ݺߣ

ݺߣShare a Scribd company logo
Environment	
 &	
 Energy	
 Under	
 Obama
POLITICS,	
 POLICY	
 AND	
 POSSIBILITIES	
 EAST	
 OF	
 EDEN
There	
 is	
 a	
 Kansas	
 character,	
 and	
 its	
 roots	
 are	
 found	
 in	
 the	
 midwestern rural	
 
traditions	
 of	
 hard	
 work,	
 struggle	
 in	
 the	
 face	
 of	
 adversity,	
 frugality,	
 
practicality,	
 individualism,	
 democracy,	
 and	
 environmental irresponsibility.
Leo	
 E.	
 Olivia,
‘Kansas:	
 A	
 Hard	
 Land	
 in	
 the	
 Heartland”	
 (1988)
“The	
 Environment”
AS	
 OPPOSED	
 TO…
“The	
 Economy”?
“Humanity”?
“Technology”?
“The	
 Built	
 Environment”?
“Energy”?
“Agriculture”?
“Public	
 Health”?
RELATIVE	
 TO…
“political	
 possibility”?
“political	
 history”?
“the	
 financial	
 cost”?
“the	
 identifiable	
 need”?
“the	
 impacts”?
“doing	
 nothing”?
“business	
 as	
 usual”?
American	
 
“Environmentalism”
Pick	
 either	
 end.
National	
 Democratic	
 
Party	
 /	
 Organizing	
 For	
 
Action
2012
Center	
 for	
 American	
 
Progress
Jan.	
 9,	
 2013
https://www.americanprogress.
org/issues/green/report/2013/0
1/09/49187/president-­‐obamas-­‐
clean-­‐energy-­‐progress-­‐how-­‐the-­‐
top-­‐10-­‐energy-­‐priorities-­‐fared-­‐
during-­‐his-­‐first-­‐term/
Center	
 for	
 American	
 
Progress
Jan.	
 17,	
 2013
https://www.americanprogress.
org/issues/green/report/2013/0
1/17/49979/building-­‐on-­‐
president-­‐obamas-­‐clean-­‐energy-­‐
successes/
Other	
 sample	
 sources:
DAILY	
 KOS	
 11/23/13
http://www.dailykos.com/story/2013/11/23/12
57892/-­‐Obama-­‐accomplishments
LIBERALS	
 UNITE	
 7/19/12
http://samuel-­‐warde.com/2012/07/obamas-­‐
conservation-­‐and-­‐green-­‐energy-­‐
accomplishments/
Coral	
 Davenport	
 recently	
 observed	
 in	
 the	
 New	
 York	
 Times	
 that	
 Obama	
 will	
 
likely	
 "leave	
 office	
 with	
 the	
 most	
 aggressive,	
 far-­‐reaching	
 environmental	
 
legacy	
 of	
 any	
 occupant	
 of	
 the	
 White	
 House"	
 even	
 though	
 "it	
 is	
 very	
 
possible	
 that	
 not	
 a	
 single	
 major	
 environmental	
 law	
 will	
 have	
 passed	
 during	
 
his	
 two	
 terms	
 in	
 Washington."	
 The	
 Clean	
 Air	
 Act	
 of	
 1970	
 simply	
 turns	
 out	
 
to	
 be	
 a	
 very	
 powerful	
 tool	
 crafted	
 by	
 very	
 ambitious	
 legislators,	
 who	
 
wanted	
 to	
 make	
 sure	
 future	
 administrations	
 would	
 be	
 able	
 to	
 address	
 not-­‐
yet-­‐foreseen	
 environmental	
 problems.	
 He's	
 used	
 that	
 law	
 to	
 issue	
 a	
 
"series	
 of	
 landmark	
 regulations	
 on	
 air	
 pollution,	
 from	
 soot	
 to	
 smog,	
 to	
 
mercury	
 and	
 planet-­‐warming	
 carbon	
 dioxide."
The	
 New	
 York	
 Times,	
 11/26/14,	
 Obama	
 Builds	
 Environmental	
 Legacy	
 with	
 1970	
 Law	
 by	
 Coral	
 Davenport
“Obama’s
Regulatory	
 
