ݺߣ

ݺߣShare a Scribd company logo
12/4/2014 DailyJournal­California'sLargestLegalNewsProvider
http://www.dailyjournal.com/subscriber/submain.cfm#section=DJStoryContent.cfm%3Fseloption%3DNEWS%26pubdate%3D12/04/2014%26shNewsType%3… 1/7
Classifieds/Jobs/OfficeSpace : Experts/Services : MCLE : Search : Logout
FRIDAY MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY TODAY
LucyH.Koh
U.S.DistrictJudge
NorthernDistrictofCalifornia(SanJose)
Careerhighlights:AppointedbyPresident
BarackObamatoU.S.DistrictCourt,2010;
appointedbyGov.ArnoldSchwarzenegger
toSantaClaraCountySuperiorCourt,
2008;partner,McDermottWill&Emery
LLP,2002­08;associate,WilsonSonsini
Goodrich&RosatiPC,2000­02;assistant
U.S.attorney,CentralDistrictof
California,1997­2000;specialcounsel,
U.S.DepartmentofJustice,1994­97;
fellow,U.S.SenateJudiciaryCommittee,
1993­94
Lawschool:HarvardLawSchool,1993
Age:46
NEWS RULINGS VERDICTS
QuestionsandComments
Thursday,December4,2014
CaliforniaSupremeCourt
StatehighcourtjusticessayJessica'sLaw
hasbackfired
Intwocasesthisweek,thestateSupremeCourt
leftnodoubtthatthe2006ballotmeasureJessica's
Law,forbiddingregisteredsexoffendersfrom
livingwithin2,000feetofschoolsandparks,wasa
well­intendedbutbadlaw.
Entertainment&Sports
MGAtussleswithfinancialadvisorsover
toysale
TheVanNuyscompanyistryingtorecover
hundredsofmillionsofdollarsfromthebotched
acquisitionofaFrenchtoymanufacturer.
U.S.SupremeCourt
NarrowingprecedentattheUShighcourt
PrecedentistheU.S.SupremeCourt'sbusiness,yet
thereislittleconsensusabouthowthecourtshould
treatitsownpastdecisions.ByRichardRe
Mergers&Acquisitions
Skadden,Lathamhandle$3.54Bpharma
deal
AlisoViejo­basedAvanirPharmaceuticalswas
counseledbyLatham&WatkinsLLPinitssaleto
OtsukaPharmaceutical,aJapansesecompetitor
representedbySkadden,Arps,Slate,Meagher&
FlomLLP&Affliliates.
CaliforniaCourtsofAppeal
StatelawrequiringDNAsamplecollection
unconstitutional,appealscourtrules
AstatecourtofappealhereruledonWednesday
thataCalifornialawrequiringpolicetocollecta
DNAsamplefromanyonearrestedofafelonyis
unconstitutional.
Mergers&Acquisitions
Dealmakers
Aroundupofrecenttransactionsacrossthestate
andthelawyersinvolved.
Litigation
Agencyaccusedofunlawfullyissuing
permitsforoilandgasdrillingtechniques
TheEnvironmentalDefenseCenterclaimsa
federalagencyfailedtoperformenvironmental
reviewsandnotifythepublicoftheuseoffracking
andacidizingbeforesigningoffontheextraction
techniques.
Criminal
LosAngelescityattorneyreceivesfundsfor
Previous Next
ThisisthepropertyoftheDailyJournalCorporationandfullyprotectedbycopyright.ItismadeavailableonlytoDailyJournalsubscribersfor
personalorcollaborativepurposesandmaynotbedistributed,reproduced,modified,storedortransferredwithoutwrittenpermission.Please
click“Reprint”toorderpresentation­readycopiestodistributetoclientsoruseincommercialmarketingmaterialsorforpermissiontoposton
awebsite.
ClicktopurchaseJudicialProfilewithaddedinformation.
LucyH.Koh
Fromactivisttoprosecutor,corporatelawyertothebench,Judge
LucyKohismakingabigimpact.
ByHadleyRobinson
SANJOSE­LucyH.Kohusedto
stareoutthewindowduringthe
hour­and­a­halfbusridetoher
publicschoolinPortGibson,Miss.
everyday.Sheandhersiblingswere
theonlyAsian­Americansata
predominantlyblackelementary
school.
Windingthroughthewooded
streets,shenoticedtheparochial
schools­withwhitechildrenin
uniformmarchingaroundtheschool
yards­andthoughtofthedifference
toherownclassroom,inatrailer.
