際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
A Skeptics Guide to String Theory
George Musser  1 November 2008
 and not just string theory
1. THE PROBLEM OF UNIFICATION
The Tree
of
Physics
Mercury Nov/Dec 97
2. THE ZOOM BUTTON
Powers of 10
息 1995-2008 by Michael W. Davidson and The Florida State University. Used by permission.
http://micro.magnet.fsu.edu/primer/java/scienceopticsu/powersof10/
Energy and Size in Quantum Theory
PositionMomentum
Energy and Size in Quantum Theory
Energy and Size in General Relativity
Threshold for Black Hole Formation
6 Kilometers  1 Solar Mass
1 Centimeter  1 Earth Mass
0.1 Millimeter  1 Moon Mass
Energy and Size in General Relativity
Energy and Size in Both Theories
Planck scale
The Fine Filigree of Spacetime
American Scientist Nov/Dec 91
3. IS QUANTUM GRAVITY SCIENCE?
Energy and Size in Both Theories
Planck scale
LHC
Cosmic rays
Accelerator limit Known universeHuman
The Skeptics Dilemma
 If quantum gravity cant be tested, is it really
science?
 But if its not science, do we have to give up
the pursuit of deeper explanation?
Moir辿 pattern
Photoelectric Effect
Photoelectric Effect
http://www.semiconductor-sanyo.com/images/amorton/feature/wavelength.gif
New York Skeptics Society talk, 1 Nov 08
Science 299:1171 (2003)
Just because a theory isnt (yet) falsifiable
doesnt mean its not scientific.
4. WHAT IT MEANS FOR SKEPTICS
 Use the unity of nature as a criterion for
evaluating claims (but carefully).
 Never ascribe to design what you can ascribe
to luck.
The Tree
of
Physics
Mercury Nov/Dec 97
For a copy of the talk, visit
www.strings.musser.com
BACKUP SLIDES
Moir辿 pattern
Particle
Accelerators
101
www.atlas.ch/multimedia/animation_lhc_event.html; CERN-EX-0401001
www.ippp.dur.ac.uk/~georg/lhcilc/cern0702/lhclco_tricomi.pdf;
iguanacms.web.cern.ch/iguanacms/gallery-page4.html
Creation of Gluinos
RAW MATERIAL
The Tree
of
Physics
Mercury Nov/Dec 97
The
Tree of
Physics
Simpler

More Related Content

What's hot (19)

