際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
Innovative Public Engagement Techniques for Transportation Projects December 9 th , 2010
Agenda Welcome Formal Presentation Interactive Workshop Participant Follow-up Dissemination of Materials via Streetwise
Presentation Development Process Insights Gained from Across North America and Australia Participation on the TRB Visualization, Public Involvement, and Access Management Committees Discussions with Clients and Teaming Partners Continuous Development of the Process
Work Samples Majority of work samples are our own Due to the time-sensitive nature of public involvement and lack of way to discover past efforts Wed like to collaborate, learn as much from you as otherwise Provide your examples In the informal workshop after the presentation Online at  http://streetwise.kittelson.com/ Lets keep the discussion going after the workshop
Public Involvement vs. Engagement Informed, Educated, and Actively Engaged Stakeholders Transparent Process  Breadcrumb Test Compliant
油
Storyboarding Public Engagement Scripting the Process Upfront Do you understand how the story will unfold from start to finish? Things to ask yourself about all meetings, workshops, virtual workshops, web interactions, and open houses What is the objective of the engagement?油  How will you engage the participants?油  Who is your audience? What questions are likely to come from participants?油 What are the likely action items from these engagements and schedule to achieving those items? Where do you want the process to go from that meeting?
Storyboarding the Process to the Public Answering the Who, What, Why, Where, and How
油
油
Maintaining Transparency Peoples interests are fleeting. Capture it once. Push communications bring the future generations their information. Its easy to communicate in all formats people find comfortable: In person, via email, online, facebook, twitter
Alternative Development Tools
Alternative Development Tools
IAMP Tools
Example IAMP Design Tool Scaled to match the aerial Shows common measurements such as minimum ramp lengths, loop ramp radii, access spacing standards, etc.
How to Use the Tool
油
IAMP Breadcrumb Test Example Compliance with Breadcrumb Test (Part 1) Why this crossroad location? Why this interchange form? Why this local circulation plan? Why this access management plan? (Part 2)  Why not this? Why not this crossroad location? Why not this interchange form? Why not this local circulation plan? Why not this access management plan?
Breadcrumb Approach
Staging Venues for Optimal Performance Transforming the Environment  Developing a Playbook Create a Learning Environment to Form Concepts & Opinions Develop Brick and Mortar and Online Venues
油
油
Use of Icons and Colors Corridor Alignment Streetscape Features Land Use/ Transportation Integration  Project Implementation
油
Interactive 3-D Models
油
油
172 nd  / 190 th  Corridor Plan Why here? Why now?
Website Demonstrations US20: Pioneer Mountain to Eddyville http://us20pme.com/ Tigard Trails Public Drawing Tool http://prj.kittelson.com/tigardtrails 172 nd /190 th  Corridor Plan Virtual Workshops http://voh.172nd.com/   http://vw3.project.kittelson.com/ Interactive Transportation System Plan http://monmouth.project.kittelson.com/
Lessons Learned From Online Public Involvement Consistency is hard Providing a personal experience is hard Lack of search standings due to time-limited nature of public involvement Including discovery of past efforts and achievements by the industry Different people Less vocal minority More guided experience for those without vested, immediate experience necessary
Emerging Trends Interest in moving more public involvement onto the internet Passive forms of communication are commonplace for younger generations Phone calls -> Text Messages Telling people about their life -> Facebook Technology and computers have caught up to provide rich, interactive experiences Nothing replaces human-to-human communication
Other Resources http:// choosingviz.org / Visualization tools list http://www.trbvis.org/ TRB visualization committee http://www.trbpi.com TRB public involvement committee http://mapnificent.net Online mapping website
Demonstration Projects  Louisville, CO
Demonstration Projects
Demonstration Projects
Demonstration Projects
Next Stage of Active Engagement? + +
Workshop Overview Workshop Directions Refreshment Stop Workshop Participation Green Group  Website Tools (Green Room) Yellow Group  Tools and Models (Yellow Room) Red Group  3-D Models (Red Room)
Next Steps Send your Favorite Examples to Streetwise by  December 17 th   Kyle will summarize the examples and share them with the Group Kyle will provide a TRB Update in early February

