際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
Designing for cooks:
interactive instructions for
everyday use
Lucy Buykx
n

My research investigates how cooks engage and
interact with recipe instructions to inform the
design of interactive recipe systems
Human-Food Interaction
n

Helping create the perfect recipe in the kitchen
n

CounterActive (Ju, Hurwitz, Judd & Lee 2001)

n

Augmented Reality Kitchen(Bonanni, Lee & Selker 2005)

n

Kitchen of the Future (Siio, Hamada, Mima 2005)

n

PersonalChef (Mennicken, Karrer, Russell, Borchers 2010)

n

panavi (Uriu, Namai, Tokuhisa, Kashiwagi, Inami, Okude
2012)
not just cooking...
n

Shopping, meal planning
n

integrating persuasive & social media

n

healthy eating, local food, sustainability
Initial studies with older adults
n

focus groups with 15

n

food diaries with 12
n

n

meals & shopping for
7 days
home interviews
Thesis seminar - Designing for cooks: interactive recipes for everyday use
Initial studies with younger adults

n

questionnaire & interviews
n

n

80% collected recipes
11% used interactive
technology
Capturing Family Recipes for
digital sharing across generations

n

n

Lucy Buykx, Helen Petrie,
Paul Cairns
include 2011, Helen
Hamlyn Centre for Design
n

Contribution is innovative technology in the
kitchen

n

Little theory behind claims

n

Low quality evaluations
n

Research questions:
n

What problems do cooks experience working
with recipes?

n

What factors cause problems?

n

How can interactive design mitigate these?
Procedural instructions
n

n

n

step-by-step
little explanation of how
the system works
can be used without prior
knowledge
Recipe instruction set
n

title

n

list of ingredients

n

preparation instructions

n

method instructions

n

meta-data
Guidelines for procedural instructions
for initial use (Ganier 2004)
n

Segmented text... numbered steps rather than
paragraphs

n

Chronological linear organisation

n

Use pictures together with text

n

Use headings 鍖tting to goals or sub-goals
Experiments x 2
n

24 cooks, 3 recipes

n

2 experimental conditions + control

n

Videoed and analysed

n

n

Quantitative measures: time to complete, reading
time, cooks ratings
Qualitative analysis: comments and feedback
during cooking, problems, errors made
Experiment 1

Experiment 2

Segmented instructions

Segmented instructions with
pictures

Integrated, chronological
instructions

Semantic structured recipe with
sub-goals

Control

Control
Exp1: Segmented instructions
Exp1:
Integrated,
chronological
instructions
Integrated, chronological
Control
Results mixed
n
n

n

n

No timing differences or rating differences
Cooks disliked long paragraph steps AND
segmented steps
Cooks did not move linearly, needed to understand
context
Cooks did not follow instructions perfectly
Papers at
n

Cooking & Eating Activities workshop IEEE MM
CEA2011

n

Food & Interaction Design workshop CHI2012

n

Food for thought workshop DIS2012
Experiment 2
n

Compared affect of
n

Segmented instructions with goal state pictures

n

Semantic structure with sub-goals

n

against control
Segmented instructions with
goal-state pictures
n

Add the mince
and carrot, and
cook for about 8
minutes, stirring
all the time, until
the meat is nearly
cooked.
n
n

n

Drain the pasta
Add the pasta to
the meat sauce
with a couple of
tablespoons of the
pasta water.
Mix well, saut辿
for a minute.
Semantic structured recipe with sub-goals
Analysis ongoing
n

Structured recipe with sub-goals
n

n
n

rated easier to understand and better organised
than control
fewer errors

Reliance on pictures - impact on validity
Conclusion
n

Instruction design can offer insights recipe design
n

n

But cooking is complex domain

Results show were existing interactive recipe
systems are not helpful ... can inform more
sophisticated design
Future research
n

