ºÝºÝߣ

ºÝºÝߣShare a Scribd company logo
Online Regulation and Effective Regulatory
Engagement

David Naylor
Robert Blamires



11 November 2010
Overview
1. OFT remit
2. OFT priorities
3. OFT enforcement powers
4. Typical infringements
5. Process
6. Effective engagement in investigations
7. Effective engagement as a proactive strategy
8. Conclusion/questions
1. OFT remit
¡°Making markets work well for consumers¡±
1. Encouraging compliance
   through self-regulation
2. Enforcement action
3. Studying markets and
   recommending action
4. Empowering consumers
2. OFT prioritisation principles


1. Impact
2. Strategic significance
3. Risks
4. Resources
2. OFT enforcement priorities
Practical observations:


1. High profile traders
   ?   Tesco
   ?   Dell
   ?   Sportsdirect.com
   ?   Bulldog Broadband
2. OFT enforcement priorities

2. Bad guys
  ?   Failure to deliver goods
  ?   Taking multiple payments


3. Test cases/precedent
  ?   Intermediary liability
  ?   File sharing
3. OFT enforcement powers

? Enterprise Act 2002
  ? Community infringements
  ? domestic infringements
? Enforcement directly under other statutes
  ? express power to enforce
  ? assumed power to enforce where in furtherance of OFT¡¯s
    functions
4. Typical infringements
? Distance Selling Regulations:
  ? onerous/prescriptive procedures/formalities for returning goods
  ? charging for return of faulty goods
  ? failing to provide a refund within 30 days


? Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts Regulations
  ? unfairly excluding/limiting liability
  ? indicative list of terms which may be regarded as unfair
4. Typical infringements
? Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations
  ? misleading actions/omissions
  ? aggressive practices
  ? banned practices
     ? bait advertising
     ? bait and switch
     ? advertorials
     ? presenting legal rights as part of the offer
     ? ¡®closing down¡¯ promotions
     ? pyramid schemes
5. Process
? Identification
? Preliminary enquiries/investigation
? Information gathering
   ?   information requests
   ?   informal requests
   ?   raids
? Consultation
? Undertakings
? Enforcement orders
? Publication
6. Effective engagement in investigations

? Early legal involvement
? Is process being followed?
? Valid exercise of powers?
? Technical breaches vs non-compliance 'strategies'
7. Effective engagement as a proactive strategy
? OFT notification
? OFT duty to act?
  ? Enterprise Act
  ? Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations and Business
    Protection from Misleading Marketing Regulations
      ? ¡°duty to enforce¡±
  ? Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts Regulations and Distance Selling
    Regulations
      ? ¡°duty to consider any complaint¡±

? Strategic considerations
8. Questions?


David Naylor
+44 (0) 20 7861 4150
david.naylor@ffw.com
Robert Blamires
+44 (0) 20 7861 4136
robert.blamires@ffw.com

More Related Content

Viewers also liked (12)

majalah detik_96
 majalah detik_96 majalah detik_96
majalah detik_96
Muhammad Noval
?
Tc sales direct
Tc sales directTc sales direct
Tc sales direct
TC Sales Direct
?
Virtue and vice 7
Virtue and vice 7Virtue and vice 7
Virtue and vice 7
Mut Somoeun
?
Herramientas de internet iicyh 2Herramientas de internet iicyh 2
Herramientas de internet iicyh 2
smendoza18
?
Beauty & Health Ltd. - About company
Beauty & Health Ltd. - About companyBeauty & Health Ltd. - About company
Beauty & Health Ltd. - About company
Marina Rogkova
?
BXP DM EST Meeting - July
BXP DM EST Meeting - JulyBXP DM EST Meeting - July
BXP DM EST Meeting - July
Jazman Barizi
?
Revista Catalunya 94 -Febrer 2008
Revista Catalunya  94 -Febrer 2008 Revista Catalunya  94 -Febrer 2008
Revista Catalunya 94 -Febrer 2008
Revista Catalunya
?
Joubert_Dianna_Resume
Joubert_Dianna_ResumeJoubert_Dianna_Resume
Joubert_Dianna_Resume
Dianna Joubert
?
µÚ3ÕÂ ´Ê·¨·ÖÎö
µÚ3ÕÂ ´Ê·¨·ÖÎöµÚ3ÕÂ ´Ê·¨·ÖÎö
µÚ3ÕÂ ´Ê·¨·ÖÎö
tjpucompiler
?
SensMax-leaflet-people-counting-system-for-retail-trade-english
SensMax-leaflet-people-counting-system-for-retail-trade-englishSensMax-leaflet-people-counting-system-for-retail-trade-english
SensMax-leaflet-people-counting-system-for-retail-trade-english
mohammed abdul moqueem
?
Social Media Gratitude
Social Media GratitudeSocial Media Gratitude
Social Media Gratitude
DrSonica Krishan
?
Herramientas de internet iicyh 2Herramientas de internet iicyh 2
Herramientas de internet iicyh 2
smendoza18
?
Beauty & Health Ltd. - About company
Beauty & Health Ltd. - About companyBeauty & Health Ltd. - About company
Beauty & Health Ltd. - About company
Marina Rogkova
?
BXP DM EST Meeting - July
BXP DM EST Meeting - JulyBXP DM EST Meeting - July
BXP DM EST Meeting - July
Jazman Barizi
?
Revista Catalunya 94 -Febrer 2008
Revista Catalunya  94 -Febrer 2008 Revista Catalunya  94 -Febrer 2008
Revista Catalunya 94 -Febrer 2008
Revista Catalunya
?
µÚ3ÕÂ ´Ê·¨·ÖÎö
µÚ3ÕÂ ´Ê·¨·ÖÎöµÚ3ÕÂ ´Ê·¨·ÖÎö
µÚ3ÕÂ ´Ê·¨·ÖÎö
tjpucompiler
?
SensMax-leaflet-people-counting-system-for-retail-trade-english
SensMax-leaflet-people-counting-system-for-retail-trade-englishSensMax-leaflet-people-counting-system-for-retail-trade-english
SensMax-leaflet-people-counting-system-for-retail-trade-english
mohammed abdul moqueem
?

