ºÝºÝߣ

ºÝºÝߣShare a Scribd company logo
The Lord of the Rings vs. Braveheart By Vincent Ribordy
Frodo  William Brave Purehearted Strong  Tough Brave  Strong  Tough Leadership
Subheros Sam  Marry and Pippin Aragorn Gandolf Leglas  Gimli Boromir Princess Isabelle Robert
Quest/Misson Destroy the ring and free Middle Earth from evil Defend Scotland from English and tyranny; gain Scotland's freedom
Setting Middle Earth Scotland and England
Courage and Valor The hobbits charge in to save Frodo from Strider  Sam fights off the spider that wrapped frodo up.  Sam goes into a Mordor castle to save Frodo from the orcs and get him to mount doom. Aragorn takes the army to the black gate to draw out the forces of evil. William defends his love from an English lord. William gathers army to start a rebellion and gain freedom.
Guides Gandolf He kind of leads the fellowship through a lot of their journey and helps Frodo with his quote About ¡°we can¡¯t choose what time is given to us but only what to do with it.¡± Isabelle Warns William of danger twice Gives him a potion to help dull the pain.(he spits it out when she leaves.
Scene Parallel King Th¨¦oden rallies troops to fight Sauron¡¯s forces: ¡°Shields will splinter; spears will be shaken.¡± (King Th¨¦oden ¡°Lord of the Rings¡±) William rallies troops to fight the English:  ¡° Aye, fight and you may die. Run and you'll live -- at least a while. And dying in your beds many years from now, would you be willing to trade all the days from this day to that for one chance, just one chance to come back here and tell our enemies that they may take our lives, but they'll never take our freedom!¡±(William Wallace ¡°Braveheart¡±)
Supernatural forces Gandolf, Wizard good magic. The Dream of William¡¯s love and him seeing her one last time while being tortured for treason.
Music The Lords of the Rings did a great job in match music to the scenes in the move sad slow music for sad moments, heroic fast music for time of war, and peaceful music for peaceful times like the beginning of the film. Braveheart music matches well with its scenes sad slow music for sad moments, and heroic fast music for time of war.
Symbolism  The Ring of power: evil and Sauron The tree of kings: good and peace The Cloth from William¡¯s love: good and hope William¡¯s Sword: bravery/courage
Conflict People of Middle Earth against the forces of Sauron. Frodo against Golem. Aragorn against King of Rohan People of Scotland against King Edward the Longshanks. William against Robert. William against nobles of Scotland
Conclusion  These two films are not as closely related as some others are out there. Though these films are fairly close when it comes to the theme and message. The evil in each film have a difference in the fact in Lord of the Rings the evil is mostly supernatural, while in the other the evil is not supernatural.

More Related Content

What's hot (20)

