際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
What Can We Learn from Alternative Nicotine
Product Usage in Other Countries?
United Kingdom
Clive Bates
Counterfactual Consulting, London
FDLI Tobacco and Nicotine Products Regulation and Policy Conference
29 October 2021
Smoking and vaping 2019  Great Britain (ONS)
ONS, E-cigarette use in Great Britain in 2019, July 2020
~3m vapers
~8m smokers
2
2030 goal make smoking products obsolete
5% prevalence
Two-thirds cut
3
ONS, E-cigarette use in Great Britain in 2019, July 2020
10-year adult smoking prevalence trend
4
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
%
cigarette
smokers
(3
month
moving
average)
~One-third cut
University College London, Smoking in England, Smoking Toolkit Survey, 2020 (England)
Adult e-cigarette users by smoking status, Great Britain 2014-21
Dual use in context
Dual use has declined over time
Source: Action on Smoking and Health (UK) and YouGov - E-cigarette Use By Adults 2021
UK compared to USA
1. Split competence / Brexit
UK compared to USA
1. Split competence / Brexit
2. Notification vs authorisation
UK compared to USA
1. Split competence / Brexit
2. Notification vs authorisation
3. Category-wide approach
UK compared to USA
1. Split competence / Brexit
2. Notification vs authorisation
3. Category-wide approach
4. Product standards
UK compared to USA
1. Split competence / Brexit
2. Notification vs authorisation
3. Category-wide approach
4. Product standards
 Notification  ingredients, toxicology,
pharmacology, production process
 Technical design restrictions and requirements
 Leaflet, packaging and warning
 Advertising, promotion, sponsorship
 Cross border sales
 Disclosure commercial data
 Market surveillance
 Public disclosure of commercial data
 Surveillance for adverse effects
UK compared to USA
1. Split competence / Brexit
2. Notification vs authorisation
3. Category-wide approach
4. Product standards
5. Nicotine cap
Max 20mg/ml (~2%)
This concentration allows for a
delivery of nicotine that is
comparable to the permitted dose
of nicotine derived from a
standard cigarette during the time
needed to smoke such a
cigarette.
Source: TPD 20(3)(b) TPD recital 38
UK compared to USA
1. Split competence / Brexit
2. Notification vs authorisation
3. Category-wide approach
4. Product standards
5. Nicotine cap
6. Marketing restrictions
Cross border advertising
promotion and sponsorship for all
tobacco and vaping products is
prohibited at EU level.
Source: Tobacco Advertising Directive 2002, TPD Article 20(5)
UK compared to USA
1. Split competence / Brexit
2. Notification vs authorisation
3. Category-wide approach
4. Product standards
5. Nicotine cap
6. Marketing restrictions
 Dont be socially irresponsible
 Dont target or feature children
 Dont confuse e-cigarettes with tobacco products
 Dont make health or safety claims
 Dont make smoking cessation claims
 Dont mislead about product ingredients
 Dont mislead about where products may be use
UK compared to USA
1. Split competence / Brexit
2. Notification vs authorisation
3. Category-wide approach
4. Product standards
5. Nicotine cap
6. Marketing restrictions
7. Reduced risk claims
Manufacturers must not suggest:
that a particular tobacco product
is less harmful than others or aims
to reduce the effect of some
harmful components of smoke
Source: TPD 13(1)(b) applied to vaping products via 20(4)(b)(ii)
UK compared to USA
1. Split competence / Brexit
2. Notification vs authorisation
3. Category-wide approach
4. Product standards
5. Nicotine cap
6. Marketing restrictions
7. Reduced risk claims
8. Tax 0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
United Kingdom United States
Price of 20 Marlboro USD
Source: Numbeo
Major difference in UK
1. Split competence / Brexit
2. Notification vs authorisation
3. Category-wide approach
4. Product standards
5. Nicotine cap
6. Marketing restrictions
7. Reduced risk claims
8. Tax
9. Attitude
UK compared to USA
1. Split competence / Brexit
2. Notification vs authorisation
3. Category-wide approach
4. Product standards
5. Nicotine cap
6. Marketing restrictions
7. Reduced risk claims
8. Tax
9. Attitude
Thank you!
Clive Bates
Counterfactual
clivedbates@gmail.com
www.clivebates.com
@clive_bates

More Related Content

What's hot (20)

E-cigarette Summit - The New Tobacco Wars - 7 December 2021
E-cigarette Summit - The New Tobacco Wars - 7 December 2021E-cigarette Summit - The New Tobacco Wars - 7 December 2021
E-cigarette Summit - The New Tobacco Wars - 7 December 2021
Clive Bates
Seven insights into tobacco harm reduction
Seven insights into tobacco harm reductionSeven insights into tobacco harm reduction
Seven insights into tobacco harm reduction
Clive Bates
Regulation: why less is more... E-cigarette Summit 12 November 2013 - Clive B...