Similar to Online regulation and effective regulatory engagement (20)

Session13 chap 9 ethics in negotiation enhanced 03 oct12
Session13 chap 9 ethics in negotiation enhanced 03 oct12Session13 chap 9 ethics in negotiation enhanced 03 oct12
Session13 chap 9 ethics in negotiation enhanced 03 oct12
ctucker5
?
Module 11 - ASP Privacy Management Certfication.ppt
Module 11 - ASP Privacy Management Certfication.pptModule 11 - ASP Privacy Management Certfication.ppt
Module 11 - ASP Privacy Management Certfication.ppt
trevor501353
?
Trade Secret Asset Management
Trade Secret Asset ManagementTrade Secret Asset Management
Trade Secret Asset Management
Donal O'Connell
?
Ppt
PptPpt
Ppt
Gareth Badrian
?
SPONSORED CONTENT - Palmetier Law - Unleashing Small Business Innovations: A ...
SPONSORED CONTENT - Palmetier Law - Unleashing Small Business Innovations: A ...SPONSORED CONTENT - Palmetier Law - Unleashing Small Business Innovations: A ...
SPONSORED CONTENT - Palmetier Law - Unleashing Small Business Innovations: A ...
JSchaus & Associates
?
Managing Risks - Competition & Investment, November 8, 2001
Managing Risks - Competition & Investment, November 8, 2001Managing Risks - Competition & Investment, November 8, 2001
Managing Risks - Competition & Investment, November 8, 2001
Blake, Cassels & Graydon LLP
?
Top 10 tips in 30 mins 01 06 2014
Top 10 tips in 30 mins 01 06 2014Top 10 tips in 30 mins 01 06 2014
Top 10 tips in 30 mins 01 06 2014
NewMexico Ptap
?
Creating A Due Diligence Framework
Creating A Due Diligence Framework Creating A Due Diligence Framework
Creating A Due Diligence Framework
Now Dentons
?
Putting The Consumer First
Putting The Consumer FirstPutting The Consumer First
Putting The Consumer First
Vivastream
?
Putting the Consumer First
Putting the Consumer FirstPutting the Consumer First
Putting the Consumer First
Vivastream
?
Building Awareness Of The Business Case Is It A Rule Problem Or Is It Somet...
Building Awareness Of The Business Case   Is It A Rule Problem Or Is It Somet...Building Awareness Of The Business Case   Is It A Rule Problem Or Is It Somet...
Building Awareness Of The Business Case Is It A Rule Problem Or Is It Somet...
lisaabe
?
Week 3 procurement & supplier focus
Week 3 procurement & supplier focusWeek 3 procurement & supplier focus
Week 3 procurement & supplier focus
Fassam Consulting
?
Privacy and Data Protection CLE Presentation for Touro Law Center
Privacy and Data Protection CLE Presentation for Touro Law CenterPrivacy and Data Protection CLE Presentation for Touro Law Center
Privacy and Data Protection CLE Presentation for Touro Law Center
Jonathan Ezor
?
Employment Basics for Small Businesses and Start Ups
Employment Basics for Small Businesses and Start UpsEmployment Basics for Small Businesses and Start Ups
Employment Basics for Small Businesses and Start Ups
Parsons Behle & Latimer
?
Why MAP Polices Fail and What You Can Do So Your Policy Doesn't
Why MAP Polices Fail and What You Can Do So Your Policy Doesn't Why MAP Polices Fail and What You Can Do So Your Policy Doesn't
Why MAP Polices Fail and What You Can Do So Your Policy Doesn't
Whitney Gibson
?
Finding Fraud and What To Do With It.ppt
Finding Fraud and What To Do With It.pptFinding Fraud and What To Do With It.ppt
Finding Fraud and What To Do With It.ppt
nuredinabdella2
?
The Art of War: Strategies for Managing Unsolicited Offers and Proxy Contests
The Art of War: Strategies for Managing Unsolicited Offers and Proxy Contests The Art of War: Strategies for Managing Unsolicited Offers and Proxy Contests
The Art of War: Strategies for Managing Unsolicited Offers and Proxy Contests
Now Dentons
?
ING Presentation - BDI 7/26/11 Social Media Security & Compliance Workshop fo...
ING Presentation - BDI 7/26/11 Social Media Security & Compliance Workshop fo...ING Presentation - BDI 7/26/11 Social Media Security & Compliance Workshop fo...
ING Presentation - BDI 7/26/11 Social Media Security & Compliance Workshop fo...
Business Development Institute
?
Certified Banking TPM - Module 8 powerpoint presentation
Certified Banking TPM - Module 8 powerpoint presentationCertified Banking TPM - Module 8 powerpoint presentation
Certified Banking TPM - Module 8 powerpoint presentation