More Related Content

What's hot (7)

The Time of Our Lives: Understanding Irreversible Complex User Experiences
The Time of Our Lives: Understanding Irreversible Complex User ExperiencesThe Time of Our Lives: Understanding Irreversible Complex User Experiences
The Time of Our Lives: Understanding Irreversible Complex User Experiences
David Kreps
Digital scholarship keynote
Digital scholarship keynoteDigital scholarship keynote
Digital scholarship keynote
Martin Weller
eme2040 Day One 15 May2008
eme2040 Day One 15 May2008eme2040 Day One 15 May2008
eme2040 Day One 15 May2008
Christopher Sessums
MOOCs - how to live with them and love them
MOOCs - how to live with them and love themMOOCs - how to live with them and love them
MOOCs - how to live with them and love them
Stephen Haggard
Piet Kommers (IDS3CI - 2013)
Piet Kommers (IDS3CI - 2013)Piet Kommers (IDS3CI - 2013)
Piet Kommers (IDS3CI - 2013)
ITEA Conferences
Virtual Environments and the Future of Collaboration
Virtual Environments and the Future of CollaborationVirtual Environments and the Future of Collaboration
Virtual Environments and the Future of Collaboration
Eric Meyer
technology and Collaboration
technology and Collaborationtechnology and Collaboration
technology and Collaboration
sam ran
The Time of Our Lives: Understanding Irreversible Complex User Experiences
The Time of Our Lives: Understanding Irreversible Complex User ExperiencesThe Time of Our Lives: Understanding Irreversible Complex User Experiences
The Time of Our Lives: Understanding Irreversible Complex User Experiences
David Kreps
Digital scholarship keynote
Digital scholarship keynoteDigital scholarship keynote
Digital scholarship keynote
Martin Weller
MOOCs - how to live with them and love them
MOOCs - how to live with them and love themMOOCs - how to live with them and love them
MOOCs - how to live with them and love them
Stephen Haggard
Piet Kommers (IDS3CI - 2013)
Piet Kommers (IDS3CI - 2013)Piet Kommers (IDS3CI - 2013)
Piet Kommers (IDS3CI - 2013)
ITEA Conferences
Virtual Environments and the Future of Collaboration
Virtual Environments and the Future of CollaborationVirtual Environments and the Future of Collaboration
Virtual Environments and the Future of Collaboration
Eric Meyer
technology and Collaboration
technology and Collaborationtechnology and Collaboration
technology and Collaboration
sam ran

Viewers also liked (8)

Cleveland Avenue Bus Rapid Transit Public Meeting - July 15, 2014
Cleveland Avenue Bus Rapid Transit Public Meeting - July 15, 2014Cleveland Avenue Bus Rapid Transit Public Meeting - July 15, 2014
Cleveland Avenue Bus Rapid Transit Public Meeting - July 15, 2014
COTA BUS
Atlantic Highway - Norway
Atlantic Highway - NorwayAtlantic Highway - Norway
Atlantic Highway - Norway
Kittelson 際際滷s
Reliability Workshop Presentation
Reliability Workshop PresentationReliability Workshop Presentation
Reliability Workshop Presentation
Kittelson 際際滷s
Public Workshop #5
Public Workshop #5Public Workshop #5
Public Workshop #5
Kittelson 際際滷s
FPMweb overview
FPMweb overviewFPMweb overview
FPMweb overview
Kittelson 際際滷s
TSMO & Reliability
TSMO & ReliabilityTSMO & Reliability
TSMO & Reliability
Kittelson 際際滷s
Planning for operations 3-31-2011
Planning for operations 3-31-2011Planning for operations 3-31-2011
Planning for operations 3-31-2011
Kittelson 際際滷s
Public Workshop #1
Public Workshop #1Public Workshop #1
Public Workshop #1
Kittelson 際際滷s
Cleveland Avenue Bus Rapid Transit Public Meeting - July 15, 2014
Cleveland Avenue Bus Rapid Transit Public Meeting - July 15, 2014Cleveland Avenue Bus Rapid Transit Public Meeting - July 15, 2014
Cleveland Avenue Bus Rapid Transit Public Meeting - July 15, 2014
COTA BUS
Reliability Workshop Presentation
Reliability Workshop PresentationReliability Workshop Presentation
Reliability Workshop Presentation
Kittelson 際際滷s
Planning for operations 3-31-2011
Planning for operations 3-31-2011Planning for operations 3-31-2011
Planning for operations 3-31-2011
Kittelson 際際滷s

