際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
Demystifying Comps
Xue Xing
Workforce Education
University of Georgia
General things to know
 For Workforce Education program:
 One month to respond to four questions:
Theory
Foundations
Research
Practice
 15 pages double-space excluding references for each question
 Cover page for each question before your response
 References could be at the end of all four responses or of each response
(the latter is preferred)
 Binders with responses to all four questions for each of your committee
member
 APA format
When will you know
 Preliminary meeting with your committee
Introduction about yourself, program of study, current research
Your dissertation proposal abstract (one page, references upon request)
Brief intro
Statement of Purpose
Methodology (Design, Participants, Instrumentation, Procedure, Data
analysis)
 Your committee will ask you questions about your proposal
 Each committee member picks up a question and imply you the direction of
his/her question
 Communicate with your advisor to make sure you understand what questions
are probably going to be asked
Strategies to complete
 Start when you are ready!
 Have a draft of Ch1, 2, 3 before you start
 Your comps questions are entirely based on your research
 The deeper you understand your research, the better you are prepared
 The aim of comps is to prepare you for your proposal/prospectus
 Once your start:
Make sure you understand each question well  Never start writing
when you are not sure!! Stop! Go to that committee member and ask!
Manage your time well
Always save your work
Try to write down your responses and then revise once or twice
Remember the big picture!
Lets be prepared!
 Theory
What theory explains your Dependent Variable (DV) ?
What do we know about that theory?
What does that theory say about your DV?
What part of that theory guide your study? And How?
How does that theory explain the relationship between your DV and your
selection of Independent Variables (IVs)?
 Foundations
 Research
 Practice
Lets be prepared!
 Theory
 Foundations
What are some foundational issues of your study?
If you are constructing a test, the question may be what is the process of
test construction
If you are studying the impact of A on DV, the question may be what are
impacts of A on DV based on the literature
 Research
 Practice
Lets be prepared!
 Theory
 Foundations
 Research
What method are you going to use in your study?
What do we know about that method?
How should that method be used (procedures, assumptions, data
analysis, interpretations)?
Why do you select that method?
 Practice
Lets be prepared!
 Theory
 Foundations
 Research
 Practice
What is the practical implementation of your study? or
What is the educational systems in China? or
How does student-run business work (suppose you are studying work-
based learning activities)? or
What is the procedure of policy-making?
Golden tips
 Use the most updated literature!
 Communicate with your committee when you encounter problems!
 Go back to your statement of purpose and remind yourself why you want to
do this study when necessary!
 Reward yourself and have some fun during comps!
Thank you!
If you have any questions, contact me cherxing@uga.edu

More Related Content

What's hot (19)