Overreach?”
“Obama’s	
 
Environmental	
 
Legacy?”
C2E2 Strategies, LLC 3
“The	
 Obama	
 Strategy?”
Reflects	
 how	
 Federal	
 environmental	
 policy	
 was	
 intended	
 to	
 be	
 developed	
 and	
 deployed.
Reflects	
 what	
 is	
 political	
 possible	
 in	
 the	
 current	
 cultural	
 and	
 political	
 reality.
Perhaps	
 reflects	
 Obama’s	
 priorities	
 and/or	
 focus	
 for	
 policy	
 and	
 political	
 authority,	
 his	
 leadership	
 
style	
 and	
 core	
 competency,	
 and/or	
 his	
 political	
 sensibility.
Perhaps	
 the	
 difficult	
 reality	
 is	
 that	
 the	
 energy	
 and	
 environmental	
 challenges	
 we	
 face	
 are	
 
essentially	
 unprecedented	
 in	
 scope,	
 intensity,	
 convergence,	
 and	
 integration	
 – all	
 policies	
 to	
 date	
 
have	
 been	
 insufficient	
 as	
 measured	
 against	
 the	
 challenges	
 they	
 are	
 meant	
 to	
 address.	
 Perhaps	
 
this	
 is	
 not	
 an	
 “Obama”	
 problem	
 or	
 an	
 “Obama”	
 shortcoming,	
 but	
 a	
 “human”	
 and	
 “industrial”	
 
problem.
And	
 let	
 us	
 not	
 forget	
 the	
 opposition…
Groundhog	
  Days:Utilities Wrong	
 Again	
 About	
 Pollution	
  Safeguard	
 Costs	
 By	
 Daniel	
 J.	
 Weiss	
 and	
 Miranda	
 Peterson	
 March	
 19,	
 2014,	
 Center	
  for	
 American	
 Progress.
Government	
  Regulation:	
 Costs	
 Lower,	
 Benefits	
 Greater	
 Than	
 Industry	
 Estimates,	
 May	
 26,	
 2015	
 Clean	
 Energy	
 Initiative	
 Fact	
 Sheet,	
 PEW	
 Charitable	
  Trusts.
…the	
 other	
 priorities…
WNY	
 Labor	
 Today,	
 July	
 1,	
 2012.
…the	
 actual	
 results…
Benefits	
 and	
 Costs	
 of	
 the	
 Clean	
 Air	
 Act:	
 Second	
 Prospective	
 Study,	
  1990-­‐2020,	
 US	
 EPA,	
 updated	
  April	
 2011.
Six	
 Principal	
  Pollutants:	
  The	
 Latest	
 Findings	
 on	
 Air	
 Quality,	
  US	
 EPA,	
 2008.
…or	
 what’s	
 at	
 stake.
2014	
 On	
 Track	
 to	
 be	
 the	
 Hottest	
  Year	
 on	
 Record	
 by	
 Andrea	
 Thompson,	
  Climate	
 Central,	
  9/18/14.
An	
 Excellent	
 Return	
  on	
 Investment:	
 Protecting	
  Human	
 Health	
 Through	
 the	
 Clean	
 Air	
 Act,	
 Russell	
 Meyer,	
 Center	
 for	
 Climate	
  and	
 Energy	
 Solutions,	
  3/3/11.
The	
 Assault	
 on	
 EPA
Current	
 economic	
 and	
 political	
 climate	
 are	
 being	
 used	
 as	
 cover	
 for	
 an	
 
unprecedented	
 assault	
 upon	
 public	
 health	
 and	
 environmental	
 protections
EPA	
 and	
 implementation	
 of	
 the	
 Clean	
 Air	
 and	
 Clean	
 Water	
 Acts	
 coincide	
 
