際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
Indexicality & Stance Workshop Objectives Indexicality Indexical terms The big challenge: parsing Silverstein Why is it useful? (Is it?)
Indexicality & Stance Workshop Stance Definitions Examples Practice Useful for what?
Objectives Explicate the terms and their use Further explore their potential as a group, hopefully for your later use!
Indexicality Write down as many examples of things you think are indexes in the next 100 seconds!
Indexicality What questions do you have about indexicality?
Terms in Peircean meaning Icon : a sign vehicle that resembles that which it signifies. buzz, or rising intonation in some cases Symbol : meaning depends entirely on an abstract arbitrary connection Index : pure indexes are features of speech which, independent of any referential speech events that may be occurring, signal some particular value of one or more contextual variables. Silverstein (1995[1976]:201) Shifters : referential indexes which have rules of use that gain reference only in context (tense, place deixis)
Terms in Peircean meaning 76 Definitions of The Sign by C. S. Peirce collected and analyzed by Robert Marty Department of Mathematics University of Perpignan Perpignan, France With an Appendix of 12 Further Definitions or Equivalents proposed by Alfred Lang Dept of Psychology University of Bern Bern, Switzerland http://www.cspeirce.com/menu/library/rsources/76defs/76defs.htm
Big Questions How and why  are indexical meanings  realised?
Presupposing and creative presupposing : assumes (follows) rules of use (e.g., this chair and that chair) creative or performative -- entailment : make explicit and overt the parameters of the ongoing event (English pronouns, esp. 2p) Examples??
Indexical orders Similar to Labovian awareness although discussed in terms of metapragmatic discourse and less reliant on widely shared norms in the speech community.  A process of conventionalization. As you go up indexical orders, they have more creative effects.
To the text! Silverstein, Michael. 2003. Indexical order and the dialectics of sociolinguistic life.  Language & Communication , 23: 193-229.
Indexical fields (webs?) indexical field : constellation of ideologically related meanings any one of which can be activated in the situated use of the variable
Indexical fields
Questions about your examples  or just questions? Shy? Write questions down and leave them up here during the break.
How are these terminological distinctions useful in different areas of sociolinguistics?
Stance What is it? Write down what YOU think it is.
Big Questions Methodologically, how do we find it?  How does stance get created?  How do linguistic things work together to create a stance?
What is it again?  (Technical version) How you stand in relation to another thing, including people and the ideas you represent. Linguistically created through the fractional congruence of different linguistic stuff.
Aspects of Stance Stance Object: Person, thing, idea, talk Affect: Emotion or alignment Epistemicity: Knowledge representation Social axes: Power and solidarity Stance is  relational  and  fluid
Example Various bits of stance created by Mick in the early stages of example 1. Stance Object: Person, thing, idea, talk Affect: Emotion or alignment Epistemicity: Knowledge representation Social axes: Power and solidarity
Ad

