ݺߣ

ݺߣShare a Scribd company logo
Compare and contrast


Ali Baba and the forty thieves and Aladdin are some very similar
folktales. But they have many differences. In this writing piece I’ll tell
you more about them.

       One similarity is, both stories are Arabian folktales. Arabian
folktales usually come from Arabia because people there made up stories
involving magic, tricky thieves, sorcery, and mythical creatures. I think
it’s very interesting that people there may be less wealthy than us but
have such creative minds.

       Another similarity is both Ali Baba and the forty thieves and
Aladdin have thieves in their story. Thieves that are in my opinion cruel,
greedy, mean, and scary . But thieves in comparison to other stories are
just the same. Another thing is that usually most thieves want gold and
riches. And most of them will do just about anything to get it.

       The last similarity is both folktales have a trickster character. In Ali
Baba and the forty thieves Morgana plays the trickster. She earns that
title by killing all of the thieves silently with just some hot oil, and she
also is pretty undercover by only being the housekeeper. In Aladdin,
Aladdin himself plays the trickster because in the end he tricks Jafar into
becoming a genie that’s gets trapped inside a lamp.

       A difference between both folktales is in Aladdin, Aladdin doesn’t
steal anything like gold or riches. He steals some bread but nothing
major. But in Ali Baba and the forty thieves he steal a sack full of gold
and doesn’t go to jail! I think Aladdin just because it was a Disney movie
they made it just for kids and saying stealing is not right. You know? I’m
almost positive if it wasn’t a Disney movie it probably would have much
more stealing and such.
Another difference between these stories is that Aladdin the hero
character is a boy and in Ali Baba the hero character is a girl. I think this
proves that both genders can be smart and witty. I think that’s cool and
pretty different because you don’t see that very often with there being a
boy and a girl hero.

       The last difference is that Aladdin is a movie and Ali Baba is a story
text. I really think this is a big difference in a story. Because with a book
you have to get a picture in your head and with a movie you just see the
picture right there in front of you. I think I like Ali Baba and the forty
thieves format better but Aladdin’s storyline more.

In conclusion I really enjoyed both story’s and had a good time reading
and watching both  I hope we can do more compare and contrast
stories like these.
                               By:
                              Jessica

More Related Content

What's hot (20)

