ºÝºÝߣ

ºÝºÝߣShare a Scribd company logo
Towards a classification
framework for social machines
Submission at the SOCM2013 workshop @ WWW2013
Elena Simperl, Max Van Kleek
13 March 2013
Motivation and objectives
? Future ICT systems as sophisticated assemblies of data-intensive,
complex automation and deep community involvement
? Defining social machines and their characteristic properties as
necessary step towards a principled understanding of the science and
engineering of such systems
? Objectives of this work
¨C Identify and define the constructs to describe, study and compare
social machines
¨C Achieve a shared understanding of basic notions and terminology
through involvement from the broader community
? Useful tool for both researchers in social and computer sciences and for
developers and operators of existing and future social machines
2
Social machines and related areas
? Social machines
¨C Interaction among
algorithmic and social
components
¨C Different notion of
computation (cf Turing) w.r.t.
problem specification,
performance, quality of
outputs, termination
¨C Incentives and motivation,
network effects
? Related areas
¨C Computer science: CSCW,
social computing, human
computation
¨C Organizational
management/social sciences:
wisdom of the crowds,
collective intelligence, open
innovation, crowdsourcing
3
The polyarchical relationship of social machines
? Platforms/technologies vs social machines created for specific
purposes. E.g., MediaWiki vs Wikipedia
? Broader vs narrower-scoped social machines. E.g., Twitter vs Obama¡¯12
? Ecosystem of social machines. E.g., results from GalaxyZoo taken up in
Wikipedia articles
4
Challenges and research questions
? What do specific instances of a social machine have in
common, and how do they differ dynamically?
? How do certain design decisions taken at the level of the
infrastructure, frameworks and service propagate into
narrower-focused systems?
? How do such decisions affect a broader ecosystem of social
machines, each with their own, though overlapping,
purposes and communities?
5
Framework overview
? Repertory grid elicitation to derive an initial set of
elements (instances of social machines) and constructs
(characteristics of social machines) ? 10 grids, 56
elements, 117 constructs
? Consolidation and clustering of constructs ? 31 constructs,
four clusters
¨C Popularity
¨C Tasks and purpose
¨C Participants and roles
¨C Motivation and incentives
6
Constructs: purpose of the system and contributions
? Purpose of the system, types of contributions, degree to
which these change
7
Constructs: people, roles, motivation
? Types of audience, autonomy and anonymity, roles and role
hierarchies
? Intrinsic vs. extrinsic motivation, rewards
8
Using the constructs
9
Next steps: refine constructs
? Standard listings for types of contributions, actions, activities
? Relationship between roles, autonomy, and anonymity and motivators
? Motivation and incentives: participation in the definition of the overall purpose,
transparency of purpose
? Missing
¨C Nature of the good produced
¨C Existing social structures
¨C Interaction between algorithmic and social components, workflows
¨C Consolidation and aggregation of contributions, quality assurance
10
Next steps: community engagement and evaluation
? Community engagement: building a social machine to
define the SOCIAM classification framework
? Evaluation:
¨C Task-independent using criteria from knowledge
engineering (completeness, correctness, readability,
redundancy etc)
¨C Task-dependent: Can the framework be used to describe
existing social machines?
11

More Related Content

Viewers also liked (14)

Social Interfaces
Social InterfacesSocial Interfaces
Social Interfaces
SOCIAM Project
?
Balaustra prot.gm 01 2012 innov.nella trad
Balaustra prot.gm 01 2012 innov.nella tradBalaustra prot.gm 01 2012 innov.nella trad
Balaustra prot.gm 01 2012 innov.nella trad
Massoneria Universale
?
Mvk 2013-february -health-social-machines
Mvk 2013-february -health-social-machinesMvk 2013-february -health-social-machines
Mvk 2013-february -health-social-machines
SOCIAM Project
?
Security and Legitimacy in a Web Observatory: Requirements for Data Linkage, ...
Security and Legitimacy in a Web Observatory: Requirements for Data Linkage, ...Security and Legitimacy in a Web Observatory: Requirements for Data Linkage, ...