Theteachersometimesabandoned
theclasstodoherowngrocery
shopping.
Theimbalanceofopportunityfor
herclassmates,whooftendidnot
havemoneytoaffordbackpacksand
broughttheirbookstoschoolin
cerealboxes,wasoneexperiencethat
ignitedherinterestinthelaw,Koh
wroteinanarticlewhileinlaw
school.
Shecontinuedtoseeracialand
genderdiscriminationinheryoung
life,andasanundergraduateand
lawstudentatHarvardUniversity,
sheorganizedralliesandcampaignsadvocatingforretentionofmoreminoritiesand
femaletenuredprofessors.InajobsearchguidepublishedbyHarvardLawSchool,
KohwrotehercareergoalsweretoworkattheDepartmentofJusticeCivilDivisionand
fortheNAACPLegalDefenseandEducationalFund,whereshehadinterned.
Twodecadeslater,Kohhasfoundherselfinadifferentplacethansheanticipated.
AsafederaljudgeinSiliconValley,sheismakingcrucialdecisionsaboutthewealthiest
companiesintheworld.
Kohrefereesbillion­dollarbattlesbetweensmartphonebehemoths,tacklesemerging
privacyconcerns,andrecentlyshockedthelegalworldwhensherejected­astoolow­
a$324millionsettlementbetweenagroupofengineersandtheiremployers.
Shehasbeenunafraidtoupsetthepowerfulcompaniesandtheirlawyerswhenthey
ventureinsideherSanJosecourtroom,sometimesrulingfortheunderdogs,and
keepingacloseeyeoutforunfairtreatmentanduninhibitedpower.
AsanundergraduateatHarvard,adeanadmittedtoKohandotherdiversity
Reprints EmailRecentJudicialProfiles
12/4/2014 DailyJournal­California'sLargestLegalNewsProvider
http://www.dailyjournal.com/subscriber/submain.cfm#section=DJStoryContent.cfm%3Fseloption%3DNEWS%26pubdate%3D12/04/2014%26shNewsType%3… 2/7
Prop.47cases
Theofficewillgetover$400,000tofill15positions
tohandlenewlyclassifiedmisdemeanorcases
underthenewlaw.
IntellectualProperty
Patentcasefilingsonpacetoreachthree­
yearnadir
Plaintiffsarecurrentlyonpacetofilethefewest
patentlawsuitsinthreeyears,followinga
sustainedperiodoflacklusterlitigationactivity
overthesecondhalfof2014,accordingtoanew
roundofdata.
Criminal
Ironyaboundsinthecaseofthe'accidental
witness'
Howdoyouquestionagangwitnesswhen
"snitchesgetstitches?"ByRichardLaFianza
andFrankLoo
Labor/Employment
ToWARNornottoWARN,thatistheissue
thecourtfaced
Mustafinanciallytroubledemployer,anticipating
thatasaleofitsbusinesswillsolveitsfinancial
problems,givefederallymandatedlayoffnoticesto
itsemployees?ByIvanL.Kallick
CivilRights
Wiseup,andmakewebsitesaccessible
TheInternethasbroughtawealthofnew
experienceswithinreachofnearlyeveryoneinour
country.Yetithasalsocreatedanewbreedof
segregation.ByCarolineE.Jackson,Kathryn
A.RobertsonandAdinaS.Katz
CorporateCounsel
AmandaT.Harrell
Seniorvicepresidentofbusinessandlegalaffairs
atUnitedArtistsMediaGroupSantaMonica
JudicialProfile
LucyH.Koh
U.S.DistrictJudgeNorthernDistrictofCalifornia
(SanJose)
Government
Somevoicedoubtovernewstateequal
protectionlaw
U.S.SupremeCourtdecisionshaveerodedakey
precedentandhurtminorityadvocates'confidence
inchallengingallegedlydiscriminatorylawsin
federalcourt.Inresponse,thisOctobertheypassed
California'sAB2646.
advocatesthatonechemistryprofessorforbadewomenfrombeinginhislabgroup.
Thedeansuggestedthey"raisehell"butdidn'tguaranteethatwouldgetresults.
"Iraisedhell,buttheydidnothingbecausethatprofessorwonaNobelPrize,"Koh
wroteinthelawschoolpublication."Nobellaureatescandiscriminatewithimpunity."
Kohmaynolongerbetheactivistofheryoungerdays.Butsheisjustasoutspoken,
andasajudge,shehastriedtoensurecompanies,executives,orcriminals­nomatter
theirsizeorinfluence­can'tactwithimpunityeither.