Similar to Innovative Public Engagement Techniques (20)

Future E Government Conference 2009
Future E Government Conference 2009Future E Government Conference 2009
Future E Government Conference 2009
Catherine Howe
Collective Intelligence and Online Deliberation Platforms for Citizen Engagem...
Collective Intelligence and Online Deliberation Platforms for Citizen Engagem...Collective Intelligence and Online Deliberation Platforms for Citizen Engagem...
Collective Intelligence and Online Deliberation Platforms for Citizen Engagem...
Anna De Liddo
Zonta Area 3&4 2009 Spring Workshop
Zonta Area 3&4 2009 Spring WorkshopZonta Area 3&4 2009 Spring Workshop
Zonta Area 3&4 2009 Spring Workshop
Marta Calderon
Scrutiny in the spotlight: Networked Councillors and the Scrutiny process
Scrutiny in the spotlight:  Networked Councillors and the Scrutiny processScrutiny in the spotlight:  Networked Councillors and the Scrutiny process
Scrutiny in the spotlight: Networked Councillors and the Scrutiny process
Catherine Howe
web conferencing
web conferencingweb conferencing
web conferencing
u082934
next generation technologies to build sustainable communities of practice
next generation technologies to build sustainable communities of practicenext generation technologies to build sustainable communities of practice
next generation technologies to build sustainable communities of practice
George Roberts
Anders - ABC15 - FavNextBigThings.pptx
Anders - ABC15 - FavNextBigThings.pptxAnders - ABC15 - FavNextBigThings.pptx
Anders - ABC15 - FavNextBigThings.pptx
Abram Anders
Mb Pd Draft Presentation
Mb Pd Draft PresentationMb Pd Draft Presentation
Mb Pd Draft Presentation
melmb3
MHIT 603: Introduction to Interaction Design
MHIT 603: Introduction to Interaction DesignMHIT 603: Introduction to Interaction Design
MHIT 603: Introduction to Interaction Design
Mark Billinghurst
Poll everywhere presentation
Poll everywhere presentationPoll everywhere presentation
Poll everywhere presentation
dwalke17
Navca Sw Regional Champions Presentation
Navca Sw Regional Champions PresentationNavca Sw Regional Champions Presentation
Navca Sw Regional Champions Presentation
Julie Hawker
Web conferencing
Web conferencingWeb conferencing
Web conferencing
mazyooonah
web confrancing
web confrancingweb confrancing
web confrancing
u082934
Top Ten Digital Engagement Tools - WASHTO 2013 Annual Meeting
Top Ten Digital Engagement Tools - WASHTO 2013 Annual MeetingTop Ten Digital Engagement Tools - WASHTO 2013 Annual Meeting
Top Ten Digital Engagement Tools - WASHTO 2013 Annual Meeting
krmobley1
Enterprise User Experience in Higher Education
Enterprise User Experience in Higher EducationEnterprise User Experience in Higher Education
Enterprise User Experience in Higher Education
Tarik (Rick) Dzekman
Characterizing Online Participation in Civic Technologies - PhD
Characterizing Online Participation in Civic Technologies - PhDCharacterizing Online Participation in Civic Technologies - PhD
Characterizing Online Participation in Civic Technologies - PhD
Pablo Arag坦n
Evaluating crowdsourcing websites
Evaluating crowdsourcing websitesEvaluating crowdsourcing websites
Evaluating crowdsourcing websites
donellemckinley
Institutional Change - Emerge ALT-C09
Institutional Change - Emerge ALT-C09Institutional Change - Emerge ALT-C09
Institutional Change - Emerge ALT-C09
George Roberts
Human factor in big data qrowd bdve
Human factor in big data qrowd bdveHuman factor in big data qrowd bdve
Human factor in big data qrowd bdve
Luis Daniel Ib叩単ez
Web conferencing
Web conferencingWeb conferencing