Robust prototype to test in-home

n

Investigate recipe designs to support deviations

n

Work with semantic researchers to create on-the鍖y transformations
Ad

Recommended

Collaboration between Higher Education Associations for the Agricultural and ...
Collaboration between Higher Education Associations for the Agricultural and ...
Francois Stepman
Diary Entries Investigation
Diary Entries Investigation
lauraswatman
Experiencia Educativa Inglesa
Experiencia Educativa Inglesa
UBA
Panavi CHI2012 Presentation
Panavi CHI2012 Presentation
Daisuke Uriu
Design Thinking - content courtesy: https://www.coursera.org/course/designbiz
Design Thinking - content courtesy: https://www.coursera.org/course/designbiz
Kanisha Raina
Cooking 101 Syllabus
Cooking 101 Syllabus
Harry Park
Westerman 2005 Honours theis abstract
Westerman 2005 Honours theis abstract
Lucinda Westerman
5. EPP 2ND QUARTER W -1.pptx grade two lessons
5. EPP 2ND QUARTER W -1.pptx grade two lessons
JosephTaguinod1
Present planning final
Present planning final
Sophia Amenyah
PKM. Syllabu. Cookery.pdf
PKM. Syllabu. Cookery.pdf
JoannAbad1
Food Mile 2[1]
Food Mile 2[1]
navreetk
To give Social Skills Training Program for Children.pptx
To give Social Skills Training Program for Children.pptx
getchalachew2021
Assessing the COOKING SKILLS Development of Grade 11 Cookery Students in Cari...
Assessing the COOKING SKILLS Development of Grade 11 Cookery Students in Cari...
GilbertObanil2
Food for thought
Food for thought
akmosier
Atm Powerpoint
Atm Powerpoint
PhilWhelan
Science and Cooking at Harvard
Science and Cooking at Harvard
Naveen Sinha
Foodinsider International focus group 23 febbraio 2018_public
Foodinsider International focus group 23 febbraio 2018_public
Claudia Rita Paltrinieri
Lesson plan a nutrition
Lesson plan a nutrition
marbush50
PBL in Economics
PBL in Economics
Buck Institute for Education
19. Nutrition Intervention Planning.pptx
19. Nutrition Intervention Planning.pptx
poli17690
Hana Cantral Resume B
Hana Cantral Resume B
Hana Cantral
Master PitchdeckMarch2020
Master PitchdeckMarch2020
Layla Sabourian
Basic Cookery Practical Class Rubric copy.docx
Basic Cookery Practical Class Rubric copy.docx
AzharMustafa3
Food and Nutrition Sciences Course Information Sheet
Food and Nutrition Sciences Course Information Sheet
ChrissyYCDSB
Chef Koochooloo Pitch
Chef Koochooloo Pitch
Layla Sabourian
Chichportich tech unit_outline
Chichportich tech unit_outline
MsJessie23
dll-tle-9-cookery.docx
dll-tle-9-cookery.docx
MarifePascua3
Cookery daily Lesson Log Fir Grade 9 Technology and Livelihood Education
Cookery daily Lesson Log Fir Grade 9 Technology and Livelihood Education
JuanPauloVillamor
Capturing family recipes for digital sharing across generations
Capturing family recipes for digital sharing across generations
Lucy Buykx
Recipes for cooking
Recipes for cooking
Lucy Buykx

More Related Content

Similar to Thesis seminar - Designing for cooks: interactive recipes for everyday use (20)