with	
 extraordinary	
 growth	
 in	
 U.S.	
 GDP	
 and	
 economic	
 growth,	
 as	
 well	
 as	
 
quality	
 of	
 life
Opposition	
 to	
 carbon	
 &	
 climate	
 change	
 regs	
 =	
 Trojan	
 horse	
 to	
 roll	
 back	
 40	
 
years	
 of	
 health	
 and	
 enviro	
 protections
“Obama	
 regulations”	
 misleading	
 -­‐ decades	
 of	
 bi-­‐partisan	
 development
Without	
 EPA	
 regulatory	
 authority,	
 U.S.	
 transition	
 to	
 a	
 clean	
 energy	
 economy	
 
is	
 impossible,	
 certainly	
 in	
 time	
 to	
 prevent	
 incalculable	
 climate,	
 health,	
 and	
 
environmental	
 damage
ݺߣ	
 from	
 a	
 November	
 2011	
 presentation	
 deck.
Thank	
 you.
allegrooch@me.com

More Related Content

What's hot (19)

28. Climate Change: Ethics and Collective Action Problems
28. Climate Change: Ethics and Collective Action Problems28. Climate Change: Ethics and Collective Action Problems
28. Climate Change: Ethics and Collective Action Problems
Adam Briggle
What purpose do the economy, energy, or environment serve?
What purpose do the economy, energy, or environment serve?What purpose do the economy, energy, or environment serve?
What purpose do the economy, energy, or environment serve?
Anupam Saraph
Chapt23 lecture
Chapt23 lectureChapt23 lecture
Chapt23 lecture
lschmidt1170
Topic 8
Topic 8Topic 8
Topic 8
Michael Smith
Socio-ecological systems: Moving beyond the Human Exemptionalist Paradigm
Socio-ecological systems: Moving beyond the Human Exemptionalist ParadigmSocio-ecological systems: Moving beyond the Human Exemptionalist Paradigm
Socio-ecological systems: Moving beyond the Human Exemptionalist Paradigm
Madhusudan Katti
CCAP Review
CCAP ReviewCCAP Review
CCAP Review
Peter Miles
Mining Environmental Management - 2006
Mining Environmental Management - 2006Mining Environmental Management - 2006
Mining Environmental Management - 2006
Turlough Guerin GAICD FGIA
Ecology Against Capitalism by Christopher Pickering
Ecology Against Capitalism  by Christopher PickeringEcology Against Capitalism  by Christopher Pickering
Ecology Against Capitalism by Christopher Pickering
Ratbag Media
Sustainability Reading: Natural Capital and Ecosystem Rights
Sustainability Reading: Natural Capital and Ecosystem RightsSustainability Reading: Natural Capital and Ecosystem Rights
Sustainability Reading: Natural Capital and Ecosystem Rights
Sam Bleiberg
Healing by Design
Healing by DesignHealing by Design
Healing by Design
Ali Akbar Sahiwala
State of Working America key slides
State of Working America key slidesState of Working America key slides
State of Working America key slides
Isaiah Poole
Ldb Permacultura_Kent evidence for action pc rd 2013 b
Ldb Permacultura_Kent evidence for action pc rd 2013 bLdb Permacultura_Kent evidence for action pc rd 2013 b
Ldb Permacultura_Kent evidence for action pc rd 2013 b
laboratoridalbasso
Cea agricultural ghg and n report summary 2012
Cea agricultural ghg and n report summary 2012Cea agricultural ghg and n report summary 2012
Cea agricultural ghg and n report summary 2012
allenhopper
Environmental implications of Kuznet curve
Environmental implications of Kuznet curveEnvironmental implications of Kuznet curve
Environmental implications of Kuznet curve
swtnspicyaqua
Contemporary affairs thinggggg
Contemporary affairs thingggggContemporary affairs thinggggg
