狠狠撸

狠狠撸Share a Scribd company logo
July 21, 2020
VIA EMAIL
Jim Hartnett
San Mateo County Transit District
hartnettj@samtrans.com
Dear San Mateo County Transit District Board Members:
As Special Counsel to the San Mateo County Transit District, I was tasked with looking
at SB 797, the recent California law that provides a unique opportunity for Caltrain to submit a
one-eighth cent sales tax measure to the voters to support our vital local train service. However,
the one thing that is clear is that it must be a clean ballot proposal requiring that “the net
revenues from the tax” must “be used by the board for the operating and capital purposes of the
Caltrain rail services.”
Simply put, the law means the political bodies needing to approve the ballot measure
must not impose collateral or delaying conditions on use of the funds. Thus, the law prohibits
linking the straightforward fiscal measure designed to save Caltrain to unrelated—even if
salutary—organizational or other objectives. Specifically, it is my strong opinion that larding
approval with requirements of changed governance or targeted or restricted spending
requirements will render the tax subject to a successful taxpayer legal challenge.
Importantly, there is nothing that prevents the three members of the JPA from continuing
their separate discussions about organizational change and management structure. Plainly,
however, the California Legislature was saying you can do that, just don’t tie such political
negotiations to the overall economic wellbeing of the railway.
Very truly yours,
James M. Wagstaffe
Ad

Recommended

Legislative Advocacy - What MACPA does for you that nobody else does
Legislative Advocacy - What MACPA does for you that nobody else does
Tom Hood, CPA,CITP,CGMA
?
Lottery Structure in Arkansas
Lottery Structure in Arkansas
Robbie Wills
?
Project Delivery Workshop # 2 狠狠撸s.pdf
Project Delivery Workshop # 2 狠狠撸s.pdf
Adina Levin
?
SPUR + TransbayCoalition-Project Delivery Workshop 1 08.31.22.pdf
SPUR + TransbayCoalition-Project Delivery Workshop 1 08.31.22.pdf
Adina Levin
?
megaprojects, SPUR 2022.pdf
megaprojects, SPUR 2022.pdf
Adina Levin
?
Southeast San Francisco New Caltrain Stations
Southeast San Francisco New Caltrain Stations
Adina Levin
?
Regional options for caltrain governance
Regional options for caltrain governance
Adina Levin
?
SF resolution Caltrain sales tax
SF resolution Caltrain sales tax
Adina Levin
?
Senator Hill letter SB797 Caltrain
Senator Hill letter SB797 Caltrain
Adina Levin
?
West Bay Legislators support Caltrain ballot measure
West Bay Legislators support Caltrain ballot measure
Adina Levin
?
Caltrain_Equity_522
Caltrain_Equity_522
Adina Levin
?
San Jose Transit first policy nomination
San Jose Transit first policy nomination
Adina Levin
?
More Homes Less Driving TransForm 2-6-20
More Homes Less Driving TransForm 2-6-20
Adina Levin
?
More Homes Less Driving Sares Regis 2-6-20
More Homes Less Driving Sares Regis 2-6-20
Adina Levin
?
More Homes Less Driving First Community Housing 2-6-20
More Homes Less Driving First Community Housing 2-6-20
Adina Levin
?
Fj pa-friendsof caltrain-levin-responseltr-10-09-2019 (1) (1)
Fj pa-friendsof caltrain-levin-responseltr-10-09-2019 (1) (1)
Adina Levin
?
Caltrain 20190822 (1) (1)
Caltrain 20190822 (1) (1)
Adina Levin
?
High speed rail eir preferred alternative sf-sj - fo c (1) (1)
High speed rail eir preferred alternative sf-sj - fo c (1) (1)
Adina Levin
?
Dumbarton Crossbay
Dumbarton Crossbay
Adina Levin
?
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Caltrain Governance Resolution
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Caltrain Governance Resolution
Adina Levin
?
Connecting Communities Optimizing Highways Event April 18
Connecting Communities Optimizing Highways Event April 18
Adina Levin
?
Irfp 1819 07 dtx project delivery review services
Irfp 1819 07 dtx project delivery review services
Adina Levin
?
2018 TIMMA toll policy recommendations final
2018 TIMMA toll policy recommendations final
Adina Levin
?
More Caltrain service to South San Jose and South Santa Clara County
More Caltrain service to South San Jose and South Santa Clara County
Adina Levin
?
VTA Rfp s18181 strategic plan for high capacity transit corridors final
VTA Rfp s18181 strategic plan for high capacity transit corridors final
Adina Levin
?
MTC RFQ Alameda County Rail Connections
MTC RFQ Alameda County Rail Connections
Adina Levin
?
5-23-18 - Means Based joint support letter
5-23-18 - Means Based joint support letter
Adina Levin
?
2016 11-03 ta bod highway-101-92 interchange
2016 11-03 ta bod highway-101-92 interchange
Adina Levin
?
Trusted Site To Buy Verified Payoneer Accounts In This Time.pdf
Trusted Site To Buy Verified Payoneer Accounts In This Time.pdf
https://top5starshop.com/product/buy-verified-cash-app-accounts/
?
UN World Marine Fishery Health Situation Full Report 2025
UN World Marine Fishery Health Situation Full Report 2025
Energy for One World
?