Recommended

Deixis presentation
Deixis presentation
Ijaz Ahmed
Power in Everyday Discourse
Power in Everyday Discourse
muzzboi
Discourse style
Discourse style
tanaphorn
Presentation for language, discourse and power
Presentation for language, discourse and power
racheleharrison
Negotiation Power
Negotiation Power
Jon R Wallace
Presentation1
Presentation1
Lelly Istiani
Discourse Analysis article shared by Azhar Khan ..1
Discourse Analysis article shared by Azhar Khan ..1
Abdullah Saleem
Language & power part 1
Language & power part 1
L Lambe
Deixis And Distance
Deixis And Distance
hermionemars
Interactional sociolinguistics
Interactional sociolinguistics
JESSIE GRACE RUBRICO
Language, culture, and identity
Language, culture, and identity
nona hr
Culture and Identity
Culture and Identity
University of Calgary, School of Creative and Performing Arts
Discourse analysis
Discourse analysis
Lyudmila Osinovskaya
Discourse Analysis
Discourse Analysis
Dr. Cupid Lucid
Discourse Analysis ppt
Discourse Analysis ppt
Aisyah Pujakesuma
How To Do A Discourse Analysis
How To Do A Discourse Analysis
guestfca522
Pragmatics - George Yule
Pragmatics - George Yule
Anthony Salinas
Information technologies of cognitive thesauri design
Information technologies of cognitive thesauri design
Philippovich Andrey
Meaning In Communication Cognition And Reality Outline Of A Theory From Semio...
Meaning In Communication Cognition And Reality Outline Of A Theory From Semio...
loritrody16
Semiotic analysis
Semiotic analysis
Archana R Singh
Semiotics and information science
Semiotics and information science
Florence Paisey
Semiotics and Information Science
Semiotics and Information Science
Florence Paisey
paradigmatic controversies, contradictions, and emerging confluences
paradigmatic controversies, contradictions, and emerging confluences
felipemtz89
Class3 - What is This Language Structure
Class3 - What is This Language Structure
Nathacia Lucena
328977061-English-Lexicology-2014 2015.pdf
328977061-English-Lexicology-2014 2015.pdf
MaryamAfzal41
No Show 2012 - Clara Fern叩ndez-Vara - Environmental Storytelling
No Show 2012 - Clara Fern叩ndez-Vara - Environmental Storytelling
No Show Conference
Meeting 2 - Research Paradigm.ppt
Meeting 2 - Research Paradigm.ppt
Mahadi Bahari
Da vinci presentation ontology epistemology Dr Rica VIljoen
Da vinci presentation ontology epistemology Dr Rica VIljoen
Dr Rica Viljoen
OLEX
OLEX
Oleksandr Slobodianyk
Writing workshop part 1
Writing workshop part 1
Espen Stranger-Johannessen

More Related Content

Viewers also liked (9)

Deixis And Distance
Deixis And Distance
hermionemars
Interactional sociolinguistics
Interactional sociolinguistics
JESSIE GRACE RUBRICO
Language, culture, and identity
Language, culture, and identity
nona hr
Culture and Identity
Culture and Identity
University of Calgary, School of Creative and Performing Arts
Discourse analysis
Discourse analysis
Lyudmila Osinovskaya
Discourse Analysis
Discourse Analysis
Dr. Cupid Lucid
Discourse Analysis ppt
Discourse Analysis ppt
Aisyah Pujakesuma
How To Do A Discourse Analysis
How To Do A Discourse Analysis
guestfca522
Pragmatics - George Yule
Pragmatics - George Yule
Anthony Salinas

Similar to Stance indexicalityworkshop (20)