Present planning final
Present planning final
Sophia Amenyah
PKM. Syllabu. Cookery.pdf
PKM. Syllabu. Cookery.pdf
JoannAbad1
Food Mile 2[1]
Food Mile 2[1]
navreetk
To give Social Skills Training Program for Children.pptx
To give Social Skills Training Program for Children.pptx
getchalachew2021
Assessing the COOKING SKILLS Development of Grade 11 Cookery Students in Cari...
Assessing the COOKING SKILLS Development of Grade 11 Cookery Students in Cari...
GilbertObanil2
Food for thought
Food for thought
akmosier
Atm Powerpoint
Atm Powerpoint
PhilWhelan
Science and Cooking at Harvard
Science and Cooking at Harvard
Naveen Sinha
Foodinsider International focus group 23 febbraio 2018_public
Foodinsider International focus group 23 febbraio 2018_public
Claudia Rita Paltrinieri
Lesson plan a nutrition
Lesson plan a nutrition
marbush50
PBL in Economics
PBL in Economics
Buck Institute for Education
19. Nutrition Intervention Planning.pptx
19. Nutrition Intervention Planning.pptx
poli17690
Hana Cantral Resume B
Hana Cantral Resume B
Hana Cantral
Master PitchdeckMarch2020
Master PitchdeckMarch2020
Layla Sabourian
Basic Cookery Practical Class Rubric copy.docx
Basic Cookery Practical Class Rubric copy.docx
AzharMustafa3
Food and Nutrition Sciences Course Information Sheet
Food and Nutrition Sciences Course Information Sheet
ChrissyYCDSB
Chef Koochooloo Pitch
Chef Koochooloo Pitch
Layla Sabourian
Chichportich tech unit_outline
Chichportich tech unit_outline
MsJessie23
dll-tle-9-cookery.docx
dll-tle-9-cookery.docx
MarifePascua3
Cookery daily Lesson Log Fir Grade 9 Technology and Livelihood Education
Cookery daily Lesson Log Fir Grade 9 Technology and Livelihood Education
JuanPauloVillamor
Present planning final
Present planning final
Sophia Amenyah
PKM. Syllabu. Cookery.pdf
PKM. Syllabu. Cookery.pdf
JoannAbad1
Food Mile 2[1]
Food Mile 2[1]
navreetk
To give Social Skills Training Program for Children.pptx
To give Social Skills Training Program for Children.pptx
getchalachew2021
Assessing the COOKING SKILLS Development of Grade 11 Cookery Students in Cari...
Assessing the COOKING SKILLS Development of Grade 11 Cookery Students in Cari...
GilbertObanil2
Food for thought
Food for thought
akmosier
Atm Powerpoint
Atm Powerpoint
PhilWhelan
Science and Cooking at Harvard
Science and Cooking at Harvard
Naveen Sinha
Foodinsider International focus group 23 febbraio 2018_public
Foodinsider International focus group 23 febbraio 2018_public
Claudia Rita Paltrinieri
Lesson plan a nutrition
Lesson plan a nutrition
marbush50
19. Nutrition Intervention Planning.pptx
19. Nutrition Intervention Planning.pptx
poli17690
Hana Cantral Resume B
Hana Cantral Resume B
Hana Cantral
Master PitchdeckMarch2020
Master PitchdeckMarch2020
Layla Sabourian
Basic Cookery Practical Class Rubric copy.docx
Basic Cookery Practical Class Rubric copy.docx
AzharMustafa3
Food and Nutrition Sciences Course Information Sheet
Food and Nutrition Sciences Course Information Sheet
ChrissyYCDSB
Chef Koochooloo Pitch
Chef Koochooloo Pitch
Layla Sabourian
Chichportich tech unit_outline
Chichportich tech unit_outline
MsJessie23
dll-tle-9-cookery.docx
dll-tle-9-cookery.docx
MarifePascua3
Cookery daily Lesson Log Fir Grade 9 Technology and Livelihood Education
Cookery daily Lesson Log Fir Grade 9 Technology and Livelihood Education
JuanPauloVillamor

More from Lucy Buykx (7)

