際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
Degrowth: tentative ideas about a research agenda Giorgos Kallis, ICREA Researcher 2nd International Conference on Degrowth, Barcelona, 28 March 2010
This presentation Definition of degrowth. My take on the state of degrowth research. Tentative research agenda.
1. What is degrowth?
Three notions Reduction of production and consumption in physical terms through downscaling (and not just efficiency improvements). Decolonization of the imaginary (a-growth) Decommodification  reducing the domain of market rationality.
The degrowth propositions Growth is unsustainable.  Degrowth has environmental and social benefits (double dividend).
2. State of degrowth research
Strengths Plurality of approaches. Creative mix of different approaches and ideas.
Contributions Unsustainability of eco-modernization (rebound effect, Jevon卒s paradox, etc) Political, cultural and anthropological cricisims of development, economism, technocentrism and utilitarianism.  (Re)emerging fresh proposals (basic income, reduced working hours, resource sanctuaries, moratoria, etc) and practical examples.
Weaknesses Programmatic laundry lists. Lack of solid theoretical grounding or theoretical development. We do not engage enough with our own contradictions. Empirical works on alternatives are often methodologically and theoretically weak.
3. Tentative research agenda
Tentative research agenda Strengthen propositions. Engage with contradictions. Develop theory.
Strengthen propositions Unsustainability of growth Sustainability of degrowth How to? The process of transition. Characterize the end state.
Unsustainability of growth Strengthen theoretically and empirically the case against the possibility of dematerializing growth.
Sustainability of degrowth Hypothesize/model impacts on Population. Renewable Energies. Employment and Social Security.  Social infrastructures, etc.  Metabolic scenarios (e.g. how many people can be fed by oil-free agriculture and at what levels?).  Psychological effects under different scenarios vis--vis human behavior.
How to? The process of transition Structural barriers. Can capitalism degrow sustainably? Political processes and transformation.
The end state The degrowth economy. The degrowth democracy.  International relations.
Contradictions Degrowth vs. a-growth.  Ecotaxation vs. Decommodification. Imperative vs. Political proposal. Well-being vs. Anti-utilitarianism.  Community Democracy vs. degrow this, but grow that.
Theory Can we build a coherent theory/ies? Do we have to?
What is a theory How and why things work the way they do? Why x is happening and not y or z?  Agents of change.  Central problem. Value theory.  Marxists have a theory. Neoliberal economists have a theory. We dont.
Tentative research agenda Strengthen propositions. Engage with contradictions. Develop theory.
Thank you! [email_address]

More Related Content

What's hot (18)

