際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
Joseph Higgins
ATEC 3352
Benchmark Portfolio Deck
Player Pain Points
While the UI of the Witcher 3 is
good, there are issues that players
have encountered.
 Too many HUD options
 HUD controls not needed
 Lack of item descriptions
 Unneeded world interactions
However the focus of my redesign
will be focused on the HUD
Which Player types buy the Witcher 3?
Explorers 80% Achievers 20%
Suffering Player Demographic: Explorers
 Disrupted Immersion
 Too many HUD
features
 Unnecessary Text
 Poor HUD framing
What do explorers
look for in a game?
 Drawn to discovery
 Enjoy the experience of the world
story
 Seek after side quests and their
own subtle narratives
 Finding new witcher contracts
 Discovering what each marker
has in store for the player
Causes of Disrupted Immersion
 HUD Framing - The games UI isnt flush against the edges of the player view.
Causing more space to be obstructed from the noise of the UI elements.
 Information Load - The game provides information such as button commands,
multiple items, combat log, map, time of day, distance from objective, and
player statistics all at once.
Current Design
UI Frame
Here we see a
small bit of screen
lost because of the
UI frame.
Unfortunately this
wastes space and
reduces how much
the player may see.
Unnecessary Information pt.1
The game provides button commands the
entire game. At a certain point this is simply
takes up player space and is unused.
These visual cues unfortunately lose their
usefulness as the player becomes more familiar
with the game.
Unnecessary Information pt.2
Time
The time of day is also given to the player. It is
never needed to understand the time of day.
Items
The game provides 5 item slots and keys that
fail to map similarly to the keyboard.
Also the text for each item adds more clutter to
the screen.
Design Solution from BloodBorne: Items
Bloodborne (as seen on the
right) only shows text for the
currently selected item. IT
reduces screen clutter and
streamlines on the spot
inventory uses.
BloodBorne
Proposed Design
Comparison
 The proposed design solution allows for the player to see more and reduces the noise from the poor
framing of the UI elements.

More Related Content

What's hot (20)

Video game proposal
Video game proposalVideo game proposal
Video game proposal
missstevenson01
UWP Adaptive UI
UWP Adaptive UIUWP Adaptive UI
UWP Adaptive UI
James Quick
4 lecture (mda frame work) 25 1-2021
4 lecture (mda frame work) 25 1-20214 lecture (mda frame work) 25 1-2021
4 lecture (mda frame work) 25 1-2021
Durgesh Pandey
Game design doc template
Game design doc   templateGame design doc   template
Game design doc template
davewilliamharrison
How to deliver a game in kodu
How to deliver a game in koduHow to deliver a game in kodu
How to deliver a game in kodu
Nour Khouja
Android game -english11
Android game -english11Android game -english11
Android game -english11
tonychan1972
6 lecture (game elements ) 2 2-2021
6 lecture (game elements ) 2 2-20216 lecture (game elements ) 2 2-2021
6 lecture (game elements ) 2 2-2021
Durgesh Pandey
Game design document
Game design document Game design document
Game design document
ARshut Syabrin
Games Design Document
Games Design DocumentGames Design Document
Games Design Document
missstevenson01
LAFS PREPRO Session 7 - Game Audio and Levels
LAFS PREPRO Session 7 - Game Audio and LevelsLAFS PREPRO Session 7 - Game Audio and Levels
LAFS PREPRO Session 7 - Game Audio and Levels
David Mullich
LAFS Game Design 1 - Dynamic Elements
LAFS Game Design 1 - Dynamic ElementsLAFS Game Design 1 - Dynamic Elements
LAFS Game Design 1 - Dynamic Elements
David Mullich
Ai on video games
Ai on video gamesAi on video games
Ai on video games
Faria Priya
Pergames2005 Paper
Pergames2005 PaperPergames2005 Paper
Pergames2005 Paper
Trond Nilsen
1. case study
1. case study1. case study
1. case study
Louis Robinson
Sims game genre
Sims game genreSims game genre
Sims game genre
Tara Peak
Game Design 2: Lecture 9 - Immersion through UI
Game Design 2: Lecture 9 - Immersion through UIGame Design 2: Lecture 9 - Immersion through UI
Game Design 2: Lecture 9 - Immersion through UI
David Farrell
Game classifications
Game classificationsGame classifications
Game classifications
Yhen Celeste
Introduction To 3D Gaming
Introduction To 3D GamingIntroduction To 3D Gaming
Introduction To 3D Gaming
Clint Edmonson
2. initial plans (1)
2. initial plans (1)2. initial plans (1)
2. initial plans (1)
Patrick-Colman1
2 lecture (gdd, responsibilites, level of game) 18 1-2021
2 lecture (gdd, responsibilites, level of game) 18 1-20212 lecture (gdd, responsibilites, level of game) 18 1-2021
2 lecture (gdd, responsibilites, level of game) 18 1-2021
Durgesh Pandey
UWP Adaptive UI
UWP Adaptive UIUWP Adaptive UI
UWP Adaptive UI
James Quick
4 lecture (mda frame work) 25 1-2021
4 lecture (mda frame work) 25 1-20214 lecture (mda frame work) 25 1-2021
4 lecture (mda frame work) 25 1-2021
Durgesh Pandey
How to deliver a game in kodu
How to deliver a game in koduHow to deliver a game in kodu
How to deliver a game in kodu
Nour Khouja
Android game -english11
Android game -english11Android game -english11
Android game -english11
tonychan1972
6 lecture (game elements ) 2 2-2021
6 lecture (game elements ) 2 2-20216 lecture (game elements ) 2 2-2021
6 lecture (game elements ) 2 2-2021
Durgesh Pandey
Game design document
Game design document Game design document
Game design document
ARshut Syabrin
Games Design Document
Games Design DocumentGames Design Document
Games Design Document
missstevenson01
LAFS PREPRO Session 7 - Game Audio and Levels
LAFS PREPRO Session 7 - Game Audio and LevelsLAFS PREPRO Session 7 - Game Audio and Levels
LAFS PREPRO Session 7 - Game Audio and Levels
David Mullich
LAFS Game Design 1 - Dynamic Elements
LAFS Game Design 1 - Dynamic ElementsLAFS Game Design 1 - Dynamic Elements
LAFS Game Design 1 - Dynamic Elements
David Mullich
Ai on video games
Ai on video gamesAi on video games
Ai on video games
Faria Priya
Pergames2005 Paper
Pergames2005 PaperPergames2005 Paper
Pergames2005 Paper
Trond Nilsen
Sims game genre
Sims game genreSims game genre
Sims game genre
Tara Peak
Game Design 2: Lecture 9 - Immersion through UI
Game Design 2: Lecture 9 - Immersion through UIGame Design 2: Lecture 9 - Immersion through UI
Game Design 2: Lecture 9 - Immersion through UI
David Farrell
Game classifications
Game classificationsGame classifications
Game classifications
Yhen Celeste
Introduction To 3D Gaming
Introduction To 3D GamingIntroduction To 3D Gaming
Introduction To 3D Gaming
Clint Edmonson
2 lecture (gdd, responsibilites, level of game) 18 1-2021
2 lecture (gdd, responsibilites, level of game) 18 1-20212 lecture (gdd, responsibilites, level of game) 18 1-2021
2 lecture (gdd, responsibilites, level of game) 18 1-2021
Durgesh Pandey