Regulation: why less is more... E-cigarette Summit 12 November 2013 - Clive B...Regulation: why less is more... E-cigarette Summit 12 November 2013 - Clive B...
Regulation: why less is more... E-cigarette Summit 12 November 2013 - Clive B...
Clive Bates
Innovation for Consumers: E-cigarettes and novel tobacco products - Part of t...
Innovation for Consumers: E-cigarettes and novel tobacco products - Part of t...Innovation for Consumers: E-cigarettes and novel tobacco products - Part of t...
Innovation for Consumers: E-cigarettes and novel tobacco products - Part of t...
Clive Bates
Respect Vapers Ireland - webinar on tobacco harm reduction
Respect Vapers Ireland - webinar on tobacco harm reductionRespect Vapers Ireland - webinar on tobacco harm reduction
Respect Vapers Ireland - webinar on tobacco harm reduction
Clive Bates
Bad science - 10 insights for advocates
Bad science - 10 insights for advocatesBad science - 10 insights for advocates
Bad science - 10 insights for advocates
Clive Bates
Asia House - Six insights into tobacco harm reduction
Asia House - Six insights into tobacco harm reductionAsia House - Six insights into tobacco harm reduction
Asia House - Six insights into tobacco harm reduction
Clive Bates
The Endgame Revisited - US E-cigarette Summit 2021
The Endgame Revisited - US E-cigarette Summit 2021The Endgame Revisited - US E-cigarette Summit 2021
The Endgame Revisited - US E-cigarette Summit 2021
Clive Bates
Vaping and tobacco: six things you need to know about harm reduction
Vaping and tobacco:  six things you need to know about harm reductionVaping and tobacco:  six things you need to know about harm reduction
Vaping and tobacco: six things you need to know about harm reduction
Clive Bates
NYU College of Global Health - E-cigarette seminar - New York
NYU College of Global Health - E-cigarette seminar - New YorkNYU College of Global Health - E-cigarette seminar - New York
NYU College of Global Health - E-cigarette seminar - New York
Clive Bates
Science based policy or policy based science?
Science based policy or policy based science?Science based policy or policy based science?
Science based policy or policy based science?
Clive Bates
Harm reduction - six insights
Harm reduction - six insightsHarm reduction - six insights
Harm reduction - six insights
Clive Bates
Global Forum on Nicotine 2016: What would good regulation look like
Global Forum on Nicotine 2016: What would good regulation look likeGlobal Forum on Nicotine 2016: What would good regulation look like
Global Forum on Nicotine 2016: What would good regulation look like
Clive Bates
The MRTP process - Seven provocations - FDLI webinar 30 July 2020
The MRTP process - Seven provocations - FDLI webinar 30 July 2020The MRTP process - Seven provocations - FDLI webinar 30 July 2020
The MRTP process - Seven provocations - FDLI webinar 30 July 2020
Clive Bates
Wells Fargo 2013
Wells Fargo 2013 Wells Fargo 2013
Wells Fargo 2013
Clive Bates
our vision and leadership for tobacco control in hertfordshire
our vision and leadership for tobacco control in hertfordshireour vision and leadership for tobacco control in hertfordshire
our vision and leadership for tobacco control in hertfordshire
Professor Jim McManus AFBPsS,FFPH,CSci, FRSB, CPsychol
Competent or careless? Directions in European policy on low-risk nicotine pr...
Competent or careless?  Directions in European policy on low-risk nicotine pr...Competent or careless?  Directions in European policy on low-risk nicotine pr...
Competent or careless? Directions in European policy on low-risk nicotine pr...
Clive Bates
Effects of alternative nicotine delivery systems on cigarette consumption and...
Effects of alternative nicotine delivery systems on cigarette consumption and...Effects of alternative nicotine delivery systems on cigarette consumption and...
Effects of alternative nicotine delivery systems on cigarette consumption and...
Clive Bates
Tobacco harm reduction in the UK: e-cigarettes (EC) are making a difference
Tobacco harm reduction in the UK: e-cigarettes (EC) are making a differenceTobacco harm reduction in the UK: e-cigarettes (EC) are making a difference
Tobacco harm reduction in the UK: e-cigarettes (EC) are making a difference
Clive Bates
Wells Fargo 2014 E-cig conference - Bates
Wells Fargo 2014 E-cig conference - BatesWells Fargo 2014 E-cig conference - Bates
Wells Fargo 2014 E-cig conference - Bates
Clive Bates
E-cigarette Summit - The New Tobacco Wars - 7 December 2021
E-cigarette Summit - The New Tobacco Wars - 7 December 2021E-cigarette Summit - The New Tobacco Wars - 7 December 2021
E-cigarette Summit - The New Tobacco Wars - 7 December 2021
Clive Bates
Seven insights into tobacco harm reduction
Seven insights into tobacco harm reductionSeven insights into tobacco harm reduction
Seven insights into tobacco harm reduction
Clive Bates
Regulation: why less is more... E-cigarette Summit 12 November 2013 - Clive B...