Contemporary affairs thinggggg
Wes Weaver
Ldb Permacultura_Kent a_few_thoughts_v3_5_schumacher
Ldb Permacultura_Kent a_few_thoughts_v3_5_schumacherLdb Permacultura_Kent a_few_thoughts_v3_5_schumacher
Ldb Permacultura_Kent a_few_thoughts_v3_5_schumacher
laboratoridalbasso
Pillars or Sandcastles?
Pillars or Sandcastles?Pillars or Sandcastles?
Pillars or Sandcastles?
John Van Doren
Limits to growth
Limits to growthLimits to growth
Limits to growth
Anupam Saraph
17 limits to growth of human populations
17 limits to growth of human populations17 limits to growth of human populations
17 limits to growth of human populations
Puneet Gupta
28. Climate Change: Ethics and Collective Action Problems
28. Climate Change: Ethics and Collective Action Problems28. Climate Change: Ethics and Collective Action Problems
28. Climate Change: Ethics and Collective Action Problems
Adam Briggle
What purpose do the economy, energy, or environment serve?
What purpose do the economy, energy, or environment serve?What purpose do the economy, energy, or environment serve?
What purpose do the economy, energy, or environment serve?
Anupam Saraph
Socio-ecological systems: Moving beyond the Human Exemptionalist Paradigm
Socio-ecological systems: Moving beyond the Human Exemptionalist ParadigmSocio-ecological systems: Moving beyond the Human Exemptionalist Paradigm
Socio-ecological systems: Moving beyond the Human Exemptionalist Paradigm
Madhusudan Katti
Ecology Against Capitalism by Christopher Pickering
Ecology Against Capitalism  by Christopher PickeringEcology Against Capitalism  by Christopher Pickering
Ecology Against Capitalism by Christopher Pickering
Ratbag Media
Sustainability Reading: Natural Capital and Ecosystem Rights
Sustainability Reading: Natural Capital and Ecosystem RightsSustainability Reading: Natural Capital and Ecosystem Rights
Sustainability Reading: Natural Capital and Ecosystem Rights
Sam Bleiberg
State of Working America key slides
State of Working America key slidesState of Working America key slides
State of Working America key slides
Isaiah Poole
Ldb Permacultura_Kent evidence for action pc rd 2013 b
Ldb Permacultura_Kent evidence for action pc rd 2013 bLdb Permacultura_Kent evidence for action pc rd 2013 b
Ldb Permacultura_Kent evidence for action pc rd 2013 b
laboratoridalbasso
Cea agricultural ghg and n report summary 2012
Cea agricultural ghg and n report summary 2012Cea agricultural ghg and n report summary 2012
Cea agricultural ghg and n report summary 2012
allenhopper
Environmental implications of Kuznet curve
Environmental implications of Kuznet curveEnvironmental implications of Kuznet curve
Environmental implications of Kuznet curve
swtnspicyaqua
Contemporary affairs thinggggg
Contemporary affairs thingggggContemporary affairs thinggggg
Contemporary affairs thinggggg
Wes Weaver
Ldb Permacultura_Kent a_few_thoughts_v3_5_schumacher
Ldb Permacultura_Kent a_few_thoughts_v3_5_schumacherLdb Permacultura_Kent a_few_thoughts_v3_5_schumacher
Ldb Permacultura_Kent a_few_thoughts_v3_5_schumacher
laboratoridalbasso
17 limits to growth of human populations
17 limits to growth of human populations17 limits to growth of human populations
17 limits to growth of human populations
Puneet Gupta

Similar to ObamaEnvironmentDCD (10)