Information technologies of cognitive thesauri design
Information technologies of cognitive thesauri design
Philippovich Andrey
Meaning In Communication Cognition And Reality Outline Of A Theory From Semio...
Meaning In Communication Cognition And Reality Outline Of A Theory From Semio...
loritrody16
Semiotic analysis
Semiotic analysis
Archana R Singh
Semiotics and information science
Semiotics and information science
Florence Paisey
Semiotics and Information Science
Semiotics and Information Science
Florence Paisey
paradigmatic controversies, contradictions, and emerging confluences
paradigmatic controversies, contradictions, and emerging confluences
felipemtz89
Class3 - What is This Language Structure
Class3 - What is This Language Structure
Nathacia Lucena
328977061-English-Lexicology-2014 2015.pdf
328977061-English-Lexicology-2014 2015.pdf
MaryamAfzal41
No Show 2012 - Clara Fern叩ndez-Vara - Environmental Storytelling
No Show 2012 - Clara Fern叩ndez-Vara - Environmental Storytelling
No Show Conference
Meeting 2 - Research Paradigm.ppt
Meeting 2 - Research Paradigm.ppt
Mahadi Bahari
Da vinci presentation ontology epistemology Dr Rica VIljoen
Da vinci presentation ontology epistemology Dr Rica VIljoen
Dr Rica Viljoen
OLEX
OLEX
Oleksandr Slobodianyk
Writing workshop part 1
Writing workshop part 1
Espen Stranger-Johannessen
Physical artefacts, indices and experience in communication
Physical artefacts, indices and experience in communication
Merja Bauters
Meaningful Interaction Analysis
Meaningful Interaction Analysis
fridolin.wild
Participants in Discourse
Participants in Discourse
Mary Anne Colico-Bantiling
Indexical Cycles
Indexical Cycles
Scott F. Kiesling
Semiotics and conceptual modeling gv 2015
Semiotics and conceptual modeling gv 2015
Guido Vetere
The State of Semantics
The State of Semantics
Seth Grimes
Research Paradigms and Logic of Research and Implications for Research Design...
Research Paradigms and Logic of Research and Implications for Research Design...
NoreenRafique3
Information technologies of cognitive thesauri design
Information technologies of cognitive thesauri design
Philippovich Andrey
Meaning In Communication Cognition And Reality Outline Of A Theory From Semio...
Meaning In Communication Cognition And Reality Outline Of A Theory From Semio...
loritrody16
Semiotics and information science
Semiotics and information science
Florence Paisey
Semiotics and Information Science
Semiotics and Information Science
Florence Paisey
paradigmatic controversies, contradictions, and emerging confluences
paradigmatic controversies, contradictions, and emerging confluences
felipemtz89
Class3 - What is This Language Structure
Class3 - What is This Language Structure
Nathacia Lucena
328977061-English-Lexicology-2014 2015.pdf
328977061-English-Lexicology-2014 2015.pdf
MaryamAfzal41
No Show 2012 - Clara Fern叩ndez-Vara - Environmental Storytelling
No Show 2012 - Clara Fern叩ndez-Vara - Environmental Storytelling
No Show Conference
Meeting 2 - Research Paradigm.ppt
Meeting 2 - Research Paradigm.ppt
Mahadi Bahari
Da vinci presentation ontology epistemology Dr Rica VIljoen
Da vinci presentation ontology epistemology Dr Rica VIljoen
Dr Rica Viljoen
Physical artefacts, indices and experience in communication
Physical artefacts, indices and experience in communication
Merja Bauters
Meaningful Interaction Analysis
Meaningful Interaction Analysis
fridolin.wild
Semiotics and conceptual modeling gv 2015
Semiotics and conceptual modeling gv 2015
Guido Vetere
The State of Semantics
The State of Semantics
Seth Grimes
Research Paradigms and Logic of Research and Implications for Research Design...
Research Paradigms and Logic of Research and Implications for Research Design...
NoreenRafique3
Ad

Recently uploaded (20)