How a star is born, lives,
How a star is born, lives,How a star is born, lives,
How a star is born, lives,
Matt
Astronomy group-2
Astronomy group-2Astronomy group-2
Astronomy group-2
University of Cebu
赫温鉛温恰霞s
赫温鉛温恰霞s赫温鉛温恰霞s
赫温鉛温恰霞s
beaumai15
Meteors And Meteorites
Meteors And MeteoritesMeteors And Meteorites
Meteors And Meteorites
North Shore School District 112
Crowsnest Fire
Crowsnest FireCrowsnest Fire
Crowsnest Fire
Jonathan
What is a meteoroid
What is a meteoroidWhat is a meteoroid
What is a meteoroid
Amy Dickey
Scientific theory
Scientific theoryScientific theory
Scientific theory
reenakang
Writing an Argument About the Channel on Mars
Writing an Argument About the Channel on MarsWriting an Argument About the Channel on Mars
Writing an Argument About the Channel on Mars
dwinter1
Expanding universe
Expanding universeExpanding universe
Expanding universe
Akshat Gulati
Gk project
Gk projectGk project
Gk project
PREEITI
BLACK HOLE FOR FYBA STUDENTS
BLACK HOLE FOR FYBA STUDENTS BLACK HOLE FOR FYBA STUDENTS
BLACK HOLE FOR FYBA STUDENTS
aksshaypara
Cosmology,bigbang and dark energy
Cosmology,bigbang and dark energyCosmology,bigbang and dark energy
Cosmology,bigbang and dark energy
rvrjc college of enggineering
1.12 how did the universe begin
1.12 how did the universe begin1.12 how did the universe begin
1.12 how did the universe begin
mrrayner
Expanding universe
Expanding universeExpanding universe
Expanding universe
RODELoreto MORALESson
Meteor, meteoroid and meteorites
Meteor, meteoroid and meteoritesMeteor, meteoroid and meteorites
Meteor, meteoroid and meteorites
Jan Del Rosario
Asteroids and meteoroids
Asteroids and meteoroidsAsteroids and meteoroids
Asteroids and meteoroids
Stephanie Rooke
A1 23 The Universe
A1 23 The UniverseA1 23 The Universe
A1 23 The Universe
Park University
Unit 3: Why Does the Sun Shine?
Unit 3: Why Does the Sun Shine?Unit 3: Why Does the Sun Shine?
Unit 3: Why Does the Sun Shine?
Big History Project
Meteor shower
Meteor showerMeteor shower
Meteor shower
nievanot
How a star is born, lives,
How a star is born, lives,How a star is born, lives,
How a star is born, lives,
Matt
赫温鉛温恰霞s
赫温鉛温恰霞s赫温鉛温恰霞s
赫温鉛温恰霞s
beaumai15
Crowsnest Fire
Crowsnest FireCrowsnest Fire
Crowsnest Fire
Jonathan
What is a meteoroid
What is a meteoroidWhat is a meteoroid
What is a meteoroid
Amy Dickey
Scientific theory
Scientific theoryScientific theory
Scientific theory
reenakang
Writing an Argument About the Channel on Mars
Writing an Argument About the Channel on MarsWriting an Argument About the Channel on Mars
Writing an Argument About the Channel on Mars
dwinter1
Expanding universe
Expanding universeExpanding universe
Expanding universe
Akshat Gulati
Gk project
Gk projectGk project
Gk project
PREEITI
BLACK HOLE FOR FYBA STUDENTS
BLACK HOLE FOR FYBA STUDENTS BLACK HOLE FOR FYBA STUDENTS
BLACK HOLE FOR FYBA STUDENTS
aksshaypara
1.12 how did the universe begin
1.12 how did the universe begin1.12 how did the universe begin
1.12 how did the universe begin
mrrayner
Meteor, meteoroid and meteorites
Meteor, meteoroid and meteoritesMeteor, meteoroid and meteorites
Meteor, meteoroid and meteorites
Jan Del Rosario
Asteroids and meteoroids
Asteroids and meteoroidsAsteroids and meteoroids
Asteroids and meteoroids
Stephanie Rooke
Unit 3: Why Does the Sun Shine?
Unit 3: Why Does the Sun Shine?Unit 3: Why Does the Sun Shine?
Unit 3: Why Does the Sun Shine?
Big History Project
Meteor shower
Meteor showerMeteor shower
Meteor shower
nievanot

Similar to New York Skeptics Society talk, 1 Nov 08 (20)