Security and Legitimacy in a Web Observatory: Requirements for Data Linkage, ...
SOCIAM Project
?
Big Data meets Big Social: Social Machines and the Semantic Web
Big Data meets Big Social: Social Machines and the Semantic WebBig Data meets Big Social: Social Machines and the Semantic Web
Big Data meets Big Social: Social Machines and the Semantic Web
David De Roure
?
Incentives-driven technology design
Incentives-driven technology designIncentives-driven technology design
Incentives-driven technology design
Elena Simperl
?
Il Perch¨¦ delle Api - Tavola Massonica del Fratello Domenico Vittorio Ripa M...
Il Perch¨¦ delle Api -  Tavola Massonica del Fratello Domenico Vittorio Ripa M...Il Perch¨¦ delle Api -  Tavola Massonica del Fratello Domenico Vittorio Ripa M...
Il Perch¨¦ delle Api - Tavola Massonica del Fratello Domenico Vittorio Ripa M...
Massoneria Universale
?
Prefazione alla Seconda Edizione dei Volumi Pubblicati dalla Casa Editrice Gr...
Prefazione alla Seconda Edizione dei Volumi Pubblicati dalla Casa Editrice Gr...Prefazione alla Seconda Edizione dei Volumi Pubblicati dalla Casa Editrice Gr...
Prefazione alla Seconda Edizione dei Volumi Pubblicati dalla Casa Editrice Gr...
Massoneria Universale
?
Phoenix Mappa del Sito della Gran Loggia Phoenix degli ALAM ?
Phoenix Mappa del Sito della Gran Loggia Phoenix degli ALAM ?Phoenix Mappa del Sito della Gran Loggia Phoenix degli ALAM ?
Phoenix Mappa del Sito della Gran Loggia Phoenix degli ALAM ?
Massoneria Universale
?
Emergency Action Plan Training Review
Emergency Action Plan Training ReviewEmergency Action Plan Training Review
Emergency Action Plan Training Review
Jamie Cyphers
?
Social Machines of Science and Scholarship
Social Machines of Science and ScholarshipSocial Machines of Science and Scholarship
Social Machines of Science and Scholarship
David De Roure
?
WEBBOX
WEBBOXWEBBOX
WEBBOX
SOCIAM Project
?
Social Machines GSS
Social Machines GSSSocial Machines GSS
Social Machines GSS
David De Roure
?
Balaustra prot.gm 01 2012 innov.nella trad
Balaustra prot.gm 01 2012 innov.nella tradBalaustra prot.gm 01 2012 innov.nella trad
Balaustra prot.gm 01 2012 innov.nella trad
Massoneria Universale
?
Mvk 2013-february -health-social-machines
Mvk 2013-february -health-social-machinesMvk 2013-february -health-social-machines
Mvk 2013-february -health-social-machines
SOCIAM Project
?
Security and Legitimacy in a Web Observatory: Requirements for Data Linkage, ...
Security and Legitimacy in a Web Observatory: Requirements for Data Linkage, ...Security and Legitimacy in a Web Observatory: Requirements for Data Linkage, ...
Security and Legitimacy in a Web Observatory: Requirements for Data Linkage, ...
SOCIAM Project
?
Big Data meets Big Social: Social Machines and the Semantic Web
Big Data meets Big Social: Social Machines and the Semantic WebBig Data meets Big Social: Social Machines and the Semantic Web
Big Data meets Big Social: Social Machines and the Semantic Web
David De Roure
?
Incentives-driven technology design
Incentives-driven technology designIncentives-driven technology design
Incentives-driven technology design
Elena Simperl
?
Il Perch¨¦ delle Api - Tavola Massonica del Fratello Domenico Vittorio Ripa M...
Il Perch¨¦ delle Api -  Tavola Massonica del Fratello Domenico Vittorio Ripa M...Il Perch¨¦ delle Api -  Tavola Massonica del Fratello Domenico Vittorio Ripa M...