TreadingNewGround
Koh'sprofilehasrisentremendouslyinthefouryearssincePresidentBarackObama
appointedher,thefirstKorean­Americandistrictjudge,totheNorthernDistrictbench.
Sheishumbleabouttheattention,andhasastrictpolicyagainsttalkingontherecord
tothepress.Shedeclinedcommentforthisarticle.
Shehasbecomewell­knownbecauseherhigh­profilecasesofteninvolveleading
technologycompaniesandemergingareasofthelaw.Butherdecisionshaveattracted
publicitybecauseheranalysisoftentreadsnewground.
InSeptember,Kohallowedconsumerswhohadpersonalinformationstolenina
databreachofAdobeSystemsInc.toproceedwithalawsuit.Sincelitigationinvolving
hackingattackshassurgedinthelasttwoyears,mostfederaljudgeshavesidedwith
companiesclaimingthatunlessconsumersareharmedbyabreach,theycannotsue.
NotKoh.Shewrote,"thethreatenedinjuryherecouldbemoreimminentonlyif
Plaintiffscouldallegethattheirstolenpersonalinformationhadalreadybeen
misused."AdobeSystemsInc.PrivacyLitigationCV13­5226(N.D.Cal.,filedNov.11,
2013).
DefenseattorneyshavesaidKoh'sdecision,andasimilaronefromaSanDiego
federaljudge,makeittougherforcompaniestogetadatabreachcasedismissedearly
inCalifornia.
Lastyear,inaclassactionallegingGooglescannedemailstocollectpersonaldatafor
marketingpurposes,Kohrejectedthecompany'sargumentthatitspracticeswerepart
ofthe"ordinarycourseofbusiness,"whichexemptsactionsfromviolationsoffederal
wiretaplaws.GoogleInc.GmailLitigation,MD13­2430(N.D.Cal.,filedApril1,2013).
Thedecisiondifferedfromotherjudges'readontheexception,includingher
colleagueU.S.MagistrateJudgePaulS.Grewal,whointerpreteditmorebroadly.
ThoughshelaterruledforGoogleinaclasscertificationmotion,endingthecase,her
earlydecisionhadramifications.Internetusershavefiledfollow­oncomplaints
accusingcompaniesofscanningmessagesinviolationoffederallaw,citingKoh's
opinion.
DanielJ.Solove,alawprofessoratGeorgeWashingtonUniversity,authoreda
leadingprivacytextbook,"InformationPrivacyLaw."Theneweditionincludessomeof
Koh'sdecisions.Hesaidhercasesaretheones"thateveryoneinthefieldistalking
about."
ExpertsattheAmericanLawInstitutesaythoughthereisnoofficialtally,Kohis
likelyhandlingmoreprivacycasesthananyotherfederaljudgeinthecountry.
"Theypresentcomplexissuesabouthowtounderstandprivacyharmandnovel
issuesabouthowtoapplyvariouslawstoverynewsituationsandtechnologies,"Solove
said."Fartoooften,judgesjustseeminahurrytogetridofthecases­theyseemtoo
difficultanddifferent­andsomanyjudgesdispatchthecasestooquickly,without
adequatelyanalyzingthem.WhatimpressesmeaboutJudgeKohisthatshedoesn'tdo
that.Sheengageswiththeissuesandisn'tdismissive."
BattleTested
Inthecourtroom,Kohhasareputationoffranknessandcandor,lettinglawyers
knowexactlyhowshefeels,sometimestothepointofdiscomfort.Sheisn'tafraidtoput
lawyersonthespot.
InafamouscaseinvolvingAppleInc.'saccusationsthatSamsungElectronicsCo.
Ltd.infringeditsphoneandtabletdesignpatents,Kohonceheldbothcompanies'
12/4/2014 DailyJournal­California'sLargestLegalNewsProvider
http://www.dailyjournal.com/subscriber/submain.cfm#section=DJStoryContent.cfm%3Fseloption%3DNEWS%26pubdate%3D12/04/2014%26shNewsType%3… 3/7
tabletsnexttoeachother,andaskedSamsung'slawyerKathleenM.Sullivan­aformer
StanfordLawSchooldean­ifshecouldtellwhichwaswhich.
Afterseveraluncomfortableseconds,theQuinnEmanuelUrquhart&SullivanLLP
partnerreplied"notatthisdistanceyou'rehonor,"beforeturningtoherlegalteamfor
help.
Kohwashandlingamountainofmotions,evidenceandobjectionsbetweenthetwo
companies,representedbylawyerswithdecadesofexperienceonher.