Dipak gyawali
Dipak gyawaliDipak gyawali
Dipak gyawali
ClimDev15
Innovation: managing risk, not avoiding it - report
Innovation: managing risk, not avoiding it - reportInnovation: managing risk, not avoiding it - report
Innovation: managing risk, not avoiding it - report
bis_foresight
The City Sustains ItselfEnvironmental StudiesWe have.docx
The City Sustains ItselfEnvironmental StudiesWe have.docxThe City Sustains ItselfEnvironmental StudiesWe have.docx
The City Sustains ItselfEnvironmental StudiesWe have.docx
mehek4
AmericannaturalistssuchasJohnMuir(1838–1914),AldoLeopold(.docx
AmericannaturalistssuchasJohnMuir(1838–1914),AldoLeopold(.docxAmericannaturalistssuchasJohnMuir(1838–1914),AldoLeopold(.docx
AmericannaturalistssuchasJohnMuir(1838–1914),AldoLeopold(.docx
nettletondevon
Managing In The Global Environment
Managing In The Global EnvironmentManaging In The Global Environment
Managing In The Global Environment
Website That Will Write A Paper For You Wheeling University
In The Early 1980S, Environment Justice Activist Prioritized
In The Early 1980S, Environment Justice Activist PrioritizedIn The Early 1980S, Environment Justice Activist Prioritized
In The Early 1980S, Environment Justice Activist Prioritized
Kelley Hunter
Environmental Scanning
Environmental ScanningEnvironmental Scanning
Environmental Scanning
Jo Balucanag - Bitonio
What If...Hydraulic Fracturing Was Banned?
What If...Hydraulic Fracturing Was Banned?What If...Hydraulic Fracturing Was Banned?
What If...Hydraulic Fracturing Was Banned?
Marcellus Drilling News
Answer ThisState of the AirThus far in this course we ha.docx
Answer ThisState of the AirThus far in this course we ha.docxAnswer ThisState of the AirThus far in this course we ha.docx
Answer ThisState of the AirThus far in this course we ha.docx
YASHU40
אפליה בהקמת מתקנים מזהמים בקרב שכבות חלשות
אפליה בהקמת מתקנים מזהמים בקרב שכבות חלשותאפליה בהקמת מתקנים מזהמים בקרב שכבות חלשות
אפליה בהקמת מתקנים מזהמים בקרב שכבות חלשות
הקואליציה לבריאות הציבור
Innovation: managing risk, not avoiding it - report
Innovation: managing risk, not avoiding it - reportInnovation: managing risk, not avoiding it - report
Innovation: managing risk, not avoiding it - report
bis_foresight
The City Sustains ItselfEnvironmental StudiesWe have.docx
The City Sustains ItselfEnvironmental StudiesWe have.docxThe City Sustains ItselfEnvironmental StudiesWe have.docx
The City Sustains ItselfEnvironmental StudiesWe have.docx
mehek4
AmericannaturalistssuchasJohnMuir(1838–1914),AldoLeopold(.docx
AmericannaturalistssuchasJohnMuir(1838–1914),AldoLeopold(.docxAmericannaturalistssuchasJohnMuir(1838–1914),AldoLeopold(.docx
AmericannaturalistssuchasJohnMuir(1838–1914),AldoLeopold(.docx
nettletondevon
In The Early 1980S, Environment Justice Activist Prioritized
In The Early 1980S, Environment Justice Activist PrioritizedIn The Early 1980S, Environment Justice Activist Prioritized
In The Early 1980S, Environment Justice Activist Prioritized
Kelley Hunter
Answer ThisState of the AirThus far in this course we ha.docx
Answer ThisState of the AirThus far in this course we ha.docxAnswer ThisState of the AirThus far in this course we ha.docx
Answer ThisState of the AirThus far in this course we ha.docx
YASHU40