trevor501353
?
Whistle blowing
Whistle blowingWhistle blowing
Whistle blowing
Ofqual ºÝºÝߣshare
?
Session13 chap 9 ethics in negotiation enhanced 03 oct12
Session13 chap 9 ethics in negotiation enhanced 03 oct12Session13 chap 9 ethics in negotiation enhanced 03 oct12
Session13 chap 9 ethics in negotiation enhanced 03 oct12
ctucker5
?
Module 11 - ASP Privacy Management Certfication.ppt
Module 11 - ASP Privacy Management Certfication.pptModule 11 - ASP Privacy Management Certfication.ppt
Module 11 - ASP Privacy Management Certfication.ppt
trevor501353
?
Trade Secret Asset Management
Trade Secret Asset ManagementTrade Secret Asset Management
Trade Secret Asset Management
Donal O'Connell
?
SPONSORED CONTENT - Palmetier Law - Unleashing Small Business Innovations: A ...
SPONSORED CONTENT - Palmetier Law - Unleashing Small Business Innovations: A ...SPONSORED CONTENT - Palmetier Law - Unleashing Small Business Innovations: A ...
SPONSORED CONTENT - Palmetier Law - Unleashing Small Business Innovations: A ...
JSchaus & Associates
?
Managing Risks - Competition & Investment, November 8, 2001
Managing Risks - Competition & Investment, November 8, 2001Managing Risks - Competition & Investment, November 8, 2001
Managing Risks - Competition & Investment, November 8, 2001
Blake, Cassels & Graydon LLP
?
Top 10 tips in 30 mins 01 06 2014
Top 10 tips in 30 mins 01 06 2014Top 10 tips in 30 mins 01 06 2014
Top 10 tips in 30 mins 01 06 2014
NewMexico Ptap
?
Creating A Due Diligence Framework
Creating A Due Diligence Framework Creating A Due Diligence Framework
Creating A Due Diligence Framework
Now Dentons
?
Putting The Consumer First
Putting The Consumer FirstPutting The Consumer First
Putting The Consumer First
Vivastream
?
Putting the Consumer First
Putting the Consumer FirstPutting the Consumer First
Putting the Consumer First
Vivastream
?
Building Awareness Of The Business Case Is It A Rule Problem Or Is It Somet...
Building Awareness Of The Business Case   Is It A Rule Problem Or Is It Somet...Building Awareness Of The Business Case   Is It A Rule Problem Or Is It Somet...
Building Awareness Of The Business Case Is It A Rule Problem Or Is It Somet...
lisaabe
?
Week 3 procurement & supplier focus
Week 3 procurement & supplier focusWeek 3 procurement & supplier focus
Week 3 procurement & supplier focus
Fassam Consulting
?
Privacy and Data Protection CLE Presentation for Touro Law Center
Privacy and Data Protection CLE Presentation for Touro Law CenterPrivacy and Data Protection CLE Presentation for Touro Law Center
Privacy and Data Protection CLE Presentation for Touro Law Center
Jonathan Ezor
?
Employment Basics for Small Businesses and Start Ups
Employment Basics for Small Businesses and Start UpsEmployment Basics for Small Businesses and Start Ups
Employment Basics for Small Businesses and Start Ups
Parsons Behle & Latimer
?
Why MAP Polices Fail and What You Can Do So Your Policy Doesn't
Why MAP Polices Fail and What You Can Do So Your Policy Doesn't Why MAP Polices Fail and What You Can Do So Your Policy Doesn't
Why MAP Polices Fail and What You Can Do So Your Policy Doesn't
Whitney Gibson
?
Finding Fraud and What To Do With It.ppt
Finding Fraud and What To Do With It.pptFinding Fraud and What To Do With It.ppt
Finding Fraud and What To Do With It.ppt
nuredinabdella2
?
The Art of War: Strategies for Managing Unsolicited Offers and Proxy Contests
The Art of War: Strategies for Managing Unsolicited Offers and Proxy Contests The Art of War: Strategies for Managing Unsolicited Offers and Proxy Contests
The Art of War: Strategies for Managing Unsolicited Offers and Proxy Contests
Now Dentons
?
ING Presentation - BDI 7/26/11 Social Media Security & Compliance Workshop fo...
ING Presentation - BDI 7/26/11 Social Media Security & Compliance Workshop fo...ING Presentation - BDI 7/26/11 Social Media Security & Compliance Workshop fo...
ING Presentation - BDI 7/26/11 Social Media Security & Compliance Workshop fo...
Business Development Institute
?
Certified Banking TPM - Module 8 powerpoint presentation
Certified Banking TPM - Module 8 powerpoint presentationCertified Banking TPM - Module 8 powerpoint presentation
Certified Banking TPM - Module 8 powerpoint presentation
trevor501353
?