FIDO Seminar: Targeting Trust: The Future of Identity in the Workforce.pptx
FIDO Seminar: Targeting Trust: The Future of Identity in the Workforce.pptx
FIDO Alliance
A Constitutional Quagmire - Ethical Minefields of AI, Cyber, and Privacy.pdf
A Constitutional Quagmire - Ethical Minefields of AI, Cyber, and Privacy.pdf
Priyanka Aash
Raman Bhaumik - Passionate Tech Enthusiast
Raman Bhaumik - Passionate Tech Enthusiast
Raman Bhaumik
"How to survive Black Friday: preparing e-commerce for a peak season", Yurii ...
"How to survive Black Friday: preparing e-commerce for a peak season", Yurii ...
Fwdays
Lessons Learned from Developing Secure AI Workflows.pdf
Lessons Learned from Developing Secure AI Workflows.pdf
Priyanka Aash
Improving Data Integrity: Synchronization between EAM and ArcGIS Utility Netw...
Improving Data Integrity: Synchronization between EAM and ArcGIS Utility Netw...
Safe Software
9-1-1 Addressing: End-to-End Automation Using FME
9-1-1 Addressing: End-to-End Automation Using FME
Safe Software
Techniques for Automatic Device Identification and Network Assignment.pdf
Techniques for Automatic Device Identification and Network Assignment.pdf
Priyanka Aash
Python Conference Singapore - 19 Jun 2025
Python Conference Singapore - 19 Jun 2025
ninefyi
PyCon SG 25 - Firecracker Made Easy with Python.pdf
PyCon SG 25 - Firecracker Made Easy with Python.pdf
Muhammad Yuga Nugraha
From Manual to Auto Searching- FME in the Driver's Seat
From Manual to Auto Searching- FME in the Driver's Seat
Safe Software
Cyber Defense Matrix Workshop - RSA Conference
Cyber Defense Matrix Workshop - RSA Conference
Priyanka Aash
AI VIDEO MAGAZINE - June 2025 - r/aivideo
AI VIDEO MAGAZINE - June 2025 - r/aivideo
1pcity Studios, Inc
OpenACC and Open Hackathons Monthly Highlights June 2025
OpenACC and Open Hackathons Monthly Highlights June 2025
OpenACC
Smarter Aviation Data Management: Lessons from Swedavia Airports and Sweco
Smarter Aviation Data Management: Lessons from Swedavia Airports and Sweco
Safe Software
Securing Account Lifecycles in the Age of Deepfakes.pptx
Securing Account Lifecycles in the Age of Deepfakes.pptx
FIDO Alliance
FIDO Alliance Seminar State of Passkeys.pptx
FIDO Alliance Seminar State of Passkeys.pptx
FIDO Alliance
Key Requirements to Successfully Implement Generative AI in Edge DevicesOpt...
Key Requirements to Successfully Implement Generative AI in Edge DevicesOpt...
Edge AI and Vision Alliance
MuleSoft for AgentForce : Topic Center and API Catalog
MuleSoft for AgentForce : Topic Center and API Catalog
shyamraj55
Security Tips for Enterprise Azure Solutions
Security Tips for Enterprise Azure Solutions
Michele Leroux Bustamante
FIDO Seminar: Targeting Trust: The Future of Identity in the Workforce.pptx
FIDO Seminar: Targeting Trust: The Future of Identity in the Workforce.pptx
FIDO Alliance
A Constitutional Quagmire - Ethical Minefields of AI, Cyber, and Privacy.pdf
A Constitutional Quagmire - Ethical Minefields of AI, Cyber, and Privacy.pdf
Priyanka Aash
Raman Bhaumik - Passionate Tech Enthusiast
Raman Bhaumik - Passionate Tech Enthusiast
Raman Bhaumik
"How to survive Black Friday: preparing e-commerce for a peak season", Yurii ...
"How to survive Black Friday: preparing e-commerce for a peak season", Yurii ...
Fwdays
Lessons Learned from Developing Secure AI Workflows.pdf
Lessons Learned from Developing Secure AI Workflows.pdf
Priyanka Aash
Improving Data Integrity: Synchronization between EAM and ArcGIS Utility Netw...
Improving Data Integrity: Synchronization between EAM and ArcGIS Utility Netw...
Safe Software
9-1-1 Addressing: End-to-End Automation Using FME
9-1-1 Addressing: End-to-End Automation Using FME
Safe Software
Techniques for Automatic Device Identification and Network Assignment.pdf
Techniques for Automatic Device Identification and Network Assignment.pdf
Priyanka Aash
Python Conference Singapore - 19 Jun 2025
Python Conference Singapore - 19 Jun 2025
ninefyi
PyCon SG 25 - Firecracker Made Easy with Python.pdf
PyCon SG 25 - Firecracker Made Easy with Python.pdf
Muhammad Yuga Nugraha
From Manual to Auto Searching- FME in the Driver's Seat
From Manual to Auto Searching- FME in the Driver's Seat
Safe Software
Cyber Defense Matrix Workshop - RSA Conference
Cyber Defense Matrix Workshop - RSA Conference
Priyanka Aash
AI VIDEO MAGAZINE - June 2025 - r/aivideo
AI VIDEO MAGAZINE - June 2025 - r/aivideo
1pcity Studios, Inc
OpenACC and Open Hackathons Monthly Highlights June 2025
OpenACC and Open Hackathons Monthly Highlights June 2025
OpenACC
Smarter Aviation Data Management: Lessons from Swedavia Airports and Sweco
Smarter Aviation Data Management: Lessons from Swedavia Airports and Sweco
Safe Software
Securing Account Lifecycles in the Age of Deepfakes.pptx
Securing Account Lifecycles in the Age of Deepfakes.pptx
FIDO Alliance
FIDO Alliance Seminar State of Passkeys.pptx
FIDO Alliance Seminar State of Passkeys.pptx
FIDO Alliance
Key Requirements to Successfully Implement Generative AI in Edge DevicesOpt...
Key Requirements to Successfully Implement Generative AI in Edge DevicesOpt...
Edge AI and Vision Alliance
MuleSoft for AgentForce : Topic Center and API Catalog
MuleSoft for AgentForce : Topic Center and API Catalog
shyamraj55
Security Tips for Enterprise Azure Solutions
Security Tips for Enterprise Azure Solutions
Michele Leroux Bustamante
Ad