Il Perch¨¦ delle Api - Tavola Massonica del Fratello Domenico Vittorio Ripa M...
Massoneria Universale
?
Prefazione alla Seconda Edizione dei Volumi Pubblicati dalla Casa Editrice Gr...
Prefazione alla Seconda Edizione dei Volumi Pubblicati dalla Casa Editrice Gr...Prefazione alla Seconda Edizione dei Volumi Pubblicati dalla Casa Editrice Gr...
Prefazione alla Seconda Edizione dei Volumi Pubblicati dalla Casa Editrice Gr...
Massoneria Universale
?
Phoenix Mappa del Sito della Gran Loggia Phoenix degli ALAM ?
Phoenix Mappa del Sito della Gran Loggia Phoenix degli ALAM ?Phoenix Mappa del Sito della Gran Loggia Phoenix degli ALAM ?
Phoenix Mappa del Sito della Gran Loggia Phoenix degli ALAM ?
Massoneria Universale
?
Emergency Action Plan Training Review
Emergency Action Plan Training ReviewEmergency Action Plan Training Review
Emergency Action Plan Training Review
Jamie Cyphers
?
Social Machines of Science and Scholarship
Social Machines of Science and ScholarshipSocial Machines of Science and Scholarship
Social Machines of Science and Scholarship
David De Roure
?

Similar to Towards a classification framework for social machines copy (20)

Tinati - the HTP Model understanding the development of social machines
Tinati  - the HTP Model understanding the development of social machinesTinati  - the HTP Model understanding the development of social machines
Tinati - the HTP Model understanding the development of social machines
Ramine Tinati
?
Catalyst negotiation workshop may 15 v5
Catalyst negotiation workshop may 15 v5Catalyst negotiation workshop may 15 v5
Catalyst negotiation workshop may 15 v5
Wikiprogress_slides
?
Catalyst negotiation workshop may 15 v5
Catalyst negotiation workshop may 15 v5Catalyst negotiation workshop may 15 v5
Catalyst negotiation workshop may 15 v5
Wikiprogress_slides
?
Socio Technical Systems
Socio Technical SystemsSocio Technical Systems
Socio Technical Systems
Vikram Rao
?
socio technical system theory.pdf
socio technical system theory.pdfsocio technical system theory.pdf
socio technical system theory.pdf
Ogunleye Samuel
?
Lec 1 computational modeling - Introduction.pdf
Lec 1 computational modeling - Introduction.pdfLec 1 computational modeling - Introduction.pdf
Lec 1 computational modeling - Introduction.pdf
ArwaAbdelHamid1
?
Hybrid Collective Adaptive Systems
Hybrid Collective Adaptive SystemsHybrid Collective Adaptive Systems
Hybrid Collective Adaptive Systems
Ognjen Scekic
?
HUman computer Interaction Socio-organizational Issues.ppt
HUman computer Interaction Socio-organizational Issues.pptHUman computer Interaction Socio-organizational Issues.ppt
HUman computer Interaction Socio-organizational Issues.ppt
Jayaprasanna4
?
HUman computer Interaction Socio-organizational Issues.ppt
HUman computer Interaction Socio-organizational Issues.pptHUman computer Interaction Socio-organizational Issues.ppt
HUman computer Interaction Socio-organizational Issues.ppt
Jayaprasanna4
?
e3-chap-13.ppt
e3-chap-13.ppte3-chap-13.ppt
e3-chap-13.ppt
kannanramu4
?
E3 chap-13
E3 chap-13E3 chap-13
E3 chap-13
Welly Dian Astika
?
e3-chap-13.pptttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttt
e3-chap-13.pptttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttte3-chap-13.pptttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttt
e3-chap-13.pptttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttt
ssuserc64fd9
?
On data-driven systems analyzing, supporting and enhancing users¡¯ interaction...
On data-driven systems analyzing, supporting and enhancing users¡¯ interaction...On data-driven systems analyzing, supporting and enhancing users¡¯ interaction...