ICAR-IFPRI - Basic Research Questions lecture 1 - Devesh Roy, IFPRI
ICAR-IFPRI - Basic Research Questions lecture 1 - Devesh Roy, IFPRIICAR-IFPRI - Basic Research Questions lecture 1 - Devesh Roy, IFPRI
ICAR-IFPRI - Basic Research Questions lecture 1 - Devesh Roy, IFPRI
International Food Policy Research Institute- South Asia Office
Researcher and Research Student Enrichment Program (R2SEP)
Researcher and Research Student Enrichment Program (R2SEP)Researcher and Research Student Enrichment Program (R2SEP)
Researcher and Research Student Enrichment Program (R2SEP)
BC Chew
Literature Review
Literature ReviewLiterature Review
Literature Review
BC Chew
Level 7 note making
Level 7 note makingLevel 7 note making
Level 7 note making
JAHennessyMurdoch
Class 4 Surveys
Class 4   SurveysClass 4   Surveys
Class 4 Surveys
rharr
Thesis & viva student version 2013 [compatibility mode]
Thesis & viva student version 2013 [compatibility mode]Thesis & viva student version 2013 [compatibility mode]
Thesis & viva student version 2013 [compatibility mode]
VreckaScott
Presenting your Research at the ECTEL Doctoral Consortium
Presenting your Research at the ECTEL Doctoral ConsortiumPresenting your Research at the ECTEL Doctoral Consortium
Presenting your Research at the ECTEL Doctoral Consortium
Christian Glahn
How to Select the Most Promising Research Problem for Your Thesis/Dissertation
How to Select the Most Promising Research Problem for Your Thesis/DissertationHow to Select the Most Promising Research Problem for Your Thesis/Dissertation
How to Select the Most Promising Research Problem for Your Thesis/Dissertation
DoctoralNet Limited
Developing A Research Question
Developing A Research QuestionDeveloping A Research Question
Developing A Research Question
jmonroe3
The Research Question
The Research QuestionThe Research Question
The Research Question
unmgrc
Developing Research Questions
Developing Research QuestionsDeveloping Research Questions
Developing Research Questions
Andy Cramp
Phd viva general questions
Phd viva general questionsPhd viva general questions
Phd viva general questions
Marcus Leaning
Critical Research Question Help
Critical Research Question HelpCritical Research Question Help
Critical Research Question Help
Media Studies
8. Are you ready to write the overview for your study?
8. Are you ready to write the overview for your study? 8. Are you ready to write the overview for your study?
8. Are you ready to write the overview for your study?
DoctoralNet Limited
How to develop a research topic
How to develop a research topicHow to develop a research topic
How to develop a research topic
phoebeleung
Research questions and research design
Research questions and research design Research questions and research design
Research questions and research design
Normative
Doing a masters thesis
Doing a masters thesisDoing a masters thesis
Doing a masters thesis
BabakFarshchian
How to read a scientific paper
How to read a scientific paperHow to read a scientific paper
How to read a scientific paper
Ingrid Mel辿ndez Nieves
Critical Research Introduction
Critical Research IntroductionCritical Research Introduction
Critical Research Introduction
Media Studies
Researcher and Research Student Enrichment Program (R2SEP)
Researcher and Research Student Enrichment Program (R2SEP)Researcher and Research Student Enrichment Program (R2SEP)
Researcher and Research Student Enrichment Program (R2SEP)
BC Chew
Literature Review
Literature ReviewLiterature Review
Literature Review
BC Chew
Class 4 Surveys
Class 4   SurveysClass 4   Surveys
Class 4 Surveys
rharr
Thesis & viva student version 2013 [compatibility mode]
Thesis & viva student version 2013 [compatibility mode]Thesis & viva student version 2013 [compatibility mode]
Thesis & viva student version 2013 [compatibility mode]
VreckaScott
Presenting your Research at the ECTEL Doctoral Consortium
Presenting your Research at the ECTEL Doctoral ConsortiumPresenting your Research at the ECTEL Doctoral Consortium
Presenting your Research at the ECTEL Doctoral Consortium
Christian Glahn
How to Select the Most Promising Research Problem for Your Thesis/Dissertation
How to Select the Most Promising Research Problem for Your Thesis/DissertationHow to Select the Most Promising Research Problem for Your Thesis/Dissertation
How to Select the Most Promising Research Problem for Your Thesis/Dissertation
DoctoralNet Limited
Developing A Research Question
Developing A Research QuestionDeveloping A Research Question
Developing A Research Question
jmonroe3
The Research Question
The Research QuestionThe Research Question
The Research Question
unmgrc
Developing Research Questions
Developing Research QuestionsDeveloping Research Questions
Developing Research Questions
Andy Cramp
Phd viva general questions
Phd viva general questionsPhd viva general questions
Phd viva general questions
Marcus Leaning
Critical Research Question Help
Critical Research Question HelpCritical Research Question Help
Critical Research Question Help
Media Studies
8. Are you ready to write the overview for your study?
8. Are you ready to write the overview for your study? 8. Are you ready to write the overview for your study?
8. Are you ready to write the overview for your study?
DoctoralNet Limited
How to develop a research topic
How to develop a research topicHow to develop a research topic
How to develop a research topic
phoebeleung
Research questions and research design
Research questions and research design Research questions and research design
Research questions and research design
Normative
Doing a masters thesis
Doing a masters thesisDoing a masters thesis
Doing a masters thesis
BabakFarshchian
Critical Research Introduction
Critical Research IntroductionCritical Research Introduction
Critical Research Introduction
Media Studies

Similar to Demystifying Comps (20)