Similar to josephHiggins_BenchmarkPortfolioDeck (20)

Playstation Cerberus
Playstation CerberusPlaystation Cerberus
Playstation Cerberus
Christopher Nelson
User Experience 4: Usable User Interface
User Experience 4: Usable User InterfaceUser Experience 4: Usable User Interface
User Experience 4: Usable User Interface
Marc Miquel
Noughts and Crosses Specification
Noughts and Crosses SpecificationNoughts and Crosses Specification
Noughts and Crosses Specification
Christopher Orchard
Game Design 2 (2010): Lecture 8 - Immersion through UI
Game Design 2 (2010): Lecture 8 - Immersion through UIGame Design 2 (2010): Lecture 8 - Immersion through UI
Game Design 2 (2010): Lecture 8 - Immersion through UI
David Farrell
The complete srs documentation of our developed game.
The complete srs documentation of our developed game. The complete srs documentation of our developed game.
The complete srs documentation of our developed game.
Isfand yar Khan
Game Design 2 (2013): Immersion Through Game UI
Game Design 2 (2013): Immersion Through Game UIGame Design 2 (2013): Immersion Through Game UI
Game Design 2 (2013): Immersion Through Game UI
David Farrell
Purge First Person Shooting (FPS) Game
Purge  First Person Shooting (FPS) GamePurge  First Person Shooting (FPS) Game
Purge First Person Shooting (FPS) Game
IRJET Journal
Can a Paper-Based Sketching Interface Improve the Gamer Experience in Strateg...
Can a Paper-Based Sketching Interface Improve the Gamer Experience in Strateg...Can a Paper-Based Sketching Interface Improve the Gamer Experience in Strateg...
Can a Paper-Based Sketching Interface Improve the Gamer Experience in Strateg...
Matthieu Macret
ICS3211 lecture 12
ICS3211 lecture 12ICS3211 lecture 12
ICS3211 lecture 12
Vanessa Camilleri
Shootemup report
Shootemup reportShootemup report
Shootemup report
Vivek Prasad
IRJET- Game Development Project Sparta
IRJET-  	  Game Development Project  SpartaIRJET-  	  Game Development Project  Sparta
IRJET- Game Development Project Sparta
IRJET Journal
BGA Studio Guidelines
BGA Studio GuidelinesBGA Studio Guidelines
BGA Studio Guidelines
Board Game Arena
Future Warfare
Future WarfareFuture Warfare
Future Warfare
Andrea Prosseda
Social game UX test ( with Gameloft)
Social game UX test ( with Gameloft)Social game UX test ( with Gameloft)
Social game UX test ( with Gameloft)
XiaoyeLainLin
Joker Game.pptx
Joker Game.pptxJoker Game.pptx
Joker Game.pptx
GURU103976
Unit 1-NEW - game game Game Core Design.pdf
Unit 1-NEW - game game Game Core Design.pdfUnit 1-NEW - game game Game Core Design.pdf
Unit 1-NEW - game game Game Core Design.pdf
VinsmokeSomya
98 374 Lesson 03-slides
98 374 Lesson 03-slides98 374 Lesson 03-slides
98 374 Lesson 03-slides
Tracie King
Video games
Video gamesVideo games
Video games
Jack Ward
project
projectproject
project
Matthew Conte
An Introduction To Game development
An Introduction To Game developmentAn Introduction To Game development
An Introduction To Game development
Ahmed
User Experience 4: Usable User Interface
User Experience 4: Usable User InterfaceUser Experience 4: Usable User Interface
User Experience 4: Usable User Interface
Marc Miquel
Noughts and Crosses Specification
Noughts and Crosses SpecificationNoughts and Crosses Specification
Noughts and Crosses Specification
Christopher Orchard
Game Design 2 (2010): Lecture 8 - Immersion through UI
Game Design 2 (2010): Lecture 8 - Immersion through UIGame Design 2 (2010): Lecture 8 - Immersion through UI
Game Design 2 (2010): Lecture 8 - Immersion through UI
David Farrell
The complete srs documentation of our developed game.
The complete srs documentation of our developed game. The complete srs documentation of our developed game.
The complete srs documentation of our developed game.
Isfand yar Khan
Game Design 2 (2013): Immersion Through Game UI
