際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
The EIFFEL Think Tank  Agreeing on Disagreements Dirk Trossen, University of Cambridge EIFFEL Think Tank FIA Ghent
Some Background Think Tank established as a forum of international experts in the area of Internet research Among others: David Clark, Lixia Zhang, Karen Sollins, Joerg Ott, Bob Briscoe, Rui Aguiar, Jon Crowcroft,  Invitation-only based on recommendations and understanding that contribution to topics can be done Initiated in 2008 as an outcome of the EIFFEL expert group of the EC EIFFEL whitepaper in Dec 2006 Funded through EU (the EIFFEL project) until Sep 2010 Partners included Cambridge, UCL, RWTH, AUEB, ALB, IJS, Eurescom   息 EIFFEL Think Tank 2010 17/12/10
Objectives Establish international community Organize meetings for this community Capture their debates in certain forms Usually in form of whitepapers Disseminate the outcomes Internationally, not only EU Hidden objective:   Is such think tank sustainable without funding  or  Is the idea acceptable and  will people invest their own time and money?   息 EIFFEL Think Tank 2010 17/12/10
How Does EIFFEL Make Progress?
 By Agreeing on Disagreements Can we formulate our challenges and disagreements? Can we argue for the different viewpoints? Can we prioritize the disagreements? Can we eliminate disagreements?    start from the research community but aim to eventually involve the wider community   息 EIFFEL Think Tank 2010 17/12/10
Current Operational Model    息 EIFFEL Think Tank 2010 17/12/10 EIFFEL TT  Meeting #N FIPedia.org EIFFEL TT  Meeting #N+1 EIFFEL TT  Meeting #N+2 Dropped due to, e.g., insufficient debate, lack of identifying a disagreement Concise outputs in form of publications, whitepapers,  Community (TT and beyond)
Today Values in Architectures Shall Architectures Accommodate Varying Value Sets or Shall They Incorporate a Particular One? Leslie Dagle (ISOC) and Ian Brown (OII) Privacy Gone or Worthwhile Protecting? Karen Sollins (MIT CSAIL) and Rui Aguiar (Univ. of Aveiro)   息 EIFFEL Think Tank 2010 17/12/10
More Information EIFFEL website http://www.eiffel-thinktank.eu EIFFEL whitepaper http://www.fp7-eiffel.eu/fileadmin/docs/Report_TT2008.pdf Fipedia.org http://fipedia.org/fipedia Any questions? Email  [email_address]     息 EIFFEL Think Tank 2010 30/04/10

More Related Content

What's hot (11)

M&L 2012 - MAGICAL - Learning through collaborative game making - by Jeffrey ...
M&L 2012 - MAGICAL - Learning through collaborative game making - by Jeffrey ...M&L 2012 - MAGICAL - Learning through collaborative game making - by Jeffrey ...
M&L 2012 - MAGICAL - Learning through collaborative game making - by Jeffrey ...
Media & Learning Conference
111114 uk accentuate
111114 uk accentuate111114 uk accentuate
111114 uk accentuate
Frank Emil Moen
Open up and share: finding and re-using information literacy (IL) learning ma...
Open up and share: finding and re-using information literacy (IL) learning ma...Open up and share: finding and re-using information literacy (IL) learning ma...
Open up and share: finding and re-using information literacy (IL) learning ma...
IL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)
Unit 101: Principles of building construction, information and communication
Unit 101: Principles of building construction, information and communicationUnit 101: Principles of building construction, information and communication
Unit 101: Principles of building construction, information and communication
DjCurrie
The maker movement, social innovation and the DOIT programme: Pilot experienc...
The maker movement, social innovation and the DOIT programme: Pilot experienc...The maker movement, social innovation and the DOIT programme: Pilot experienc...
The maker movement, social innovation and the DOIT programme: Pilot experienc...