Outline & Research Design RoadmapThis exercise will help you bui.docx
Outline & Research Design RoadmapThis exercise will help you bui.docxOutline & Research Design RoadmapThis exercise will help you bui.docx
Outline & Research Design RoadmapThis exercise will help you bui.docx
alfred4lewis58146
ENV 101Final Project GuidanceDraft ScaffoldA. INTRODUCTION.docx
ENV 101Final Project GuidanceDraft ScaffoldA. INTRODUCTION.docxENV 101Final Project GuidanceDraft ScaffoldA. INTRODUCTION.docx
ENV 101Final Project GuidanceDraft ScaffoldA. INTRODUCTION.docx
SALU18
Needs Analysis
Needs AnalysisNeeds Analysis
Needs Analysis
guestedc181
Share research Questionnaires for thesis
Share research Questionnaires for thesisShare research Questionnaires for thesis
Share research Questionnaires for thesis
GliverMaeBuhat1
Final 23.3.12 cs3 mod 3 review of analysis and learning 3760
  Final 23.3.12 cs3  mod 3 review of analysis and learning 3760  Final 23.3.12 cs3  mod 3 review of analysis and learning 3760
Final 23.3.12 cs3 mod 3 review of analysis and learning 3760
Paula Nottingham
Start the term right : September 2011
Start the term right :  September 2011Start the term right :  September 2011
Start the term right : September 2011
Northeast Center, Office of Academic Support, SUNY Empire State College
Developing a Systematic Review Topic and Research Question - Dr Buna Bhandari
Developing a Systematic Review Topic and Research Question - Dr Buna BhandariDeveloping a Systematic Review Topic and Research Question - Dr Buna Bhandari
Developing a Systematic Review Topic and Research Question - Dr Buna Bhandari
ACSRM
How to Write a Research Proposal-12-12-11 [Autosaved].ppt
How to Write a Research Proposal-12-12-11 [Autosaved].pptHow to Write a Research Proposal-12-12-11 [Autosaved].ppt
How to Write a Research Proposal-12-12-11 [Autosaved].ppt
ssuserca0ec4
Start the term right January 2011
Start the term right   January 2011Start the term right   January 2011
Start the term right January 2011
Northeast Center, Office of Academic Support, SUNY Empire State College
Pg writing aims and proposal
Pg writing aims and proposalPg writing aims and proposal
Pg writing aims and proposal
RhianWynWilliams
InterviewQuestions.pdf
InterviewQuestions.pdfInterviewQuestions.pdf
InterviewQuestions.pdf
AbaidZafar1
Interview questions
Interview questionsInterview questions
Interview questions
Dr. Mutyala Subramanyam
Tesol proposoal writingworkshop
Tesol proposoal writingworkshopTesol proposoal writingworkshop
Tesol proposoal writingworkshop
Sudan University of Science and Technology (SUST)
Questionnaire design
Questionnaire design Questionnaire design
Questionnaire design
Suvarna JaipurkarGanvir
Getting a Head Start with Your Thesis Proposal
Getting a Head Start with Your Thesis ProposalGetting a Head Start with Your Thesis Proposal
Getting a Head Start with Your Thesis Proposal
wwuwritingcenter
Uw Design Power Pt
Uw Design Power PtUw Design Power Pt
Uw Design Power Pt
Jane Zahner
Writing the research proposal.pptx
Writing the research proposal.pptxWriting the research proposal.pptx
Writing the research proposal.pptx
Sumity Arora
忰悋惷惘悸 11
忰悋惷惘悸 11忰悋惷惘悸 11
忰悋惷惘悸 11
惘慍 悋惡忰惓 悋悖愕悋 悋惺悸
Q uestionnaire design
Q uestionnaire design Q uestionnaire design
Q uestionnaire design
Suvarna JaipurkarGanvir
Writing-Action-Research.pptx
Writing-Action-Research.pptxWriting-Action-Research.pptx
Writing-Action-Research.pptx
FRANCINESIMBAJON
Outline & Research Design RoadmapThis exercise will help you bui.docx
Outline & Research Design RoadmapThis exercise will help you bui.docxOutline & Research Design RoadmapThis exercise will help you bui.docx
Outline & Research Design RoadmapThis exercise will help you bui.docx
alfred4lewis58146
ENV 101Final Project GuidanceDraft ScaffoldA. INTRODUCTION.docx
ENV 101Final Project GuidanceDraft ScaffoldA. INTRODUCTION.docxENV 101Final Project GuidanceDraft ScaffoldA. INTRODUCTION.docx
ENV 101Final Project GuidanceDraft ScaffoldA. INTRODUCTION.docx
SALU18
Needs Analysis
Needs AnalysisNeeds Analysis
Needs Analysis
guestedc181
Share research Questionnaires for thesis
Share research Questionnaires for thesisShare research Questionnaires for thesis
Share research Questionnaires for thesis
GliverMaeBuhat1
Final 23.3.12 cs3 mod 3 review of analysis and learning 3760
  Final 23.3.12 cs3  mod 3 review of analysis and learning 3760  Final 23.3.12 cs3  mod 3 review of analysis and learning 3760
Final 23.3.12 cs3 mod 3 review of analysis and learning 3760
Paula Nottingham
Developing a Systematic Review Topic and Research Question - Dr Buna Bhandari
Developing a Systematic Review Topic and Research Question - Dr Buna BhandariDeveloping a Systematic Review Topic and Research Question - Dr Buna Bhandari
Developing a Systematic Review Topic and Research Question - Dr Buna Bhandari
ACSRM
How to Write a Research Proposal-12-12-11 [Autosaved].ppt
How to Write a Research Proposal-12-12-11 [Autosaved].pptHow to Write a Research Proposal-12-12-11 [Autosaved].ppt
How to Write a Research Proposal-12-12-11 [Autosaved].ppt
ssuserca0ec4
Pg writing aims and proposal
Pg writing aims and proposalPg writing aims and proposal
Pg writing aims and proposal
RhianWynWilliams
InterviewQuestions.pdf
InterviewQuestions.pdfInterviewQuestions.pdf
InterviewQuestions.pdf
AbaidZafar1
Getting a Head Start with Your Thesis Proposal
Getting a Head Start with Your Thesis ProposalGetting a Head Start with Your Thesis Proposal
Getting a Head Start with Your Thesis Proposal
wwuwritingcenter
Uw Design Power Pt
Uw Design Power PtUw Design Power Pt
Uw Design Power Pt
Jane Zahner
Writing the research proposal.pptx
Writing the research proposal.pptxWriting the research proposal.pptx
Writing the research proposal.pptx
Sumity Arora
Writing-Action-Research.pptx
Writing-Action-Research.pptxWriting-Action-Research.pptx
Writing-Action-Research.pptx
FRANCINESIMBAJON

