際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
Peer Comments
I asked my peers to go to my blog and to answer the question Does the colour scheme work?,
referring to the design below, this is their comments.

Person 1: This is so good! I love how you兵ve created a clean vector art design but applied a
messy paint 鍖nish and the condensation font is pretty cool too! don兵t think you should change
anything really.
Person 2: I think the colours work really well together, although yellow isn兵t associated with sci-鍖
green is and it looks effective.
Person 3: The colour scheme is very clever mix together well. You have also perfectly chosen
where the colours should be. The orange writing on the yellow visor looks very good. All in all a
great piece of vector art!
Person 4: I think that the colour scheme works really well, great picture looks amazing.
Person 5: Yes, i think the colours coordinate nicely together.
Person 6: Ryan this is fantastic! Colours are really good, same as Rebecca Lemker used in her
cover. The vector looks quality and so does the text! The paint in the background makes it look
less clip art and more pro! Nailed it.
Person 7: I would try replacing the green parts of the helmet with a navy blue, to contrast with the
background, everything else 鍖ts great.
Person 8: Yeah de鍖nitely, it looks great.
Person 9: Awesome design! Can兵t fault that font choice at all. The colour scheme works! Each
colour contrasts each other perfectly. You could make the skin tone a little lighter and perhaps
lighten the lips to make him look a little less feminine?
Person 10: looks really cool, but maybe the green makes it look a little jungle run. You could try
using blue or some other spacey colour.

From this feedback, I feel that the colour scheme does work, but I should explore other colours that
link more the the Sci-鍖 genre, like blue and oranges. Everything else about the design seems to be
good, only the colour scheme has some controversy.
Ad

Recommended

Ideas for the bedroom
Ideas for the bedroom
Mylene Soyer
Sensational Pitching
Sensational Pitching
Daniele Francescon
Comments from peers
Comments from peers
Mary Elson
Turck sunum
Turck sunum
sinasi
Feedback slides
Feedback slides
ucasykes
Peer ReviewOWL
Peer ReviewOWL
Charles Coursey
Comma Show
Comma Show
Jack Walton
Final Assignment Tsci 2009 2010 C.P. Rozenberg
Final Assignment Tsci 2009 2010 C.P. Rozenberg
Digital Learning
Peer review example
Peer review example
educgraves
CW final fiction quiz review ohs
CW final fiction quiz review ohs
MMcCardle
How to respond to油comments by peer reviewers
How to respond to油comments by peer reviewers
Editage Insights (Resources for authors and journals)
Peer Review
Peer Review
MMcCardle
Wireless power transfer
Wireless power transfer
Nexus
Peer Observation Form
Peer Observation Form
61820_62133
Peer and Self Assessment in the Classroom
Peer and Self Assessment in the Classroom
Dominic Penney
Peer Feedback on Writing: A SoTL work in progress
Peer Feedback on Writing: A SoTL work in progress
Christina Hendricks
360 Degree Feedback PPT
360 Degree Feedback PPT
msgexperts
Developing My Design Idea
Developing My Design Idea
Andrew Goddard
Paul tysall feedback
Paul tysall feedback
Ryan Worcester
7. evaluation
7. evaluation
Stephen Royle
5. fmp pre production
5. fmp pre production
chrislaw34
Digital graphics pro forma
Digital graphics pro forma
cloestead
7. evaluation
7. evaluation
Will Stewart
7. evaluation (fmp)
7. evaluation (fmp)
Shaun Gardner
Final design analysis
Final design analysis
Ryan Worcester
Digital Graphics pro forma (with improvements)
Digital Graphics pro forma (with improvements)
cloestead
Send
Send
Robyn Collinson
Digital Graphics Pro Forma
Digital Graphics Pro Forma
Craig Cassidy
Digital Graphics Pro Forma (improved 3)
Digital Graphics Pro Forma (improved 3)
cloestead
7. evaluation
7. evaluation
Benjamin Fahey

More Related Content

Viewers also liked (9)

Peer review example
Peer review example
educgraves
CW final fiction quiz review ohs
CW final fiction quiz review ohs
MMcCardle
How to respond to油comments by peer reviewers
How to respond to油comments by peer reviewers
Editage Insights (Resources for authors and journals)
Peer Review
Peer Review
MMcCardle
Wireless power transfer
Wireless power transfer
Nexus
Peer Observation Form
Peer Observation Form
61820_62133
Peer and Self Assessment in the Classroom
Peer and Self Assessment in the Classroom
Dominic Penney
Peer Feedback on Writing: A SoTL work in progress
Peer Feedback on Writing: A SoTL work in progress
Christina Hendricks
360 Degree Feedback PPT
360 Degree Feedback PPT
msgexperts
Peer review example
Peer review example
educgraves
CW final fiction quiz review ohs
CW final fiction quiz review ohs
MMcCardle
Peer Review
Peer Review
MMcCardle
Wireless power transfer
Wireless power transfer
Nexus
Peer Observation Form
Peer Observation Form
61820_62133
Peer and Self Assessment in the Classroom
Peer and Self Assessment in the Classroom
Dominic Penney
Peer Feedback on Writing: A SoTL work in progress
Peer Feedback on Writing: A SoTL work in progress
Christina Hendricks
360 Degree Feedback PPT
360 Degree Feedback PPT
msgexperts

Similar to Peer feedback (13)