The Antiheroes Journey - The Lord of the Rings
The Antiheroes Journey - The Lord of the RingsThe Antiheroes Journey - The Lord of the Rings
The Antiheroes Journey - The Lord of the Rings
Clarity Thinker
?
The most dangerous game
The most dangerous gameThe most dangerous game
The most dangerous game
Mar Cas
?
Wonder woman
Wonder womanWonder woman
Wonder woman
112909
?
Tv series 90's in Colombia
Tv series 90's in ColombiaTv series 90's in Colombia
Tv series 90's in Colombia
Erick Uribe
?
The lord of the rings
The lord of the ringsThe lord of the rings
The lord of the rings
Jack Dowson
?
cold mountain
cold mountaincold mountain
cold mountain
martineziacopini93
?
feature writing sample
feature writing samplefeature writing sample
feature writing sample
Kevin Smith
?
12 Angry Men (1957) story structure using hero's journey
12 Angry Men (1957) story structure using hero's journey12 Angry Men (1957) story structure using hero's journey
12 Angry Men (1957) story structure using hero's journey
Goldie Sachs
?
Lord of the Rings vs 300
Lord of the Rings vs 300Lord of the Rings vs 300
Lord of the Rings vs 300
rortega2011
?
Narrative info sheet
Narrative info sheetNarrative info sheet
Narrative info sheet
Belinda Raji
?
The most dangerous game plot pyramid
The most dangerous game plot pyramidThe most dangerous game plot pyramid
The most dangerous game plot pyramid
pvenglishteach
?
Finals for uploading
Finals for uploadingFinals for uploading
Finals for uploading
Jaikaran Mansingh
?
New titles
New titlesNew titles
New titles
Sharon Malcolm
?
Henderson the rain king
Henderson the rain kingHenderson the rain king
Henderson the rain king
schurr
?
The Lord Of the bridge
The Lord Of the bridgeThe Lord Of the bridge
The Lord Of the bridge
bman2ndbreakfast
?
The most dangerous game
The most dangerous gameThe most dangerous game
The most dangerous game
uploadlessons
?
Master q4
Master q4Master q4
Master q4
theproductagency
?
The Most Dangerous Game Jeopardy
The Most Dangerous Game JeopardyThe Most Dangerous Game Jeopardy
The Most Dangerous Game Jeopardy
kelican
?
The Hobbit - Mapping Bilbo's Journey
The Hobbit - Mapping Bilbo's JourneyThe Hobbit - Mapping Bilbo's Journey
The Hobbit - Mapping Bilbo's Journey
mmcdonald2
?
Saddam Land
Saddam LandSaddam Land
Saddam Land
Janush
?
The Antiheroes Journey - The Lord of the Rings
The Antiheroes Journey - The Lord of the RingsThe Antiheroes Journey - The Lord of the Rings
The Antiheroes Journey - The Lord of the Rings
Clarity Thinker
?
The most dangerous game
The most dangerous gameThe most dangerous game
The most dangerous game
Mar Cas
?
Wonder woman
Wonder womanWonder woman
Wonder woman
112909
?
Tv series 90's in Colombia
Tv series 90's in ColombiaTv series 90's in Colombia
Tv series 90's in Colombia
Erick Uribe
?
The lord of the rings
The lord of the ringsThe lord of the rings
The lord of the rings
Jack Dowson
?
feature writing sample
feature writing samplefeature writing sample
feature writing sample
Kevin Smith
?
12 Angry Men (1957) story structure using hero's journey
12 Angry Men (1957) story structure using hero's journey12 Angry Men (1957) story structure using hero's journey
12 Angry Men (1957) story structure using hero's journey
Goldie Sachs
?
Lord of the Rings vs 300
Lord of the Rings vs 300Lord of the Rings vs 300
Lord of the Rings vs 300
rortega2011
?
The most dangerous game plot pyramid
The most dangerous game plot pyramidThe most dangerous game plot pyramid
The most dangerous game plot pyramid
pvenglishteach
?
Henderson the rain king
Henderson the rain kingHenderson the rain king
Henderson the rain king
schurr
?
The most dangerous game
The most dangerous gameThe most dangerous game
The most dangerous game
uploadlessons
?
The Most Dangerous Game Jeopardy
The Most Dangerous Game JeopardyThe Most Dangerous Game Jeopardy
The Most Dangerous Game Jeopardy
kelican
?
The Hobbit - Mapping Bilbo's Journey
The Hobbit - Mapping Bilbo's JourneyThe Hobbit - Mapping Bilbo's Journey
The Hobbit - Mapping Bilbo's Journey
mmcdonald2
?
Saddam Land
Saddam LandSaddam Land
Saddam Land
Janush
?

Viewers also liked (20)