Shefrequentlyadmonishedtheattorneysfortheirincessantmotionsfor
reconsideration,callingthem"outofcontrol."ShefamouslyaskedoneofApple's
lawyersifhewas"smokingcrack"whenhepresentedalengthywitnesslistmid­trial.
AppleInc.v.SamsungElectronicsCV11­1846(N.D.Cal.,filedApril15,2011).
MarkLemley,aStanfordLawSchoolprofessor,followedtheApple­Samsungcase.
"Particularlyforayoungjudge,"hesaid,"theabilitytocontrolsomeextremelyassertive
lawyersinareallyimportantcaseandtotakecommandofacourtroomwasreally
impressive."
WhiletheApple­Samsungmotionsandtrialproceededin2012,Kohwashavinga
toughyearinherpersonallife.Herfatherhadstomachcancer,andhadmovedinwith
herfamilyinAprilaftertwomonthsinthehospital.
Duringthetrial,hewentintothehospitalforthelasttime,andKohwasdealingwith
hissurgeons,apalliativecareteamandnurses,saidKoh'shusbandMariano­
FlorentinoCuellar,anotherStanfordLawSchoolprofessorwhowasrecentlyappointed
totheCaliforniaSupremeCourt.
Kohsleptinherdad'shospitalroommanynightsduringtrial,Cuellarsaid.
"InthetimeLucywaspresidingoverApple­Samsung­havingalltheenergyand
hardworkoneneedstogetitright,tomakesureeveryoneunderstandsthefacts,to
makesurethejuryhadalltheinstructionstheyneed­shewasdealingwithwatching
herfathergetsickerandweaker,"hesaid.
Koh'sfatherdiedsoonafterthefirstApple­Samsungtrialended.
Anunexpectedcareerpath
Koh'sevolutionfromcivilrightsandimmigrationadvocatetoajudgehandling
importanttechnologicalandlegalconundrumscamefromKohseizingimmediate
opportunities.
ShestudiedanthropologyandsociologyincollegeatHarvardUniversity,and
pursuedherlawdegreethereferventaboutbecomingapublicinterestattorney.
Herconcernsaboutpovertyandherquesttopursuejusticeforminoritiesspawned
fromherchildhoodgrowingupinMississippiandOklahoma.Hermother,an
immigrantfromKorea,taughtatAlcornStateUniversity,thenation'sfirsthistorically
African­Americanlandgrantcollege.
"Lucyisinterestingbecauseshehashadachancetoseealotofdifferentpartsofthe
country,"Cuellarsaid."Ithinkitmakesherfeellikeeverybodyhasaroletoplayin
makingsureourgovernmentinstitutionsliveuptotheirpromise.Itsensitizedherto
thediversityofourcountryandhowallourinstitutionsneedtorespondtotheneedsof
everybody."
KohbecametheWomen'sLawandPublicPolicyFellowafterleavinglawschool,and
shecouldpickherplacement.ShechosetospendhertimeasafellowintheU.S.
SenateJudiciaryCommitteeinWashington,D.C.
Fromthere,shemovedtoPresidentBillClinton'sJusticeDepartment,workingon
civilrights,immigrationandotherlegislativeaffairs.
Despitehavinglittleinterestinitiallyincriminallaw,afterhearinghercolleaguesrave
abouttheirexperiencesasassistantU.S.attorneys,Kohdecidedshewouldliketotryit.
ShegotajobinLosAngeles,workingongeneralcrimesandmajorfrauds,andwas
laterexposedtointellectualpropertylawthroughcasesinvolvingidentitytheft,hacking
andcounterfeiting.
Asthelate'90sWebboomgrew,Kohtooktheopportunitytogetnearertothe
12/4/2014 DailyJournal­California'sLargestLegalNewsProvider
http://www.dailyjournal.com/subscriber/submain.cfm#section=DJStoryContent.cfm%3Fseloption%3DNEWS%26pubdate%3D12/04/2014%26shNewsType%3… 4/7
technologyhotspot,andhergrandparentsandfamily,inSanJose.Shewashiredtodo
intellectualpropertyworkatWilsonSonsiniGoodrich&RosatiPCandlater
McDermottWill&EmeryLLP,bothinPaloAlto.
KohandCuellarmetoverbreakfastwithamutualfriendsoonafterKohmovedto
WilsonSonsiniandCuellarbeganteachingatStanford.Cuellarwasimpressed.