On data-driven systems analyzing, supporting and enhancing users¡¯ interaction...
Grial - University of Salamanca
?
CS6010 Social Network Analysis Unit IV
CS6010 Social Network Analysis Unit IVCS6010 Social Network Analysis Unit IV
CS6010 Social Network Analysis Unit IV
pkaviya
?
Exploring Generative Models of Tripartite Graphs for Recommendation in Social...
Exploring Generative Models of Tripartite Graphs for Recommendation in Social...Exploring Generative Models of Tripartite Graphs for Recommendation in Social...
Exploring Generative Models of Tripartite Graphs for Recommendation in Social...
Charalampos Chelmis
?
Network Awareness Tool - Learning Analytics in the workplace: ?Detecting and ...
Network Awareness Tool - Learning Analytics in the workplace: ?Detecting and ...Network Awareness Tool - Learning Analytics in the workplace: ?Detecting and ...
Network Awareness Tool - Learning Analytics in the workplace: ?Detecting and ...
Maarten de Laat, LOOK, Open Universiteit, The Netherlands
?
Long tails and super users anne-alexander
Long tails and super users anne-alexanderLong tails and super users anne-alexander
Long tails and super users anne-alexander
humanitiescrowds
?
Systemic Design Toolkit - Systems Innovation Barcelona
Systemic Design Toolkit - Systems Innovation BarcelonaSystemic Design Toolkit - Systems Innovation Barcelona
Systemic Design Toolkit - Systems Innovation Barcelona
Peter Jones
?
Social and organizational perspective in HCI
Social and organizational perspective in HCISocial and organizational perspective in HCI
Social and organizational perspective in HCI
Saqib Shehzad
?
Observing Social Machines Part 1: What to Observe?
Observing Social Machines Part 1: What to Observe?Observing Social Machines Part 1: What to Observe?
Observing Social Machines Part 1: What to Observe?
David De Roure
?
Tinati - the HTP Model understanding the development of social machines
Tinati  - the HTP Model understanding the development of social machinesTinati  - the HTP Model understanding the development of social machines
Tinati - the HTP Model understanding the development of social machines
Ramine Tinati
?
Catalyst negotiation workshop may 15 v5
Catalyst negotiation workshop may 15 v5Catalyst negotiation workshop may 15 v5
Catalyst negotiation workshop may 15 v5
Wikiprogress_slides
?
Catalyst negotiation workshop may 15 v5
Catalyst negotiation workshop may 15 v5Catalyst negotiation workshop may 15 v5
Catalyst negotiation workshop may 15 v5
Wikiprogress_slides
?
Socio Technical Systems
Socio Technical SystemsSocio Technical Systems
Socio Technical Systems
Vikram Rao
?
socio technical system theory.pdf
socio technical system theory.pdfsocio technical system theory.pdf
socio technical system theory.pdf
Ogunleye Samuel
?
Lec 1 computational modeling - Introduction.pdf
Lec 1 computational modeling - Introduction.pdfLec 1 computational modeling - Introduction.pdf
Lec 1 computational modeling - Introduction.pdf
ArwaAbdelHamid1
?
Hybrid Collective Adaptive Systems
Hybrid Collective Adaptive SystemsHybrid Collective Adaptive Systems
Hybrid Collective Adaptive Systems
Ognjen Scekic
?
HUman computer Interaction Socio-organizational Issues.ppt
HUman computer Interaction Socio-organizational Issues.pptHUman computer Interaction Socio-organizational Issues.ppt
HUman computer Interaction Socio-organizational Issues.ppt
Jayaprasanna4
?
HUman computer Interaction Socio-organizational Issues.ppt
HUman computer Interaction Socio-organizational Issues.pptHUman computer Interaction Socio-organizational Issues.ppt
HUman computer Interaction Socio-organizational Issues.ppt
Jayaprasanna4
?
e3-chap-13.pptttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttt
e3-chap-13.pptttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttte3-chap-13.pptttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttt
e3-chap-13.pptttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttt
ssuserc64fd9
?
