際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
To the Man
with a Hammer
Everything
Looks like a Nail
A Discussion on Education, Technology, Tool-
selection, Decision-making and the value of
knowledge.
AAMC / WGEA Western Regional Conference, May
2013
ASSUMPTIONS
 As educators, our product is knowledge.
 Technology facilitates good ideas; it is not a
solution.
 To think exclusively of the bottom line is
antithetical to evidence-based practice.
 Medical education is an evidence-based
practice.
Curriculum Management aids these points by providing an evidence-based
method of mapping knowledge trajectory and acquisition.
 As educators, our product is knowledge.
 Technology facilitates good ideas; it is not a
solution.
 To think exclusively of the bottom line is
antithetical to evidence-based practice.
 Medical education is an evidence-based
practice.
 Technology facilitates good ideas; it is not a
solution.
 To think exclusively of the bottom line is
antithetical to evidence-based practice.
These assumptions provide tension with the financial realities most
institutions (and the people who run them) currently face; disruptive
innovation on these fronts is an enormous challenge.
 As educators, our product is knowledge.
 Technology facilitates good ideas; it is not a
solution.
 To think exclusively of the bottom line is
antithetical to evidence-based practice.
 Medical education is an evidence-based
practice.
 As educators, our product is knowledge.
 Medical education is an evidence-based
practice.
 As educators, our product is knowledge.
QUESTIONS WE SHOULD ASK
 What do we choose, and why?
 How do we test the outcomes of our choices?
 Are failures acknowledged?
 Are successes acknowledged?
 What are the metrics we use?
What are we really choosing when we adopt a tool to further education?
Tech choices are usually driven by a variety of factors, including cost, peer pressure
(everyone else is doing it), and the hope for innovative enhancement.
What are the ways your institutions test for the value and viability of the
choices made? Is there a standard? Accountability?
This is really, really important.This is even more important. We learn from failure; a lack of acknowledgment
means we are unable to move to a better method or practice.
 What do we choose, and why?
 How do we test the outcomes of our choices?
 What are the metrics we use?
Having a previously accepted set of metrics provides a level of quality assurance
necessary to understand the outcomes of our choices.
 Are successes acknowledged?
What are we really choosing when we adopt a tool
to further education?
QUESTIONS WE SHOULD ASK
A key issue in all selection processes
Why do we make the choices we
make?
Financial concerns
Workload concerns
Standardization
Internal pressures (Past practice, executive
interest)
External pressures (accreditation)
If we are a business, what is our
product?
 If so, then who is our customer? Do we sell
graduates?
 Our product is knowledge and ability. Our
customer is our graduate.Graduates!
How do we evaluate our tools?
 How do we measure success?
SUCCESS = TRUESUCCESS  TRUE
 If successful, how do we leverage that?
 If not successful, how do we act on that?
Not All Teaching Is Equal
Education is transformative. Data accumulation is not.
 Qualitative
Flipped Classroom  a new expression of an old model
 Quantitative
 Experiential
 Didactic
 Mentored
How do we approach the matching of tool to method?
Education is transformative. Data accumulation is not.
How do we identify the most effective approaches?
Education is transformative. Data accumulation is not.
How do we make the most of innovative models?
Education is transformative. Data accumulation is not.
E-Textbooks  a great addition, a questionable replacement
LMS  last weeks gleam in the eye of CFOs, todays model challenge
MOOCs -- the current bright shiny object
Not All Teaching Is Equal
Education is transformative. Data accumulation is not.
Cost
Efficiency
Educational
Results
Sustainable
Real Value
Innovative SuccessPartial Success
The Questionnaire
1. Describe the technology you are using with
your students. What do you think of this
technology?
2. Describe the selection/adoption process for
the technology you are using with your
students.
3. How do you measure educational success?
Thank You!
Sascha Benjamin Cohen
Director of Strategic Development for Ilios
UCSF School of Medicine
sascha.cohen@ucsf.edu
http://www.iliiosproject.org
https://ilios-demo.ucsf.edu

More Related Content

What's hot (18)

Education law conference, March 2017 - London - Mapping out the future landsc...
Education law conference, March 2017 - London - Mapping out the future landsc...Education law conference, March 2017 - London - Mapping out the future landsc...
Education law conference, March 2017 - London - Mapping out the future landsc...