Capitalism and the ecological crisis
Capitalism and the ecological crisisCapitalism and the ecological crisis
Capitalism and the ecological crisis
teppoeskelinen
Environmentality in the Household
Environmentality in the HouseholdEnvironmentality in the Household
Environmentality in the Household
Lazri
Architecture and global ethnographies
Architecture and global ethnographiesArchitecture and global ethnographies
Architecture and global ethnographies
John Eilermann
The Science of the City - Introduction
The Science of the City - IntroductionThe Science of the City - Introduction
The Science of the City - Introduction
Regional Science Academy
ecological-urbanism
ecological-urbanismecological-urbanism
ecological-urbanism
William Sankey
Entering the Symbiocene: a theory-method framework to reverse Silent Spring
Entering the Symbiocene: a theory-method framework to reverse Silent SpringEntering the Symbiocene: a theory-method framework to reverse Silent Spring
Entering the Symbiocene: a theory-method framework to reverse Silent Spring
Cathy Fitzgerald - Independent artist | educator | researcher
Social Change
Social ChangeSocial Change
Social Change
Prashanth v
Annotated bibliography
Annotated bibliographyAnnotated bibliography
Annotated bibliography
Jennifer Kim
Entering the Symbiocene: A Transversal Ecosophy-Action Research Framework to ...
Entering the Symbiocene: A Transversal Ecosophy-Action Research Framework to ...Entering the Symbiocene: A Transversal Ecosophy-Action Research Framework to ...
Entering the Symbiocene: A Transversal Ecosophy-Action Research Framework to ...
Cathy Fitzgerald - Independent artist | educator | researcher
The Ecological Turn: Why and How Can We Best Articulate Slow Art and Ecology...
The Ecological Turn: Why and How Can We  Best Articulate Slow Art and Ecology...The Ecological Turn: Why and How Can We  Best Articulate Slow Art and Ecology...
The Ecological Turn: Why and How Can We Best Articulate Slow Art and Ecology...
Cathy Fitzgerald - Independent artist | educator | researcher
1 modernization and social change bed
1 modernization and social change bed1 modernization and social change bed
1 modernization and social change bed
BGS Model Public School
Social change and modernization
Social change and modernizationSocial change and modernization
Social change and modernization
Mechelle Davidson
Online presentation
Online presentationOnline presentation
Online presentation
M10p3309
From the Garden to the City: a redemptive understanding through the ecology o...
From the Garden to the City: a redemptive understanding through the ecology o...From the Garden to the City: a redemptive understanding through the ecology o...
From the Garden to the City: a redemptive understanding through the ecology o...
rowemw
Systems-Based Approach to Support Sustainable and Resilient Communities, Gary...
Systems-Based Approach to Support Sustainable and Resilient Communities, Gary...Systems-Based Approach to Support Sustainable and Resilient Communities, Gary...
Systems-Based Approach to Support Sustainable and Resilient Communities, Gary...
Ecological Sequestration Trust
How do we approach messy. practical problems? A reflection on how to respond ...
How do we approach messy. practical problems? A reflection on how to respond ...How do we approach messy. practical problems? A reflection on how to respond ...
How do we approach messy. practical problems? A reflection on how to respond ...
Martin de Wit
Econosystemics
EconosystemicsEconosystemics
Econosystemics
Bryan Long
Creating A School of Applied Cultural Evolution
Creating A School of Applied Cultural EvolutionCreating A School of Applied Cultural Evolution
Creating A School of Applied Cultural Evolution
Joe Brewer
Capitalism and the ecological crisis
Capitalism and the ecological crisisCapitalism and the ecological crisis
Capitalism and the ecological crisis
teppoeskelinen
Environmentality in the Household
Environmentality in the HouseholdEnvironmentality in the Household
Environmentality in the Household
Lazri
Architecture and global ethnographies
Architecture and global ethnographiesArchitecture and global ethnographies
Architecture and global ethnographies
John Eilermann
ecological-urbanism
ecological-urbanismecological-urbanism
ecological-urbanism
William Sankey
Social Change
Social ChangeSocial Change
Social Change
Prashanth v
Annotated bibliography
Annotated bibliographyAnnotated bibliography
Annotated bibliography
Jennifer Kim
1 modernization and social change bed
1 modernization and social change bed1 modernization and social change bed
1 modernization and social change bed
BGS Model Public School
Social change and modernization
Social change and modernizationSocial change and modernization
Social change and modernization
Mechelle Davidson
Online presentation
Online presentationOnline presentation
Online presentation
M10p3309
From the Garden to the City: a redemptive understanding through the ecology o...
From the Garden to the City: a redemptive understanding through the ecology o...From the Garden to the City: a redemptive understanding through the ecology o...
From the Garden to the City: a redemptive understanding through the ecology o...
rowemw
Systems-Based Approach to Support Sustainable and Resilient Communities, Gary...
Systems-Based Approach to Support Sustainable and Resilient Communities, Gary...Systems-Based Approach to Support Sustainable and Resilient Communities, Gary...
Systems-Based Approach to Support Sustainable and Resilient Communities, Gary...
Ecological Sequestration Trust
How do we approach messy. practical problems? A reflection on how to respond ...
How do we approach messy. practical problems? A reflection on how to respond ...How do we approach messy. practical problems? A reflection on how to respond ...
How do we approach messy. practical problems? A reflection on how to respond ...
Martin de Wit
Econosystemics
EconosystemicsEconosystemics
Econosystemics
Bryan Long
Creating A School of Applied Cultural Evolution
Creating A School of Applied Cultural EvolutionCreating A School of Applied Cultural Evolution
Creating A School of Applied Cultural Evolution
Joe Brewer

Similar to Degrowth: tentative ideas about a research agenda (20)