Game Design 2 (2013): Immersion Through Game UIGame Design 2 (2013): Immersion Through Game UI
Game Design 2 (2013): Immersion Through Game UI
David Farrell
Purge First Person Shooting (FPS) Game
Purge  First Person Shooting (FPS) GamePurge  First Person Shooting (FPS) Game
Purge First Person Shooting (FPS) Game
IRJET Journal
Can a Paper-Based Sketching Interface Improve the Gamer Experience in Strateg...
Can a Paper-Based Sketching Interface Improve the Gamer Experience in Strateg...Can a Paper-Based Sketching Interface Improve the Gamer Experience in Strateg...
Can a Paper-Based Sketching Interface Improve the Gamer Experience in Strateg...
Matthieu Macret
Shootemup report
Shootemup reportShootemup report
Shootemup report
Vivek Prasad
IRJET- Game Development Project Sparta
IRJET-  	  Game Development Project  SpartaIRJET-  	  Game Development Project  Sparta
IRJET- Game Development Project Sparta
IRJET Journal
Social game UX test ( with Gameloft)
Social game UX test ( with Gameloft)Social game UX test ( with Gameloft)
Social game UX test ( with Gameloft)
XiaoyeLainLin
Joker Game.pptx
Joker Game.pptxJoker Game.pptx
Joker Game.pptx
GURU103976
Unit 1-NEW - game game Game Core Design.pdf
Unit 1-NEW - game game Game Core Design.pdfUnit 1-NEW - game game Game Core Design.pdf
Unit 1-NEW - game game Game Core Design.pdf
VinsmokeSomya
98 374 Lesson 03-slides
98 374 Lesson 03-slides98 374 Lesson 03-slides
98 374 Lesson 03-slides
Tracie King
Video games
Video gamesVideo games
Video games
Jack Ward
An Introduction To Game development
An Introduction To Game developmentAn Introduction To Game development
An Introduction To Game development
Ahmed

josephHiggins_BenchmarkPortfolioDeck

  • 2. Player Pain Points While the UI of the Witcher 3 is good, there are issues that players have encountered. Too many HUD options HUD controls not needed Lack of item descriptions Unneeded world interactions However the focus of my redesign will be focused on the HUD
  • 3. Which Player types buy the Witcher 3? Explorers 80% Achievers 20%
  • 4. Suffering Player Demographic: Explorers Disrupted Immersion Too many HUD features Unnecessary Text Poor HUD framing
  • 5. What do explorers look for in a game? Drawn to discovery Enjoy the experience of the world story Seek after side quests and their own subtle narratives Finding new witcher contracts Discovering what each marker has in store for the player
  • 6. Causes of Disrupted Immersion HUD Framing - The games UI isnt flush against the edges of the player view. Causing more space to be obstructed from the noise of the UI elements. Information Load - The game provides information such as button commands, multiple items, combat log, map, time of day, distance from objective, and player statistics all at once.
  • 8. UI Frame Here we see a small bit of screen lost because of the UI frame. Unfortunately this wastes space and reduces how much the player may see.
  • 9. Unnecessary Information pt.1 The game provides button commands the entire game. At a certain point this is simply takes up player space and is unused. These visual cues unfortunately lose their usefulness as the player becomes more familiar with the game.
  • 10. Unnecessary Information pt.2 Time The time of day is also given to the player. It is never needed to understand the time of day. Items The game provides 5 item slots and keys that fail to map similarly to the keyboard. Also the text for each item adds more clutter to the screen.
  • 11. Design Solution from BloodBorne: Items Bloodborne (as seen on the right) only shows text for the currently selected item. IT reduces screen clutter and streamlines on the spot inventory uses. BloodBorne
  • 13. Comparison The proposed design solution allows for the player to see more and reduces the noise from the poor framing of the UI elements.