DOIT Entrepreneurial skills for young social innovators in an open digital world
2020 Floss Roadmap Version 2009 Owf
2020 Floss Roadmap Version 2009 Owf2020 Floss Roadmap Version 2009 Owf
2020 Floss Roadmap Version 2009 Owf
CompatibleOne
Delftx voor OWD13
Delftx voor OWD13Delftx voor OWD13
Delftx voor OWD13
Willem van Valkenburg
Week 11 social roadmap
Week 11   social roadmapWeek 11   social roadmap
Week 11 social roadmap
IngeVervoort1
Some cases of open source products that have great impact in recent years
Some cases of open source products that have great impact in recent yearsSome cases of open source products that have great impact in recent years
Some cases of open source products that have great impact in recent years
Wan Leung Wong
Unit 101 Level 1 Principles of building construction, information and communi...
Unit 101 Level 1 Principles of building construction, information and communi...Unit 101 Level 1 Principles of building construction, information and communi...
Unit 101 Level 1 Principles of building construction, information and communi...
gsr101
Icore nov2018
Icore nov2018Icore nov2018
Icore nov2018
Alastair Creelman
M&L 2012 - MAGICAL - Learning through collaborative game making - by Jeffrey ...
M&L 2012 - MAGICAL - Learning through collaborative game making - by Jeffrey ...M&L 2012 - MAGICAL - Learning through collaborative game making - by Jeffrey ...
M&L 2012 - MAGICAL - Learning through collaborative game making - by Jeffrey ...
Media & Learning Conference
Open up and share: finding and re-using information literacy (IL) learning ma...
Open up and share: finding and re-using information literacy (IL) learning ma...Open up and share: finding and re-using information literacy (IL) learning ma...
Open up and share: finding and re-using information literacy (IL) learning ma...
IL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)
Unit 101: Principles of building construction, information and communication
Unit 101: Principles of building construction, information and communicationUnit 101: Principles of building construction, information and communication
Unit 101: Principles of building construction, information and communication
DjCurrie
2020 Floss Roadmap Version 2009 Owf
2020 Floss Roadmap Version 2009 Owf2020 Floss Roadmap Version 2009 Owf
2020 Floss Roadmap Version 2009 Owf
CompatibleOne
Week 11 social roadmap
Week 11   social roadmapWeek 11   social roadmap
Week 11 social roadmap
IngeVervoort1
Some cases of open source products that have great impact in recent years
Some cases of open source products that have great impact in recent yearsSome cases of open source products that have great impact in recent years
Some cases of open source products that have great impact in recent years
Wan Leung Wong
Unit 101 Level 1 Principles of building construction, information and communi...
Unit 101 Level 1 Principles of building construction, information and communi...Unit 101 Level 1 Principles of building construction, information and communi...
Unit 101 Level 1 Principles of building construction, information and communi...
gsr101

Viewers also liked (6)

F.S. Nucci - Search as an architectural component: searching for a new paradigm
F.S. Nucci - Search as an architectural component: searching for a new paradigmF.S. Nucci - Search as an architectural component: searching for a new paradigm
F.S. Nucci - Search as an architectural component: searching for a new paradigm
FIA2010
Leslie Daigle (ISOC) - Internet Architecture and Values
Leslie Daigle (ISOC) -  Internet Architecture and ValuesLeslie Daigle (ISOC) -  Internet Architecture and Values