Browne Jacobson LLP
2018 Education Ambassador Program: One-to-One Institute
2018 Education Ambassador Program: One-to-One Institute2018 Education Ambassador Program: One-to-One Institute
2018 Education Ambassador Program: One-to-One Institute
Fujitsu America
Tony Bryk - Bristol - Joining Improvement Science to NICs
Tony Bryk - Bristol - Joining Improvement Science to NICsTony Bryk - Bristol - Joining Improvement Science to NICs
Tony Bryk - Bristol - Joining Improvement Science to NICs
learningemerg
Planning the route to improved digital capability in your organisation with a...
Planning the route to improved digital capability in your organisation with a...Planning the route to improved digital capability in your organisation with a...
Planning the route to improved digital capability in your organisation with a...
Jisc
Enabling leadership moving from hero to host workshop marc mc laren
Enabling leadership moving from hero to host workshop   marc mc larenEnabling leadership moving from hero to host workshop   marc mc laren
Enabling leadership moving from hero to host workshop marc mc laren
Penelope Toth
Introducing ReallyManaging Assessment
Introducing ReallyManaging AssessmentIntroducing ReallyManaging Assessment
Introducing ReallyManaging Assessment
myknowledgemap
HTSA research methodology workshop may 22 2013
HTSA research methodology workshop may 22 2013HTSA research methodology workshop may 22 2013
HTSA research methodology workshop may 22 2013
Ruth Deakin Crick
Back to school_night_presentation
Back to school_night_presentationBack to school_night_presentation
Back to school_night_presentation
tinamarie973
Education law conference, March 2017 - Nottingham - Mapping out the future la...
Education law conference, March 2017 - Nottingham - Mapping out the future la...Education law conference, March 2017 - Nottingham - Mapping out the future la...
Education law conference, March 2017 - Nottingham - Mapping out the future la...
Browne Jacobson LLP
Bondurant-Farrar
Bondurant-FarrarBondurant-Farrar
Bondurant-Farrar
Evan Abbey
Bryk may 2014 using NICs to tackle practical problems in education
Bryk may 2014 using NICs to tackle practical problems in educationBryk may 2014 using NICs to tackle practical problems in education
Bryk may 2014 using NICs to tackle practical problems in education
learningemerg
Learning Engineering of MOOClets: Simultaneously benefiting Professional Lear...
Learning Engineering of MOOClets: Simultaneously benefiting Professional Lear...Learning Engineering of MOOClets: Simultaneously benefiting Professional Lear...
Learning Engineering of MOOClets: Simultaneously benefiting Professional Lear...
Joseph Jay Williams
ChildStory District Solutions Showcase - Main Presentation
ChildStory District Solutions Showcase - Main PresentationChildStory District Solutions Showcase - Main Presentation
ChildStory District Solutions Showcase - Main Presentation
ChildStory
20 questions you should ask before talking about learning objectives
20 questions you should ask before talking about learning objectives20 questions you should ask before talking about learning objectives
20 questions you should ask before talking about learning objectives
Jeff Kortenbosch
3. Need Assessment - To Upgrade
3. Need Assessment - To Upgrade3. Need Assessment - To Upgrade
3. Need Assessment - To Upgrade
tmcommission
FEI 2015 presentation
FEI 2015 presentationFEI 2015 presentation
FEI 2015 presentation
shanika74
Product Managers & UX Research: How Bridging the Experience Gap Can Propel Te...
Product Managers & UX Research: How Bridging the Experience Gap Can Propel Te...Product Managers & UX Research: How Bridging the Experience Gap Can Propel Te...
Product Managers & UX Research: How Bridging the Experience Gap Can Propel Te...
Aggregage
Workshop presentation UL
Workshop presentation ULWorkshop presentation UL
Workshop presentation UL
Angelica Risquez
Education law conference, March 2017 - London - Mapping out the future landsc...
Education law conference, March 2017 - London - Mapping out the future landsc...Education law conference, March 2017 - London - Mapping out the future landsc...
Education law conference, March 2017 - London - Mapping out the future landsc...
Browne Jacobson LLP
2018 Education Ambassador Program: One-to-One Institute
2018 Education Ambassador Program: One-to-One Institute2018 Education Ambassador Program: One-to-One Institute
2018 Education Ambassador Program: One-to-One Institute
Fujitsu America
Tony Bryk - Bristol - Joining Improvement Science to NICs
Tony Bryk - Bristol - Joining Improvement Science to NICsTony Bryk - Bristol - Joining Improvement Science to NICs
Tony Bryk - Bristol - Joining Improvement Science to NICs
learningemerg
Planning the route to improved digital capability in your organisation with a...
Planning the route to improved digital capability in your organisation with a...Planning the route to improved digital capability in your organisation with a...
Planning the route to improved digital capability in your organisation with a...