Web conferencing
mazyooonah
Future E Government Conference 2009
Future E Government Conference 2009Future E Government Conference 2009
Future E Government Conference 2009
Catherine Howe
Collective Intelligence and Online Deliberation Platforms for Citizen Engagem...
Collective Intelligence and Online Deliberation Platforms for Citizen Engagem...Collective Intelligence and Online Deliberation Platforms for Citizen Engagem...
Collective Intelligence and Online Deliberation Platforms for Citizen Engagem...
Anna De Liddo
Zonta Area 3&4 2009 Spring Workshop
Zonta Area 3&4 2009 Spring WorkshopZonta Area 3&4 2009 Spring Workshop
Zonta Area 3&4 2009 Spring Workshop
Marta Calderon
Scrutiny in the spotlight: Networked Councillors and the Scrutiny process
Scrutiny in the spotlight:  Networked Councillors and the Scrutiny processScrutiny in the spotlight:  Networked Councillors and the Scrutiny process
Scrutiny in the spotlight: Networked Councillors and the Scrutiny process
Catherine Howe
web conferencing
web conferencingweb conferencing
web conferencing
u082934
next generation technologies to build sustainable communities of practice
next generation technologies to build sustainable communities of practicenext generation technologies to build sustainable communities of practice
next generation technologies to build sustainable communities of practice
George Roberts
Anders - ABC15 - FavNextBigThings.pptx
Anders - ABC15 - FavNextBigThings.pptxAnders - ABC15 - FavNextBigThings.pptx
Anders - ABC15 - FavNextBigThings.pptx
Abram Anders
Mb Pd Draft Presentation
Mb Pd Draft PresentationMb Pd Draft Presentation
Mb Pd Draft Presentation
melmb3
MHIT 603: Introduction to Interaction Design
MHIT 603: Introduction to Interaction DesignMHIT 603: Introduction to Interaction Design
MHIT 603: Introduction to Interaction Design
Mark Billinghurst
Poll everywhere presentation
Poll everywhere presentationPoll everywhere presentation
Poll everywhere presentation
dwalke17
Navca Sw Regional Champions Presentation
Navca Sw Regional Champions PresentationNavca Sw Regional Champions Presentation
Navca Sw Regional Champions Presentation
Julie Hawker
Web conferencing
Web conferencingWeb conferencing
Web conferencing
mazyooonah
web confrancing
web confrancingweb confrancing
web confrancing
u082934
Top Ten Digital Engagement Tools - WASHTO 2013 Annual Meeting
Top Ten Digital Engagement Tools - WASHTO 2013 Annual MeetingTop Ten Digital Engagement Tools - WASHTO 2013 Annual Meeting
Top Ten Digital Engagement Tools - WASHTO 2013 Annual Meeting
krmobley1
Enterprise User Experience in Higher Education
Enterprise User Experience in Higher EducationEnterprise User Experience in Higher Education
Enterprise User Experience in Higher Education
Tarik (Rick) Dzekman
Characterizing Online Participation in Civic Technologies - PhD
Characterizing Online Participation in Civic Technologies - PhDCharacterizing Online Participation in Civic Technologies - PhD
Characterizing Online Participation in Civic Technologies - PhD
Pablo Arag坦n
Evaluating crowdsourcing websites
Evaluating crowdsourcing websitesEvaluating crowdsourcing websites
Evaluating crowdsourcing websites
donellemckinley
Institutional Change - Emerge ALT-C09
Institutional Change - Emerge ALT-C09Institutional Change - Emerge ALT-C09
Institutional Change - Emerge ALT-C09
George Roberts
Human factor in big data qrowd bdve
Human factor in big data qrowd bdveHuman factor in big data qrowd bdve
Human factor in big data qrowd bdve
Luis Daniel Ib叩単ez
Web conferencing
Web conferencingWeb conferencing
Web conferencing
mazyooonah

