ºÝºÝߣ

ºÝºÝߣShare a Scribd company logo
Game design 3
Game Rules
         Ben SALEM
       School of Design
   University of Northumbria
Content



1.Defining Rules
2.Content
3.Writing a design document
4.Using the design document
Defining Rules

Rules constitute the inner, formal structure of games.
All games have rules that are one of their defining
qualities
Rules are different from the experience of the game
Rules are abstract tools for thinking about the formal
structure of a game
What are Game Rules

Limit players actions
Are explicit and unambiguous
Are shared by all players
Are fixed
Are binding
Are repeatable
Rule Levels 1



Constitutive Rules
  The abstract, core mathematical rules of a game
Operational Rules
  The rules of play that players follow when they are playing the game
Implicit Rules
  The unwritten rules of etiquette and behaviour that generally go un-
  stated.
Rule Levels 2


The operational rules of the game build directly from the
game constitutive rules
There is a fuzzy boundary between operational and
implicit rules
The formal identity of a game emerges from the
relationship between the constitutive rules and the
operational rules
The formal meaning of a game emerges from the
bridging of the three level of rules
Good Rules



Good and elegant rules allow player to focus on the
experience of play rather than on the logic of the rules
Board & Computer Game Rules 1




In general the rules of a computer game are the same
than the rules of a board game
  They are directly concerned with the actions players take and the
  outcome of those actions
The internal functioning of formal game logic is also part
of the rules
Board & Computer Game Rules 2



The constitutive rules of B&C Games are quite similar
  The constitutive rules of a computer game handle the game internal
  events
The operational rules of computer games are not only
concerned with the internal events but also with the
player inputs and the game outputs
B&C games share implicit rules
Rule Levels in Computer Games



In computer games is it sometimes not possible to
clearly determine what aspect of the game belongs to
what type of rule
Games as Complex Systems 1



Fixed Systems remain the same for ever
Periodic Systems repeat the same pattern endlessly
Complex Systems exhibit patterns of behaviour more
complex than periodic systems
Chaotic systems behave in a complete random fashion
(within the scope of gaming).
Games as Complex Systems 2


When a game lacks complexity it also lack meaningful
play
  Complexity ensures that the space of possibilities of a game is
  large enough to support meaningful play
Emergent systems generate unpredictable patterns of
complexity
  e.g. In language the rules of grammar and all possible statements
Games as Emergent Systems




Emergence in games results from the formal system of
the game put to use by the players
  e.g. bluffing in poker is not explicitly stated in the rules
Emergent games have a space of possibility large
enough to reward players for exploring the game
Games & Uncertainty



Uncertainty is a key component of every game
Relationship between game decision and outcome
have three degree of uncertainty:
  Certain outcomes are completely predetermined
  Risk outcome has a known probability of happening
  Uncertain outcome is completely unknown to the player.
Game design 3

More Related Content

What's hot (20)