More Related Content

More from Adina Levin (20)

Senator Hill letter SB797 Caltrain
Senator Hill letter SB797 Caltrain
Adina Levin
?
West Bay Legislators support Caltrain ballot measure
West Bay Legislators support Caltrain ballot measure
Adina Levin
?
Caltrain_Equity_522
Caltrain_Equity_522
Adina Levin
?
San Jose Transit first policy nomination
San Jose Transit first policy nomination
Adina Levin
?
More Homes Less Driving TransForm 2-6-20
More Homes Less Driving TransForm 2-6-20
Adina Levin
?
More Homes Less Driving Sares Regis 2-6-20
More Homes Less Driving Sares Regis 2-6-20
Adina Levin
?
More Homes Less Driving First Community Housing 2-6-20
More Homes Less Driving First Community Housing 2-6-20
Adina Levin
?
Fj pa-friendsof caltrain-levin-responseltr-10-09-2019 (1) (1)
Fj pa-friendsof caltrain-levin-responseltr-10-09-2019 (1) (1)
Adina Levin
?
Caltrain 20190822 (1) (1)
Caltrain 20190822 (1) (1)
Adina Levin
?
High speed rail eir preferred alternative sf-sj - fo c (1) (1)
High speed rail eir preferred alternative sf-sj - fo c (1) (1)
Adina Levin
?
Dumbarton Crossbay
Dumbarton Crossbay
Adina Levin
?
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Caltrain Governance Resolution
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Caltrain Governance Resolution
Adina Levin
?
Connecting Communities Optimizing Highways Event April 18
Connecting Communities Optimizing Highways Event April 18
Adina Levin
?
Irfp 1819 07 dtx project delivery review services
Irfp 1819 07 dtx project delivery review services
Adina Levin
?
2018 TIMMA toll policy recommendations final
2018 TIMMA toll policy recommendations final
Adina Levin
?
More Caltrain service to South San Jose and South Santa Clara County
More Caltrain service to South San Jose and South Santa Clara County
Adina Levin
?
VTA Rfp s18181 strategic plan for high capacity transit corridors final
VTA Rfp s18181 strategic plan for high capacity transit corridors final
Adina Levin
?
MTC RFQ Alameda County Rail Connections
MTC RFQ Alameda County Rail Connections
Adina Levin
?
5-23-18 - Means Based joint support letter
5-23-18 - Means Based joint support letter
Adina Levin
?
2016 11-03 ta bod highway-101-92 interchange
2016 11-03 ta bod highway-101-92 interchange
Adina Levin
?
Senator Hill letter SB797 Caltrain
Senator Hill letter SB797 Caltrain
Adina Levin
?
West Bay Legislators support Caltrain ballot measure
West Bay Legislators support Caltrain ballot measure
Adina Levin
?
Caltrain_Equity_522
Caltrain_Equity_522
Adina Levin
?
San Jose Transit first policy nomination
San Jose Transit first policy nomination
Adina Levin
?
More Homes Less Driving TransForm 2-6-20
More Homes Less Driving TransForm 2-6-20
Adina Levin
?
More Homes Less Driving Sares Regis 2-6-20
More Homes Less Driving Sares Regis 2-6-20
Adina Levin
?
More Homes Less Driving First Community Housing 2-6-20
More Homes Less Driving First Community Housing 2-6-20
Adina Levin
?
Fj pa-friendsof caltrain-levin-responseltr-10-09-2019 (1) (1)
Fj pa-friendsof caltrain-levin-responseltr-10-09-2019 (1) (1)
Adina Levin
?
Caltrain 20190822 (1) (1)
Caltrain 20190822 (1) (1)
Adina Levin
?
High speed rail eir preferred alternative sf-sj - fo c (1) (1)
High speed rail eir preferred alternative sf-sj - fo c (1) (1)
Adina Levin
?
Dumbarton Crossbay
Dumbarton Crossbay
Adina Levin
?
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Caltrain Governance Resolution
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Caltrain Governance Resolution
Adina Levin
?
Connecting Communities Optimizing Highways Event April 18
Connecting Communities Optimizing Highways Event April 18
Adina Levin
?
Irfp 1819 07 dtx project delivery review services
Irfp 1819 07 dtx project delivery review services
Adina Levin
?
2018 TIMMA toll policy recommendations final
2018 TIMMA toll policy recommendations final
Adina Levin
?
More Caltrain service to South San Jose and South Santa Clara County
More Caltrain service to South San Jose and South Santa Clara County
Adina Levin
?
VTA Rfp s18181 strategic plan for high capacity transit corridors final
VTA Rfp s18181 strategic plan for high capacity transit corridors final
Adina Levin
?
MTC RFQ Alameda County Rail Connections
MTC RFQ Alameda County Rail Connections
Adina Levin
?
5-23-18 - Means Based joint support letter
5-23-18 - Means Based joint support letter
Adina Levin
?
2016 11-03 ta bod highway-101-92 interchange
2016 11-03 ta bod highway-101-92 interchange
Adina Levin
?