GI2015 ppt hoffmann_address_intro
GI2015 ppt hoffmann_address_introGI2015 ppt hoffmann_address_intro
GI2015 ppt hoffmann_address_intro
IGN Vorstand
?
GI2014 ppt hoffmann_address_introGI2014 ppt hoffmann_address_intro
GI2014 ppt hoffmann_address_intro
IGN Vorstand
?
GI2013 ppt schaafsma+schaaik_v2_web
GI2013 ppt schaafsma+schaaik_v2_webGI2013 ppt schaafsma+schaaik_v2_web
GI2013 ppt schaafsma+schaaik_v2_web
IGN Vorstand
?
Vohnout ppt gi2011_geoportal4everybody_final
Vohnout ppt gi2011_geoportal4everybody_finalVohnout ppt gi2011_geoportal4everybody_final
Vohnout ppt gi2011_geoportal4everybody_final
IGN Vorstand
?
Charvat ppt gi2011_habitats ¨C cross-border data harmonization_final
Charvat ppt gi2011_habitats ¨C cross-border data harmonization_finalCharvat ppt gi2011_habitats ¨C cross-border data harmonization_final
Charvat ppt gi2011_habitats ¨C cross-border data harmonization_final
IGN Vorstand
?
2011 MAR New Director Orientation
2011 MAR New Director Orientation2011 MAR New Director Orientation
2011 MAR New Director Orientation
Kathie Feldpausch
?
GI2014 ppt vohnout+team_erra prd east
GI2014 ppt vohnout+team_erra prd eastGI2014 ppt vohnout+team_erra prd east
GI2014 ppt vohnout+team_erra prd east
IGN Vorstand
?
GI2014 ppt kozuch_p4b_map_compositions
GI2014 ppt kozuch_p4b_map_compositionsGI2014 ppt kozuch_p4b_map_compositions
GI2014 ppt kozuch_p4b_map_compositions
IGN Vorstand
?
ºÚ»¡£ºÉϺ£Íò¿Æ½ðÉ«³ÇÊÐÍƹã²ßÂÔÌá°¸
ºÚ»¡£ºÉϺ£Íò¿Æ½ðÉ«³ÇÊÐÍƹã²ßÂÔÌá°¸ºÚ»¡£ºÉϺ£Íò¿Æ½ðÉ«³ÇÊÐÍƹã²ßÂÔÌá°¸
ºÚ»¡£ºÉϺ£Íò¿Æ½ðÉ«³ÇÊÐÍƹã²ßÂÔÌá°¸
axiali
?
FLAT Classroom Techniques
FLAT Classroom TechniquesFLAT Classroom Techniques
FLAT Classroom Techniques
Heather Zink
?
Icamera store
Icamera storeIcamera store
Icamera store
Tran Tien
?
Has the us war in afghanistan made us
Has the us war in afghanistan made usHas the us war in afghanistan made us
Has the us war in afghanistan made us
jadeforester
?
Kliment ppt gi2011_testing_remote_final
Kliment ppt gi2011_testing_remote_finalKliment ppt gi2011_testing_remote_final
Kliment ppt gi2011_testing_remote_final
IGN Vorstand
?
Wimba2.0
Wimba2.0Wimba2.0
Wimba2.0
Heather Zink
?
GI2014 ppt fryml+charvat_cesko jede
GI2014 ppt fryml+charvat_cesko jedeGI2014 ppt fryml+charvat_cesko jede
GI2014 ppt fryml+charvat_cesko jede
IGN Vorstand
?
Pol¨ªtica fiscalPol¨ªtica fiscal
Pol¨ªtica fiscal
Paulo Lima
?
Mildorf ppt gi2011_plan4all_final
Mildorf ppt gi2011_plan4all_finalMildorf ppt gi2011_plan4all_final
Mildorf ppt gi2011_plan4all_final
IGN Vorstand
?
Berzins raitis ppt_gi2011_biz_biz_final
Berzins raitis ppt_gi2011_biz_biz_finalBerzins raitis ppt_gi2011_biz_biz_final
Berzins raitis ppt_gi2011_biz_biz_final
IGN Vorstand
?
Tornando-se Social: como as empresas est?o aproveitando ao m¨¢ximo as m¨ªdias s...
Tornando-se Social: como as empresas est?o aproveitando ao m¨¢ximo as m¨ªdias s...Tornando-se Social: como as empresas est?o aproveitando ao m¨¢ximo as m¨ªdias s...
Tornando-se Social: como as empresas est?o aproveitando ao m¨¢ximo as m¨ªdias s...