Introduction of Games Design and Development
Introduction of Games Design and DevelopmentIntroduction of Games Design and Development
Introduction of Games Design and Development
Laili Farhana M.I.
Ìý
file1
file1file1
file1
webuploader
Ìý
6 lecture (game elements ) 2 2-2021
6 lecture (game elements ) 2 2-20216 lecture (game elements ) 2 2-2021
6 lecture (game elements ) 2 2-2021
Durgesh Pandey
Ìý
LAFS PREPRO Session 3 - Game Play
LAFS PREPRO Session 3 - Game PlayLAFS PREPRO Session 3 - Game Play
LAFS PREPRO Session 3 - Game Play
David Mullich
Ìý
An introduction to Game Theory
An introduction to Game TheoryAn introduction to Game Theory
An introduction to Game Theory
Paul Trafford
Ìý
game theory
game theorygame theory
game theory
ayesha zaheer
Ìý
Dinesh kumar
Dinesh kumarDinesh kumar
Dinesh kumar
DINESHKUMARDEI
Ìý
Game theory
Game theoryGame theory
Game theory
Sarfaraz Ahmad
Ìý
Game theory
Game theoryGame theory
Game theory
amaroks
Ìý
Game theory
Game theoryGame theory
Game theory
Soumya Bilwar
Ìý
Game theory
Game theoryGame theory
Game theory
Ekram A Attai
Ìý
Chapter 2 structure of games tsppt 1
Chapter 2 structure of games tsppt 1Chapter 2 structure of games tsppt 1
Chapter 2 structure of games tsppt 1
GKTheodora
Ìý
Game theory
Game theoryGame theory
Game theory
gtush24
Ìý
Game theory (Operation Research)
Game theory (Operation Research)Game theory (Operation Research)
Game theory (Operation Research)
kashif ayaz
Ìý
LAFS Game Design 10 - Fun and Accessability
LAFS Game Design 10 - Fun and AccessabilityLAFS Game Design 10 - Fun and Accessability
LAFS Game Design 10 - Fun and Accessability
David Mullich
Ìý
Game classifications
Game classificationsGame classifications
Game classifications
Yhen Celeste
Ìý
Game Theory - Quantitative Analysis for Decision Making
Game Theory - Quantitative Analysis for Decision MakingGame Theory - Quantitative Analysis for Decision Making
Game Theory - Quantitative Analysis for Decision Making
Ishita Bose
Ìý
Applications of game theory on event management
Applications of game theory on event management Applications of game theory on event management
Applications of game theory on event management
Sameer Dhurat
Ìý
Game theory
Game theoryGame theory
Game theory
Harry Potter
Ìý
Game theory in Economics
Game theory in EconomicsGame theory in Economics
Game theory in Economics
Elvin Aghammadzada
Ìý
Introduction of Games Design and Development
Introduction of Games Design and DevelopmentIntroduction of Games Design and Development
Introduction of Games Design and Development
Laili Farhana M.I.
Ìý
6 lecture (game elements ) 2 2-2021
6 lecture (game elements ) 2 2-20216 lecture (game elements ) 2 2-2021
6 lecture (game elements ) 2 2-2021
Durgesh Pandey
Ìý
LAFS PREPRO Session 3 - Game Play
LAFS PREPRO Session 3 - Game PlayLAFS PREPRO Session 3 - Game Play
LAFS PREPRO Session 3 - Game Play
David Mullich
Ìý
An introduction to Game Theory
An introduction to Game TheoryAn introduction to Game Theory
An introduction to Game Theory
Paul Trafford
Ìý
Game theory
Game theoryGame theory
Game theory
amaroks
Ìý
Chapter 2 structure of games tsppt 1
Chapter 2 structure of games tsppt 1Chapter 2 structure of games tsppt 1
Chapter 2 structure of games tsppt 1
GKTheodora
Ìý
Game theory
Game theoryGame theory
Game theory
gtush24
Ìý
Game theory (Operation Research)
Game theory (Operation Research)Game theory (Operation Research)
Game theory (Operation Research)
kashif ayaz
Ìý
LAFS Game Design 10 - Fun and Accessability
LAFS Game Design 10 - Fun and AccessabilityLAFS Game Design 10 - Fun and Accessability
LAFS Game Design 10 - Fun and Accessability
David Mullich
Ìý
Game classifications
Game classificationsGame classifications
Game classifications
Yhen Celeste
Ìý
Game Theory - Quantitative Analysis for Decision Making
Game Theory - Quantitative Analysis for Decision MakingGame Theory - Quantitative Analysis for Decision Making
Game Theory - Quantitative Analysis for Decision Making
Ishita Bose
Ìý
Applications of game theory on event management
Applications of game theory on event management Applications of game theory on event management
Applications of game theory on event management
Sameer Dhurat
Ìý
Game theory in Economics
Game theory in EconomicsGame theory in Economics
Game theory in Economics
Elvin Aghammadzada
Ìý

Viewers also liked (6)

Game design 2
Game design 2Game design 2
Game design 2
Benjey
Ìý
Game design 1
Game design 1Game design 1
Game design 1
Benjey
Ìý
Game Mechanics
Game MechanicsGame Mechanics
Game Mechanics
Brett Bixler
Ìý
Game Mechanics
Game MechanicsGame Mechanics
Game Mechanics
Pier Luca Lanzi
Ìý
Examples of Game Concepts
Examples of Game ConceptsExamples of Game Concepts
Examples of Game Concepts
Pier Luca Lanzi
Ìý
Gamification
GamificationGamification
Gamification
Sylvain Cottong
Ìý
Game design 2
Game design 2Game design 2
Game design 2
Benjey
Ìý
Game design 1
Game design 1Game design 1
Game design 1
Benjey
Ìý
Game Mechanics
Game MechanicsGame Mechanics
Game Mechanics
Brett Bixler
Ìý
Examples of Game Concepts
Examples of Game ConceptsExamples of Game Concepts
Examples of Game Concepts
Pier Luca Lanzi
Ìý

Similar to Game design 3 (20)