Jisc
Enabling leadership moving from hero to host workshop marc mc laren
Enabling leadership moving from hero to host workshop   marc mc larenEnabling leadership moving from hero to host workshop   marc mc laren
Enabling leadership moving from hero to host workshop marc mc laren
Penelope Toth
Introducing ReallyManaging Assessment
Introducing ReallyManaging AssessmentIntroducing ReallyManaging Assessment
Introducing ReallyManaging Assessment
myknowledgemap
HTSA research methodology workshop may 22 2013
HTSA research methodology workshop may 22 2013HTSA research methodology workshop may 22 2013
HTSA research methodology workshop may 22 2013
Ruth Deakin Crick
Back to school_night_presentation
Back to school_night_presentationBack to school_night_presentation
Back to school_night_presentation
tinamarie973
Education law conference, March 2017 - Nottingham - Mapping out the future la...
Education law conference, March 2017 - Nottingham - Mapping out the future la...Education law conference, March 2017 - Nottingham - Mapping out the future la...
Education law conference, March 2017 - Nottingham - Mapping out the future la...
Browne Jacobson LLP
Bondurant-Farrar
Bondurant-FarrarBondurant-Farrar
Bondurant-Farrar
Evan Abbey
Bryk may 2014 using NICs to tackle practical problems in education
Bryk may 2014 using NICs to tackle practical problems in educationBryk may 2014 using NICs to tackle practical problems in education
Bryk may 2014 using NICs to tackle practical problems in education
learningemerg
Learning Engineering of MOOClets: Simultaneously benefiting Professional Lear...
Learning Engineering of MOOClets: Simultaneously benefiting Professional Lear...Learning Engineering of MOOClets: Simultaneously benefiting Professional Lear...
Learning Engineering of MOOClets: Simultaneously benefiting Professional Lear...
Joseph Jay Williams
ChildStory District Solutions Showcase - Main Presentation
ChildStory District Solutions Showcase - Main PresentationChildStory District Solutions Showcase - Main Presentation
ChildStory District Solutions Showcase - Main Presentation
ChildStory
20 questions you should ask before talking about learning objectives
20 questions you should ask before talking about learning objectives20 questions you should ask before talking about learning objectives
20 questions you should ask before talking about learning objectives
Jeff Kortenbosch
3. Need Assessment - To Upgrade
3. Need Assessment - To Upgrade3. Need Assessment - To Upgrade
3. Need Assessment - To Upgrade
tmcommission
FEI 2015 presentation
FEI 2015 presentationFEI 2015 presentation
FEI 2015 presentation
shanika74
Product Managers & UX Research: How Bridging the Experience Gap Can Propel Te...
Product Managers & UX Research: How Bridging the Experience Gap Can Propel Te...Product Managers & UX Research: How Bridging the Experience Gap Can Propel Te...
Product Managers & UX Research: How Bridging the Experience Gap Can Propel Te...
Aggregage
Workshop presentation UL
Workshop presentation ULWorkshop presentation UL
Workshop presentation UL
Angelica Risquez

Similar to To the man with a hammer, EVERYTHING looks like a nail (20)

Driving Digital Change
Driving Digital ChangeDriving Digital Change
Driving Digital Change
Jeroen Spierings
Operational-Quality-Assurance-Guiler-2017.pptx
Operational-Quality-Assurance-Guiler-2017.pptxOperational-Quality-Assurance-Guiler-2017.pptx
Operational-Quality-Assurance-Guiler-2017.pptx
victoriakankutebe
Systemic Learning Analytics Symposium, October 10th 2013
Systemic Learning Analytics Symposium, October 10th 2013Systemic Learning Analytics Symposium, October 10th 2013
Systemic Learning Analytics Symposium, October 10th 2013
Adam Cooper
Career Development A Fifty Year Process
Career Development A Fifty Year ProcessCareer Development A Fifty Year Process
Career Development A Fifty Year Process
Mitchell Manning Sr.
