELAI : an Internet MELA Quiz Prelims - El Dorado 2025
Rass MELAI : an Internet MELA Quiz Prelims - El Dorado 2025
Conquiztadors- the Quiz Society of Sri Venkateswara College
Research & Research Methods: Basic Concepts and Types.pptx
Research & Research Methods: Basic Concepts and Types.pptxResearch & Research Methods: Basic Concepts and Types.pptx
Research & Research Methods: Basic Concepts and Types.pptx
Dr. Sarita Anand
How to Modify Existing Web Pages in Odoo 18
How to Modify Existing Web Pages in Odoo 18How to Modify Existing Web Pages in Odoo 18
How to Modify Existing Web Pages in Odoo 18
Celine George
A PPT Presentation on The Princess and the God: A tale of ancient India by A...
A PPT Presentation on The Princess and the God: A tale of ancient India  by A...A PPT Presentation on The Princess and the God: A tale of ancient India  by A...
A PPT Presentation on The Princess and the God: A tale of ancient India by A...
Beena E S
How to Manage Putaway Rule in Odoo 17 Inventory
How to Manage Putaway Rule in Odoo 17 InventoryHow to Manage Putaway Rule in Odoo 17 Inventory
How to Manage Putaway Rule in Odoo 17 Inventory
Celine George
FESTIVAL: SINULOG & THINGYAN-LESSON 4.pptx
FESTIVAL: SINULOG & THINGYAN-LESSON 4.pptxFESTIVAL: SINULOG & THINGYAN-LESSON 4.pptx
FESTIVAL: SINULOG & THINGYAN-LESSON 4.pptx
DanmarieMuli1
The basics of sentences session 6pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 6pptx.pptxThe basics of sentences session 6pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 6pptx.pptx
heathfieldcps1
The Story Behind the Abney Park Restoration Project by Tom Walker
The Story Behind the Abney Park Restoration Project by Tom WalkerThe Story Behind the Abney Park Restoration Project by Tom Walker
The Story Behind the Abney Park Restoration Project by Tom Walker
History of Stoke Newington
How to attach file using upload button Odoo 18
How to attach file using upload button Odoo 18How to attach file using upload button Odoo 18
How to attach file using upload button Odoo 18
Celine George
Reordering Rules in Odoo 17 Inventory - Odoo 際際滷s
Reordering Rules in Odoo 17 Inventory - Odoo 際際滷sReordering Rules in Odoo 17 Inventory - Odoo 際際滷s
Reordering Rules in Odoo 17 Inventory - Odoo 際際滷s
Celine George
CBSE Arabic Grammar - Class 10 ppt.pptx
CBSE Arabic Grammar - Class 10   ppt.pptxCBSE Arabic Grammar - Class 10   ppt.pptx
CBSE Arabic Grammar - Class 10 ppt.pptx
suhail849886
APM People Interest Network Conference - Tim Lyons - The neurological levels ...
APM People Interest Network Conference - Tim Lyons - The neurological levels ...APM People Interest Network Conference - Tim Lyons - The neurological levels ...
APM People Interest Network Conference - Tim Lyons - The neurological levels ...
Association for Project Management
Modeling-Simple-Equation-Using-Bar-Models.pptx
Modeling-Simple-Equation-Using-Bar-Models.pptxModeling-Simple-Equation-Using-Bar-Models.pptx
Modeling-Simple-Equation-Using-Bar-Models.pptx
maribethlacno2
How to Setup WhatsApp in Odoo 17 - Odoo 際際滷s
How to Setup WhatsApp in Odoo 17 - Odoo 際際滷sHow to Setup WhatsApp in Odoo 17 - Odoo 際際滷s
How to Setup WhatsApp in Odoo 17 - Odoo 際際滷s
Celine George
EDL 290F Week 3 - Mountaintop Views (2025).pdf
EDL 290F Week 3  - Mountaintop Views (2025).pdfEDL 290F Week 3  - Mountaintop Views (2025).pdf
EDL 290F Week 3 - Mountaintop Views (2025).pdf
Liz Walsh-Trevino
PUBH1000 Module 3: Public Health Systems
PUBH1000 Module 3: Public Health SystemsPUBH1000 Module 3: Public Health Systems
PUBH1000 Module 3: Public Health Systems
Jonathan Hallett
QuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online How to Make the Move
QuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online  How to Make the MoveQuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online  How to Make the Move
QuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online How to Make the Move
TechSoup
APM People Interest Network Conference - Oliver Randall & David Bovis - Own Y...
APM People Interest Network Conference - Oliver Randall & David Bovis - Own Y...APM People Interest Network Conference - Oliver Randall & David Bovis - Own Y...
APM People Interest Network Conference - Oliver Randall & David Bovis - Own Y...
Association for Project Management
TLE 7 - 3rd Topic - Hand Tools, Power Tools, Instruments, and Equipment Used ...
TLE 7 - 3rd Topic - Hand Tools, Power Tools, Instruments, and Equipment Used ...TLE 7 - 3rd Topic - Hand Tools, Power Tools, Instruments, and Equipment Used ...
TLE 7 - 3rd Topic - Hand Tools, Power Tools, Instruments, and Equipment Used ...
RizaBedayo
Research & Research Methods: Basic Concepts and Types.pptx
Research & Research Methods: Basic Concepts and Types.pptxResearch & Research Methods: Basic Concepts and Types.pptx
Research & Research Methods: Basic Concepts and Types.pptx
Dr. Sarita Anand
How to Modify Existing Web Pages in Odoo 18
How to Modify Existing Web Pages in Odoo 18How to Modify Existing Web Pages in Odoo 18
How to Modify Existing Web Pages in Odoo 18
Celine George