Capturing family recipes for digital sharing across generations
Capturing family recipes for digital sharing across generations
Lucy Buykx
Recipes for cooking
Recipes for cooking
Lucy Buykx
Recipes: Instructional design and interactional design
Recipes: Instructional design and interactional design
Lucy Buykx
What cooks need from multimedia and textually enhanced recipes
What cooks need from multimedia and textually enhanced recipes
Lucy Buykx
Challenging assumptions : Older people's attitudes to technology and cooking
Challenging assumptions : Older people's attitudes to technology and cooking
Lucy Buykx
HCI and Shepherd's Pie
HCI and Shepherd's Pie
Lucy Buykx
Collaborative heuristic evaluation - masters project presentation
Collaborative heuristic evaluation - masters project presentation
Lucy Buykx
Capturing family recipes for digital sharing across generations
Capturing family recipes for digital sharing across generations
Lucy Buykx
Recipes for cooking
Recipes for cooking
Lucy Buykx
Recipes: Instructional design and interactional design
Recipes: Instructional design and interactional design
Lucy Buykx
What cooks need from multimedia and textually enhanced recipes
What cooks need from multimedia and textually enhanced recipes
Lucy Buykx
Challenging assumptions : Older people's attitudes to technology and cooking
Challenging assumptions : Older people's attitudes to technology and cooking
Lucy Buykx
HCI and Shepherd's Pie
HCI and Shepherd's Pie
Lucy Buykx
Collaborative heuristic evaluation - masters project presentation
Collaborative heuristic evaluation - masters project presentation
Lucy Buykx
Ad

Recently uploaded (20)