On data-driven systems analyzing, supporting and enhancing users¡¯ interaction...
On data-driven systems analyzing, supporting and enhancing users¡¯ interaction...On data-driven systems analyzing, supporting and enhancing users¡¯ interaction...
On data-driven systems analyzing, supporting and enhancing users¡¯ interaction...
Grial - University of Salamanca
?
CS6010 Social Network Analysis Unit IV
CS6010 Social Network Analysis Unit IVCS6010 Social Network Analysis Unit IV
CS6010 Social Network Analysis Unit IV
pkaviya
?
Exploring Generative Models of Tripartite Graphs for Recommendation in Social...
Exploring Generative Models of Tripartite Graphs for Recommendation in Social...Exploring Generative Models of Tripartite Graphs for Recommendation in Social...
Exploring Generative Models of Tripartite Graphs for Recommendation in Social...
Charalampos Chelmis
?
Long tails and super users anne-alexander
Long tails and super users anne-alexanderLong tails and super users anne-alexander
Long tails and super users anne-alexander
humanitiescrowds
?
Systemic Design Toolkit - Systems Innovation Barcelona
Systemic Design Toolkit - Systems Innovation BarcelonaSystemic Design Toolkit - Systems Innovation Barcelona
Systemic Design Toolkit - Systems Innovation Barcelona
Peter Jones
?
Social and organizational perspective in HCI
Social and organizational perspective in HCISocial and organizational perspective in HCI
Social and organizational perspective in HCI
Saqib Shehzad
?
Observing Social Machines Part 1: What to Observe?
Observing Social Machines Part 1: What to Observe?Observing Social Machines Part 1: What to Observe?
Observing Social Machines Part 1: What to Observe?
David De Roure
?

Recently uploaded (20)

How Discord Indexes Trillions of Messages: Scaling Search Infrastructure by V...
How Discord Indexes Trillions of Messages: Scaling Search Infrastructure by V...How Discord Indexes Trillions of Messages: Scaling Search Infrastructure by V...
How Discord Indexes Trillions of Messages: Scaling Search Infrastructure by V...
ScyllaDB
?
Revolutionizing-Government-Communication-The-OSWAN-Success-Story
Revolutionizing-Government-Communication-The-OSWAN-Success-StoryRevolutionizing-Government-Communication-The-OSWAN-Success-Story
Revolutionizing-Government-Communication-The-OSWAN-Success-Story
ssuser52ad5e
?
Deno ...................................
Deno ...................................Deno ...................................
Deno ...................................
Robert MacLean
?
Fl studio crack version 12.9 Free Download
Fl studio crack version 12.9 Free DownloadFl studio crack version 12.9 Free Download
Fl studio crack version 12.9 Free Download
kherorpacca127
?
Cloud of everything Tech of the 21 century in Aviation
Cloud of everything Tech of the 21 century in AviationCloud of everything Tech of the 21 century in Aviation
Cloud of everything Tech of the 21 century in Aviation
Assem mousa
?
Technology use over time and its impact on consumers and businesses.pptx
Technology use over time and its impact on consumers and businesses.pptxTechnology use over time and its impact on consumers and businesses.pptx
Technology use over time and its impact on consumers and businesses.pptx
kaylagaze
?
Field Device Management Market Report 2030 - TechSci Research
Field Device Management Market Report 2030 - TechSci ResearchField Device Management Market Report 2030 - TechSci Research
Field Device Management Market Report 2030 - TechSci Research
Vipin Mishra
?
A Framework for Model-Driven Digital Twin Engineering
A Framework for Model-Driven Digital Twin EngineeringA Framework for Model-Driven Digital Twin Engineering
A Framework for Model-Driven Digital Twin Engineering
Daniel Lehner
?
Future-Proof Your Career with AI Options
Future-Proof Your  Career with AI OptionsFuture-Proof Your  Career with AI Options
Future-Proof Your Career with AI Options
DianaGray10
?