Beyond Cuts and Taxation: Critical Alternatives and the Idea of Higher Education
Beyond Cuts and Taxation: Critical Alternatives and the Idea of Higher EducationBeyond Cuts and Taxation: Critical Alternatives and the Idea of Higher Education
Beyond Cuts and Taxation: Critical Alternatives and the Idea of Higher Education
Richard Hall
What is-degrowth demaria
What is-degrowth demariaWhat is-degrowth demaria
What is-degrowth demaria
danieleferragina
Articulo microeconomic
Articulo microeconomicArticulo microeconomic
Articulo microeconomic
jhonathangonzalezmah
MISC full paper AS
MISC full paper ASMISC full paper AS
MISC full paper AS
Anne Snick
"LIMITS TO GROWTH REVISITED"; White Paper of the 2012 Winter School by the Pa...
"LIMITS TO GROWTH REVISITED"; White Paper of the 2012 Winter School by the Pa..."LIMITS TO GROWTH REVISITED"; White Paper of the 2012 Winter School by the Pa...
"LIMITS TO GROWTH REVISITED"; White Paper of the 2012 Winter School by the Pa...
VolkswagenStiftung
Conceptualize Sustainable Development
Conceptualize Sustainable DevelopmentConceptualize Sustainable Development
Conceptualize Sustainable Development
Laura Martin
What can we do about this "Sustainability Thing"?
What can we do about this "Sustainability Thing"?What can we do about this "Sustainability Thing"?
What can we do about this "Sustainability Thing"?
jennigoricanec
Social sustainability, mass intellectuality and the idea of the University
Social sustainability, mass intellectuality and the idea of the UniversitySocial sustainability, mass intellectuality and the idea of the University
Social sustainability, mass intellectuality and the idea of the University
Richard Hall
An Essay On Population
An Essay On PopulationAn Essay On Population
An Essay On Population
Paper Writer Service
Low Soo Peng Economic Development
Low Soo Peng Economic DevelopmentLow Soo Peng Economic Development
Low Soo Peng Economic Development
Soo Peng Charles Low
Economic theories and perspectives on development1 (1).ppt
Economic theories and perspectives on development1 (1).pptEconomic theories and perspectives on development1 (1).ppt
Economic theories and perspectives on development1 (1).ppt
NanoSana
Globalization Theory Revised1
Globalization Theory Revised1Globalization Theory Revised1
Globalization Theory Revised1
Khenddro Low
Why We Disagree About Climate Change - Book Review
Why We Disagree About Climate Change - Book ReviewWhy We Disagree About Climate Change - Book Review
Why We Disagree About Climate Change - Book Review
Rose K.
Population, urbanization and environment
Population, urbanization and environmentPopulation, urbanization and environment
Population, urbanization and environment
Daniel Gabad坦n-Estevan
Manifesto: Luc Soete
Manifesto: Luc SoeteManifesto: Luc Soete
Manifesto: Luc Soete
STEPS Centre
Future of Modernization- Essay
Future of Modernization- EssayFuture of Modernization- Essay
Future of Modernization- Essay
SnowPea Guh
Outlines on environmental philosophy part 2
Outlines on environmental philosophy   part 2Outlines on environmental philosophy   part 2
Outlines on environmental philosophy part 2
Steven Ghezzo
"The New Responsibility Paradigm: Implications for Strategic Competitiveness"
"The New Responsibility Paradigm: Implications for Strategic Competitiveness""The New Responsibility Paradigm: Implications for Strategic Competitiveness"
"The New Responsibility Paradigm: Implications for Strategic Competitiveness"
Art Stewart, MPM
Problems with QE aka Printing Money - sanders richard - csiro paper - nub of ...
Problems with QE aka Printing Money - sanders richard - csiro paper - nub of ...Problems with QE aka Printing Money - sanders richard - csiro paper - nub of ...
Problems with QE aka Printing Money - sanders richard - csiro paper - nub of ...
Awethentic
Cultivating a Future
Cultivating a FutureCultivating a Future
Cultivating a Future
School Vegetable Gardening - Victory Gardens
Beyond Cuts and Taxation: Critical Alternatives and the Idea of Higher Education
Beyond Cuts and Taxation: Critical Alternatives and the Idea of Higher EducationBeyond Cuts and Taxation: Critical Alternatives and the Idea of Higher Education
Beyond Cuts and Taxation: Critical Alternatives and the Idea of Higher Education
Richard Hall
What is-degrowth demaria
What is-degrowth demariaWhat is-degrowth demaria
What is-degrowth demaria
danieleferragina
MISC full paper AS
MISC full paper ASMISC full paper AS
MISC full paper AS
Anne Snick
"LIMITS TO GROWTH REVISITED"; White Paper of the 2012 Winter School by the Pa...
"LIMITS TO GROWTH REVISITED"; White Paper of the 2012 Winter School by the Pa..."LIMITS TO GROWTH REVISITED"; White Paper of the 2012 Winter School by the Pa...
"LIMITS TO GROWTH REVISITED"; White Paper of the 2012 Winter School by the Pa...
VolkswagenStiftung
Conceptualize Sustainable Development
Conceptualize Sustainable DevelopmentConceptualize Sustainable Development
Conceptualize Sustainable Development
Laura Martin
What can we do about this "Sustainability Thing"?
What can we do about this "Sustainability Thing"?What can we do about this "Sustainability Thing"?
What can we do about this "Sustainability Thing"?
jennigoricanec
Social sustainability, mass intellectuality and the idea of the University
Social sustainability, mass intellectuality and the idea of the UniversitySocial sustainability, mass intellectuality and the idea of the University
Social sustainability, mass intellectuality and the idea of the University
Richard Hall
Low Soo Peng Economic Development
Low Soo Peng Economic DevelopmentLow Soo Peng Economic Development
Low Soo Peng Economic Development
Soo Peng Charles Low
Economic theories and perspectives on development1 (1).ppt
Economic theories and perspectives on development1 (1).pptEconomic theories and perspectives on development1 (1).ppt
Economic theories and perspectives on development1 (1).ppt
NanoSana
Globalization Theory Revised1
Globalization Theory Revised1Globalization Theory Revised1
Globalization Theory Revised1
Khenddro Low
Why We Disagree About Climate Change - Book Review
Why We Disagree About Climate Change - Book ReviewWhy We Disagree About Climate Change - Book Review
Why We Disagree About Climate Change - Book Review
Rose K.
Population, urbanization and environment
Population, urbanization and environmentPopulation, urbanization and environment
Population, urbanization and environment
Daniel Gabad坦n-Estevan
Manifesto: Luc Soete
Manifesto: Luc SoeteManifesto: Luc Soete
Manifesto: Luc Soete
STEPS Centre
Future of Modernization- Essay
Future of Modernization- EssayFuture of Modernization- Essay
Future of Modernization- Essay
SnowPea Guh
Outlines on environmental philosophy part 2
Outlines on environmental philosophy   part 2Outlines on environmental philosophy   part 2
Outlines on environmental philosophy part 2
Steven Ghezzo
"The New Responsibility Paradigm: Implications for Strategic Competitiveness"
"The New Responsibility Paradigm: Implications for Strategic Competitiveness""The New Responsibility Paradigm: Implications for Strategic Competitiveness"
"The New Responsibility Paradigm: Implications for Strategic Competitiveness"
Art Stewart, MPM
Problems with QE aka Printing Money - sanders richard - csiro paper - nub of ...
Problems with QE aka Printing Money - sanders richard - csiro paper - nub of ...Problems with QE aka Printing Money - sanders richard - csiro paper - nub of ...
Problems with QE aka Printing Money - sanders richard - csiro paper - nub of ...
Awethentic