More from Rob Blamires (12)

UsedSoft and Exhaustion of Distribution Rights in Software - Presentation to ...
UsedSoft and Exhaustion of Distribution Rights in Software - Presentation to ...UsedSoft and Exhaustion of Distribution Rights in Software - Presentation to ...
UsedSoft and Exhaustion of Distribution Rights in Software - Presentation to ...
Rob Blamires
?
EU Privacy for US Businesses - Presentation to Union Square Ventures
EU Privacy for US Businesses - Presentation to Union Square VenturesEU Privacy for US Businesses - Presentation to Union Square Ventures
EU Privacy for US Businesses - Presentation to Union Square Ventures
Rob Blamires
?
EU Privacy for US Businesses - Presentation to Union Square Ventures
EU Privacy for US Businesses - Presentation to Union Square VenturesEU Privacy for US Businesses - Presentation to Union Square Ventures
EU Privacy for US Businesses - Presentation to Union Square Ventures
Rob Blamires
?
EU legal issues for US enterprise
EU legal issues for US enterpriseEU legal issues for US enterprise
EU legal issues for US enterprise
Rob Blamires
?
E commerce developments and use of social media
E commerce developments and use of social mediaE commerce developments and use of social media
E commerce developments and use of social media
Rob Blamires
?
Virtual worlds
Virtual worldsVirtual worlds
Virtual worlds
Rob Blamires
?
European legal issues for US enterprise
European legal issues for US enterpriseEuropean legal issues for US enterprise
European legal issues for US enterprise
Rob Blamires
?
Internet Regulation
Internet RegulationInternet Regulation
Internet Regulation
Rob Blamires
?
Consumer Protection - OFT v Purely Creative et al
Consumer Protection - OFT v Purely Creative et alConsumer Protection - OFT v Purely Creative et al
Consumer Protection - OFT v Purely Creative et al
Rob Blamires
?
Exploitation of digital media rights
Exploitation of digital media rightsExploitation of digital media rights
Exploitation of digital media rights
Rob Blamires
?
What does .brand mean for you?
What does .brand mean for you?What does .brand mean for you?
What does .brand mean for you?
Rob Blamires
?
Keeping Your House In Order Getting It Right When Selling Online
Keeping Your House In Order   Getting It Right When Selling OnlineKeeping Your House In Order   Getting It Right When Selling Online
Keeping Your House In Order Getting It Right When Selling Online
Rob Blamires
?
UsedSoft and Exhaustion of Distribution Rights in Software - Presentation to ...
UsedSoft and Exhaustion of Distribution Rights in Software - Presentation to ...UsedSoft and Exhaustion of Distribution Rights in Software - Presentation to ...
UsedSoft and Exhaustion of Distribution Rights in Software - Presentation to ...
Rob Blamires
?
EU Privacy for US Businesses - Presentation to Union Square Ventures
EU Privacy for US Businesses - Presentation to Union Square VenturesEU Privacy for US Businesses - Presentation to Union Square Ventures
EU Privacy for US Businesses - Presentation to Union Square Ventures
Rob Blamires
?
EU Privacy for US Businesses - Presentation to Union Square Ventures
EU Privacy for US Businesses - Presentation to Union Square VenturesEU Privacy for US Businesses - Presentation to Union Square Ventures
EU Privacy for US Businesses - Presentation to Union Square Ventures
Rob Blamires
?
EU legal issues for US enterprise
EU legal issues for US enterpriseEU legal issues for US enterprise
EU legal issues for US enterprise
Rob Blamires
?
E commerce developments and use of social media
E commerce developments and use of social mediaE commerce developments and use of social media
E commerce developments and use of social media
Rob Blamires
?
European legal issues for US enterprise
European legal issues for US enterpriseEuropean legal issues for US enterprise
European legal issues for US enterprise
Rob Blamires
?
Consumer Protection - OFT v Purely Creative et al
Consumer Protection - OFT v Purely Creative et alConsumer Protection - OFT v Purely Creative et al
Consumer Protection - OFT v Purely Creative et al
Rob Blamires
?
Exploitation of digital media rights
Exploitation of digital media rightsExploitation of digital media rights
Exploitation of digital media rights
Rob Blamires
?
What does .brand mean for you?
What does .brand mean for you?What does .brand mean for you?
What does .brand mean for you?
Rob Blamires
?
Keeping Your House In Order Getting It Right When Selling Online
Keeping Your House In Order   Getting It Right When Selling OnlineKeeping Your House In Order   Getting It Right When Selling Online
Keeping Your House In Order Getting It Right When Selling Online
Rob Blamires
?