Regulation: why less is more... E-cigarette Summit 12 November 2013 - Clive B...Regulation: why less is more... E-cigarette Summit 12 November 2013 - Clive B...
Regulation: why less is more... E-cigarette Summit 12 November 2013 - Clive B...
Clive Bates
Innovation for Consumers: E-cigarettes and novel tobacco products - Part of t...
Innovation for Consumers: E-cigarettes and novel tobacco products - Part of t...Innovation for Consumers: E-cigarettes and novel tobacco products - Part of t...
Innovation for Consumers: E-cigarettes and novel tobacco products - Part of t...
Clive Bates
Respect Vapers Ireland - webinar on tobacco harm reduction
Respect Vapers Ireland - webinar on tobacco harm reductionRespect Vapers Ireland - webinar on tobacco harm reduction
Respect Vapers Ireland - webinar on tobacco harm reduction
Clive Bates
Bad science - 10 insights for advocates
Bad science - 10 insights for advocatesBad science - 10 insights for advocates
Bad science - 10 insights for advocates
Clive Bates
Asia House - Six insights into tobacco harm reduction
Asia House - Six insights into tobacco harm reductionAsia House - Six insights into tobacco harm reduction
Asia House - Six insights into tobacco harm reduction
Clive Bates
The Endgame Revisited - US E-cigarette Summit 2021
The Endgame Revisited - US E-cigarette Summit 2021The Endgame Revisited - US E-cigarette Summit 2021
The Endgame Revisited - US E-cigarette Summit 2021
Clive Bates
Vaping and tobacco: six things you need to know about harm reduction
Vaping and tobacco:  six things you need to know about harm reductionVaping and tobacco:  six things you need to know about harm reduction
Vaping and tobacco: six things you need to know about harm reduction
Clive Bates
NYU College of Global Health - E-cigarette seminar - New York
NYU College of Global Health - E-cigarette seminar - New YorkNYU College of Global Health - E-cigarette seminar - New York
NYU College of Global Health - E-cigarette seminar - New York
Clive Bates
Science based policy or policy based science?
Science based policy or policy based science?Science based policy or policy based science?
Science based policy or policy based science?
Clive Bates
Harm reduction - six insights
Harm reduction - six insightsHarm reduction - six insights
Harm reduction - six insights
Clive Bates
Global Forum on Nicotine 2016: What would good regulation look like
Global Forum on Nicotine 2016: What would good regulation look likeGlobal Forum on Nicotine 2016: What would good regulation look like
Global Forum on Nicotine 2016: What would good regulation look like
Clive Bates
The MRTP process - Seven provocations - FDLI webinar 30 July 2020
The MRTP process - Seven provocations - FDLI webinar 30 July 2020The MRTP process - Seven provocations - FDLI webinar 30 July 2020
The MRTP process - Seven provocations - FDLI webinar 30 July 2020
Clive Bates
Wells Fargo 2013
Wells Fargo 2013 Wells Fargo 2013
Wells Fargo 2013
Clive Bates
Competent or careless? Directions in European policy on low-risk nicotine pr...
Competent or careless?  Directions in European policy on low-risk nicotine pr...Competent or careless?  Directions in European policy on low-risk nicotine pr...
Competent or careless? Directions in European policy on low-risk nicotine pr...
Clive Bates
Effects of alternative nicotine delivery systems on cigarette consumption and...
Effects of alternative nicotine delivery systems on cigarette consumption and...Effects of alternative nicotine delivery systems on cigarette consumption and...
Effects of alternative nicotine delivery systems on cigarette consumption and...
Clive Bates
Tobacco harm reduction in the UK: e-cigarettes (EC) are making a difference
Tobacco harm reduction in the UK: e-cigarettes (EC) are making a differenceTobacco harm reduction in the UK: e-cigarettes (EC) are making a difference
Tobacco harm reduction in the UK: e-cigarettes (EC) are making a difference
Clive Bates
Wells Fargo 2014 E-cig conference - Bates
Wells Fargo 2014 E-cig conference - BatesWells Fargo 2014 E-cig conference - Bates
Wells Fargo 2014 E-cig conference - Bates
Clive Bates

Similar to FDLI - Lesson for the US from other jurisdictions - the United Kingdom -29 October 2021 (20)

African Harm Reduction Exchange - Dec 2022
African Harm Reduction Exchange - Dec 2022African Harm Reduction Exchange - Dec 2022
African Harm Reduction Exchange - Dec 2022
Clive Bates
Barriers and unintended consequences How poor regulation of low-risk alternat...