UiPath Automation Developer Associate Training Series 2025 - Session 1
UiPath Automation Developer Associate Training Series 2025 - Session 1UiPath Automation Developer Associate Training Series 2025 - Session 1
UiPath Automation Developer Associate Training Series 2025 - Session 1
DianaGray10
?
Gojek Clone Multi-Service Super App.pptx
Gojek Clone Multi-Service Super App.pptxGojek Clone Multi-Service Super App.pptx
Gojek Clone Multi-Service Super App.pptx
V3cube
?
Wondershare Dr.Fone Crack Free Download 2025
Wondershare Dr.Fone Crack Free Download 2025Wondershare Dr.Fone Crack Free Download 2025
Wondershare Dr.Fone Crack Free Download 2025
maharajput103
?
1.1. Evolution-and-Scope-of-Business-Analytics.pptx
1.1. Evolution-and-Scope-of-Business-Analytics.pptx1.1. Evolution-and-Scope-of-Business-Analytics.pptx
1.1. Evolution-and-Scope-of-Business-Analytics.pptx
Jitendra Tomar
?
FinTech - US Annual Funding Report - 2024.pptx
FinTech - US Annual Funding Report - 2024.pptxFinTech - US Annual Funding Report - 2024.pptx
FinTech - US Annual Funding Report - 2024.pptx
Tracxn
?
Transform Your Future with Front-End Development Training
Transform Your Future with Front-End Development TrainingTransform Your Future with Front-End Development Training
Transform Your Future with Front-End Development Training
Vtechlabs
?
Formal Methods: Whence and Whither? [Martin Fr?nzle Festkolloquium, 2025]
Formal Methods: Whence and Whither? [Martin Fr?nzle Festkolloquium, 2025]Formal Methods: Whence and Whither? [Martin Fr?nzle Festkolloquium, 2025]
Formal Methods: Whence and Whither? [Martin Fr?nzle Festkolloquium, 2025]
Jonathan Bowen
?
Build with AI on Google Cloud Session #4
Build with AI on Google Cloud Session #4Build with AI on Google Cloud Session #4
Build with AI on Google Cloud Session #4
Margaret Maynard-Reid
?
Inside Freshworks' Migration from Cassandra to ScyllaDB by Premkumar Patturaj
Inside Freshworks' Migration from Cassandra to ScyllaDB by Premkumar PatturajInside Freshworks' Migration from Cassandra to ScyllaDB by Premkumar Patturaj
Inside Freshworks' Migration from Cassandra to ScyllaDB by Premkumar Patturaj
ScyllaDB
?
Q4 2024 Earnings and Investor Presentation
Q4 2024 Earnings and Investor PresentationQ4 2024 Earnings and Investor Presentation
Q4 2024 Earnings and Investor Presentation
Dropbox
?
DAO UTokyo 2025 DLT mass adoption case studies IBM Tsuyoshi Hirayama (ƽɽÒã)
DAO UTokyo 2025 DLT mass adoption case studies IBM Tsuyoshi Hirayama (ƽɽÒã)DAO UTokyo 2025 DLT mass adoption case studies IBM Tsuyoshi Hirayama (ƽɽÒã)
DAO UTokyo 2025 DLT mass adoption case studies IBM Tsuyoshi Hirayama (ƽɽÒã)
Tsuyoshi Hirayama
?
How Discord Indexes Trillions of Messages: Scaling Search Infrastructure by V...
How Discord Indexes Trillions of Messages: Scaling Search Infrastructure by V...How Discord Indexes Trillions of Messages: Scaling Search Infrastructure by V...
How Discord Indexes Trillions of Messages: Scaling Search Infrastructure by V...
ScyllaDB
?
Revolutionizing-Government-Communication-The-OSWAN-Success-Story
Revolutionizing-Government-Communication-The-OSWAN-Success-StoryRevolutionizing-Government-Communication-The-OSWAN-Success-Story
Revolutionizing-Government-Communication-The-OSWAN-Success-Story
ssuser52ad5e
?