Appreciative Inquiry
Appreciative InquiryAppreciative Inquiry
Appreciative Inquiry
John Gray
Portfolio Study NATCON 2008
Portfolio Study NATCON 2008Portfolio Study NATCON 2008
Portfolio Study NATCON 2008
The Centre for Education and Work
ISE Webinar - 'Squaring the circle'
ISE Webinar - 'Squaring the circle'ISE Webinar - 'Squaring the circle'
ISE Webinar - 'Squaring the circle'
Anima & Atman
Random Collection of Marketing 際際滷s, Lean, Action Research
Random Collection of Marketing 際際滷s, Lean, Action Research Random Collection of Marketing 際際滷s, Lean, Action Research
Random Collection of Marketing 際際滷s, Lean, Action Research
Business901
Deanz cbam
Deanz cbamDeanz cbam
Deanz cbam
Derek Wenmoth
Managing Operations Workshop
Managing Operations WorkshopManaging Operations Workshop
Managing Operations Workshop
Karen Vignare
My job as a growth company CEO
My job as a growth company CEOMy job as a growth company CEO
My job as a growth company CEO
TheFamily
Social Learning Snapshot Survey: The Performance Hub
Social Learning Snapshot Survey: The Performance HubSocial Learning Snapshot Survey: The Performance Hub
Social Learning Snapshot Survey: The Performance Hub
The Performance Hub
Making Critical Thinking Real with Creative Coding, Digital Games & Movie Cre...
Making Critical Thinking Real with Creative Coding, Digital Games & Movie Cre...Making Critical Thinking Real with Creative Coding, Digital Games & Movie Cre...
Making Critical Thinking Real with Creative Coding, Digital Games & Movie Cre...
Julie Evans
Addressing the Risks & Opportunities of Implementing an Outcomes Based Strategy
Addressing the Risks & Opportunities of Implementing an Outcomes Based Strategy Addressing the Risks & Opportunities of Implementing an Outcomes Based Strategy
Addressing the Risks & Opportunities of Implementing an Outcomes Based Strategy
Blackbaud Pacific
KNOWLEDGE-PULL EDUCATION: STRATEGIES TO PROMOTE STUDENT RETENTION IN E-LEARNI...
KNOWLEDGE-PULL EDUCATION: STRATEGIES TO PROMOTE STUDENT RETENTION IN E-LEARNI...KNOWLEDGE-PULL EDUCATION: STRATEGIES TO PROMOTE STUDENT RETENTION IN E-LEARNI...
KNOWLEDGE-PULL EDUCATION: STRATEGIES TO PROMOTE STUDENT RETENTION IN E-LEARNI...
Kathleen Deery
Using an ocp to accomplish business measures online
Using an ocp to accomplish business measures onlineUsing an ocp to accomplish business measures online
Using an ocp to accomplish business measures online
Eric Bruggeman ET
Growth Mindset_Staff Training_Building Day 1_2014_Presentation with Cuts
Growth Mindset_Staff Training_Building Day 1_2014_Presentation with CutsGrowth Mindset_Staff Training_Building Day 1_2014_Presentation with Cuts
Growth Mindset_Staff Training_Building Day 1_2014_Presentation with Cuts
Craig Curry
Cbam pld
Cbam pldCbam pld
Cbam pld
Derek Wenmoth
Teaching Excellence Series: The Educator Perspective
Teaching Excellence Series: The Educator PerspectiveTeaching Excellence Series: The Educator Perspective
Teaching Excellence Series: The Educator Perspective
Newcastle Educators
AHDS Conference workshop: TB Self evaluation
AHDS Conference workshop: TB Self evaluationAHDS Conference workshop: TB Self evaluation
AHDS Conference workshop: TB Self evaluation
AHDScotland
Operational-Quality-Assurance-Guiler-2017.pptx
Operational-Quality-Assurance-Guiler-2017.pptxOperational-Quality-Assurance-Guiler-2017.pptx
Operational-Quality-Assurance-Guiler-2017.pptx
victoriakankutebe
Systemic Learning Analytics Symposium, October 10th 2013
Systemic Learning Analytics Symposium, October 10th 2013Systemic Learning Analytics Symposium, October 10th 2013
Systemic Learning Analytics Symposium, October 10th 2013
Adam Cooper
Career Development A Fifty Year Process
Career Development A Fifty Year ProcessCareer Development A Fifty Year Process
Career Development A Fifty Year Process
Mitchell Manning Sr.
Appreciative Inquiry
Appreciative InquiryAppreciative Inquiry
Appreciative Inquiry
John Gray
ISE Webinar - 'Squaring the circle'
ISE Webinar - 'Squaring the circle'ISE Webinar - 'Squaring the circle'
ISE Webinar - 'Squaring the circle'
Anima & Atman
Random Collection of Marketing 際際滷s, Lean, Action Research
Random Collection of Marketing 際際滷s, Lean, Action Research Random Collection of Marketing 際際滷s, Lean, Action Research
Random Collection of Marketing 際際滷s, Lean, Action Research
Business901
Managing Operations Workshop
Managing Operations WorkshopManaging Operations Workshop
Managing Operations Workshop
Karen Vignare
My job as a growth company CEO
My job as a growth company CEOMy job as a growth company CEO
My job as a growth company CEO
TheFamily
Social Learning Snapshot Survey: The Performance Hub
Social Learning Snapshot Survey: The Performance HubSocial Learning Snapshot Survey: The Performance Hub
Social Learning Snapshot Survey: The Performance Hub
The Performance Hub
Making Critical Thinking Real with Creative Coding, Digital Games & Movie Cre...