Leslie Daigle (ISOC) - Internet Architecture and Values
FIA2010
Future Internet Week Budapest
Future Internet Week  BudapestFuture Internet Week  Budapest
Future Internet Week Budapest
FIA2010
Gyula Sallai: Presentation of the next FIA in Budapest
Gyula Sallai: Presentation of the next FIA in Budapest Gyula Sallai: Presentation of the next FIA in Budapest
Gyula Sallai: Presentation of the next FIA in Budapest
FIA2010
Ariane-5 shuttle Case study fault tollerance
Ariane-5 shuttle Case study fault tolleranceAriane-5 shuttle Case study fault tollerance
Ariane-5 shuttle Case study fault tollerance
Dharshana Kasun Warusavitharana
Ian Brown (Oxford Internet Institute): Constitutions and tussles in cyberspace
Ian Brown (Oxford Internet Institute): Constitutions and tussles in cyberspaceIan Brown (Oxford Internet Institute): Constitutions and tussles in cyberspace
Ian Brown (Oxford Internet Institute): Constitutions and tussles in cyberspace
FIA2010
F.S. Nucci - Search as an architectural component: searching for a new paradigm
F.S. Nucci - Search as an architectural component: searching for a new paradigmF.S. Nucci - Search as an architectural component: searching for a new paradigm
F.S. Nucci - Search as an architectural component: searching for a new paradigm
FIA2010
Leslie Daigle (ISOC) - Internet Architecture and Values
Leslie Daigle (ISOC) -  Internet Architecture and ValuesLeslie Daigle (ISOC) -  Internet Architecture and Values
Leslie Daigle (ISOC) - Internet Architecture and Values
FIA2010
Future Internet Week Budapest
Future Internet Week  BudapestFuture Internet Week  Budapest
Future Internet Week Budapest
FIA2010
Gyula Sallai: Presentation of the next FIA in Budapest
Gyula Sallai: Presentation of the next FIA in Budapest Gyula Sallai: Presentation of the next FIA in Budapest
Gyula Sallai: Presentation of the next FIA in Budapest
FIA2010
Ian Brown (Oxford Internet Institute): Constitutions and tussles in cyberspace
Ian Brown (Oxford Internet Institute): Constitutions and tussles in cyberspaceIan Brown (Oxford Internet Institute): Constitutions and tussles in cyberspace
Ian Brown (Oxford Internet Institute): Constitutions and tussles in cyberspace
FIA2010

Similar to Dirk Trossen (University of Cambridge): The EIFFEL Think Tank - Agreeing on disagreements (20)

TEDxAalto presents: TEDxLive TED2012
TEDxAalto presents: TEDxLive TED2012TEDxAalto presents: TEDxLive TED2012
TEDxAalto presents: TEDxLive TED2012
San Francisco Oy
Open Science at the European Commission
Open Science at the European CommissionOpen Science at the European Commission
Open Science at the European Commission
Carl-Christian Buhr
"ODF in The Netherlands, What's Next ..."
"ODF in The Netherlands, What's Next ...""ODF in The Netherlands, What's Next ..."
"ODF in The Netherlands, What's Next ..."
Fabrice Mous
Open science at Opencamp
Open science at OpencampOpen science at Opencamp
Open science at Opencamp
Open Knowledge Maps
IFLA ARL Satellite conference 2023: What needs to be done to ensure the maxim...
IFLA ARL Satellite conference 2023: What needs to be done to ensure the maxim...IFLA ARL Satellite conference 2023: What needs to be done to ensure the maxim...
IFLA ARL Satellite conference 2023: What needs to be done to ensure the maxim...
IFLAAcademicandResea
IFLA ARL Satellite conference 2023: Realising equity, inclusion and diversity...
IFLA ARL Satellite conference 2023: Realising equity, inclusion and diversity...IFLA ARL Satellite conference 2023: Realising equity, inclusion and diversity...
IFLA ARL Satellite conference 2023: Realising equity, inclusion and diversity...