The color purple review by Muskan Kathuria
The color purple review by Muskan KathuriaThe color purple review by Muskan Kathuria
The color purple review by Muskan Kathuria
Muskan Kathuria
Romanticism in Frankenstein
Romanticism in FrankensteinRomanticism in Frankenstein
Romanticism in Frankenstein
hezaltrivedi
The White Tiger Themes
The White Tiger ThemesThe White Tiger Themes
The White Tiger Themes
sejalchauhan
Contemporary literature features
Contemporary literature featuresContemporary literature features
Contemporary literature features
totaaalupiii
Magical realism in what a tapster saw.docx
Magical realism in what a tapster saw.docxMagical realism in what a tapster saw.docx
Magical realism in what a tapster saw.docx
SnoberAbbas
Elements of short story
Elements of short storyElements of short story
Elements of short story
Lorna Cammille Mina
Feminist criticism
Feminist criticismFeminist criticism
Feminist criticism
Kavita Mehta
Universal Human Laws in The Waste Land (T.S. Eliot)
Universal Human Laws in The Waste Land (T.S. Eliot)Universal Human Laws in The Waste Land (T.S. Eliot)
Universal Human Laws in The Waste Land (T.S. Eliot)
Dilip Barad
Genres
GenresGenres
Genres
lisaladow
HUM 105 - Male and Female Divine
HUM 105 - Male and Female DivineHUM 105 - Male and Female Divine
HUM 105 - Male and Female Divine
Francisco Pesante
Yellow Wallpaper Lecture
Yellow Wallpaper LectureYellow Wallpaper Lecture
Yellow Wallpaper Lecture
tranceking
Characters and Characterization PowerPoint Presentation
Characters and Characterization PowerPoint PresentationCharacters and Characterization PowerPoint Presentation
Characters and Characterization PowerPoint Presentation
Zanele Mofokeng
G9 adverbs
G9 adverbsG9 adverbs
G9 adverbs
Leah Condina
an analysis on the short story sleeping beauty.
an analysis on the short story sleeping beauty.an analysis on the short story sleeping beauty.
an analysis on the short story sleeping beauty.
ZaryabQureshi3
The Fence by Jose Garcia Villa
The Fence by Jose Garcia VillaThe Fence by Jose Garcia Villa
The Fence by Jose Garcia Villa
Cheene Mae Bocalid
Literary Genre Fiction Sort
Literary Genre Fiction SortLiterary Genre Fiction Sort
Literary Genre Fiction Sort
Emma Zayas
Elements Of Plot Cinderella
Elements Of Plot   CinderellaElements Of Plot   Cinderella
Elements Of Plot Cinderella
mrswjohnston
Things fall apart themes
Things fall apart themesThings fall apart themes
Things fall apart themes
Mery Mangini
Cinderella fairytale short story analysis
Cinderella fairytale short story analysisCinderella fairytale short story analysis
Cinderella fairytale short story analysis
reginahelnaz
Legends
LegendsLegends
Legends
MT Dayang
The color purple review by Muskan Kathuria
The color purple review by Muskan KathuriaThe color purple review by Muskan Kathuria
The color purple review by Muskan Kathuria
Muskan Kathuria
Romanticism in Frankenstein
Romanticism in FrankensteinRomanticism in Frankenstein
Romanticism in Frankenstein
hezaltrivedi
Contemporary literature features
Contemporary literature featuresContemporary literature features
Contemporary literature features
totaaalupiii
Magical realism in what a tapster saw.docx
Magical realism in what a tapster saw.docxMagical realism in what a tapster saw.docx
Magical realism in what a tapster saw.docx
SnoberAbbas
Universal Human Laws in The Waste Land (T.S. Eliot)
Universal Human Laws in The Waste Land (T.S. Eliot)Universal Human Laws in The Waste Land (T.S. Eliot)
Universal Human Laws in The Waste Land (T.S. Eliot)
Dilip Barad
Yellow Wallpaper Lecture
Yellow Wallpaper LectureYellow Wallpaper Lecture
Yellow Wallpaper Lecture
tranceking
Characters and Characterization PowerPoint Presentation
Characters and Characterization PowerPoint PresentationCharacters and Characterization PowerPoint Presentation
Characters and Characterization PowerPoint Presentation
Zanele Mofokeng
an analysis on the short story sleeping beauty.
an analysis on the short story sleeping beauty.an analysis on the short story sleeping beauty.
an analysis on the short story sleeping beauty.
ZaryabQureshi3
Literary Genre Fiction Sort
Literary Genre Fiction SortLiterary Genre Fiction Sort
Literary Genre Fiction Sort
Emma Zayas
Elements Of Plot Cinderella
Elements Of Plot   CinderellaElements Of Plot   Cinderella
Elements Of Plot Cinderella
mrswjohnston
Things fall apart themes
Things fall apart themesThings fall apart themes
Things fall apart themes
Mery Mangini
Cinderella fairytale short story analysis
Cinderella fairytale short story analysisCinderella fairytale short story analysis
Cinderella fairytale short story analysis
reginahelnaz

Similar to Ali baba and the forty thieves and aladdin (20)

Compare contrast 1
Compare contrast 1Compare contrast 1
Compare contrast 1
dominck22098
Compare and contrast
Compare and contrastCompare and contrast
Compare and contrast
Matt12998
Compare and contrast
Compare and contrastCompare and contrast
Compare and contrast
oboeplayer99
Compare and contrast
Compare and contrastCompare and contrast
Compare and contrast
trevor2498
Aladdin and ali baba
Aladdin and ali babaAladdin and ali baba
Aladdin and ali baba
batesbugs1999
Aladdin and ali baba
Aladdin and ali babaAladdin and ali baba
Aladdin and ali baba
batesbugs1999
Alibaba and the forty thieves vs
Alibaba and the forty thieves vsAlibaba and the forty thieves vs
Alibaba and the forty thieves vs
allstar44
Ali baba and the forty thieves
Ali baba and the forty thievesAli baba and the forty thieves
Ali baba and the forty thieves
michaelarose99
Aladdin or ali babe
Aladdin or ali babeAladdin or ali babe
Aladdin or ali babe
sweetbr98
Aladdin or Ali Baba
Aladdin or Ali BabaAladdin or Ali Baba
Aladdin or Ali Baba
sweetbr98
Compare and contrast-
Compare and contrast-Compare and contrast-
Compare and contrast-
palmtrees4ever
Compare and contrast
Compare and contrastCompare and contrast
Compare and contrast
Jillian121497
Compare and contrast
Compare and contrastCompare and contrast
Compare and contrast
Jillian121497
Ali baba and aladdin
Ali baba and aladdinAli baba and aladdin
Ali baba and aladdin
cubbypanda1234
Ali baba and aladdin
Ali baba and aladdinAli baba and aladdin
Ali baba and aladdin
cubbypanda1234
Aladdin and ali baba
Aladdin and ali babaAladdin and ali baba
Aladdin and ali baba
ltmis399
Compare and contrast_story
Compare and contrast_storyCompare and contrast_story
Compare and contrast_story
julia92598
Compare and contrast_story
Compare and contrast_storyCompare and contrast_story
Compare and contrast_story
julia92598
Comparing ali baba_and_aladdin
Comparing ali baba_and_aladdinComparing ali baba_and_aladdin
Comparing ali baba_and_aladdin
mitchell8798
Aladdin and alibaba
Aladdin and alibabaAladdin and alibaba
Aladdin and alibaba
wfashionesta