Academic or Not?

  • 1. Lets play SPOT THE ACADEMIC RESOURCE! Are you ready? Then lets begin.
  • 2. For each resource presented, review all the information available. Would you count this as an academic source for an assignment? Why or why not?
  • 3. Article found in Discovery
  • 4. Article found in Discovery Verdict: YES!
  • 5. Article found in Discovery Abstract: Mainstream media images of female beauty disproportionately feature slim, White women. Although Black American women typically report higher self and body esteem, and lower internalization of media ideals than White women, the extent to which specific media affinities are implicated in Black women's body image concerns remain unclear. The present survey study (n = 141) examines how young women's views of self and of female media personae predict body consciousness. Black women reported lower body surveillance, concern with others' approval, and wishful identification with a favorite media persona than White women. However, results of regression analyses showed that increased wishful identification with and decreased perceived similarity to favorite female media personae predicted body surveillance for all women (controlling for body mass index and self-esteem). Others' approval concerns predicted body concerns after accounting for all other study variables. Key ethnic distinctions did emerge as a function of body type and ethnicity of media personae. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2013 APA, all rights reserved) (journal abstract)
  • 6. Article found in Discovery Abstract: Mainstream media images of female beauty disproportionately feature slim, White women. Although Black American women typically report higher self and body esteem, and lower internalization of media ideals than White women, the extent to which specific media affinities are implicated in Black women's body image concerns remain unclear. The present survey study (n = 141) examines how young women's views of self and of female media personae predict body consciousness. Black women reported lower body surveillance, concern with others' approval, and wishful identification with a favorite media persona than White women. However, results of regression analyses showed that increased wishful identification with and decreased perceived similarity to favorite female media personae predicted body surveillance for all women (controlling for body mass index and self-esteem). Others' approval concerns predicted body concerns after accounting for all other study variables. Key ethnic distinctions did emerge as a function of body type and ethnicity of media personae. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2013 APA, all rights reserved) (journal abstract) Verdict: YES!
  • 7. Article found in Discovery
  • 8. Article found in Discovery Includes images. Verdict: NO!
  • 9. Book found in Library catalogue
  • 10. Book found in Library catalogue Verdict: YES!
  • 11. Book found in Discovery
  • 12. Book found in Discovery Boring cover, no images Verdict: Probably yescheck the language/intended audience/publisher.
  • 14. Website found online (Google) Not an academic or research institution Who wrote this? Uncertain authorship. Language seems written for a popular audience. Verdict: NO! But maybe find some of these references.
  • 15. KEYS TO DETERMINING AN ACADEMIC SOURCE Where did you find it? A Library database or the open web? What is the source a peer-reviewed journal, an academic journal, a newspaper, a magazine, or a website? Does it have references (citations)? Who is the author? What are their credentials? What is the writing style? Does the writing read like it was written for a scholarly, popular or business audience? What is the purpose of the article to make an argument/propose a new theory or to give general background information about the topic? Can you find a thesis statement?

Editor's Notes

  • #2: Yes listed as academic in the db (when you click on the journal title)
  • #3: Yes listed as academic in the db (when you click on the journal title)
  • #4: Yes listed as academic in the db (when you click on the journal title)
  • #5: Yes listed as academic in the db (when you click on the journal title)
  • #6: Yes multiple authors, long title, journal title, language of abstract
  • #7: Yes multiple authors, long title, journal title, language of abstract
  • #8: No look more like social history/advocacy; no references
  • #9: No look more like social history/advocacy; no references
  • #10: No news aricle Point out language written for a popular audience
  • #11: No news aricle Point out language written for a popular audience
  • #12: No, but the original research might be. Could use the stats but this would not count for an academic resource
  • #13: No, but the original research might be. Could use the stats but this would not count for an academic resource
  • #14: No, but the original research might be. Could use the stats but this would not count for an academic resource
  • #15: No, but the original research might be. Could use the stats but this would not count for an academic resource
  • #16: Pairwork: make a list of criteria that help you determine if a source is popular or not.