Making Critical Thinking Real with Creative Coding, Digital Games & Movie Cre...Making Critical Thinking Real with Creative Coding, Digital Games & Movie Cre...
Making Critical Thinking Real with Creative Coding, Digital Games & Movie Cre...
Julie Evans
Addressing the Risks & Opportunities of Implementing an Outcomes Based Strategy
Addressing the Risks & Opportunities of Implementing an Outcomes Based Strategy Addressing the Risks & Opportunities of Implementing an Outcomes Based Strategy
Addressing the Risks & Opportunities of Implementing an Outcomes Based Strategy
Blackbaud Pacific
KNOWLEDGE-PULL EDUCATION: STRATEGIES TO PROMOTE STUDENT RETENTION IN E-LEARNI...
KNOWLEDGE-PULL EDUCATION: STRATEGIES TO PROMOTE STUDENT RETENTION IN E-LEARNI...KNOWLEDGE-PULL EDUCATION: STRATEGIES TO PROMOTE STUDENT RETENTION IN E-LEARNI...
KNOWLEDGE-PULL EDUCATION: STRATEGIES TO PROMOTE STUDENT RETENTION IN E-LEARNI...
Kathleen Deery
Using an ocp to accomplish business measures online
Using an ocp to accomplish business measures onlineUsing an ocp to accomplish business measures online
Using an ocp to accomplish business measures online
Eric Bruggeman ET
Growth Mindset_Staff Training_Building Day 1_2014_Presentation with Cuts
Growth Mindset_Staff Training_Building Day 1_2014_Presentation with CutsGrowth Mindset_Staff Training_Building Day 1_2014_Presentation with Cuts
Growth Mindset_Staff Training_Building Day 1_2014_Presentation with Cuts
Craig Curry
Teaching Excellence Series: The Educator Perspective
Teaching Excellence Series: The Educator PerspectiveTeaching Excellence Series: The Educator Perspective
Teaching Excellence Series: The Educator Perspective
Newcastle Educators
AHDS Conference workshop: TB Self evaluation
AHDS Conference workshop: TB Self evaluationAHDS Conference workshop: TB Self evaluation
AHDS Conference workshop: TB Self evaluation
AHDScotland

Recently uploaded (20)

The Broccoli Dog's inner voice (look A)
The Broccoli Dog's inner voice  (look A)The Broccoli Dog's inner voice  (look A)
The Broccoli Dog's inner voice (look A)
merasan
TLE 7 - 2nd Topic - Codes and Standards in Industrial Arts Services.pptx
TLE 7 - 2nd Topic - Codes and Standards in Industrial Arts Services.pptxTLE 7 - 2nd Topic - Codes and Standards in Industrial Arts Services.pptx
TLE 7 - 2nd Topic - Codes and Standards in Industrial Arts Services.pptx
RizaBedayo
Principle and Practices of Animal Breeding || Boby Basnet
Principle and Practices of Animal Breeding || Boby BasnetPrinciple and Practices of Animal Breeding || Boby Basnet
Principle and Practices of Animal Breeding || Boby Basnet
Boby Basnet
The Story Behind the Abney Park Restoration Project by Tom Walker
The Story Behind the Abney Park Restoration Project by Tom WalkerThe Story Behind the Abney Park Restoration Project by Tom Walker
The Story Behind the Abney Park Restoration Project by Tom Walker
History of Stoke Newington
QuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online How to Make the Move
QuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online  How to Make the MoveQuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online  How to Make the Move
QuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online How to Make the Move
TechSoup
EDL 290F Week 3 - Mountaintop Views (2025).pdf
EDL 290F Week 3  - Mountaintop Views (2025).pdfEDL 290F Week 3  - Mountaintop Views (2025).pdf
EDL 290F Week 3 - Mountaintop Views (2025).pdf
Liz Walsh-Trevino
TLE 7 - 3rd Topic - Hand Tools, Power Tools, Instruments, and Equipment Used ...
TLE 7 - 3rd Topic - Hand Tools, Power Tools, Instruments, and Equipment Used ...TLE 7 - 3rd Topic - Hand Tools, Power Tools, Instruments, and Equipment Used ...