More from jessicaschool11 (11)

Dear dr
Dear drDear dr
Dear dr
jessicaschool11
The 'Big Bad Chipmunks'
The 'Big Bad Chipmunks'The 'Big Bad Chipmunks'
The 'Big Bad Chipmunks'
jessicaschool11
Birds eye view
Birds eye viewBirds eye view
Birds eye view
jessicaschool11
Birds eye view
Birds eye viewBirds eye view
Birds eye view
jessicaschool11
Drenzeele
DrenzeeleDrenzeele
Drenzeele
jessicaschool11
Drenzeele
DrenzeeleDrenzeele
Drenzeele
jessicaschool11
Bibliography
BibliographyBibliography
Bibliography
jessicaschool11
Bibliography
BibliographyBibliography
Bibliography
jessicaschool11
How to Peel Cucumber's
How to Peel Cucumber'sHow to Peel Cucumber's
How to Peel Cucumber's
jessicaschool11
Compare and Contrast
Compare and ContrastCompare and Contrast
Compare and Contrast
jessicaschool11

Ali baba and the forty thieves and aladdin

  • 1. Compare and contrast Ali Baba and the forty thieves and Aladdin are some very similar folktales. But they have many differences. In this writing piece I’ll tell you more about them. One similarity is, both stories are Arabian folktales. Arabian folktales usually come from Arabia because people there made up stories involving magic, tricky thieves, sorcery, and mythical creatures. I think it’s very interesting that people there may be less wealthy than us but have such creative minds. Another similarity is both Ali Baba and the forty thieves and Aladdin have thieves in their story. Thieves that are in my opinion cruel, greedy, mean, and scary . But thieves in comparison to other stories are just the same. Another thing is that usually most thieves want gold and riches. And most of them will do just about anything to get it. The last similarity is both folktales have a trickster character. In Ali Baba and the forty thieves Morgana plays the trickster. She earns that title by killing all of the thieves silently with just some hot oil, and she also is pretty undercover by only being the housekeeper. In Aladdin, Aladdin himself plays the trickster because in the end he tricks Jafar into becoming a genie that’s gets trapped inside a lamp. A difference between both folktales is in Aladdin, Aladdin doesn’t steal anything like gold or riches. He steals some bread but nothing major. But in Ali Baba and the forty thieves he steal a sack full of gold and doesn’t go to jail! I think Aladdin just because it was a Disney movie they made it just for kids and saying stealing is not right. You know? I’m almost positive if it wasn’t a Disney movie it probably would have much more stealing and such.
  • 2. Another difference between these stories is that Aladdin the hero character is a boy and in Ali Baba the hero character is a girl. I think this proves that both genders can be smart and witty. I think that’s cool and pretty different because you don’t see that very often with there being a boy and a girl hero. The last difference is that Aladdin is a movie and Ali Baba is a story text. I really think this is a big difference in a story. Because with a book you have to get a picture in your head and with a movie you just see the picture right there in front of you. I think I like Ali Baba and the forty thieves format better but Aladdin’s storyline more. In conclusion I really enjoyed both story’s and had a good time reading and watching both  I hope we can do more compare and contrast stories like these. By: Jessica