IFLAAcademicandResea
Innovando la innovaci坦n en Europa: el modelo del EIT y sus Kics
Innovando la innovaci坦n en Europa: el modelo del EIT y sus KicsInnovando la innovaci坦n en Europa: el modelo del EIT y sus Kics
Innovando la innovaci坦n en Europa: el modelo del EIT y sus Kics
AMETIC
2 2-manufacture and industry task force jesper thestrup
2 2-manufacture and industry task force jesper thestrup2 2-manufacture and industry task force jesper thestrup
2 2-manufacture and industry task force jesper thestrup
Digital Business Innovation Community
Ed Share Jisc Jan2010
Ed Share Jisc Jan2010Ed Share Jisc Jan2010
Ed Share Jisc Jan2010
JISC SSBR
20140708 EurActory Preview
20140708 EurActory Preview20140708 EurActory Preview
20140708 EurActory Preview
euractiv
EurActory Preview, Innovative Tools July 2014
EurActory Preview, Innovative Tools July 2014EurActory Preview, Innovative Tools July 2014
EurActory Preview, Innovative Tools July 2014
euractiv
May 2012
May 2012May 2012
May 2012
linioti
JMLeceta Tertulia Fulbright: Discover Innovate, get Funding and Be Global 2013
JMLeceta Tertulia Fulbright:  Discover Innovate, get Funding and Be Global 2013JMLeceta Tertulia Fulbright:  Discover Innovate, get Funding and Be Global 2013
JMLeceta Tertulia Fulbright: Discover Innovate, get Funding and Be Global 2013
Spanish Fulbright Alumni Association
6 1-technology watch and fet task force
6 1-technology watch and fet task force6 1-technology watch and fet task force
6 1-technology watch and fet task force
Digital Business Innovation Community
Bruno Cornette: Improving the Transfer Process - The FITT Mission
Bruno Cornette: Improving the Transfer Process - The FITT MissionBruno Cornette: Improving the Transfer Process - The FITT Mission
Bruno Cornette: Improving the Transfer Process - The FITT Mission
FITT
Plenary1 01 roland_stauss
Plenary1 01 roland_staussPlenary1 01 roland_stauss
Plenary1 01 roland_stauss
kkangbi
FInES Cluster Meeting-Preparing for FP8_cma
FInES Cluster Meeting-Preparing for FP8_cmaFInES Cluster Meeting-Preparing for FP8_cma
FInES Cluster Meeting-Preparing for FP8_cma
ECFInES
FInES Cluster Meeting-Preparing for FP8_CMA
FInES Cluster Meeting-Preparing for FP8_CMAFInES Cluster Meeting-Preparing for FP8_CMA
FInES Cluster Meeting-Preparing for FP8_CMA
Digital Business Innovation Community
Enol lthematic diveristy_cases_final_ict2010
Enol lthematic diveristy_cases_final_ict2010Enol lthematic diveristy_cases_final_ict2010
Enol lthematic diveristy_cases_final_ict2010
Tuija Hirvikoski
Educating Young Social Innovators in Makerspace Settings
Educating Young Social Innovators in Makerspace SettingsEducating Young Social Innovators in Makerspace Settings
Educating Young Social Innovators in Makerspace Settings
DOIT Entrepreneurial skills for young social innovators in an open digital world
TEDxAalto presents: TEDxLive TED2012
TEDxAalto presents: TEDxLive TED2012TEDxAalto presents: TEDxLive TED2012
TEDxAalto presents: TEDxLive TED2012
San Francisco Oy
Open Science at the European Commission
Open Science at the European CommissionOpen Science at the European Commission
Open Science at the European Commission
Carl-Christian Buhr
"ODF in The Netherlands, What's Next ..."
"ODF in The Netherlands, What's Next ...""ODF in The Netherlands, What's Next ..."
"ODF in The Netherlands, What's Next ..."
Fabrice Mous
IFLA ARL Satellite conference 2023: What needs to be done to ensure the maxim...
IFLA ARL Satellite conference 2023: What needs to be done to ensure the maxim...IFLA ARL Satellite conference 2023: What needs to be done to ensure the maxim...
IFLA ARL Satellite conference 2023: What needs to be done to ensure the maxim...
IFLAAcademicandResea
IFLA ARL Satellite conference 2023: Realising equity, inclusion and diversity...
IFLA ARL Satellite conference 2023: Realising equity, inclusion and diversity...IFLA ARL Satellite conference 2023: Realising equity, inclusion and diversity...
IFLA ARL Satellite conference 2023: Realising equity, inclusion and diversity...