Week Five, Game Design
Week Five, Game DesignWeek Five, Game Design
Week Five, Game Design
University of Calgary, School of Creative and Performing Arts
Ìý
LAFS Game Design 1 - Structural Elements
LAFS Game Design 1 - Structural ElementsLAFS Game Design 1 - Structural Elements
LAFS Game Design 1 - Structural Elements
David Mullich
Ìý
Game Balance 1: What is Game Balance
Game Balance 1: What is Game BalanceGame Balance 1: What is Game Balance
Game Balance 1: What is Game Balance
Marc Miquel
Ìý
3.3 Game TheoryGame theory is a branch of applied mathematics, w.docx
3.3 Game TheoryGame theory is a branch of applied mathematics, w.docx3.3 Game TheoryGame theory is a branch of applied mathematics, w.docx
3.3 Game TheoryGame theory is a branch of applied mathematics, w.docx
gilbertkpeters11344
Ìý
Introduction to the Theory of Game Elements
Introduction to the Theory of Game ElementsIntroduction to the Theory of Game Elements
Introduction to the Theory of Game Elements
Aki Järvinen
Ìý
LAFS Game Design 9 - Balancing
LAFS Game Design 9 - BalancingLAFS Game Design 9 - Balancing
LAFS Game Design 9 - Balancing
David Mullich
Ìý
GAME MECHANIC - chapter 1 v1.4 (2019 edition)
GAME MECHANIC - chapter 1 v1.4 (2019 edition)GAME MECHANIC - chapter 1 v1.4 (2019 edition)
GAME MECHANIC - chapter 1 v1.4 (2019 edition)
Hamzah Asyrani Sulaiman
Ìý
Game balance part 1
Game balance part 1Game balance part 1
Game balance part 1
Durgesh Pandey
Ìý
Game design document template for serious games
Game design document template for serious gamesGame design document template for serious games
Game design document template for serious games
Antoine Taly
Ìý
Casual Game Design: Designing Play for the Gamer in All of Us
Casual Game Design: Designing Play for the Gamer in All of UsCasual Game Design: Designing Play for the Gamer in All of Us
Casual Game Design: Designing Play for the Gamer in All of Us
Greg Trefry
Ìý
Learning to Play Complex Games
Learning to Play Complex GamesLearning to Play Complex Games
Learning to Play Complex Games
butest
Ìý
AIIDE'13 Presentation
AIIDE'13 PresentationAIIDE'13 Presentation
AIIDE'13 Presentation
Marlon Etheredge
Ìý
New Microsoft PowerPoint Presentation.pptx
New Microsoft PowerPoint Presentation.pptxNew Microsoft PowerPoint Presentation.pptx
New Microsoft PowerPoint Presentation.pptx
nilesh405711
Ìý
Segap project(lncs)
Segap project(lncs)Segap project(lncs)
Segap project(lncs)
Cristian Catalin Mihai
Ìý
Putting the pieces together: The MDA Framework
Putting the pieces together: The MDA FrameworkPutting the pieces together: The MDA Framework
Putting the pieces together: The MDA Framework
School of Computing, Macquarie University
Ìý
Noughts and Crosses Specification
Noughts and Crosses SpecificationNoughts and Crosses Specification
Noughts and Crosses Specification
Christopher Orchard
Ìý
Fundamentals of Game Design - Ch1
Fundamentals of Game Design - Ch1Fundamentals of Game Design - Ch1
Fundamentals of Game Design - Ch1
Cynthia Marcello
Ìý
PlayerOne - Dissecting games
PlayerOne - Dissecting gamesPlayerOne - Dissecting games
PlayerOne - Dissecting games
Luca Galli
Ìý
Game Procedures
Game ProceduresGame Procedures
Game Procedures
Roy Kimmins
Ìý
Unit 1-NEW - game game Game Core Design.pdf
Unit 1-NEW - game game Game Core Design.pdfUnit 1-NEW - game game Game Core Design.pdf
Unit 1-NEW - game game Game Core Design.pdf
VinsmokeSomya
Ìý
LAFS Game Design 1 - Structural Elements
LAFS Game Design 1 - Structural ElementsLAFS Game Design 1 - Structural Elements
LAFS Game Design 1 - Structural Elements
David Mullich
Ìý
Game Balance 1: What is Game Balance
Game Balance 1: What is Game BalanceGame Balance 1: What is Game Balance
Game Balance 1: What is Game Balance
Marc Miquel
Ìý
3.3 Game TheoryGame theory is a branch of applied mathematics, w.docx
3.3 Game TheoryGame theory is a branch of applied mathematics, w.docx3.3 Game TheoryGame theory is a branch of applied mathematics, w.docx
3.3 Game TheoryGame theory is a branch of applied mathematics, w.docx
gilbertkpeters11344
Ìý
Introduction to the Theory of Game Elements
Introduction to the Theory of Game ElementsIntroduction to the Theory of Game Elements
Introduction to the Theory of Game Elements
Aki Järvinen
Ìý
LAFS Game Design 9 - Balancing
LAFS Game Design 9 - BalancingLAFS Game Design 9 - Balancing
LAFS Game Design 9 - Balancing
David Mullich
Ìý
GAME MECHANIC - chapter 1 v1.4 (2019 edition)
GAME MECHANIC - chapter 1 v1.4 (2019 edition)GAME MECHANIC - chapter 1 v1.4 (2019 edition)
GAME MECHANIC - chapter 1 v1.4 (2019 edition)
Hamzah Asyrani Sulaiman
Ìý
Game balance part 1
Game balance part 1Game balance part 1
Game balance part 1
Durgesh Pandey
Ìý
Game design document template for serious games
Game design document template for serious gamesGame design document template for serious games
Game design document template for serious games
Antoine Taly
Ìý
Casual Game Design: Designing Play for the Gamer in All of Us
Casual Game Design: Designing Play for the Gamer in All of UsCasual Game Design: Designing Play for the Gamer in All of Us
Casual Game Design: Designing Play for the Gamer in All of Us
Greg Trefry
Ìý
Learning to Play Complex Games
Learning to Play Complex GamesLearning to Play Complex Games
Learning to Play Complex Games
butest
Ìý
AIIDE'13 Presentation
AIIDE'13 PresentationAIIDE'13 Presentation
AIIDE'13 Presentation
Marlon Etheredge
Ìý
New Microsoft PowerPoint Presentation.pptx
New Microsoft PowerPoint Presentation.pptxNew Microsoft PowerPoint Presentation.pptx
New Microsoft PowerPoint Presentation.pptx
nilesh405711
Ìý
Noughts and Crosses Specification
Noughts and Crosses SpecificationNoughts and Crosses Specification
Noughts and Crosses Specification
Christopher Orchard
Ìý
Fundamentals of Game Design - Ch1
Fundamentals of Game Design - Ch1Fundamentals of Game Design - Ch1
Fundamentals of Game Design - Ch1
Cynthia Marcello
Ìý
PlayerOne - Dissecting games
PlayerOne - Dissecting gamesPlayerOne - Dissecting games
PlayerOne - Dissecting games
Luca Galli
Ìý
Game Procedures
Game ProceduresGame Procedures
Game Procedures
Roy Kimmins
Ìý
Unit 1-NEW - game game Game Core Design.pdf
Unit 1-NEW - game game Game Core Design.pdfUnit 1-NEW - game game Game Core Design.pdf
Unit 1-NEW - game game Game Core Design.pdf
VinsmokeSomya
Ìý