"Sheisverypassionateandenergeticaboutlifeandaboutthelaw,"hesaid."Sheis
livelyinconversation.Sheisveryengagingwithpeople.Shelikespeople,shelikesto
connectwithpeople,shelikestoknowtheirstories."
Thecouplehastwochildren.
Gov.ArnoldSchwarzeneggerappointedhertoajudgeshipinSantaClaraCountyin
2008,butanopeningonthefederalbenchsooncameupwhenU.S.DistrictJudge
RonaldM.Whytetookseniorstatus.ItwasthefirstvacancyinSanJosein11years.
Kohjumpedonit.
ThoughthesenatorsintheJudiciaryCommitteequestionedKohaboutherearly
politicalactivism,hervariedexperiencesasacriminalprosecutor,corporatelawyerand
Schwarzeneggerappointeehelpedhergetbipartisansupport,passingunanimously
throughcommitteeandoffthefloor.
KohtookWhyte'sseat,andthetwojudgeshavebecomeclose.WhytesaidKohisa
wonderfulcolleaguewhoneverletsabirthday,marriageorretirementpasswithouta
celebrationorrecognition.
"Ithinkshe'sincrediblyhardworking,"Whytesaid."She'sdemandingingetting
peopletodothingsinatimelyfashion.She'sverysmart,andcanhandlethetough
caseswithrealexpertise."
ManuelAraujowasapublicdefenderinSanJosewhenKohtookthebench.The
judgeheldmeetingswiththedefendersandprosecutorstogetfeedback,hesaid.
AraujohadseveralhearingsandatrialinfrontofKoh.
"She'sverydemandinginthesensethatshewantsthingtobewell­organized,she
doesn'tlikesurprisesatthelastminute,"hesaid."Youcouldseeitinhereyesifyou
displeaseherbecauseyouhaven'tdonethehomework.Shewon'tyellatyoubutyou
cantellbyherexpression,herfrustration,thatyoumessedupwithher."
ScottD.Baker,partneratReedSmithLLP,triedapatentcasebeforeKoh.
"Hertrialrulesareveryparticular,"Bakersaid."Shedoesn'twantanythingtostop
theactualflowoftestimony.Shedoesn'twanttohavethejurysittingaroundidly,while
lawyersdealwithlegalissueswithher."
ButevenifKohisnotwillingtowastejurors'time,shededicateshugeamountsofher
owntoresolvingcases.BakerhadanotherpatentcasewithKohinwhichshe
volunteeredtobethesettlementjudge.
"Itwastherightmoveanditworkedout,"Bakersaid."Shegotthecasesettledand
thepartieswereimpressedwithhowdiligentshewas,andalsoeverybodywas
comfortablehavingherbethetrialjudgeevenifwedidn'tsettle."
StrongonAppeal
Koh'srecordhasthusfarheldupinthe9thU.S.CircuitCourtofAppeals,withno
significantreversals.Butoneofherboldestdecisions,rejectinga$324millionantitrust
settlementbetweenSiliconValleytechnologycompaniesandtheiremployees,nowfaces
astifftest.
Attorneysforthecompanies­Apple,Google,IntelCorp.,andAdobeSystems­called
herdecisiona"clearlegalerror"intheirappeal.
Theplaintiffs,currentandformeremployeesatthetechcompanies,hadoriginally
askedfor$3billionindamages.
"Iwishyouhadtoldmehowweakyourcasewasforclasscertificationandallof
theseDaubertmotions,"Kohtoldtheplaintiffs."Imean,thatwouldhavebeenhelpful
information."
Shehadwrittenadetailed86­pageordergrantingtheplaintiffs'motionforclass
12/4/2014 DailyJournal­California'sLargestLegalNewsProvider
http://www.dailyjournal.com/subscriber/submain.cfm#section=DJStoryContent.cfm%3Fseloption%3DNEWS%26pubdate%3D12/04/2014%26shNewsType%3… 5/7
certification,takingintoaccountexpertreports.Koh'sfrustrationatthehearingwas
palpable.
LemleysaidthecaseisanexampleofKohnotonlyhandlinghigh­profilecases,but
writingopinionsthatmakenews.
"Rejectingthesettlementintheno­poachcaseandsayingyouhavetogototrialis
morenewsworthythanlettingthecasegoaway,"Lemleysaid."It'snotthatshe's
outsidethenormofthelaw,butshehasnotshiedawayfromtakingonthetough
cases."
Intheirappeal,thedefendantsblastedthejudge'sdecision,andaskedthe9th
Circuittointerveneandapprovethesettlement.InreHigh­TechEmployment
Litigation,CV11­2509(N.D.Cal.,May23,2011).