Stance indexicalityworkshop

  • 1. Indexicality & Stance Workshop Objectives Indexicality Indexical terms The big challenge: parsing Silverstein Why is it useful? (Is it?)
  • 2. Indexicality & Stance Workshop Stance Definitions Examples Practice Useful for what?
  • 3. Objectives Explicate the terms and their use Further explore their potential as a group, hopefully for your later use!
  • 4. Indexicality Write down as many examples of things you think are indexes in the next 100 seconds!
  • 5. Indexicality What questions do you have about indexicality?
  • 6. Terms in Peircean meaning Icon : a sign vehicle that resembles that which it signifies. buzz, or rising intonation in some cases Symbol : meaning depends entirely on an abstract arbitrary connection Index : pure indexes are features of speech which, independent of any referential speech events that may be occurring, signal some particular value of one or more contextual variables. Silverstein (1995[1976]:201) Shifters : referential indexes which have rules of use that gain reference only in context (tense, place deixis)
  • 7. Terms in Peircean meaning 76 Definitions of The Sign by C. S. Peirce collected and analyzed by Robert Marty Department of Mathematics University of Perpignan Perpignan, France With an Appendix of 12 Further Definitions or Equivalents proposed by Alfred Lang Dept of Psychology University of Bern Bern, Switzerland http://www.cspeirce.com/menu/library/rsources/76defs/76defs.htm
  • 8. Big Questions How and why are indexical meanings realised?
  • 9. Presupposing and creative presupposing : assumes (follows) rules of use (e.g., this chair and that chair) creative or performative -- entailment : make explicit and overt the parameters of the ongoing event (English pronouns, esp. 2p) Examples??
  • 10. Indexical orders Similar to Labovian awareness although discussed in terms of metapragmatic discourse and less reliant on widely shared norms in the speech community. A process of conventionalization. As you go up indexical orders, they have more creative effects.
  • 11. To the text! Silverstein, Michael. 2003. Indexical order and the dialectics of sociolinguistic life. Language & Communication , 23: 193-229.
  • 12. Indexical fields (webs?) indexical field : constellation of ideologically related meanings any one of which can be activated in the situated use of the variable
  • 14. Questions about your examples or just questions? Shy? Write questions down and leave them up here during the break.
  • 15. How are these terminological distinctions useful in different areas of sociolinguistics?
  • 16. Stance What is it? Write down what YOU think it is.
  • 17. Big Questions Methodologically, how do we find it? How does stance get created? How do linguistic things work together to create a stance?
  • 18. What is it again? (Technical version) How you stand in relation to another thing, including people and the ideas you represent. Linguistically created through the fractional congruence of different linguistic stuff.
  • 19. Aspects of Stance Stance Object: Person, thing, idea, talk Affect: Emotion or alignment Epistemicity: Knowledge representation Social axes: Power and solidarity Stance is relational and fluid
  • 20. Example Various bits of stance created by Mick in the early stages of example 1. Stance Object: Person, thing, idea, talk Affect: Emotion or alignment Epistemicity: Knowledge representation Social axes: Power and solidarity