More from Benjey (16)

Design Creativity
Design CreativityDesign Creativity
Design Creativity
Benjey
Ìý
Industrial Design Projects
Industrial Design ProjectsIndustrial Design Projects
Industrial Design Projects
Benjey
Ìý
Entertaining emotions
Entertaining emotionsEntertaining emotions
Entertaining emotions
Benjey
Ìý
Mixing Real and Virtual Worlds
Mixing Real and Virtual WorldsMixing Real and Virtual Worlds
Mixing Real and Virtual Worlds
Benjey
Ìý
Cve2000
Cve2000Cve2000
Cve2000
Benjey
Ìý
Mupe: Multiple User Profile Merging
Mupe: Multiple User Profile MergingMupe: Multiple User Profile Merging
Mupe: Multiple User Profile Merging
Benjey
Ìý
Observation of videogamers
Observation of videogamersObservation of videogamers
Observation of videogamers
Benjey
Ìý
Entertaining emotions
Entertaining emotionsEntertaining emotions
Entertaining emotions
Benjey
Ìý
Aesthetics
AestheticsAesthetics
Aesthetics
Benjey
Ìý
Current Work
Current WorkCurrent Work
Current Work
Benjey
Ìý
Designing Conscious Robots
Designing Conscious RobotsDesigning Conscious Robots
Designing Conscious Robots
Benjey
Ìý
Mixing Realities
Mixing RealitiesMixing Realities
Mixing Realities
Benjey
Ìý
Power, Death & Love
Power, Death & LovePower, Death & Love
Power, Death & Love
Benjey
Ìý
(Pro/Re) Active Forms
(Pro/Re) Active Forms(Pro/Re) Active Forms
(Pro/Re) Active Forms
Benjey
Ìý
Desform05
Desform05Desform05
Desform05
Benjey
Ìý
SmartEx results presentation
SmartEx results presentationSmartEx results presentation
SmartEx results presentation
Benjey
Ìý
Design Creativity
Design CreativityDesign Creativity
Design Creativity
Benjey
Ìý
Industrial Design Projects
Industrial Design ProjectsIndustrial Design Projects
Industrial Design Projects
Benjey
Ìý
Entertaining emotions
Entertaining emotionsEntertaining emotions
Entertaining emotions
Benjey
Ìý
Mixing Real and Virtual Worlds
Mixing Real and Virtual WorldsMixing Real and Virtual Worlds
Mixing Real and Virtual Worlds
Benjey
Ìý
Cve2000
Cve2000Cve2000
Cve2000
Benjey
Ìý
Mupe: Multiple User Profile Merging
Mupe: Multiple User Profile MergingMupe: Multiple User Profile Merging
Mupe: Multiple User Profile Merging
Benjey
Ìý
Observation of videogamers
Observation of videogamersObservation of videogamers
Observation of videogamers
Benjey
Ìý
Entertaining emotions
Entertaining emotionsEntertaining emotions
Entertaining emotions
Benjey
Ìý
Aesthetics
AestheticsAesthetics
Aesthetics
Benjey
Ìý
Current Work
Current WorkCurrent Work
Current Work
Benjey
Ìý
Designing Conscious Robots
Designing Conscious RobotsDesigning Conscious Robots
Designing Conscious Robots
Benjey
Ìý
Mixing Realities
Mixing RealitiesMixing Realities
Mixing Realities
Benjey
Ìý
Power, Death & Love
Power, Death & LovePower, Death & Love
Power, Death & Love
Benjey
Ìý
(Pro/Re) Active Forms
(Pro/Re) Active Forms(Pro/Re) Active Forms
(Pro/Re) Active Forms
Benjey
Ìý
Desform05
Desform05Desform05
Desform05
Benjey
Ìý
SmartEx results presentation
SmartEx results presentationSmartEx results presentation
SmartEx results presentation
Benjey
Ìý