"Itwasclearlyerroneousforthedistrictcourttosubstituteitsownjudgmentforthe
parties'agreementbasedonanunprecedented'benchmark'analysis,"wroteRobertA.
VanNest,ofKeker&VanNestLLP.
The9thCircuithasagreedtotakethecasebuthasnotyetsetadatefororal
argument.
Koh'sdecisionshavesurvivedscrutinyfromtheU.S.CourtofAppealsfortheFederal
Circuit,whichhandlespatentchallenges,aswell.
ThefirstApple­Samsungtrialresultedina$1billionjuryverdictthathassincebeen
trimmedandretried.Kohhasmadeimportantpost­trialdecisions,includingdenying
Apple'srequesttobanthesaleofsomeofSamsung'solderdevicesbygrantinga
permanentinjunction.
Onappeal,theFederalCircuitfoundflawsinKoh'soriginalanalysisandremanded
partofthemotionbacktoher,withaloosenedstandardforgrantinganinjunction.
Butina42­pageorder,KohrejectedApple'srequestforasalesbanagain,finding
thecompanyhasfailedtoprovethatthethreeminorinfringedsoftwarepatentswere
drivingconsumerdemandforSamsung'sproducts.TheFederalCircuitupheldher
decision.
Cuellarsaidalthoughsomeofhiswife'sdecisionsarecloselyfollowedbythepublicor
legalcommunity,herdedicationtothelawcomesfromwithin.
"Sometimesyou'reunderalotofscrutinyandpeopleareanalyzingeverymoveand
sometimesthey'renot,butthemotivationtogetitrighthastocomefrominside,"he
said."Shehasthatinspades."
HerearesomerecentcasesinfrontofJudgeKohandtheattorneysinvolved:
ColumbiaCasualtyInsuranceCo.v.GordonTrucking,AmericanInt'lSpecialty
LinesInsuranceCo.,CV09­05441­insurance
Fortheplaintiff:PatrickA.Cathcart,LosAngelesCountySuperiorCourt,Los
Angeles;JosephP.Collins,PacificPalisades
Forthedefendant:FrankKaplan,BinghamMcCutchenLLP,SantaMonica
Lift­Uv.RiconCorp.,CV10­1850­patent
Fortheplaintiff:ScottJ.Allen,PacificGrove
Forthedefendant:BarryCoyne,ReedSmithLLP,Pittsburgh,Penn.;ScottD.Baker,
ReedSmithLLP,SanFrancisco
U.S.v.Orellana,CR09­96­narcotics
Fortheprosecution:GrantP.Fondo,GoodwinProcterLLP,MenloPark;JeffreyD.
Nedrow,U.S.attorney'soffice,SanJose
Forthedefense:JamesP.Vaughns,Oakland
LosPadresForestwatchv.U.S.ForestServiceetal.,CV10­3653­environmental
dispute
12/4/2014 DailyJournal­California'sLargestLegalNewsProvider
http://www.dailyjournal.com/subscriber/submain.cfm#section=DJStoryContent.cfm%3Fseloption%3DNEWS%26pubdate%3D12/04/2014%26shNewsType%3… 6/7
LucyH.Koh
UnitedStatesDistrict
CourtofCalifornia­
SanJose
JamesE.Herman
SuperiorCourtof
CaliforniaSanta
BarbaraCounty­
AnacapaBuilding
(SouthCounty)
HarryMark
Dorfman
SuperiorCourtof
CaliforniaCountyof
SanFrancisco­Civic
CenterCourthouse
JamesK.Voysey
SuperiorCourtof
CaliforniaSanta
BarbaraCounty­
LompocDivision
(NorthCounty)
DonaldS.
Kennedy
SuperiorCourtof
CaliforniaCountyof
LosAngeles­Central
ArraignmentCourt
HOME : MOBILESITE : CLASSIFIEDS : EXPERTS/SERVICES : MCLE : DIRECTORIES : SEARCH : PRIVACY : LOGOUT
Fortheplaintiff:MichaelGraf,ElCerrito
Forthedefendant:PeterC.Whitfield,Baker&HostetlerLLP,Washington,D.C.
InreGoogleInc.GmailLitigation,CV13­2430­privacy
Fortheplaintiff:SeanRommel,Wyly~RommelPLLC,Texarkana,Texas;Jerome
Tapley,CoryWatsonCrowder&DeGaris,P.C.,Birmingham,Ala.