Deno ...................................
Deno ...................................Deno ...................................
Deno ...................................
Robert MacLean
?
Fl studio crack version 12.9 Free Download
Fl studio crack version 12.9 Free DownloadFl studio crack version 12.9 Free Download
Fl studio crack version 12.9 Free Download
kherorpacca127
?
Cloud of everything Tech of the 21 century in Aviation
Cloud of everything Tech of the 21 century in AviationCloud of everything Tech of the 21 century in Aviation
Cloud of everything Tech of the 21 century in Aviation
Assem mousa
?
Technology use over time and its impact on consumers and businesses.pptx
Technology use over time and its impact on consumers and businesses.pptxTechnology use over time and its impact on consumers and businesses.pptx
Technology use over time and its impact on consumers and businesses.pptx
kaylagaze
?
Field Device Management Market Report 2030 - TechSci Research
Field Device Management Market Report 2030 - TechSci ResearchField Device Management Market Report 2030 - TechSci Research
Field Device Management Market Report 2030 - TechSci Research
Vipin Mishra
?
A Framework for Model-Driven Digital Twin Engineering
A Framework for Model-Driven Digital Twin EngineeringA Framework for Model-Driven Digital Twin Engineering
A Framework for Model-Driven Digital Twin Engineering
Daniel Lehner
?
Future-Proof Your Career with AI Options
Future-Proof Your  Career with AI OptionsFuture-Proof Your  Career with AI Options
Future-Proof Your Career with AI Options
DianaGray10
?
UiPath Automation Developer Associate Training Series 2025 - Session 1
UiPath Automation Developer Associate Training Series 2025 - Session 1UiPath Automation Developer Associate Training Series 2025 - Session 1
UiPath Automation Developer Associate Training Series 2025 - Session 1
DianaGray10
?
Gojek Clone Multi-Service Super App.pptx
Gojek Clone Multi-Service Super App.pptxGojek Clone Multi-Service Super App.pptx
Gojek Clone Multi-Service Super App.pptx
V3cube
?
Wondershare Dr.Fone Crack Free Download 2025
Wondershare Dr.Fone Crack Free Download 2025Wondershare Dr.Fone Crack Free Download 2025
Wondershare Dr.Fone Crack Free Download 2025
maharajput103
?
1.1. Evolution-and-Scope-of-Business-Analytics.pptx
1.1. Evolution-and-Scope-of-Business-Analytics.pptx1.1. Evolution-and-Scope-of-Business-Analytics.pptx
1.1. Evolution-and-Scope-of-Business-Analytics.pptx
Jitendra Tomar
?
FinTech - US Annual Funding Report - 2024.pptx
FinTech - US Annual Funding Report - 2024.pptxFinTech - US Annual Funding Report - 2024.pptx
FinTech - US Annual Funding Report - 2024.pptx
Tracxn
?
Transform Your Future with Front-End Development Training
Transform Your Future with Front-End Development TrainingTransform Your Future with Front-End Development Training
Transform Your Future with Front-End Development Training
Vtechlabs
?
Formal Methods: Whence and Whither? [Martin Fr?nzle Festkolloquium, 2025]
Formal Methods: Whence and Whither? [Martin Fr?nzle Festkolloquium, 2025]Formal Methods: Whence and Whither? [Martin Fr?nzle Festkolloquium, 2025]
Formal Methods: Whence and Whither? [Martin Fr?nzle Festkolloquium, 2025]
Jonathan Bowen
?
Build with AI on Google Cloud Session #4
Build with AI on Google Cloud Session #4Build with AI on Google Cloud Session #4
Build with AI on Google Cloud Session #4
Margaret Maynard-Reid
?
Inside Freshworks' Migration from Cassandra to ScyllaDB by Premkumar Patturaj
Inside Freshworks' Migration from Cassandra to ScyllaDB by Premkumar PatturajInside Freshworks' Migration from Cassandra to ScyllaDB by Premkumar Patturaj
Inside Freshworks' Migration from Cassandra to ScyllaDB by Premkumar Patturaj
ScyllaDB
?