Demystifying Comps

  • 1. Demystifying Comps Xue Xing Workforce Education University of Georgia
  • 2. General things to know For Workforce Education program: One month to respond to four questions: Theory Foundations Research Practice 15 pages double-space excluding references for each question Cover page for each question before your response References could be at the end of all four responses or of each response (the latter is preferred) Binders with responses to all four questions for each of your committee member APA format
  • 3. When will you know Preliminary meeting with your committee Introduction about yourself, program of study, current research Your dissertation proposal abstract (one page, references upon request) Brief intro Statement of Purpose Methodology (Design, Participants, Instrumentation, Procedure, Data analysis) Your committee will ask you questions about your proposal Each committee member picks up a question and imply you the direction of his/her question Communicate with your advisor to make sure you understand what questions are probably going to be asked
  • 4. Strategies to complete Start when you are ready! Have a draft of Ch1, 2, 3 before you start Your comps questions are entirely based on your research The deeper you understand your research, the better you are prepared The aim of comps is to prepare you for your proposal/prospectus Once your start: Make sure you understand each question well Never start writing when you are not sure!! Stop! Go to that committee member and ask! Manage your time well Always save your work Try to write down your responses and then revise once or twice Remember the big picture!
  • 5. Lets be prepared! Theory What theory explains your Dependent Variable (DV) ? What do we know about that theory? What does that theory say about your DV? What part of that theory guide your study? And How? How does that theory explain the relationship between your DV and your selection of Independent Variables (IVs)? Foundations Research Practice
  • 6. Lets be prepared! Theory Foundations What are some foundational issues of your study? If you are constructing a test, the question may be what is the process of test construction If you are studying the impact of A on DV, the question may be what are impacts of A on DV based on the literature Research Practice
  • 7. Lets be prepared! Theory Foundations Research What method are you going to use in your study? What do we know about that method? How should that method be used (procedures, assumptions, data analysis, interpretations)? Why do you select that method? Practice
  • 8. Lets be prepared! Theory Foundations Research Practice What is the practical implementation of your study? or What is the educational systems in China? or How does student-run business work (suppose you are studying work- based learning activities)? or What is the procedure of policy-making?
  • 9. Golden tips Use the most updated literature! Communicate with your committee when you encounter problems! Go back to your statement of purpose and remind yourself why you want to do this study when necessary! Reward yourself and have some fun during comps!
  • 10. Thank you! If you have any questions, contact me cherxing@uga.edu