More from Kittelson 際際滷s (17)

CNU Planning Guidance
CNU Planning GuidanceCNU Planning Guidance
CNU Planning Guidance
Kittelson 際際滷s
St johns farmers market postcard
St johns farmers market postcardSt johns farmers market postcard
St johns farmers market postcard
Kittelson 際際滷s
Livability
LivabilityLivability
Livability
Kittelson 際際滷s
Public Workshop #4
Public Workshop #4Public Workshop #4
Public Workshop #4
Kittelson 際際滷s
Public Workshop #3
Public Workshop #3Public Workshop #3
Public Workshop #3
Kittelson 際際滷s
Public Workshop #3
Public Workshop #3Public Workshop #3
Public Workshop #3
Kittelson 際際滷s
Public Workshop #2
Public Workshop #2Public Workshop #2
Public Workshop #2
Kittelson 際際滷s
Kittelson Workshop: Road Safety Audit
Kittelson Workshop: Road Safety AuditKittelson Workshop: Road Safety Audit
Kittelson Workshop: Road Safety Audit
Kittelson 際際滷s
Complete Streets workshop presentation
Complete Streets workshop presentationComplete Streets workshop presentation
Complete Streets workshop presentation
Kittelson 際際滷s
Performance Based Analysis & Practical Design
Performance Based Analysis & Practical DesignPerformance Based Analysis & Practical Design
Performance Based Analysis & Practical Design
Kittelson 際際滷s
2010 Highway Capacity Manual
2010 Highway Capacity Manual2010 Highway Capacity Manual
2010 Highway Capacity Manual
Kittelson 際際滷s
Planning for Operations
Planning for OperationsPlanning for Operations
Planning for Operations
Kittelson 際際滷s
Darcy Bullock Presentation 2-3-10
Darcy Bullock Presentation 2-3-10Darcy Bullock Presentation 2-3-10
Darcy Bullock Presentation 2-3-10
Kittelson 際際滷s
KAI - Arterial Performance Measures 02-03-10
KAI - Arterial Performance Measures 02-03-10KAI - Arterial Performance Measures 02-03-10
KAI - Arterial Performance Measures 02-03-10
Kittelson 際際滷s
KAI - Pedestrian Mid Block Crossings Presentation
KAI - Pedestrian Mid Block Crossings PresentationKAI - Pedestrian Mid Block Crossings Presentation
KAI - Pedestrian Mid Block Crossings Presentation
Kittelson 際際滷s
Train Arrival Times At Highway Railroad Grade Crossing
Train Arrival Times At Highway Railroad Grade CrossingTrain Arrival Times At Highway Railroad Grade Crossing
Train Arrival Times At Highway Railroad Grade Crossing
Kittelson 際際滷s
KAI - Modern Urban Roundabouts
KAI - Modern Urban RoundaboutsKAI - Modern Urban Roundabouts
KAI - Modern Urban Roundabouts
Kittelson 際際滷s