IFLAAcademicandResea
Innovando la innovaci坦n en Europa: el modelo del EIT y sus Kics
Innovando la innovaci坦n en Europa: el modelo del EIT y sus KicsInnovando la innovaci坦n en Europa: el modelo del EIT y sus Kics
Innovando la innovaci坦n en Europa: el modelo del EIT y sus Kics
AMETIC
Ed Share Jisc Jan2010
Ed Share Jisc Jan2010Ed Share Jisc Jan2010
Ed Share Jisc Jan2010
JISC SSBR
20140708 EurActory Preview
20140708 EurActory Preview20140708 EurActory Preview
20140708 EurActory Preview
euractiv
EurActory Preview, Innovative Tools July 2014
EurActory Preview, Innovative Tools July 2014EurActory Preview, Innovative Tools July 2014
EurActory Preview, Innovative Tools July 2014
euractiv
May 2012
May 2012May 2012
May 2012
linioti
JMLeceta Tertulia Fulbright: Discover Innovate, get Funding and Be Global 2013
JMLeceta Tertulia Fulbright:  Discover Innovate, get Funding and Be Global 2013JMLeceta Tertulia Fulbright:  Discover Innovate, get Funding and Be Global 2013
JMLeceta Tertulia Fulbright: Discover Innovate, get Funding and Be Global 2013
Spanish Fulbright Alumni Association
Bruno Cornette: Improving the Transfer Process - The FITT Mission
Bruno Cornette: Improving the Transfer Process - The FITT MissionBruno Cornette: Improving the Transfer Process - The FITT Mission
Bruno Cornette: Improving the Transfer Process - The FITT Mission
FITT
Plenary1 01 roland_stauss
Plenary1 01 roland_staussPlenary1 01 roland_stauss
Plenary1 01 roland_stauss
kkangbi
FInES Cluster Meeting-Preparing for FP8_cma
FInES Cluster Meeting-Preparing for FP8_cmaFInES Cluster Meeting-Preparing for FP8_cma
FInES Cluster Meeting-Preparing for FP8_cma
ECFInES
Enol lthematic diveristy_cases_final_ict2010
Enol lthematic diveristy_cases_final_ict2010Enol lthematic diveristy_cases_final_ict2010
Enol lthematic diveristy_cases_final_ict2010
Tuija Hirvikoski

More from FIA2010 (20)

Karen Sollins (MIT, US): Privacy: Can we afford not to?
Karen Sollins (MIT, US): Privacy: Can we afford not to? Karen Sollins (MIT, US): Privacy: Can we afford not to?
Karen Sollins (MIT, US): Privacy: Can we afford not to?
FIA2010
Josef Weber (Siemens): Scenarios for Future Internet Business@Energy
Josef Weber (Siemens): Scenarios for Future Internet Business@EnergyJosef Weber (Siemens): Scenarios for Future Internet Business@Energy
Josef Weber (Siemens): Scenarios for Future Internet Business@Energy
FIA2010
Keith Popplewell, Jenny Harding: Realising the Digital Opportunity: Redesigni...
Keith Popplewell, Jenny Harding: Realising the Digital Opportunity: Redesigni...Keith Popplewell, Jenny Harding: Realising the Digital Opportunity: Redesigni...
Keith Popplewell, Jenny Harding: Realising the Digital Opportunity: Redesigni...
FIA2010
Josema Cavanillas: An industry view on Future Internet Businesses
Josema Cavanillas: An industry view on Future Internet BusinessesJosema Cavanillas: An industry view on Future Internet Businesses
Josema Cavanillas: An industry view on Future Internet Businesses
FIA2010
Ingrid Moerman, Stefan Bouckaert: IP CREW - Cognitive Radio Experimentation ...
Ingrid Moerman, Stefan Bouckaert:  IP CREW - Cognitive Radio Experimentation ...Ingrid Moerman, Stefan Bouckaert:  IP CREW - Cognitive Radio Experimentation ...
Ingrid Moerman, Stefan Bouckaert: IP CREW - Cognitive Radio Experimentation ...
FIA2010
Smart Santander
Smart Santander Smart Santander
Smart Santander
FIA2010
Ofelia open calls
Ofelia open callsOfelia open calls
Ofelia open calls
FIA2010
Julie Marguerite - Tefis open calls (fia dec 2010)
Julie Marguerite - Tefis open calls  (fia dec 2010)Julie Marguerite - Tefis open calls  (fia dec 2010)
Julie Marguerite - Tefis open calls (fia dec 2010)
FIA2010
Florian Schreiner: Plans for open calls and offering by BonFIRE
Florian Schreiner: Plans for open calls and offering by BonFIREFlorian Schreiner: Plans for open calls and offering by BonFIRE
Florian Schreiner: Plans for open calls and offering by BonFIRE
FIA2010
Jacques Magen - Future Internet Research and Experimentation (FIRE): Successf...