Forthedefendant:MichaelG.Rhodes,WhittySomvichian,CooleyLLP,San
Francisco
hadley_robinson@dailyjournal.com
DailyJournalProfileGuidelines
RecentJudicialProfiles
ladj008/DJICText/News/Text/1060752D12042014I7.htm
EditorialId:938687
PublicationDate:12/04/2014
Previous Next
12/4/2014 DailyJournal­California'sLargestLegalNewsProvider
http://www.dailyjournal.com/subscriber/submain.cfm#section=DJStoryContent.cfm%3Fseloption%3DNEWS%26pubdate%3D12/04/2014%26shNewsType%3… 7/7

More Related Content

Viewers also liked (14)

растения и крупы
растения и крупырастения и крупы
растения и крупы
irina71
съедобные растения
съедобные растениясъедобные растения
съедобные растения
irina71
My CV and Certifications
My CV and Certifications My CV and Certifications
My CV and Certifications
Ahmed Abdel-Maksoud
Tasia ppt
Tasia pptTasia ppt
Tasia ppt
tasia17
памятники архитектуры слободского на конкурс о городе
памятники архитектуры слободского на конкурс о городепамятники архитектуры слободского на конкурс о городе
памятники архитектуры слободского на конкурс о городе
irina71
Upender CV
Upender CVUpender CV
Upender CV
upender bandari
ядовитые растения
ядовитые растенияядовитые растения
ядовитые растения
irina71
Кировская область
Кировская областьКировская область
Кировская область
irina71
лекарственные растения кировской области
лекарственные растения кировской областилекарственные растения кировской области
лекарственные растения кировской области
irina71
Beriman Teguh
Beriman TeguhBeriman Teguh
Beriman Teguh
Shareen R.
Echinodermata
EchinodermataEchinodermata
Echinodermata
Shareen R.
Michael abrahams resume payroll technician 2016
Michael abrahams resume payroll  technician 2016Michael abrahams resume payroll  technician 2016
Michael abrahams resume payroll technician 2016
Michael Abrahams
Computational linguistics
Computational linguisticsComputational linguistics
Computational linguistics
1101989
Eclectic method
Eclectic methodEclectic method
Eclectic method
1101989
растения и крупы
растения и крупырастения и крупы
растения и крупы
irina71
съедобные растения
съедобные растениясъедобные растения
съедобные растения
irina71
памятники архитектуры слободского на конкурс о городе
памятники архитектуры слободского на конкурс о городепамятники архитектуры слободского на конкурс о городе
памятники архитектуры слободского на конкурс о городе
irina71
ядовитые растения
ядовитые растенияядовитые растения
ядовитые растения
irina71
Кировская область
Кировская областьКировская область
Кировская область
irina71
лекарственные растения кировской области
лекарственные растения кировской областилекарственные растения кировской области
лекарственные растения кировской области
irina71
Michael abrahams resume payroll technician 2016
Michael abrahams resume payroll  technician 2016Michael abrahams resume payroll  technician 2016
Michael abrahams resume payroll technician 2016
Michael Abrahams
Computational linguistics
Computational linguisticsComputational linguistics
Computational linguistics
1101989
Eclectic method
Eclectic methodEclectic method
Eclectic method
1101989

Similar to Koh Profile (20)

Doretta Walker 2014 PA-PAC Questionnaire
Doretta Walker 2014 PA-PAC QuestionnaireDoretta Walker 2014 PA-PAC Questionnaire
Doretta Walker 2014 PA-PAC Questionnaire
People's Alliance
Resume Law--Final
Resume Law--FinalResume Law--Final
Resume Law--Final
Andrew Dósa
Lawyer Ratings & Attorney Search By Super Lawyers
Lawyer Ratings & Attorney Search By Super LawyersLawyer Ratings & Attorney Search By Super Lawyers
Lawyer Ratings & Attorney Search By Super Lawyers
Joyce Thomas
BAKER DONELSON - Government Positions It Appears To CONTROL/OWN
BAKER DONELSON - Government Positions It Appears To CONTROL/OWNBAKER DONELSON - Government Positions It Appears To CONTROL/OWN
BAKER DONELSON - Government Positions It Appears To CONTROL/OWN
VogelDenise
Baker donelson (ties to govt officals whitehouse)
Baker donelson (ties to govt officals whitehouse)Baker donelson (ties to govt officals whitehouse)
Baker donelson (ties to govt officals whitehouse)
VogelDenise
Social Media: The Good, the Bad, and the Lucky
Social Media: The Good, the Bad, and the LuckySocial Media: The Good, the Bad, and the Lucky
Social Media: The Good, the Bad, and the Lucky
Kelly Hart & Hallman LLP
Randy A. Fleischer
Randy A. FleischerRandy A. Fleischer
Randy A. Fleischer
JohnCena22
Cliff's CV
Cliff's CVCliff's CV
Cliff's CV
Cliff Rieders
Solo by Choice: Being the Lawyer You Always Wanted to Be
Solo by Choice: Being the Lawyer You Always Wanted to BeSolo by Choice: Being the Lawyer You Always Wanted to Be
Solo by Choice: Being the Lawyer You Always Wanted to Be
Carolyn Elefant
Resume
ResumeResume
Resume
Ivetta Avanesov
Handling Cases Involving Self-Represented Litigants - A Bench Guide for Judges.