Innovative Public Engagement Techniques

  • 1. Innovative Public Engagement Techniques for Transportation Projects December 9 th , 2010
  • 2. Agenda Welcome Formal Presentation Interactive Workshop Participant Follow-up Dissemination of Materials via Streetwise
  • 3. Presentation Development Process Insights Gained from Across North America and Australia Participation on the TRB Visualization, Public Involvement, and Access Management Committees Discussions with Clients and Teaming Partners Continuous Development of the Process
  • 4. Work Samples Majority of work samples are our own Due to the time-sensitive nature of public involvement and lack of way to discover past efforts Wed like to collaborate, learn as much from you as otherwise Provide your examples In the informal workshop after the presentation Online at http://streetwise.kittelson.com/ Lets keep the discussion going after the workshop
  • 5. Public Involvement vs. Engagement Informed, Educated, and Actively Engaged Stakeholders Transparent Process Breadcrumb Test Compliant
  • 6.
  • 7. Storyboarding Public Engagement Scripting the Process Upfront Do you understand how the story will unfold from start to finish? Things to ask yourself about all meetings, workshops, virtual workshops, web interactions, and open houses What is the objective of the engagement?油 How will you engage the participants?油 Who is your audience? What questions are likely to come from participants?油 What are the likely action items from these engagements and schedule to achieving those items? Where do you want the process to go from that meeting?
  • 8. Storyboarding the Process to the Public Answering the Who, What, Why, Where, and How
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11. Maintaining Transparency Peoples interests are fleeting. Capture it once. Push communications bring the future generations their information. Its easy to communicate in all formats people find comfortable: In person, via email, online, facebook, twitter
  • 15. Example IAMP Design Tool Scaled to match the aerial Shows common measurements such as minimum ramp lengths, loop ramp radii, access spacing standards, etc.
  • 16. How to Use the Tool
  • 17.
  • 18. IAMP Breadcrumb Test Example Compliance with Breadcrumb Test (Part 1) Why this crossroad location? Why this interchange form? Why this local circulation plan? Why this access management plan? (Part 2) Why not this? Why not this crossroad location? Why not this interchange form? Why not this local circulation plan? Why not this access management plan?
  • 20. Staging Venues for Optimal Performance Transforming the Environment Developing a Playbook Create a Learning Environment to Form Concepts & Opinions Develop Brick and Mortar and Online Venues
  • 21.
  • 22.
  • 23. Use of Icons and Colors Corridor Alignment Streetscape Features Land Use/ Transportation Integration Project Implementation
  • 24.
  • 26.
  • 27.
  • 28. 172 nd / 190 th Corridor Plan Why here? Why now?
  • 29. Website Demonstrations US20: Pioneer Mountain to Eddyville http://us20pme.com/ Tigard Trails Public Drawing Tool http://prj.kittelson.com/tigardtrails 172 nd /190 th Corridor Plan Virtual Workshops http://voh.172nd.com/ http://vw3.project.kittelson.com/ Interactive Transportation System Plan http://monmouth.project.kittelson.com/
  • 30. Lessons Learned From Online Public Involvement Consistency is hard Providing a personal experience is hard Lack of search standings due to time-limited nature of public involvement Including discovery of past efforts and achievements by the industry Different people Less vocal minority More guided experience for those without vested, immediate experience necessary
  • 31. Emerging Trends Interest in moving more public involvement onto the internet Passive forms of communication are commonplace for younger generations Phone calls -> Text Messages Telling people about their life -> Facebook Technology and computers have caught up to provide rich, interactive experiences Nothing replaces human-to-human communication
  • 32. Other Resources http:// choosingviz.org / Visualization tools list http://www.trbvis.org/ TRB visualization committee http://www.trbpi.com TRB public involvement committee http://mapnificent.net Online mapping website
  • 33. Demonstration Projects Louisville, CO
  • 37. Next Stage of Active Engagement? + +
  • 38. Workshop Overview Workshop Directions Refreshment Stop Workshop Participation Green Group Website Tools (Green Room) Yellow Group Tools and Models (Yellow Room) Red Group 3-D Models (Red Room)
  • 39. Next Steps Send your Favorite Examples to Streetwise by December 17 th Kyle will summarize the examples and share them with the Group Kyle will provide a TRB Update in early February

Editor's Notes

  • #8: Things to ask yourself about all meetings, workshops, and open houses What is the objective of the meeting?油 >油 What does your client need out of it?油 What do the other participants need out of it?油 What do you need out of it? What is the best medium(s) (aerials, handouts, PowerPoint, animation, etc.) to use to describe the issue, solution, etc. How many people will there be?油 How many handouts do I need? What are the likely questions that will come from each individual?油 Is there additional materials that could be used to address these issues? What are the likely action items and schedule to achieving those items? Where do you want the process to go from that meeting?油油 Have you set up the agenda and provided the right information prior to or during the meeting to achieve that direction?
  • #19: Discuss Matts IAMP Graphic on the Wall
  • #21: Discuss Tools