Developing My Design Idea
Developing My Design Idea
Andrew Goddard
Paul tysall feedback
Paul tysall feedback
Ryan Worcester
7. evaluation
7. evaluation
Stephen Royle
5. fmp pre production
5. fmp pre production
chrislaw34
Digital graphics pro forma
Digital graphics pro forma
cloestead
7. evaluation
7. evaluation
Will Stewart
7. evaluation (fmp)
7. evaluation (fmp)
Shaun Gardner
Final design analysis
Final design analysis
Ryan Worcester
Digital Graphics pro forma (with improvements)
Digital Graphics pro forma (with improvements)
cloestead
Send
Send
Robyn Collinson
Digital Graphics Pro Forma
Digital Graphics Pro Forma
Craig Cassidy
Digital Graphics Pro Forma (improved 3)
Digital Graphics Pro Forma (improved 3)
cloestead
7. evaluation
7. evaluation
Benjamin Fahey
Developing My Design Idea
Developing My Design Idea
Andrew Goddard
Paul tysall feedback
Paul tysall feedback
Ryan Worcester
5. fmp pre production
5. fmp pre production
chrislaw34
Digital graphics pro forma
Digital graphics pro forma
cloestead
7. evaluation (fmp)
7. evaluation (fmp)
Shaun Gardner
Final design analysis
Final design analysis
Ryan Worcester
Digital Graphics pro forma (with improvements)
Digital Graphics pro forma (with improvements)
cloestead
Digital Graphics Pro Forma
Digital Graphics Pro Forma
Craig Cassidy
Digital Graphics Pro Forma (improved 3)
Digital Graphics Pro Forma (improved 3)
cloestead
Ad

More from Ryan Worcester (20)

Graphic design
Graphic design
Ryan Worcester
111 physicsdynamics research
111 physicsdynamics research
Ryan Worcester
Graphic design
Graphic design
Ryan Worcester
Marketing keynote finished
Marketing keynote finished
Ryan Worcester
Animation evaluation
Animation evaluation
Ryan Worcester
Graphic design evaluation
Graphic design evaluation
Ryan Worcester
Target audience profile
Target audience profile
Ryan Worcester
Monty info
Monty info
Ryan Worcester
Comic panels transitions
Comic panels transitions
Ryan Worcester
Mag ownership and distribution
Mag ownership and distribution
Ryan Worcester
Total film page furniture
Total film page furniture
Ryan Worcester
Lwl page furniture
Lwl page furniture
Ryan Worcester
Total film flat plan
Total film flat plan
Ryan Worcester
Shame issue flat plan
Shame issue flat plan
Ryan Worcester
Page furniture
Page furniture
Ryan Worcester
History of film magazines
History of film magazines
Ryan Worcester
Draft designs feedback
Draft designs feedback
Ryan Worcester
Focus
Focus
Ryan Worcester
Composition
Composition
Ryan Worcester
Lighting
Lighting
Ryan Worcester
111 physicsdynamics research
111 physicsdynamics research
Ryan Worcester
Marketing keynote finished
Marketing keynote finished
Ryan Worcester
Animation evaluation
Animation evaluation
Ryan Worcester
Graphic design evaluation
Graphic design evaluation
Ryan Worcester
Target audience profile
Target audience profile
Ryan Worcester
Comic panels transitions
Comic panels transitions
Ryan Worcester
Mag ownership and distribution
Mag ownership and distribution
Ryan Worcester
Total film page furniture
Total film page furniture
Ryan Worcester
Total film flat plan
Total film flat plan
Ryan Worcester
Shame issue flat plan
Shame issue flat plan
Ryan Worcester
History of film magazines
History of film magazines
Ryan Worcester
Draft designs feedback
Draft designs feedback
Ryan Worcester
Ad

Peer feedback

  • 1. Peer Comments I asked my peers to go to my blog and to answer the question Does the colour scheme work?, referring to the design below, this is their comments. Person 1: This is so good! I love how you兵ve created a clean vector art design but applied a messy paint 鍖nish and the condensation font is pretty cool too! don兵t think you should change anything really. Person 2: I think the colours work really well together, although yellow isn兵t associated with sci-鍖 green is and it looks effective. Person 3: The colour scheme is very clever mix together well. You have also perfectly chosen where the colours should be. The orange writing on the yellow visor looks very good. All in all a great piece of vector art! Person 4: I think that the colour scheme works really well, great picture looks amazing. Person 5: Yes, i think the colours coordinate nicely together. Person 6: Ryan this is fantastic! Colours are really good, same as Rebecca Lemker used in her cover. The vector looks quality and so does the text! The paint in the background makes it look less clip art and more pro! Nailed it. Person 7: I would try replacing the green parts of the helmet with a navy blue, to contrast with the background, everything else 鍖ts great. Person 8: Yeah de鍖nitely, it looks great. Person 9: Awesome design! Can兵t fault that font choice at all. The colour scheme works! Each colour contrasts each other perfectly. You could make the skin tone a little lighter and perhaps lighten the lips to make him look a little less feminine? Person 10: looks really cool, but maybe the green makes it look a little jungle run. You could try using blue or some other spacey colour. From this feedback, I feel that the colour scheme does work, but I should explore other colours that link more the the Sci-鍖 genre, like blue and oranges. Everything else about the design seems to be good, only the colour scheme has some controversy.