Barriers and unintended consequences How poor regulation of low-risk alternat...Barriers and unintended consequences How poor regulation of low-risk alternat...
Barriers and unintended consequences How poor regulation of low-risk alternat...
Clive Bates
Electronic Cigarette Regulations: When Less is More
Electronic Cigarette Regulations: When Less is MoreElectronic Cigarette Regulations: When Less is More
Electronic Cigarette Regulations: When Less is More
ecigarettesummit
Clive bates the royal society london 11 13
Clive bates the royal society london 11 13Clive bates the royal society london 11 13
Clive bates the royal society london 11 13
Brownstone Communications LLC
E-Cigarette Summit Speaker: Clive Bates
E-Cigarette Summit Speaker: Clive BatesE-Cigarette Summit Speaker: Clive Bates
E-Cigarette Summit Speaker: Clive Bates
Lindsay Fox
The end of what? UK E-cigarette Summit 2023
The end of what? UK E-cigarette Summit 2023The end of what? UK E-cigarette Summit 2023
The end of what? UK E-cigarette Summit 2023
Clive Bates
Vaping and Tobacco Harm Reduction
Vaping and Tobacco Harm ReductionVaping and Tobacco Harm Reduction
Vaping and Tobacco Harm Reduction
Clive Bates
US E-cigarette Summit: Taming the nicotine industrial complex
US E-cigarette Summit: Taming the nicotine industrial complexUS E-cigarette Summit: Taming the nicotine industrial complex
US E-cigarette Summit: Taming the nicotine industrial complex
Clive Bates
Why is FDA regulation such a mess
Why is FDA regulation such a messWhy is FDA regulation such a mess
Why is FDA regulation such a mess
Clive Bates
INDIAN TOBACCO
INDIAN TOBACCOINDIAN TOBACCO
INDIAN TOBACCO
NANDHA KUMAR
TOBACCO INDUSTRY IN Uk1
TOBACCO INDUSTRY IN Uk1TOBACCO INDUSTRY IN Uk1
TOBACCO INDUSTRY IN Uk1
Hardik Bendbar
The APPH Standard: What Does it Actually Mean?
The APPH Standard:  What Does it Actually Mean?The APPH Standard:  What Does it Actually Mean?
The APPH Standard: What Does it Actually Mean?
Clive Bates
Am叩rach Poll on E-Cigarettes June 2018
Am叩rach Poll on E-Cigarettes June 2018Am叩rach Poll on E-Cigarettes June 2018
Am叩rach Poll on E-Cigarettes June 2018
Amarach Research
dis
disdis
dis
Paige Heath
Tobacco Free Ireland - Fenton Howell
Tobacco Free Ireland - Fenton HowellTobacco Free Ireland - Fenton Howell
Tobacco Free Ireland - Fenton Howell
Institute of Public Health in Ireland
Tobacco Free Ireland- Fenton Howell
Tobacco Free Ireland- Fenton HowellTobacco Free Ireland- Fenton Howell
Tobacco Free Ireland- Fenton Howell
Institute of Public Health in Ireland
E-cigarettes: pros, cons and controversy
E-cigarettes: pros, cons and controversy E-cigarettes: pros, cons and controversy
E-cigarettes: pros, cons and controversy
Laura-Jane Smith
Tobacco advertising in china compared to thailand australia usa
Tobacco advertising in china compared to thailand australia usaTobacco advertising in china compared to thailand australia usa
Tobacco advertising in china compared to thailand australia usa
Alexander Li
GASO 11.20.2014 - The Tobacco Epidemic in the 21st Century
GASO 11.20.2014 - The Tobacco Epidemic in the 21st CenturyGASO 11.20.2014 - The Tobacco Epidemic in the 21st Century
GASO 11.20.2014 - The Tobacco Epidemic in the 21st Century
Georgia State School of Public Health
The tobacco products directive: an opportunity for a generation
The tobacco products directive: an opportunity for a generationThe tobacco products directive: an opportunity for a generation
The tobacco products directive: an opportunity for a generation
European Economic and Social Committee - SOC Section
African Harm Reduction Exchange - Dec 2022
African Harm Reduction Exchange - Dec 2022African Harm Reduction Exchange - Dec 2022
African Harm Reduction Exchange - Dec 2022
Clive Bates
Barriers and unintended consequences How poor regulation of low-risk alternat...
Barriers and unintended consequences How poor regulation of low-risk alternat...Barriers and unintended consequences How poor regulation of low-risk alternat...