Jacques Magen - Future Internet Research and Experimentation (FIRE): Successf...Jacques Magen - Future Internet Research and Experimentation (FIRE): Successf...
Jacques Magen - Future Internet Research and Experimentation (FIRE): Successf...
FIA2010
Obj 1.6 FIRE: Paradiso2 Roger Torrenti
Obj 1.6 FIRE: Paradiso2 Roger Torrenti Obj 1.6 FIRE: Paradiso2 Roger Torrenti
Obj 1.6 FIRE: Paradiso2 Roger Torrenti
FIA2010
Mikhail Simonov - The enabling role of the information broker: an example
Mikhail Simonov - The enabling role of the information broker: an example Mikhail Simonov - The enabling role of the information broker: an example
Mikhail Simonov - The enabling role of the information broker: an example
FIA2010
J. Cave - Information as an economic good in the future internet
J. Cave - Information as an economic good in the future internetJ. Cave - Information as an economic good in the future internet
J. Cave - Information as an economic good in the future internet
FIA2010
Latif Ladid - Ipv6, The two-way internet. The next big thing
Latif Ladid - Ipv6, The two-way internet. The next big thingLatif Ladid - Ipv6, The two-way internet. The next big thing
Latif Ladid - Ipv6, The two-way internet. The next big thing
FIA2010
Ranganai Chaparadza: Can Autonomicity help Migration, and what could be a pos...
Ranganai Chaparadza: Can Autonomicity help Migration, and what could be a pos...Ranganai Chaparadza: Can Autonomicity help Migration, and what could be a pos...
Ranganai Chaparadza: Can Autonomicity help Migration, and what could be a pos...
FIA2010
Ultan mulligan - Future Network Standardisation at ETSI
Ultan mulligan - Future Network Standardisation at ETSIUltan mulligan - Future Network Standardisation at ETSI
Ultan mulligan - Future Network Standardisation at ETSI
FIA2010
Walter Colitti (Vrije Universiteit Brussel): Our vision
Walter Colitti (Vrije Universiteit Brussel): Our visionWalter Colitti (Vrije Universiteit Brussel): Our vision
Walter Colitti (Vrije Universiteit Brussel): Our vision
FIA2010
Isidro Laso Ballesteros (DG Information Society and Media) Internet Architect...
Isidro Laso Ballesteros (DG Information Society and Media) Internet Architect...Isidro Laso Ballesteros (DG Information Society and Media) Internet Architect...
Isidro Laso Ballesteros (DG Information Society and Media) Internet Architect...
FIA2010
Theodore Zahariadis (Synelixis Solutions): Fundamental Limitation of Current ...
Theodore Zahariadis (Synelixis Solutions): Fundamental Limitation of Current ...Theodore Zahariadis (Synelixis Solutions): Fundamental Limitation of Current ...
Theodore Zahariadis (Synelixis Solutions): Fundamental Limitation of Current ...
FIA2010
Dimitri Papadimitriou (Alcatel-Lucent Bell) - Future Internet Architecture (F...
Dimitri Papadimitriou (Alcatel-Lucent Bell) - Future Internet Architecture (F...Dimitri Papadimitriou (Alcatel-Lucent Bell) - Future Internet Architecture (F...
Dimitri Papadimitriou (Alcatel-Lucent Bell) - Future Internet Architecture (F...
FIA2010
Karen Sollins (MIT, US): Privacy: Can we afford not to?
Karen Sollins (MIT, US): Privacy: Can we afford not to? Karen Sollins (MIT, US): Privacy: Can we afford not to?
Karen Sollins (MIT, US): Privacy: Can we afford not to?