Game design 3

  • 2. Game Rules Ben SALEM School of Design University of Northumbria
  • 3. Content 1.Defining Rules 2.Content 3.Writing a design document 4.Using the design document
  • 4. Defining Rules Rules constitute the inner, formal structure of games. All games have rules that are one of their defining qualities Rules are different from the experience of the game Rules are abstract tools for thinking about the formal structure of a game
  • 5. What are Game Rules Limit players actions Are explicit and unambiguous Are shared by all players Are fixed Are binding Are repeatable
  • 6. Rule Levels 1 Constitutive Rules The abstract, core mathematical rules of a game Operational Rules The rules of play that players follow when they are playing the game Implicit Rules The unwritten rules of etiquette and behaviour that generally go un- stated.
  • 7. Rule Levels 2 The operational rules of the game build directly from the game constitutive rules There is a fuzzy boundary between operational and implicit rules The formal identity of a game emerges from the relationship between the constitutive rules and the operational rules The formal meaning of a game emerges from the bridging of the three level of rules
  • 8. Good Rules Good and elegant rules allow player to focus on the experience of play rather than on the logic of the rules
  • 9. Board & Computer Game Rules 1 In general the rules of a computer game are the same than the rules of a board game They are directly concerned with the actions players take and the outcome of those actions The internal functioning of formal game logic is also part of the rules
  • 10. Board & Computer Game Rules 2 The constitutive rules of B&C Games are quite similar The constitutive rules of a computer game handle the game internal events The operational rules of computer games are not only concerned with the internal events but also with the player inputs and the game outputs B&C games share implicit rules
  • 11. Rule Levels in Computer Games In computer games is it sometimes not possible to clearly determine what aspect of the game belongs to what type of rule
  • 12. Games as Complex Systems 1 Fixed Systems remain the same for ever Periodic Systems repeat the same pattern endlessly Complex Systems exhibit patterns of behaviour more complex than periodic systems Chaotic systems behave in a complete random fashion (within the scope of gaming).
  • 13. Games as Complex Systems 2 When a game lacks complexity it also lack meaningful play Complexity ensures that the space of possibilities of a game is large enough to support meaningful play Emergent systems generate unpredictable patterns of complexity e.g. In language the rules of grammar and all possible statements
  • 14. Games as Emergent Systems Emergence in games results from the formal system of the game put to use by the players e.g. bluffing in poker is not explicitly stated in the rules Emergent games have a space of possibility large enough to reward players for exploring the game
  • 15. Games & Uncertainty Uncertainty is a key component of every game Relationship between game decision and outcome have three degree of uncertainty: Certain outcomes are completely predetermined Risk outcome has a known probability of happening Uncertain outcome is completely unknown to the player.