GenAI Opportunities and Challenges - Where 370 Enterprises Are Focusing Now.pdf
GenAI Opportunities and Challenges - Where 370 Enterprises Are Focusing Now.pdf
Priyanka Aash
MuleSoft for AgentForce : Topic Center and API Catalog
MuleSoft for AgentForce : Topic Center and API Catalog
shyamraj55
Coordinated Disclosure for ML - What's Different and What's the Same.pdf
Coordinated Disclosure for ML - What's Different and What's the Same.pdf
Priyanka Aash
The Future of Data, AI, and AR: Innovation Inspired by You.pdf
The Future of Data, AI, and AR: Innovation Inspired by You.pdf
Safe Software
Enhance GitHub Copilot using MCP - Enterprise version.pdf
Enhance GitHub Copilot using MCP - Enterprise version.pdf
Nilesh Gule
Key Requirements to Successfully Implement Generative AI in Edge DevicesOpt...
Key Requirements to Successfully Implement Generative AI in Edge DevicesOpt...
Edge AI and Vision Alliance
cnc-processing-centers-centateq-p-110-en.pdf
cnc-processing-centers-centateq-p-110-en.pdf
AmirStern2
Wenn alles versagt - IBM Tape sch端tzt, was z辰hlt! Und besonders mit dem neust...
Wenn alles versagt - IBM Tape sch端tzt, was z辰hlt! Und besonders mit dem neust...
Josef Weingand
FIDO Seminar: Targeting Trust: The Future of Identity in the Workforce.pptx
FIDO Seminar: Targeting Trust: The Future of Identity in the Workforce.pptx
FIDO Alliance
9-1-1 Addressing: End-to-End Automation Using FME
9-1-1 Addressing: End-to-End Automation Using FME
Safe Software
"Database isolation: how we deal with hundreds of direct connections to the d...
"Database isolation: how we deal with hundreds of direct connections to the d...
Fwdays
FIDO Seminar: Perspectives on Passkeys & Consumer Adoption.pptx
FIDO Seminar: Perspectives on Passkeys & Consumer Adoption.pptx
FIDO Alliance
Securing AI - There Is No Try, Only Do!.pdf
Securing AI - There Is No Try, Only Do!.pdf
Priyanka Aash
Crypto Super 500 - 14th Report - June2025.pdf
Crypto Super 500 - 14th Report - June2025.pdf
Stephen Perrenod
You are not excused! How to avoid security blind spots on the way to production
You are not excused! How to avoid security blind spots on the way to production
Michele Leroux Bustamante
Raman Bhaumik - Passionate Tech Enthusiast
Raman Bhaumik - Passionate Tech Enthusiast
Raman Bhaumik
Tech-ASan: Two-stage check for Address Sanitizer - Yixuan Cao.pdf
Tech-ASan: Two-stage check for Address Sanitizer - Yixuan Cao.pdf
caoyixuan2019
OWASP Barcelona 2025 Threat Model Library
OWASP Barcelona 2025 Threat Model Library
PetraVukmirovic
CapCut Pro Crack For PC Latest Version {Fully Unlocked} 2025
CapCut Pro Crack For PC Latest Version {Fully Unlocked} 2025
pcprocore
A Constitutional Quagmire - Ethical Minefields of AI, Cyber, and Privacy.pdf
A Constitutional Quagmire - Ethical Minefields of AI, Cyber, and Privacy.pdf
Priyanka Aash
GenAI Opportunities and Challenges - Where 370 Enterprises Are Focusing Now.pdf
GenAI Opportunities and Challenges - Where 370 Enterprises Are Focusing Now.pdf
Priyanka Aash
MuleSoft for AgentForce : Topic Center and API Catalog
MuleSoft for AgentForce : Topic Center and API Catalog
shyamraj55
Coordinated Disclosure for ML - What's Different and What's the Same.pdf
Coordinated Disclosure for ML - What's Different and What's the Same.pdf
Priyanka Aash
The Future of Data, AI, and AR: Innovation Inspired by You.pdf
The Future of Data, AI, and AR: Innovation Inspired by You.pdf
Safe Software
Enhance GitHub Copilot using MCP - Enterprise version.pdf
Enhance GitHub Copilot using MCP - Enterprise version.pdf
Nilesh Gule
Key Requirements to Successfully Implement Generative AI in Edge DevicesOpt...
Key Requirements to Successfully Implement Generative AI in Edge DevicesOpt...
Edge AI and Vision Alliance
cnc-processing-centers-centateq-p-110-en.pdf
cnc-processing-centers-centateq-p-110-en.pdf
AmirStern2
Wenn alles versagt - IBM Tape sch端tzt, was z辰hlt! Und besonders mit dem neust...
Wenn alles versagt - IBM Tape sch端tzt, was z辰hlt! Und besonders mit dem neust...
Josef Weingand
FIDO Seminar: Targeting Trust: The Future of Identity in the Workforce.pptx
FIDO Seminar: Targeting Trust: The Future of Identity in the Workforce.pptx
FIDO Alliance
9-1-1 Addressing: End-to-End Automation Using FME
9-1-1 Addressing: End-to-End Automation Using FME
Safe Software
"Database isolation: how we deal with hundreds of direct connections to the d...
"Database isolation: how we deal with hundreds of direct connections to the d...
Fwdays
FIDO Seminar: Perspectives on Passkeys & Consumer Adoption.pptx
FIDO Seminar: Perspectives on Passkeys & Consumer Adoption.pptx
FIDO Alliance
Securing AI - There Is No Try, Only Do!.pdf
Securing AI - There Is No Try, Only Do!.pdf
Priyanka Aash
Crypto Super 500 - 14th Report - June2025.pdf
Crypto Super 500 - 14th Report - June2025.pdf
Stephen Perrenod
You are not excused! How to avoid security blind spots on the way to production
You are not excused! How to avoid security blind spots on the way to production
Michele Leroux Bustamante
Raman Bhaumik - Passionate Tech Enthusiast
Raman Bhaumik - Passionate Tech Enthusiast
Raman Bhaumik
Tech-ASan: Two-stage check for Address Sanitizer - Yixuan Cao.pdf
Tech-ASan: Two-stage check for Address Sanitizer - Yixuan Cao.pdf
caoyixuan2019
OWASP Barcelona 2025 Threat Model Library
OWASP Barcelona 2025 Threat Model Library
PetraVukmirovic
CapCut Pro Crack For PC Latest Version {Fully Unlocked} 2025
CapCut Pro Crack For PC Latest Version {Fully Unlocked} 2025
pcprocore
A Constitutional Quagmire - Ethical Minefields of AI, Cyber, and Privacy.pdf
A Constitutional Quagmire - Ethical Minefields of AI, Cyber, and Privacy.pdf
Priyanka Aash
Ad

Thesis seminar - Designing for cooks: interactive recipes for everyday use