Barriers and unintended consequences How poor regulation of low-risk alternat...
Clive Bates
Electronic Cigarette Regulations: When Less is More
Electronic Cigarette Regulations: When Less is MoreElectronic Cigarette Regulations: When Less is More
Electronic Cigarette Regulations: When Less is More
ecigarettesummit
E-Cigarette Summit Speaker: Clive Bates
E-Cigarette Summit Speaker: Clive BatesE-Cigarette Summit Speaker: Clive Bates
E-Cigarette Summit Speaker: Clive Bates
Lindsay Fox
The end of what? UK E-cigarette Summit 2023
The end of what? UK E-cigarette Summit 2023The end of what? UK E-cigarette Summit 2023
The end of what? UK E-cigarette Summit 2023
Clive Bates
Vaping and Tobacco Harm Reduction
Vaping and Tobacco Harm ReductionVaping and Tobacco Harm Reduction
Vaping and Tobacco Harm Reduction
Clive Bates
US E-cigarette Summit: Taming the nicotine industrial complex
US E-cigarette Summit: Taming the nicotine industrial complexUS E-cigarette Summit: Taming the nicotine industrial complex
US E-cigarette Summit: Taming the nicotine industrial complex
Clive Bates
Why is FDA regulation such a mess
Why is FDA regulation such a messWhy is FDA regulation such a mess
Why is FDA regulation such a mess
Clive Bates
TOBACCO INDUSTRY IN Uk1
TOBACCO INDUSTRY IN Uk1TOBACCO INDUSTRY IN Uk1
TOBACCO INDUSTRY IN Uk1
Hardik Bendbar
The APPH Standard: What Does it Actually Mean?
The APPH Standard:  What Does it Actually Mean?The APPH Standard:  What Does it Actually Mean?
The APPH Standard: What Does it Actually Mean?
Clive Bates
Am叩rach Poll on E-Cigarettes June 2018
Am叩rach Poll on E-Cigarettes June 2018Am叩rach Poll on E-Cigarettes June 2018
Am叩rach Poll on E-Cigarettes June 2018
Amarach Research
E-cigarettes: pros, cons and controversy
E-cigarettes: pros, cons and controversy E-cigarettes: pros, cons and controversy
E-cigarettes: pros, cons and controversy
Laura-Jane Smith
Tobacco advertising in china compared to thailand australia usa
Tobacco advertising in china compared to thailand australia usaTobacco advertising in china compared to thailand australia usa
Tobacco advertising in china compared to thailand australia usa
Alexander Li

Recently uploaded (20)

MORPHOLOGICAL FEATURES OF PNEUMONIA.....
MORPHOLOGICAL FEATURES OF PNEUMONIA.....MORPHOLOGICAL FEATURES OF PNEUMONIA.....
MORPHOLOGICAL FEATURES OF PNEUMONIA.....
maheenmazhar021
Tongue carcinoma presentation ENT
Tongue    carcinoma   presentation   ENTTongue    carcinoma   presentation   ENT
Tongue carcinoma presentation ENT
ENTHTJS
Dr. Jaymee Shells Perspective on COVID-19
Dr. Jaymee Shells Perspective on COVID-19Dr. Jaymee Shells Perspective on COVID-19
Dr. Jaymee Shells Perspective on COVID-19
Jaymee Shell
Sudurpaschim logsewa aayog Medical Officer 8th Level Curriculum
Sudurpaschim logsewa aayog Medical Officer 8th Level CurriculumSudurpaschim logsewa aayog Medical Officer 8th Level Curriculum
Sudurpaschim logsewa aayog Medical Officer 8th Level Curriculum
Dr Ovels
Increased Clinical Trial Complexity | Dr. Ulana Rey | MindLumina
Increased Clinical Trial Complexity | Dr. Ulana Rey | MindLuminaIncreased Clinical Trial Complexity | Dr. Ulana Rey | MindLumina
Increased Clinical Trial Complexity | Dr. Ulana Rey | MindLumina
Ulana Rey PharmD
4-PuroKalusugan 2025 DM 2025-0024 (1).pptx
4-PuroKalusugan 2025 DM 2025-0024 (1).pptx4-PuroKalusugan 2025 DM 2025-0024 (1).pptx
4-PuroKalusugan 2025 DM 2025-0024 (1).pptx
NashiedaLilangBuale
Characteristics and Criteria of Good Research.pptx
Characteristics and Criteria of Good Research.pptxCharacteristics and Criteria of Good Research.pptx
Characteristics and Criteria of Good Research.pptx
Dr. Binu Babu Nursing Lectures Incredibly Easy
4-PuroKalusugasan 2025 DM 2025-0024.pptx
4-PuroKalusugasan 2025 DM 2025-0024.pptx4-PuroKalusugasan 2025 DM 2025-0024.pptx
4-PuroKalusugasan 2025 DM 2025-0024.pptx
NashiedaLilangBuale
Modern Practice Principles in Lung CancerFirst Find the Targets, Then Treat ...