Handling Cases Involving Self-Represented Litigants - A Bench Guide for Judges.Handling Cases Involving Self-Represented Litigants - A Bench Guide for Judges.
Handling Cases Involving Self-Represented Litigants - A Bench Guide for Judges.
Umesh Heendeniya
Resume
ResumeResume
Resume
Leah Housler
2015RedfordResume
2015RedfordResume2015RedfordResume
2015RedfordResume
Lauren Redford
2015RedfordResume
2015RedfordResume2015RedfordResume
2015RedfordResume
Lauren Redford
Resume Cronquist Esq
Resume Cronquist EsqResume Cronquist Esq
Resume Cronquist Esq
Brentley Cronquist, J.D.
Powerpoint slides brochure
Powerpoint slides brochurePowerpoint slides brochure
Powerpoint slides brochure
dlpgrouppr
e-newslayout3744pages
e-newslayout3744pagese-newslayout3744pages
e-newslayout3744pages
Alonzo Jackson Jr., J.D., M.P.A.
very long resume form
very long resume formvery long resume form
very long resume form
Robert Rivas
THE BRIEFS - The Belvin Perry & Bake Donelson Connection
THE BRIEFS - The Belvin Perry & Bake Donelson ConnectionTHE BRIEFS - The Belvin Perry & Bake Donelson Connection
THE BRIEFS - The Belvin Perry & Bake Donelson Connection
VogelDenise
RESUME 2013
RESUME 2013RESUME 2013
RESUME 2013
Wendy Wonnell
Doretta Walker 2014 PA-PAC Questionnaire
Doretta Walker 2014 PA-PAC QuestionnaireDoretta Walker 2014 PA-PAC Questionnaire
Doretta Walker 2014 PA-PAC Questionnaire
People's Alliance
Lawyer Ratings & Attorney Search By Super Lawyers
Lawyer Ratings & Attorney Search By Super LawyersLawyer Ratings & Attorney Search By Super Lawyers
Lawyer Ratings & Attorney Search By Super Lawyers
Joyce Thomas
BAKER DONELSON - Government Positions It Appears To CONTROL/OWN
BAKER DONELSON - Government Positions It Appears To CONTROL/OWNBAKER DONELSON - Government Positions It Appears To CONTROL/OWN
BAKER DONELSON - Government Positions It Appears To CONTROL/OWN
VogelDenise
Baker donelson (ties to govt officals whitehouse)
Baker donelson (ties to govt officals whitehouse)Baker donelson (ties to govt officals whitehouse)
Baker donelson (ties to govt officals whitehouse)
VogelDenise
Solo by Choice: Being the Lawyer You Always Wanted to Be
Solo by Choice: Being the Lawyer You Always Wanted to BeSolo by Choice: Being the Lawyer You Always Wanted to Be
Solo by Choice: Being the Lawyer You Always Wanted to Be
Carolyn Elefant
Handling Cases Involving Self-Represented Litigants - A Bench Guide for Judges.
Handling Cases Involving Self-Represented Litigants - A Bench Guide for Judges.Handling Cases Involving Self-Represented Litigants - A Bench Guide for Judges.
Handling Cases Involving Self-Represented Litigants - A Bench Guide for Judges.
Umesh Heendeniya
Powerpoint slides brochure
Powerpoint slides brochurePowerpoint slides brochure
Powerpoint slides brochure
dlpgrouppr
THE BRIEFS - The Belvin Perry & Bake Donelson Connection
THE BRIEFS - The Belvin Perry & Bake Donelson ConnectionTHE BRIEFS - The Belvin Perry & Bake Donelson Connection
THE BRIEFS - The Belvin Perry & Bake Donelson Connection
VogelDenise

Koh Profile