Q4 2024 Earnings and Investor Presentation
Q4 2024 Earnings and Investor PresentationQ4 2024 Earnings and Investor Presentation
Q4 2024 Earnings and Investor Presentation
Dropbox
?
DAO UTokyo 2025 DLT mass adoption case studies IBM Tsuyoshi Hirayama (ƽɽÒã)
DAO UTokyo 2025 DLT mass adoption case studies IBM Tsuyoshi Hirayama (ƽɽÒã)DAO UTokyo 2025 DLT mass adoption case studies IBM Tsuyoshi Hirayama (ƽɽÒã)
DAO UTokyo 2025 DLT mass adoption case studies IBM Tsuyoshi Hirayama (ƽɽÒã)
Tsuyoshi Hirayama
?

Towards a classification framework for social machines copy

  • 1. Towards a classification framework for social machines Submission at the SOCM2013 workshop @ WWW2013 Elena Simperl, Max Van Kleek 13 March 2013
  • 2. Motivation and objectives ? Future ICT systems as sophisticated assemblies of data-intensive, complex automation and deep community involvement ? Defining social machines and their characteristic properties as necessary step towards a principled understanding of the science and engineering of such systems ? Objectives of this work ¨C Identify and define the constructs to describe, study and compare social machines ¨C Achieve a shared understanding of basic notions and terminology through involvement from the broader community ? Useful tool for both researchers in social and computer sciences and for developers and operators of existing and future social machines 2
  • 3. Social machines and related areas ? Social machines ¨C Interaction among algorithmic and social components ¨C Different notion of computation (cf Turing) w.r.t. problem specification, performance, quality of outputs, termination ¨C Incentives and motivation, network effects ? Related areas ¨C Computer science: CSCW, social computing, human computation ¨C Organizational management/social sciences: wisdom of the crowds, collective intelligence, open innovation, crowdsourcing 3
  • 4. The polyarchical relationship of social machines ? Platforms/technologies vs social machines created for specific purposes. E.g., MediaWiki vs Wikipedia ? Broader vs narrower-scoped social machines. E.g., Twitter vs Obama¡¯12 ? Ecosystem of social machines. E.g., results from GalaxyZoo taken up in Wikipedia articles 4
  • 5. Challenges and research questions ? What do specific instances of a social machine have in common, and how do they differ dynamically? ? How do certain design decisions taken at the level of the infrastructure, frameworks and service propagate into narrower-focused systems? ? How do such decisions affect a broader ecosystem of social machines, each with their own, though overlapping, purposes and communities? 5
  • 6. Framework overview ? Repertory grid elicitation to derive an initial set of elements (instances of social machines) and constructs (characteristics of social machines) ? 10 grids, 56 elements, 117 constructs ? Consolidation and clustering of constructs ? 31 constructs, four clusters ¨C Popularity ¨C Tasks and purpose ¨C Participants and roles ¨C Motivation and incentives 6
  • 7. Constructs: purpose of the system and contributions ? Purpose of the system, types of contributions, degree to which these change 7
  • 8. Constructs: people, roles, motivation ? Types of audience, autonomy and anonymity, roles and role hierarchies ? Intrinsic vs. extrinsic motivation, rewards 8
  • 10. Next steps: refine constructs ? Standard listings for types of contributions, actions, activities ? Relationship between roles, autonomy, and anonymity and motivators ? Motivation and incentives: participation in the definition of the overall purpose, transparency of purpose ? Missing ¨C Nature of the good produced ¨C Existing social structures ¨C Interaction between algorithmic and social components, workflows ¨C Consolidation and aggregation of contributions, quality assurance 10
  • 11. Next steps: community engagement and evaluation ? Community engagement: building a social machine to define the SOCIAM classification framework ? Evaluation: ¨C Task-independent using criteria from knowledge engineering (completeness, correctness, readability, redundancy etc) ¨C Task-dependent: Can the framework be used to describe existing social machines? 11