Modern Practice Principles in Lung CancerFirst Find the Targets, Then Treat ...Modern Practice Principles in Lung CancerFirst Find the Targets, Then Treat ...
Modern Practice Principles in Lung CancerFirst Find the Targets, Then Treat ...
PVI, PeerView Institute for Medical Education
One Health Rabies Control in Indonesia_APCAT meeting May 2022.pptx
One Health Rabies Control in Indonesia_APCAT meeting May 2022.pptxOne Health Rabies Control in Indonesia_APCAT meeting May 2022.pptx
One Health Rabies Control in Indonesia_APCAT meeting May 2022.pptx
Wahid Husein
ISPE Baseline PEG Volumen 7 Risk-Based Manufacture Pharmaceutical Products 2n...
ISPE Baseline PEG Volumen 7 Risk-Based Manufacture Pharmaceutical Products 2n...ISPE Baseline PEG Volumen 7 Risk-Based Manufacture Pharmaceutical Products 2n...
ISPE Baseline PEG Volumen 7 Risk-Based Manufacture Pharmaceutical Products 2n...
alokksharma18
HUMAN SEXUALITY AND SEXUAL RESPONCE CYCLE
HUMAN SEXUALITY AND SEXUAL RESPONCE CYCLEHUMAN SEXUALITY AND SEXUAL RESPONCE CYCLE
HUMAN SEXUALITY AND SEXUAL RESPONCE CYCLE
daminipatel37
Creatines Untold Story and How 30-Year-Old Lessons Can Shape the Future
Creatines Untold Story and How 30-Year-Old Lessons Can Shape the FutureCreatines Untold Story and How 30-Year-Old Lessons Can Shape the Future
Creatines Untold Story and How 30-Year-Old Lessons Can Shape the Future
Steve Jennings
Digestive Powerhouses: Liver, Gallbladder, and Pancreas for Nursing Students
Digestive Powerhouses: Liver, Gallbladder, and Pancreas for Nursing StudentsDigestive Powerhouses: Liver, Gallbladder, and Pancreas for Nursing Students
Digestive Powerhouses: Liver, Gallbladder, and Pancreas for Nursing Students
Viresh Mahajani
physiology 1 T3T4 & Jaundice & capillary circulation 愕悗悋.pptx
physiology 1 T3T4 & Jaundice & capillary circulation 愕悗悋.pptxphysiology 1 T3T4 & Jaundice & capillary circulation 愕悗悋.pptx
physiology 1 T3T4 & Jaundice & capillary circulation 愕悗悋.pptx
amralmohammady27
Renal Physiology - Regulation of GFR and RBF
Renal Physiology - Regulation of GFR and RBFRenal Physiology - Regulation of GFR and RBF
Renal Physiology - Regulation of GFR and RBF
MedicoseAcademics
Evidence - Based Practice - Nursing Research
Evidence - Based Practice - Nursing ResearchEvidence - Based Practice - Nursing Research
Evidence - Based Practice - Nursing Research
Dr. Binu Babu Nursing Lectures Incredibly Easy
Regulation of tubular reabsorption _AntiCopy.pdf
Regulation of tubular reabsorption _AntiCopy.pdfRegulation of tubular reabsorption _AntiCopy.pdf
Regulation of tubular reabsorption _AntiCopy.pdf
MedicoseAcademics
IMMUNO-ONCOLOGY DESCOVERING THE IMPORTANCE OF CLINICAL IMUNOLOGY IN MEDICINE
IMMUNO-ONCOLOGY  DESCOVERING THE IMPORTANCE OF CLINICAL IMUNOLOGY IN MEDICINEIMMUNO-ONCOLOGY  DESCOVERING THE IMPORTANCE OF CLINICAL IMUNOLOGY IN MEDICINE
IMMUNO-ONCOLOGY DESCOVERING THE IMPORTANCE OF CLINICAL IMUNOLOGY IN MEDICINE
RelianceNwosu
Research Problems - Nursing Research....
Research Problems - Nursing Research....Research Problems - Nursing Research....
Research Problems - Nursing Research....
Dr. Binu Babu Nursing Lectures Incredibly Easy
MORPHOLOGICAL FEATURES OF PNEUMONIA.....
MORPHOLOGICAL FEATURES OF PNEUMONIA.....MORPHOLOGICAL FEATURES OF PNEUMONIA.....