Online regulation and effective regulatory engagement

  • 1. Online Regulation and Effective Regulatory Engagement David Naylor Robert Blamires 11 November 2010
  • 2. Overview 1. OFT remit 2. OFT priorities 3. OFT enforcement powers 4. Typical infringements 5. Process 6. Effective engagement in investigations 7. Effective engagement as a proactive strategy 8. Conclusion/questions
  • 3. 1. OFT remit ¡°Making markets work well for consumers¡± 1. Encouraging compliance through self-regulation 2. Enforcement action 3. Studying markets and recommending action 4. Empowering consumers
  • 4. 2. OFT prioritisation principles 1. Impact 2. Strategic significance 3. Risks 4. Resources
  • 5. 2. OFT enforcement priorities Practical observations: 1. High profile traders ? Tesco ? Dell ? Sportsdirect.com ? Bulldog Broadband
  • 6. 2. OFT enforcement priorities 2. Bad guys ? Failure to deliver goods ? Taking multiple payments 3. Test cases/precedent ? Intermediary liability ? File sharing
  • 7. 3. OFT enforcement powers ? Enterprise Act 2002 ? Community infringements ? domestic infringements ? Enforcement directly under other statutes ? express power to enforce ? assumed power to enforce where in furtherance of OFT¡¯s functions
  • 8. 4. Typical infringements ? Distance Selling Regulations: ? onerous/prescriptive procedures/formalities for returning goods ? charging for return of faulty goods ? failing to provide a refund within 30 days ? Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts Regulations ? unfairly excluding/limiting liability ? indicative list of terms which may be regarded as unfair
  • 9. 4. Typical infringements ? Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations ? misleading actions/omissions ? aggressive practices ? banned practices ? bait advertising ? bait and switch ? advertorials ? presenting legal rights as part of the offer ? ¡®closing down¡¯ promotions ? pyramid schemes
  • 10. 5. Process ? Identification ? Preliminary enquiries/investigation ? Information gathering ? information requests ? informal requests ? raids ? Consultation ? Undertakings ? Enforcement orders ? Publication
  • 11. 6. Effective engagement in investigations ? Early legal involvement ? Is process being followed? ? Valid exercise of powers? ? Technical breaches vs non-compliance 'strategies'
  • 12. 7. Effective engagement as a proactive strategy ? OFT notification ? OFT duty to act? ? Enterprise Act ? Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations and Business Protection from Misleading Marketing Regulations ? ¡°duty to enforce¡± ? Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts Regulations and Distance Selling Regulations ? ¡°duty to consider any complaint¡± ? Strategic considerations
  • 13. 8. Questions? David Naylor +44 (0) 20 7861 4150 david.naylor@ffw.com Robert Blamires +44 (0) 20 7861 4136 robert.blamires@ffw.com