Recently uploaded (20)

Trusted Site To Buy Verified Payoneer Accounts In This Time.pdf
Trusted Site To Buy Verified Payoneer Accounts In This Time.pdf
https://top5starshop.com/product/buy-verified-cash-app-accounts/
?
UN World Marine Fishery Health Situation Full Report 2025
UN World Marine Fishery Health Situation Full Report 2025
Energy for One World
?
combinepdf1-250218074557- cb23d7f4.pdf
combinepdf1-250218074557- cb23d7f4.pdf
bsarashka
?
“Strategic Evolution and Global Impact of BRICS: Trade, Governance & Future D...
“Strategic Evolution and Global Impact of BRICS: Trade, Governance & Future D...
br3002611
?
Outreach Proramme on Sensitizing the Diductor for Better TDS / TCS Compliance
Outreach Proramme on Sensitizing the Diductor for Better TDS / TCS Compliance
COLOURIMPRESSION
?
一比一原版(贬诲惭毕业证)斯图加特媒体学院毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(贬诲惭毕业证)斯图加特媒体学院毕业证如何办理
taqyed
?
DFARS Part 235 - Reseach And Development Contracts
DFARS Part 235 - Reseach And Development Contracts
JSchaus & Associates
?
Rs 50 Entry at Shivsrushti Ongoing Till July 15, Thanks to Abhay Bhutada Foun...
Rs 50 Entry at Shivsrushti Ongoing Till July 15, Thanks to Abhay Bhutada Foun...
Swapnil Pednekar
?
VertexsdfrgsdfgsgfsdxcvsefgsawedwsdaHD.pdf
VertexsdfrgsdfgsgfsdxcvsefgsawedwsdaHD.pdf
CenWong
?
最新版美国路易斯安那理工大学毕业证(尝补罢别肠丑毕业证书)原版定制
最新版美国路易斯安那理工大学毕业证(尝补罢别肠丑毕业证书)原版定制
taqyea
?
Texas Water Association: 89th Legislative Recap
Texas Water Association: 89th Legislative Recap
Texas Water Association
?
加拿大爱德华王子岛大学成绩单范本调鲍笔贰滨毕业完成信鲍笔贰滨成绩单防伪皑100%复刻
加拿大爱德华王子岛大学成绩单范本调鲍笔贰滨毕业完成信鲍笔贰滨成绩单防伪皑100%复刻
Taqyea
?
Competency of Interactive Diplomacy.pdf.pdf
Competency of Interactive Diplomacy.pdf.pdf
giselladarfian
?
The Data City, United Kingdom - Fatima Garcia
The Data City, United Kingdom - Fatima Garcia
OECD CFE
?
When History Became Affordable: Abhay Bhutada Foundation and the Shivsrushti ...
When History Became Affordable: Abhay Bhutada Foundation and the Shivsrushti ...
Lokesh Agrawal
?
How SafeLives Is Working to End Domestic Abuse
How SafeLives Is Working to End Domestic Abuse
Mark Lyttleton
?
Citizen Perception Survey (CPS) 2024 | Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics
Citizen Perception Survey (CPS) 2024 | Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics
Razin Mustafiz
?
MiSST: Making Children’s Lives Better Through Classical Music
MiSST: Making Children’s Lives Better Through Classical Music
Mark Lyttleton
?
Strategic Planning for Grassroots Organizations 2025.pptx.pptx
Strategic Planning for Grassroots Organizations 2025.pptx.pptx
Joyce Lewis-Andrews
?
Government at a Glance 2025 Launch Presentation.pdf
Government at a Glance 2025 Launch Presentation.pdf
OECD Governance
?
UN World Marine Fishery Health Situation Full Report 2025
UN World Marine Fishery Health Situation Full Report 2025
Energy for One World
?
combinepdf1-250218074557- cb23d7f4.pdf
combinepdf1-250218074557- cb23d7f4.pdf
bsarashka
?
“Strategic Evolution and Global Impact of BRICS: Trade, Governance & Future D...
“Strategic Evolution and Global Impact of BRICS: Trade, Governance & Future D...
br3002611
?
Outreach Proramme on Sensitizing the Diductor for Better TDS / TCS Compliance
Outreach Proramme on Sensitizing the Diductor for Better TDS / TCS Compliance
COLOURIMPRESSION
?
一比一原版(贬诲惭毕业证)斯图加特媒体学院毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(贬诲惭毕业证)斯图加特媒体学院毕业证如何办理
taqyed
?