ricardodepaula
?
GI2015 ppt hoffmann_address_intro
GI2015 ppt hoffmann_address_introGI2015 ppt hoffmann_address_intro
GI2015 ppt hoffmann_address_intro
IGN Vorstand
?
GI2014 ppt hoffmann_address_introGI2014 ppt hoffmann_address_intro
GI2014 ppt hoffmann_address_intro
IGN Vorstand
?
GI2013 ppt schaafsma+schaaik_v2_web
GI2013 ppt schaafsma+schaaik_v2_webGI2013 ppt schaafsma+schaaik_v2_web
GI2013 ppt schaafsma+schaaik_v2_web
IGN Vorstand
?
Vohnout ppt gi2011_geoportal4everybody_final
Vohnout ppt gi2011_geoportal4everybody_finalVohnout ppt gi2011_geoportal4everybody_final
Vohnout ppt gi2011_geoportal4everybody_final
IGN Vorstand
?
Charvat ppt gi2011_habitats ¨C cross-border data harmonization_final
Charvat ppt gi2011_habitats ¨C cross-border data harmonization_finalCharvat ppt gi2011_habitats ¨C cross-border data harmonization_final
Charvat ppt gi2011_habitats ¨C cross-border data harmonization_final
IGN Vorstand
?
2011 MAR New Director Orientation
2011 MAR New Director Orientation2011 MAR New Director Orientation
2011 MAR New Director Orientation
Kathie Feldpausch
?
GI2014 ppt vohnout+team_erra prd east
GI2014 ppt vohnout+team_erra prd eastGI2014 ppt vohnout+team_erra prd east
GI2014 ppt vohnout+team_erra prd east
IGN Vorstand
?
GI2014 ppt kozuch_p4b_map_compositions
GI2014 ppt kozuch_p4b_map_compositionsGI2014 ppt kozuch_p4b_map_compositions
GI2014 ppt kozuch_p4b_map_compositions
IGN Vorstand
?
ºÚ»¡£ºÉϺ£Íò¿Æ½ðÉ«³ÇÊÐÍƹã²ßÂÔÌá°¸
ºÚ»¡£ºÉϺ£Íò¿Æ½ðÉ«³ÇÊÐÍƹã²ßÂÔÌá°¸ºÚ»¡£ºÉϺ£Íò¿Æ½ðÉ«³ÇÊÐÍƹã²ßÂÔÌá°¸
ºÚ»¡£ºÉϺ£Íò¿Æ½ðÉ«³ÇÊÐÍƹã²ßÂÔÌá°¸
axiali
?
FLAT Classroom Techniques
FLAT Classroom TechniquesFLAT Classroom Techniques
FLAT Classroom Techniques
Heather Zink
?
Has the us war in afghanistan made us
Has the us war in afghanistan made usHas the us war in afghanistan made us
Has the us war in afghanistan made us
jadeforester
?
Kliment ppt gi2011_testing_remote_final
Kliment ppt gi2011_testing_remote_finalKliment ppt gi2011_testing_remote_final
Kliment ppt gi2011_testing_remote_final
IGN Vorstand
?
GI2014 ppt fryml+charvat_cesko jede
GI2014 ppt fryml+charvat_cesko jedeGI2014 ppt fryml+charvat_cesko jede
GI2014 ppt fryml+charvat_cesko jede
IGN Vorstand
?
Pol¨ªtica fiscalPol¨ªtica fiscal
Pol¨ªtica fiscal
Paulo Lima
?
Mildorf ppt gi2011_plan4all_final
Mildorf ppt gi2011_plan4all_finalMildorf ppt gi2011_plan4all_final
Mildorf ppt gi2011_plan4all_final
IGN Vorstand
?
Berzins raitis ppt_gi2011_biz_biz_final
Berzins raitis ppt_gi2011_biz_biz_finalBerzins raitis ppt_gi2011_biz_biz_final
Berzins raitis ppt_gi2011_biz_biz_final
IGN Vorstand
?
Tornando-se Social: como as empresas est?o aproveitando ao m¨¢ximo as m¨ªdias s...
Tornando-se Social: como as empresas est?o aproveitando ao m¨¢ximo as m¨ªdias s...Tornando-se Social: como as empresas est?o aproveitando ao m¨¢ximo as m¨ªdias s...
Tornando-se Social: como as empresas est?o aproveitando ao m¨¢ximo as m¨ªdias s...
ricardodepaula
?