MORPHOLOGICAL FEATURES OF PNEUMONIA.....
maheenmazhar021
Tongue carcinoma presentation ENT
Tongue    carcinoma   presentation   ENTTongue    carcinoma   presentation   ENT
Tongue carcinoma presentation ENT
ENTHTJS
Dr. Jaymee Shells Perspective on COVID-19
Dr. Jaymee Shells Perspective on COVID-19Dr. Jaymee Shells Perspective on COVID-19
Dr. Jaymee Shells Perspective on COVID-19
Jaymee Shell
Sudurpaschim logsewa aayog Medical Officer 8th Level Curriculum
Sudurpaschim logsewa aayog Medical Officer 8th Level CurriculumSudurpaschim logsewa aayog Medical Officer 8th Level Curriculum
Sudurpaschim logsewa aayog Medical Officer 8th Level Curriculum
Dr Ovels
Increased Clinical Trial Complexity | Dr. Ulana Rey | MindLumina
Increased Clinical Trial Complexity | Dr. Ulana Rey | MindLuminaIncreased Clinical Trial Complexity | Dr. Ulana Rey | MindLumina
Increased Clinical Trial Complexity | Dr. Ulana Rey | MindLumina
Ulana Rey PharmD
4-PuroKalusugan 2025 DM 2025-0024 (1).pptx
4-PuroKalusugan 2025 DM 2025-0024 (1).pptx4-PuroKalusugan 2025 DM 2025-0024 (1).pptx
4-PuroKalusugan 2025 DM 2025-0024 (1).pptx
NashiedaLilangBuale
4-PuroKalusugasan 2025 DM 2025-0024.pptx
4-PuroKalusugasan 2025 DM 2025-0024.pptx4-PuroKalusugasan 2025 DM 2025-0024.pptx
4-PuroKalusugasan 2025 DM 2025-0024.pptx
NashiedaLilangBuale
One Health Rabies Control in Indonesia_APCAT meeting May 2022.pptx
One Health Rabies Control in Indonesia_APCAT meeting May 2022.pptxOne Health Rabies Control in Indonesia_APCAT meeting May 2022.pptx
One Health Rabies Control in Indonesia_APCAT meeting May 2022.pptx
Wahid Husein
ISPE Baseline PEG Volumen 7 Risk-Based Manufacture Pharmaceutical Products 2n...
ISPE Baseline PEG Volumen 7 Risk-Based Manufacture Pharmaceutical Products 2n...ISPE Baseline PEG Volumen 7 Risk-Based Manufacture Pharmaceutical Products 2n...
ISPE Baseline PEG Volumen 7 Risk-Based Manufacture Pharmaceutical Products 2n...
alokksharma18
HUMAN SEXUALITY AND SEXUAL RESPONCE CYCLE
HUMAN SEXUALITY AND SEXUAL RESPONCE CYCLEHUMAN SEXUALITY AND SEXUAL RESPONCE CYCLE
HUMAN SEXUALITY AND SEXUAL RESPONCE CYCLE
daminipatel37
Creatines Untold Story and How 30-Year-Old Lessons Can Shape the Future
Creatines Untold Story and How 30-Year-Old Lessons Can Shape the FutureCreatines Untold Story and How 30-Year-Old Lessons Can Shape the Future
Creatines Untold Story and How 30-Year-Old Lessons Can Shape the Future
Steve Jennings
Digestive Powerhouses: Liver, Gallbladder, and Pancreas for Nursing Students
Digestive Powerhouses: Liver, Gallbladder, and Pancreas for Nursing StudentsDigestive Powerhouses: Liver, Gallbladder, and Pancreas for Nursing Students
Digestive Powerhouses: Liver, Gallbladder, and Pancreas for Nursing Students
Viresh Mahajani
physiology 1 T3T4 & Jaundice & capillary circulation 愕悗悋.pptx
physiology 1 T3T4 & Jaundice & capillary circulation 愕悗悋.pptxphysiology 1 T3T4 & Jaundice & capillary circulation 愕悗悋.pptx
physiology 1 T3T4 & Jaundice & capillary circulation 愕悗悋.pptx
amralmohammady27
Renal Physiology - Regulation of GFR and RBF
Renal Physiology - Regulation of GFR and RBFRenal Physiology - Regulation of GFR and RBF
Renal Physiology - Regulation of GFR and RBF
MedicoseAcademics
Regulation of tubular reabsorption _AntiCopy.pdf
Regulation of tubular reabsorption _AntiCopy.pdfRegulation of tubular reabsorption _AntiCopy.pdf
Regulation of tubular reabsorption _AntiCopy.pdf
MedicoseAcademics
IMMUNO-ONCOLOGY DESCOVERING THE IMPORTANCE OF CLINICAL IMUNOLOGY IN MEDICINE
IMMUNO-ONCOLOGY  DESCOVERING THE IMPORTANCE OF CLINICAL IMUNOLOGY IN MEDICINEIMMUNO-ONCOLOGY  DESCOVERING THE IMPORTANCE OF CLINICAL IMUNOLOGY IN MEDICINE
IMMUNO-ONCOLOGY DESCOVERING THE IMPORTANCE OF CLINICAL IMUNOLOGY IN MEDICINE
RelianceNwosu

FDLI - Lesson for the US from other jurisdictions - the United Kingdom -29 October 2021

  • 1. What Can We Learn from Alternative Nicotine Product Usage in Other Countries? United Kingdom Clive Bates Counterfactual Consulting, London FDLI Tobacco and Nicotine Products Regulation and Policy Conference 29 October 2021