ObamaEnvironmentDCD

  • 1. Environment & Energy Under Obama POLITICS, POLICY AND POSSIBILITIES EAST OF EDEN
  • 2. There is a Kansas character, and its roots are found in the midwestern rural traditions of hard work, struggle in the face of adversity, frugality, practicality, individualism, democracy, and environmental irresponsibility. Leo E. Olivia, ‘Kansas: A Hard Land in the Heartland” (1988)
  • 3. “The Environment” AS OPPOSED TO… “The Economy”? “Humanity”? “Technology”? “The Built Environment”? “Energy”? “Agriculture”? “Public Health”? RELATIVE TO… “political possibility”? “political history”? “the financial cost”? “the identifiable need”? “the impacts”? “doing nothing”? “business as usual”?
  • 5. National Democratic Party / Organizing For Action 2012
  • 6. Center for American Progress Jan. 9, 2013 https://www.americanprogress. org/issues/green/report/2013/0 1/09/49187/president-­‐obamas-­‐ clean-­‐energy-­‐progress-­‐how-­‐the-­‐ top-­‐10-­‐energy-­‐priorities-­‐fared-­‐ during-­‐his-­‐first-­‐term/
  • 7. Center for American Progress Jan. 17, 2013 https://www.americanprogress. org/issues/green/report/2013/0 1/17/49979/building-­‐on-­‐ president-­‐obamas-­‐clean-­‐energy-­‐ successes/
  • 8. Other sample sources: DAILY KOS 11/23/13 http://www.dailykos.com/story/2013/11/23/12 57892/-­‐Obama-­‐accomplishments LIBERALS UNITE 7/19/12 http://samuel-­‐warde.com/2012/07/obamas-­‐ conservation-­‐and-­‐green-­‐energy-­‐ accomplishments/
  • 9. Coral Davenport recently observed in the New York Times that Obama will likely "leave office with the most aggressive, far-­‐reaching environmental legacy of any occupant of the White House" even though "it is very possible that not a single major environmental law will have passed during his two terms in Washington." The Clean Air Act of 1970 simply turns out to be a very powerful tool crafted by very ambitious legislators, who wanted to make sure future administrations would be able to address not-­‐ yet-­‐foreseen environmental problems. He's used that law to issue a "series of landmark regulations on air pollution, from soot to smog, to mercury and planet-­‐warming carbon dioxide." The New York Times, 11/26/14, Obama Builds Environmental Legacy with 1970 Law by Coral Davenport
  • 12. “The Obama Strategy?” Reflects how Federal environmental policy was intended to be developed and deployed. Reflects what is political possible in the current cultural and political reality. Perhaps reflects Obama’s priorities and/or focus for policy and political authority, his leadership style and core competency, and/or his political sensibility. Perhaps the difficult reality is that the energy and environmental challenges we face are essentially unprecedented in scope, intensity, convergence, and integration – all policies to date have been insufficient as measured against the challenges they are meant to address. Perhaps this is not an “Obama” problem or an “Obama” shortcoming, but a “human” and “industrial” problem.
  • 13. And let us not forget the opposition… Groundhog Days:Utilities Wrong Again About Pollution Safeguard Costs By Daniel J. Weiss and Miranda Peterson March 19, 2014, Center for American Progress. Government Regulation: Costs Lower, Benefits Greater Than Industry Estimates, May 26, 2015 Clean Energy Initiative Fact Sheet, PEW Charitable Trusts.
  • 14. …the other priorities… WNY Labor Today, July 1, 2012.
  • 15. …the actual results… Benefits and Costs of the Clean Air Act: Second Prospective Study, 1990-­‐2020, US EPA, updated April 2011. Six Principal Pollutants: The Latest Findings on Air Quality, US EPA, 2008.
  • 16. …or what’s at stake. 2014 On Track to be the Hottest Year on Record by Andrea Thompson, Climate Central, 9/18/14. An Excellent Return on Investment: Protecting Human Health Through the Clean Air Act, Russell Meyer, Center for Climate and Energy Solutions, 3/3/11.
  • 17. The Assault on EPA Current economic and political climate are being used as cover for an unprecedented assault upon public health and environmental protections EPA and implementation of the Clean Air and Clean Water Acts coincide with extraordinary growth in U.S. GDP and economic growth, as well as quality of life Opposition to carbon & climate change regs = Trojan horse to roll back 40 years of health and enviro protections “Obama regulations” misleading -­‐ decades of bi-­‐partisan development Without EPA regulatory authority, U.S. transition to a clean energy economy is impossible, certainly in time to prevent incalculable climate, health, and environmental damage ݺߣ from a November 2011 presentation deck.