FIA2010
Josef Weber (Siemens): Scenarios for Future Internet Business@Energy
Josef Weber (Siemens): Scenarios for Future Internet Business@EnergyJosef Weber (Siemens): Scenarios for Future Internet Business@Energy
Josef Weber (Siemens): Scenarios for Future Internet Business@Energy
FIA2010
Keith Popplewell, Jenny Harding: Realising the Digital Opportunity: Redesigni...
Keith Popplewell, Jenny Harding: Realising the Digital Opportunity: Redesigni...Keith Popplewell, Jenny Harding: Realising the Digital Opportunity: Redesigni...
Keith Popplewell, Jenny Harding: Realising the Digital Opportunity: Redesigni...
FIA2010
Josema Cavanillas: An industry view on Future Internet Businesses
Josema Cavanillas: An industry view on Future Internet BusinessesJosema Cavanillas: An industry view on Future Internet Businesses
Josema Cavanillas: An industry view on Future Internet Businesses
FIA2010
Ingrid Moerman, Stefan Bouckaert: IP CREW - Cognitive Radio Experimentation ...
Ingrid Moerman, Stefan Bouckaert:  IP CREW - Cognitive Radio Experimentation ...Ingrid Moerman, Stefan Bouckaert:  IP CREW - Cognitive Radio Experimentation ...
Ingrid Moerman, Stefan Bouckaert: IP CREW - Cognitive Radio Experimentation ...
FIA2010
Smart Santander
Smart Santander Smart Santander
Smart Santander
FIA2010
Ofelia open calls
Ofelia open callsOfelia open calls
Ofelia open calls
FIA2010
Julie Marguerite - Tefis open calls (fia dec 2010)
Julie Marguerite - Tefis open calls  (fia dec 2010)Julie Marguerite - Tefis open calls  (fia dec 2010)
Julie Marguerite - Tefis open calls (fia dec 2010)
FIA2010
Florian Schreiner: Plans for open calls and offering by BonFIRE
Florian Schreiner: Plans for open calls and offering by BonFIREFlorian Schreiner: Plans for open calls and offering by BonFIRE
Florian Schreiner: Plans for open calls and offering by BonFIRE
FIA2010
Jacques Magen - Future Internet Research and Experimentation (FIRE): Successf...
Jacques Magen - Future Internet Research and Experimentation (FIRE): Successf...Jacques Magen - Future Internet Research and Experimentation (FIRE): Successf...
Jacques Magen - Future Internet Research and Experimentation (FIRE): Successf...
FIA2010
Obj 1.6 FIRE: Paradiso2 Roger Torrenti
Obj 1.6 FIRE: Paradiso2 Roger Torrenti Obj 1.6 FIRE: Paradiso2 Roger Torrenti
Obj 1.6 FIRE: Paradiso2 Roger Torrenti
FIA2010
Mikhail Simonov - The enabling role of the information broker: an example
Mikhail Simonov - The enabling role of the information broker: an example Mikhail Simonov - The enabling role of the information broker: an example
Mikhail Simonov - The enabling role of the information broker: an example
FIA2010
J. Cave - Information as an economic good in the future internet
J. Cave - Information as an economic good in the future internetJ. Cave - Information as an economic good in the future internet
J. Cave - Information as an economic good in the future internet
FIA2010
Latif Ladid - Ipv6, The two-way internet. The next big thing
Latif Ladid - Ipv6, The two-way internet. The next big thingLatif Ladid - Ipv6, The two-way internet. The next big thing
Latif Ladid - Ipv6, The two-way internet. The next big thing
FIA2010
Ranganai Chaparadza: Can Autonomicity help Migration, and what could be a pos...
Ranganai Chaparadza: Can Autonomicity help Migration, and what could be a pos...Ranganai Chaparadza: Can Autonomicity help Migration, and what could be a pos...
Ranganai Chaparadza: Can Autonomicity help Migration, and what could be a pos...