Similar to comparison (9)

Film comparison for media2
Film comparison for media2Film comparison for media2
Film comparison for media2
jkampfer
?
local_media417141215259689153.pptx
local_media417141215259689153.pptxlocal_media417141215259689153.pptx
local_media417141215259689153.pptx
EdrianeEnterina1
?
The lord fof the ring
The lord fof the ringThe lord fof the ring
The lord fof the ring
Dimos Derventlis
?
Iron Man vs. LOTR
Iron Man vs. LOTRIron Man vs. LOTR
Iron Man vs. LOTR
Oskaloosa High School
?
The Lord of the Rings
The Lord of the Rings  The Lord of the Rings
The Lord of the Rings
Fahad Saleem
?
Lord Of The Rings / Titanic
Lord Of The Rings / TitanicLord Of The Rings / Titanic
Lord Of The Rings / Titanic
KinseyBrooks
?
comparison
comparisoncomparison
comparison
CRICKETTS
?
LOTR
LOTRLOTR
LOTR
Bilal Munir
?
Lord of the Rings
Lord of the RingsLord of the Rings
Lord of the Rings
jabernethy
?

comparison

  • 1. The Lord of the Rings vs. Braveheart By Vincent Ribordy
  • 2. Frodo William Brave Purehearted Strong Tough Brave Strong Tough Leadership
  • 3. Subheros Sam Marry and Pippin Aragorn Gandolf Leglas Gimli Boromir Princess Isabelle Robert
  • 4. Quest/Misson Destroy the ring and free Middle Earth from evil Defend Scotland from English and tyranny; gain Scotland's freedom
  • 5. Setting Middle Earth Scotland and England
  • 6. Courage and Valor The hobbits charge in to save Frodo from Strider Sam fights off the spider that wrapped frodo up. Sam goes into a Mordor castle to save Frodo from the orcs and get him to mount doom. Aragorn takes the army to the black gate to draw out the forces of evil. William defends his love from an English lord. William gathers army to start a rebellion and gain freedom.
  • 7. Guides Gandolf He kind of leads the fellowship through a lot of their journey and helps Frodo with his quote About ¡°we can¡¯t choose what time is given to us but only what to do with it.¡± Isabelle Warns William of danger twice Gives him a potion to help dull the pain.(he spits it out when she leaves.
  • 8. Scene Parallel King Th¨¦oden rallies troops to fight Sauron¡¯s forces: ¡°Shields will splinter; spears will be shaken.¡± (King Th¨¦oden ¡°Lord of the Rings¡±) William rallies troops to fight the English: ¡° Aye, fight and you may die. Run and you'll live -- at least a while. And dying in your beds many years from now, would you be willing to trade all the days from this day to that for one chance, just one chance to come back here and tell our enemies that they may take our lives, but they'll never take our freedom!¡±(William Wallace ¡°Braveheart¡±)
  • 9. Supernatural forces Gandolf, Wizard good magic. The Dream of William¡¯s love and him seeing her one last time while being tortured for treason.
  • 10. Music The Lords of the Rings did a great job in match music to the scenes in the move sad slow music for sad moments, heroic fast music for time of war, and peaceful music for peaceful times like the beginning of the film. Braveheart music matches well with its scenes sad slow music for sad moments, and heroic fast music for time of war.
  • 11. Symbolism The Ring of power: evil and Sauron The tree of kings: good and peace The Cloth from William¡¯s love: good and hope William¡¯s Sword: bravery/courage
  • 12. Conflict People of Middle Earth against the forces of Sauron. Frodo against Golem. Aragorn against King of Rohan People of Scotland against King Edward the Longshanks. William against Robert. William against nobles of Scotland
  • 13. Conclusion These two films are not as closely related as some others are out there. Though these films are fairly close when it comes to the theme and message. The evil in each film have a difference in the fact in Lord of the Rings the evil is mostly supernatural, while in the other the evil is not supernatural.