DFARS Part 235 - Reseach And Development Contracts
DFARS Part 235 - Reseach And Development Contracts
JSchaus & Associates
?
Rs 50 Entry at Shivsrushti Ongoing Till July 15, Thanks to Abhay Bhutada Foun...
Rs 50 Entry at Shivsrushti Ongoing Till July 15, Thanks to Abhay Bhutada Foun...
Swapnil Pednekar
?
VertexsdfrgsdfgsgfsdxcvsefgsawedwsdaHD.pdf
VertexsdfrgsdfgsgfsdxcvsefgsawedwsdaHD.pdf
CenWong
?
最新版美国路易斯安那理工大学毕业证(尝补罢别肠丑毕业证书)原版定制
最新版美国路易斯安那理工大学毕业证(尝补罢别肠丑毕业证书)原版定制
taqyea
?
Texas Water Association: 89th Legislative Recap
Texas Water Association: 89th Legislative Recap
Texas Water Association
?
加拿大爱德华王子岛大学成绩单范本调鲍笔贰滨毕业完成信鲍笔贰滨成绩单防伪皑100%复刻
加拿大爱德华王子岛大学成绩单范本调鲍笔贰滨毕业完成信鲍笔贰滨成绩单防伪皑100%复刻
Taqyea
?
Competency of Interactive Diplomacy.pdf.pdf
Competency of Interactive Diplomacy.pdf.pdf
giselladarfian
?
The Data City, United Kingdom - Fatima Garcia
The Data City, United Kingdom - Fatima Garcia
OECD CFE
?
When History Became Affordable: Abhay Bhutada Foundation and the Shivsrushti ...
When History Became Affordable: Abhay Bhutada Foundation and the Shivsrushti ...
Lokesh Agrawal
?
How SafeLives Is Working to End Domestic Abuse
How SafeLives Is Working to End Domestic Abuse
Mark Lyttleton
?
Citizen Perception Survey (CPS) 2024 | Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics
Citizen Perception Survey (CPS) 2024 | Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics
Razin Mustafiz
?
MiSST: Making Children’s Lives Better Through Classical Music
MiSST: Making Children’s Lives Better Through Classical Music
Mark Lyttleton
?
Strategic Planning for Grassroots Organizations 2025.pptx.pptx
Strategic Planning for Grassroots Organizations 2025.pptx.pptx
Joyce Lewis-Andrews
?
Government at a Glance 2025 Launch Presentation.pdf
Government at a Glance 2025 Launch Presentation.pdf
OECD Governance
?
Ad

Caltrain tax legal opinion

  • 1. July 21, 2020 VIA EMAIL Jim Hartnett San Mateo County Transit District hartnettj@samtrans.com Dear San Mateo County Transit District Board Members: As Special Counsel to the San Mateo County Transit District, I was tasked with looking at SB 797, the recent California law that provides a unique opportunity for Caltrain to submit a one-eighth cent sales tax measure to the voters to support our vital local train service. However, the one thing that is clear is that it must be a clean ballot proposal requiring that “the net revenues from the tax” must “be used by the board for the operating and capital purposes of the Caltrain rail services.” Simply put, the law means the political bodies needing to approve the ballot measure must not impose collateral or delaying conditions on use of the funds. Thus, the law prohibits linking the straightforward fiscal measure designed to save Caltrain to unrelated—even if salutary—organizational or other objectives. Specifically, it is my strong opinion that larding approval with requirements of changed governance or targeted or restricted spending requirements will render the tax subject to a successful taxpayer legal challenge. Importantly, there is nothing that prevents the three members of the JPA from continuing their separate discussions about organizational change and management structure. Plainly, however, the California Legislature was saying you can do that, just don’t tie such political negotiations to the overall economic wellbeing of the railway. Very truly yours, James M. Wagstaffe