Stephen Hawking Theory Of Everything
Stephen  Hawking    Theory Of  EverythingStephen  Hawking    Theory Of  Everything
Stephen Hawking Theory Of Everything
Dhiraj Upadhyay
Galaxy Forum Kansas 2013 - Nick Solomey
Galaxy Forum Kansas 2013 - Nick SolomeyGalaxy Forum Kansas 2013 - Nick Solomey
Galaxy Forum Kansas 2013 - Nick Solomey
ILOAHawaii
Dark energy.pptx
Dark energy.pptxDark energy.pptx
Dark energy.pptx
SoumyashreeRout2
Do We Live in a Black Hole? Modern Conceptions of the Multiverse
Do We Live in a Black Hole? Modern Conceptions of the MultiverseDo We Live in a Black Hole? Modern Conceptions of the Multiverse
Do We Live in a Black Hole? Modern Conceptions of the Multiverse
Luke Conlin
Accelerated expansion of universe and evolving ideas about gravity
Accelerated expansion of universe and evolving ideas about gravityAccelerated expansion of universe and evolving ideas about gravity
Accelerated expansion of universe and evolving ideas about gravity
Michael Marty
String theory of particle physics
String theory of particle physicsString theory of particle physics
String theory of particle physics
Healthcare consultant
Is There An Absent Planet In The Solar Group
Is There An Absent Planet In The Solar GroupIs There An Absent Planet In The Solar Group
Is There An Absent Planet In The Solar Group
Gerges francis
A Theoretical Perception of Gravity from the Quantum to the Relativity
A Theoretical Perception of Gravity from the Quantum to the RelativityA Theoretical Perception of Gravity from the Quantum to the Relativity
A Theoretical Perception of Gravity from the Quantum to the Relativity
DR.P.S.JAGADEESH KUMAR
Ispectrum magazine #02
Ispectrum magazine #02Ispectrum magazine #02
Ispectrum magazine #02
Ispectrum Magazine
Universal Law of Gravitation | Physics F5 KSSM
Universal Law of Gravitation | Physics F5 KSSMUniversal Law of Gravitation | Physics F5 KSSM
Universal Law of Gravitation | Physics F5 KSSM
Nurul Fadhilah
Extended Essay
Extended EssayExtended Essay
Extended Essay
Ethan Dodd
Physics grav w11
Physics grav w11Physics grav w11
Physics grav w11
ssuserba742a1
Physics grav w11
Physics grav w11Physics grav w11
Physics grav w11
ssuserba742a1
Uti index-papers-e-chapter6-todays-godless-physics
Uti index-papers-e-chapter6-todays-godless-physicsUti index-papers-e-chapter6-todays-godless-physics
Uti index-papers-e-chapter6-todays-godless-physics
HIDEUMI SEKIGUCHI
Uti index-papers-e-chapter6-todays-godless-physics
Uti index-papers-e-chapter6-todays-godless-physicsUti index-papers-e-chapter6-todays-godless-physics
Uti index-papers-e-chapter6-todays-godless-physics
Hideumi Sekiguchi
YeSen PPT9 4 Flaws in the Current "the Cause of Tides"
YeSen PPT9 4 Flaws in the Current "the Cause of Tides"YeSen PPT9 4 Flaws in the Current "the Cause of Tides"
YeSen PPT9 4 Flaws in the Current "the Cause of Tides"
Ye Er
Bp4301373380
Bp4301373380Bp4301373380
Bp4301373380
IJERA Editor
document-part- (8).doc
document-part- (8).docdocument-part- (8).doc
document-part- (8).doc
Pheo23
Out into space 1
Out into space 1Out into space 1
Out into space 1
cstraughan
Dark Energy
Dark EnergyDark Energy
Dark Energy
pixiejen
Stephen Hawking Theory Of Everything
Stephen  Hawking    Theory Of  EverythingStephen  Hawking    Theory Of  Everything
Stephen Hawking Theory Of Everything
Dhiraj Upadhyay
Galaxy Forum Kansas 2013 - Nick Solomey
Galaxy Forum Kansas 2013 - Nick SolomeyGalaxy Forum Kansas 2013 - Nick Solomey
Galaxy Forum Kansas 2013 - Nick Solomey
ILOAHawaii
Do We Live in a Black Hole? Modern Conceptions of the Multiverse
Do We Live in a Black Hole? Modern Conceptions of the MultiverseDo We Live in a Black Hole? Modern Conceptions of the Multiverse
Do We Live in a Black Hole? Modern Conceptions of the Multiverse
Luke Conlin
Accelerated expansion of universe and evolving ideas about gravity
Accelerated expansion of universe and evolving ideas about gravityAccelerated expansion of universe and evolving ideas about gravity
Accelerated expansion of universe and evolving ideas about gravity
Michael Marty
Is There An Absent Planet In The Solar Group
Is There An Absent Planet In The Solar GroupIs There An Absent Planet In The Solar Group
Is There An Absent Planet In The Solar Group
Gerges francis
A Theoretical Perception of Gravity from the Quantum to the Relativity
A Theoretical Perception of Gravity from the Quantum to the RelativityA Theoretical Perception of Gravity from the Quantum to the Relativity
A Theoretical Perception of Gravity from the Quantum to the Relativity
DR.P.S.JAGADEESH KUMAR
Universal Law of Gravitation | Physics F5 KSSM
Universal Law of Gravitation | Physics F5 KSSMUniversal Law of Gravitation | Physics F5 KSSM
Universal Law of Gravitation | Physics F5 KSSM
Nurul Fadhilah
Extended Essay
Extended EssayExtended Essay
Extended Essay
Ethan Dodd
Uti index-papers-e-chapter6-todays-godless-physics
Uti index-papers-e-chapter6-todays-godless-physicsUti index-papers-e-chapter6-todays-godless-physics
Uti index-papers-e-chapter6-todays-godless-physics
HIDEUMI SEKIGUCHI
Uti index-papers-e-chapter6-todays-godless-physics
Uti index-papers-e-chapter6-todays-godless-physicsUti index-papers-e-chapter6-todays-godless-physics
Uti index-papers-e-chapter6-todays-godless-physics
Hideumi Sekiguchi
YeSen PPT9 4 Flaws in the Current "the Cause of Tides"
YeSen PPT9 4 Flaws in the Current "the Cause of Tides"YeSen PPT9 4 Flaws in the Current "the Cause of Tides"
YeSen PPT9 4 Flaws in the Current "the Cause of Tides"
Ye Er
document-part- (8).doc
document-part- (8).docdocument-part- (8).doc
document-part- (8).doc
Pheo23
Out into space 1
Out into space 1Out into space 1
Out into space 1
cstraughan
Dark Energy
Dark EnergyDark Energy
Dark Energy
pixiejen

New York Skeptics Society talk, 1 Nov 08