FIA2010
Ultan mulligan - Future Network Standardisation at ETSI
Ultan mulligan - Future Network Standardisation at ETSIUltan mulligan - Future Network Standardisation at ETSI
Ultan mulligan - Future Network Standardisation at ETSI
FIA2010
Walter Colitti (Vrije Universiteit Brussel): Our vision
Walter Colitti (Vrije Universiteit Brussel): Our visionWalter Colitti (Vrije Universiteit Brussel): Our vision
Walter Colitti (Vrije Universiteit Brussel): Our vision
FIA2010
Isidro Laso Ballesteros (DG Information Society and Media) Internet Architect...
Isidro Laso Ballesteros (DG Information Society and Media) Internet Architect...Isidro Laso Ballesteros (DG Information Society and Media) Internet Architect...
Isidro Laso Ballesteros (DG Information Society and Media) Internet Architect...
FIA2010
Theodore Zahariadis (Synelixis Solutions): Fundamental Limitation of Current ...
Theodore Zahariadis (Synelixis Solutions): Fundamental Limitation of Current ...Theodore Zahariadis (Synelixis Solutions): Fundamental Limitation of Current ...
Theodore Zahariadis (Synelixis Solutions): Fundamental Limitation of Current ...
FIA2010
Dimitri Papadimitriou (Alcatel-Lucent Bell) - Future Internet Architecture (F...
Dimitri Papadimitriou (Alcatel-Lucent Bell) - Future Internet Architecture (F...Dimitri Papadimitriou (Alcatel-Lucent Bell) - Future Internet Architecture (F...
Dimitri Papadimitriou (Alcatel-Lucent Bell) - Future Internet Architecture (F...
FIA2010

Dirk Trossen (University of Cambridge): The EIFFEL Think Tank - Agreeing on disagreements

  • 1. The EIFFEL Think Tank Agreeing on Disagreements Dirk Trossen, University of Cambridge EIFFEL Think Tank FIA Ghent
  • 2. Some Background Think Tank established as a forum of international experts in the area of Internet research Among others: David Clark, Lixia Zhang, Karen Sollins, Joerg Ott, Bob Briscoe, Rui Aguiar, Jon Crowcroft, Invitation-only based on recommendations and understanding that contribution to topics can be done Initiated in 2008 as an outcome of the EIFFEL expert group of the EC EIFFEL whitepaper in Dec 2006 Funded through EU (the EIFFEL project) until Sep 2010 Partners included Cambridge, UCL, RWTH, AUEB, ALB, IJS, Eurescom 息 EIFFEL Think Tank 2010 17/12/10
  • 3. Objectives Establish international community Organize meetings for this community Capture their debates in certain forms Usually in form of whitepapers Disseminate the outcomes Internationally, not only EU Hidden objective: Is such think tank sustainable without funding or Is the idea acceptable and will people invest their own time and money? 息 EIFFEL Think Tank 2010 17/12/10
  • 4. How Does EIFFEL Make Progress?
  • 5. By Agreeing on Disagreements Can we formulate our challenges and disagreements? Can we argue for the different viewpoints? Can we prioritize the disagreements? Can we eliminate disagreements? start from the research community but aim to eventually involve the wider community 息 EIFFEL Think Tank 2010 17/12/10
  • 6. Current Operational Model 息 EIFFEL Think Tank 2010 17/12/10 EIFFEL TT Meeting #N FIPedia.org EIFFEL TT Meeting #N+1 EIFFEL TT Meeting #N+2 Dropped due to, e.g., insufficient debate, lack of identifying a disagreement Concise outputs in form of publications, whitepapers, Community (TT and beyond)
  • 7. Today Values in Architectures Shall Architectures Accommodate Varying Value Sets or Shall They Incorporate a Particular One? Leslie Dagle (ISOC) and Ian Brown (OII) Privacy Gone or Worthwhile Protecting? Karen Sollins (MIT CSAIL) and Rui Aguiar (Univ. of Aveiro) 息 EIFFEL Think Tank 2010 17/12/10
  • 8. More Information EIFFEL website http://www.eiffel-thinktank.eu EIFFEL whitepaper http://www.fp7-eiffel.eu/fileadmin/docs/Report_TT2008.pdf Fipedia.org http://fipedia.org/fipedia Any questions? Email [email_address] 息 EIFFEL Think Tank 2010 30/04/10