TLE 7 - 3rd Topic - Hand Tools, Power Tools, Instruments, and Equipment Used ...
RizaBedayo
APM People Interest Network Conference - Tim Lyons - The neurological levels ...
APM People Interest Network Conference - Tim Lyons - The neurological levels ...APM People Interest Network Conference - Tim Lyons - The neurological levels ...
APM People Interest Network Conference - Tim Lyons - The neurological levels ...
Association for Project Management
Blind Spots in AI and Formulation Science Knowledge Pyramid (Updated Perspect...
Blind Spots in AI and Formulation Science Knowledge Pyramid (Updated Perspect...Blind Spots in AI and Formulation Science Knowledge Pyramid (Updated Perspect...
Blind Spots in AI and Formulation Science Knowledge Pyramid (Updated Perspect...
Ajaz Hussain
Eng7-Q4-Lesson 1 Part 1 Understanding Discipline-Specific Words, Voice, and T...
Eng7-Q4-Lesson 1 Part 1 Understanding Discipline-Specific Words, Voice, and T...Eng7-Q4-Lesson 1 Part 1 Understanding Discipline-Specific Words, Voice, and T...
Eng7-Q4-Lesson 1 Part 1 Understanding Discipline-Specific Words, Voice, and T...
sandynavergas1
Useful environment methods in Odoo 18 - Odoo 際際滷s
Useful environment methods in Odoo 18 - Odoo 際際滷sUseful environment methods in Odoo 18 - Odoo 際際滷s
Useful environment methods in Odoo 18 - Odoo 際際滷s
Celine George
Computer Application in Business (commerce)
Computer Application in Business (commerce)Computer Application in Business (commerce)
Computer Application in Business (commerce)
Sudar Sudar
TPR Data strategy 2025 (1).pdf Data strategy
TPR Data strategy 2025 (1).pdf Data strategyTPR Data strategy 2025 (1).pdf Data strategy
TPR Data strategy 2025 (1).pdf Data strategy
Henry Tapper
South Hornsey: The Lost Local Authority that Merged with Stoke Newington by T...
South Hornsey: The Lost Local Authority that Merged with Stoke Newington by T...South Hornsey: The Lost Local Authority that Merged with Stoke Newington by T...
South Hornsey: The Lost Local Authority that Merged with Stoke Newington by T...
History of Stoke Newington
How to Configure Flexible Working Schedule in Odoo 18 Employee
How to Configure Flexible Working Schedule in Odoo 18 EmployeeHow to Configure Flexible Working Schedule in Odoo 18 Employee
How to Configure Flexible Working Schedule in Odoo 18 Employee
Celine George
How to Manage Putaway Rule in Odoo 17 Inventory
How to Manage Putaway Rule in Odoo 17 InventoryHow to Manage Putaway Rule in Odoo 17 Inventory
How to Manage Putaway Rule in Odoo 17 Inventory
Celine George
Database population in Odoo 18 - Odoo slides
Database population in Odoo 18 - Odoo slidesDatabase population in Odoo 18 - Odoo slides
Database population in Odoo 18 - Odoo slides
Celine George
Research & Research Methods: Basic Concepts and Types.pptx
Research & Research Methods: Basic Concepts and Types.pptxResearch & Research Methods: Basic Concepts and Types.pptx
Research & Research Methods: Basic Concepts and Types.pptx
Dr. Sarita Anand
PUBH1000 Module 3: Public Health Systems
PUBH1000 Module 3: Public Health SystemsPUBH1000 Module 3: Public Health Systems
PUBH1000 Module 3: Public Health Systems
Jonathan Hallett
DUBLIN PROGRAM DUBLIN PROGRAM DUBLIN PROGRAM
DUBLIN PROGRAM DUBLIN PROGRAM DUBLIN PROGRAMDUBLIN PROGRAM DUBLIN PROGRAM DUBLIN PROGRAM
DUBLIN PROGRAM DUBLIN PROGRAM DUBLIN PROGRAM
vlckovar
The Broccoli Dog's inner voice (look A)
The Broccoli Dog's inner voice  (look A)The Broccoli Dog's inner voice  (look A)
The Broccoli Dog's inner voice (look A)
merasan
TLE 7 - 2nd Topic - Codes and Standards in Industrial Arts Services.pptx
TLE 7 - 2nd Topic - Codes and Standards in Industrial Arts Services.pptxTLE 7 - 2nd Topic - Codes and Standards in Industrial Arts Services.pptx
TLE 7 - 2nd Topic - Codes and Standards in Industrial Arts Services.pptx
RizaBedayo
Principle and Practices of Animal Breeding || Boby Basnet
Principle and Practices of Animal Breeding || Boby BasnetPrinciple and Practices of Animal Breeding || Boby Basnet
Principle and Practices of Animal Breeding || Boby Basnet
Boby Basnet
The Story Behind the Abney Park Restoration Project by Tom Walker
The Story Behind the Abney Park Restoration Project by Tom WalkerThe Story Behind the Abney Park Restoration Project by Tom Walker
The Story Behind the Abney Park Restoration Project by Tom Walker
History of Stoke Newington
QuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online How to Make the Move
QuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online  How to Make the MoveQuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online  How to Make the Move
QuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online How to Make the Move
TechSoup
EDL 290F Week 3 - Mountaintop Views (2025).pdf
EDL 290F Week 3  - Mountaintop Views (2025).pdfEDL 290F Week 3  - Mountaintop Views (2025).pdf
EDL 290F Week 3 - Mountaintop Views (2025).pdf
Liz Walsh-Trevino
TLE 7 - 3rd Topic - Hand Tools, Power Tools, Instruments, and Equipment Used ...