  • 2. Smoking and vaping 2019 Great Britain (ONS) ONS, E-cigarette use in Great Britain in 2019, July 2020 ~3m vapers ~8m smokers 2
  • 3. 2030 goal make smoking products obsolete 5% prevalence Two-thirds cut 3 ONS, E-cigarette use in Great Britain in 2019, July 2020
  • 4. 10-year adult smoking prevalence trend 4 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 % cigarette smokers (3 month moving average) ~One-third cut University College London, Smoking in England, Smoking Toolkit Survey, 2020 (England)
  • 5. Adult e-cigarette users by smoking status, Great Britain 2014-21 Dual use in context Dual use has declined over time Source: Action on Smoking and Health (UK) and YouGov - E-cigarette Use By Adults 2021
  • 6. UK compared to USA 1. Split competence / Brexit
  • 7. UK compared to USA 1. Split competence / Brexit 2. Notification vs authorisation
  • 8. UK compared to USA 1. Split competence / Brexit 2. Notification vs authorisation 3. Category-wide approach
  • 9. UK compared to USA 1. Split competence / Brexit 2. Notification vs authorisation 3. Category-wide approach 4. Product standards
  • 10. UK compared to USA 1. Split competence / Brexit 2. Notification vs authorisation 3. Category-wide approach 4. Product standards Notification ingredients, toxicology, pharmacology, production process Technical design restrictions and requirements Leaflet, packaging and warning Advertising, promotion, sponsorship Cross border sales Disclosure commercial data Market surveillance Public disclosure of commercial data Surveillance for adverse effects
  • 11. UK compared to USA 1. Split competence / Brexit 2. Notification vs authorisation 3. Category-wide approach 4. Product standards 5. Nicotine cap Max 20mg/ml (~2%) This concentration allows for a delivery of nicotine that is comparable to the permitted dose of nicotine derived from a standard cigarette during the time needed to smoke such a cigarette. Source: TPD 20(3)(b) TPD recital 38
  • 12. UK compared to USA 1. Split competence / Brexit 2. Notification vs authorisation 3. Category-wide approach 4. Product standards 5. Nicotine cap 6. Marketing restrictions Cross border advertising promotion and sponsorship for all tobacco and vaping products is prohibited at EU level. Source: Tobacco Advertising Directive 2002, TPD Article 20(5)
  • 13. UK compared to USA 1. Split competence / Brexit 2. Notification vs authorisation 3. Category-wide approach 4. Product standards 5. Nicotine cap 6. Marketing restrictions Dont be socially irresponsible Dont target or feature children Dont confuse e-cigarettes with tobacco products Dont make health or safety claims Dont make smoking cessation claims Dont mislead about product ingredients Dont mislead about where products may be use
  • 14. UK compared to USA 1. Split competence / Brexit 2. Notification vs authorisation 3. Category-wide approach 4. Product standards 5. Nicotine cap 6. Marketing restrictions 7. Reduced risk claims Manufacturers must not suggest: that a particular tobacco product is less harmful than others or aims to reduce the effect of some harmful components of smoke Source: TPD 13(1)(b) applied to vaping products via 20(4)(b)(ii)
  • 15. UK compared to USA 1. Split competence / Brexit 2. Notification vs authorisation 3. Category-wide approach 4. Product standards 5. Nicotine cap 6. Marketing restrictions 7. Reduced risk claims 8. Tax 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 United Kingdom United States Price of 20 Marlboro USD Source: Numbeo
  • 16. Major difference in UK 1. Split competence / Brexit 2. Notification vs authorisation 3. Category-wide approach 4. Product standards 5. Nicotine cap 6. Marketing restrictions 7. Reduced risk claims 8. Tax 9. Attitude
  • 17. UK compared to USA 1. Split competence / Brexit 2. Notification vs authorisation 3. Category-wide approach 4. Product standards 5. Nicotine cap 6. Marketing restrictions 7. Reduced risk claims 8. Tax 9. Attitude Thank you! Clive Bates Counterfactual clivedbates@gmail.com www.clivebates.com @clive_bates