TLE 7 - 3rd Topic - Hand Tools, Power Tools, Instruments, and Equipment Used ...TLE 7 - 3rd Topic - Hand Tools, Power Tools, Instruments, and Equipment Used ...
TLE 7 - 3rd Topic - Hand Tools, Power Tools, Instruments, and Equipment Used ...
RizaBedayo
APM People Interest Network Conference - Tim Lyons - The neurological levels ...
APM People Interest Network Conference - Tim Lyons - The neurological levels ...APM People Interest Network Conference - Tim Lyons - The neurological levels ...
APM People Interest Network Conference - Tim Lyons - The neurological levels ...
Association for Project Management
Blind Spots in AI and Formulation Science Knowledge Pyramid (Updated Perspect...
Blind Spots in AI and Formulation Science Knowledge Pyramid (Updated Perspect...Blind Spots in AI and Formulation Science Knowledge Pyramid (Updated Perspect...
Blind Spots in AI and Formulation Science Knowledge Pyramid (Updated Perspect...
Ajaz Hussain
Eng7-Q4-Lesson 1 Part 1 Understanding Discipline-Specific Words, Voice, and T...
Eng7-Q4-Lesson 1 Part 1 Understanding Discipline-Specific Words, Voice, and T...Eng7-Q4-Lesson 1 Part 1 Understanding Discipline-Specific Words, Voice, and T...
Eng7-Q4-Lesson 1 Part 1 Understanding Discipline-Specific Words, Voice, and T...
sandynavergas1
Useful environment methods in Odoo 18 - Odoo 際際滷s
Useful environment methods in Odoo 18 - Odoo 際際滷sUseful environment methods in Odoo 18 - Odoo 際際滷s
Useful environment methods in Odoo 18 - Odoo 際際滷s
Celine George
Computer Application in Business (commerce)
Computer Application in Business (commerce)Computer Application in Business (commerce)
Computer Application in Business (commerce)
Sudar Sudar
TPR Data strategy 2025 (1).pdf Data strategy
TPR Data strategy 2025 (1).pdf Data strategyTPR Data strategy 2025 (1).pdf Data strategy
TPR Data strategy 2025 (1).pdf Data strategy
Henry Tapper
South Hornsey: The Lost Local Authority that Merged with Stoke Newington by T...
South Hornsey: The Lost Local Authority that Merged with Stoke Newington by T...South Hornsey: The Lost Local Authority that Merged with Stoke Newington by T...
South Hornsey: The Lost Local Authority that Merged with Stoke Newington by T...
History of Stoke Newington
How to Configure Flexible Working Schedule in Odoo 18 Employee
How to Configure Flexible Working Schedule in Odoo 18 EmployeeHow to Configure Flexible Working Schedule in Odoo 18 Employee
How to Configure Flexible Working Schedule in Odoo 18 Employee
Celine George
How to Manage Putaway Rule in Odoo 17 Inventory
How to Manage Putaway Rule in Odoo 17 InventoryHow to Manage Putaway Rule in Odoo 17 Inventory
How to Manage Putaway Rule in Odoo 17 Inventory
Celine George
Database population in Odoo 18 - Odoo slides
Database population in Odoo 18 - Odoo slidesDatabase population in Odoo 18 - Odoo slides
Database population in Odoo 18 - Odoo slides
Celine George
Research & Research Methods: Basic Concepts and Types.pptx
Research & Research Methods: Basic Concepts and Types.pptxResearch & Research Methods: Basic Concepts and Types.pptx
Research & Research Methods: Basic Concepts and Types.pptx
Dr. Sarita Anand
PUBH1000 Module 3: Public Health Systems
PUBH1000 Module 3: Public Health SystemsPUBH1000 Module 3: Public Health Systems
PUBH1000 Module 3: Public Health Systems
Jonathan Hallett
DUBLIN PROGRAM DUBLIN PROGRAM DUBLIN PROGRAM
DUBLIN PROGRAM DUBLIN PROGRAM DUBLIN PROGRAMDUBLIN PROGRAM DUBLIN PROGRAM DUBLIN PROGRAM
DUBLIN PROGRAM DUBLIN PROGRAM DUBLIN PROGRAM
vlckovar

To the man with a hammer, EVERYTHING looks like a nail

  • 1. To the Man with a Hammer Everything Looks like a Nail A Discussion on Education, Technology, Tool- selection, Decision-making and the value of knowledge. AAMC / WGEA Western Regional Conference, May 2013
  • 2. ASSUMPTIONS As educators, our product is knowledge. Technology facilitates good ideas; it is not a solution. To think exclusively of the bottom line is antithetical to evidence-based practice. Medical education is an evidence-based practice.
  • 3. Curriculum Management aids these points by providing an evidence-based method of mapping knowledge trajectory and acquisition. As educators, our product is knowledge. Technology facilitates good ideas; it is not a solution. To think exclusively of the bottom line is antithetical to evidence-based practice. Medical education is an evidence-based practice. Technology facilitates good ideas; it is not a solution. To think exclusively of the bottom line is antithetical to evidence-based practice.
  • 4. These assumptions provide tension with the financial realities most institutions (and the people who run them) currently face; disruptive innovation on these fronts is an enormous challenge. As educators, our product is knowledge. Technology facilitates good ideas; it is not a solution. To think exclusively of the bottom line is antithetical to evidence-based practice. Medical education is an evidence-based practice. As educators, our product is knowledge. Medical education is an evidence-based practice. As educators, our product is knowledge.
  • 5. QUESTIONS WE SHOULD ASK What do we choose, and why? How do we test the outcomes of our choices? Are failures acknowledged? Are successes acknowledged? What are the metrics we use? What are we really choosing when we adopt a tool to further education? Tech choices are usually driven by a variety of factors, including cost, peer pressure (everyone else is doing it), and the hope for innovative enhancement. What are the ways your institutions test for the value and viability of the choices made? Is there a standard? Accountability? This is really, really important.This is even more important. We learn from failure; a lack of acknowledgment means we are unable to move to a better method or practice. What do we choose, and why? How do we test the outcomes of our choices? What are the metrics we use? Having a previously accepted set of metrics provides a level of quality assurance necessary to understand the outcomes of our choices. Are successes acknowledged? What are we really choosing when we adopt a tool to further education? QUESTIONS WE SHOULD ASK
  • 6. A key issue in all selection processes
  • 7. Why do we make the choices we make? Financial concerns Workload concerns Standardization Internal pressures (Past practice, executive interest) External pressures (accreditation)
  • 8. If we are a business, what is our product? If so, then who is our customer? Do we sell graduates? Our product is knowledge and ability. Our customer is our graduate.Graduates!
  • 9. How do we evaluate our tools? How do we measure success? SUCCESS = TRUESUCCESS TRUE If successful, how do we leverage that? If not successful, how do we act on that?
  • 10. Not All Teaching Is Equal Education is transformative. Data accumulation is not. Qualitative Flipped Classroom a new expression of an old model Quantitative Experiential Didactic Mentored How do we approach the matching of tool to method? Education is transformative. Data accumulation is not. How do we identify the most effective approaches? Education is transformative. Data accumulation is not. How do we make the most of innovative models? Education is transformative. Data accumulation is not. E-Textbooks a great addition, a questionable replacement LMS last weeks gleam in the eye of CFOs, todays model challenge MOOCs -- the current bright shiny object Not All Teaching Is Equal Education is transformative. Data accumulation is not.
  • 12. The Questionnaire 1. Describe the technology you are using with your students. What do you think of this technology? 2. Describe the selection/adoption process for the technology you are using with your students. 3. How do you measure educational success?
  • 13. Thank You! Sascha Benjamin Cohen Director of Strategic Development for Ilios UCSF School of Medicine sascha.cohen@ucsf.edu http://www.iliiosproject.org https://ilios-demo.ucsf.edu

Editor's Notes

  • #7: One of the primary reasons why cost efficiency is a bad evaluation metric for selection purposes in tech adoption.