More from Goteo / Platoniq (18)

Growth, Degrowth, and Justice
Growth, Degrowth, and JusticeGrowth, Degrowth, and Justice
Growth, Degrowth, and Justice
Goteo / Platoniq
Sociology and de-growth; social change, entropy and evolution in a way-down era
Sociology and de-growth; social change, entropy and evolution in a way-down eraSociology and de-growth; social change, entropy and evolution in a way-down era
Sociology and de-growth; social change, entropy and evolution in a way-down era
Goteo / Platoniq
Degrowth; Proposals and Questions
Degrowth; Proposals and QuestionsDegrowth; Proposals and Questions
Degrowth; Proposals and Questions
Goteo / Platoniq
Barkin decrecbarcelona
Barkin decrecbarcelonaBarkin decrecbarcelona
Barkin decrecbarcelona
Goteo / Platoniq
Pathways to Sustainable Development; Co-optimizing Economic Welfare, Employme...
Pathways to Sustainable Development; Co-optimizing Economic Welfare, Employme...Pathways to Sustainable Development; Co-optimizing Economic Welfare, Employme...
Pathways to Sustainable Development; Co-optimizing Economic Welfare, Employme...
Goteo / Platoniq
Entropy, evolution, and the way-down
Entropy, evolution, and the way-downEntropy, evolution, and the way-down
Entropy, evolution, and the way-down
Goteo / Platoniq
Degrowth and unemployment; Guaranteed jobs?
Degrowth and unemployment; Guaranteed jobs?Degrowth and unemployment; Guaranteed jobs?
Degrowth and unemployment; Guaranteed jobs?
Goteo / Platoniq
Measuring progress towards a steady state economy
Measuring progress towards a steady state economyMeasuring progress towards a steady state economy
Measuring progress towards a steady state economy
Goteo / Platoniq
Save by Sharing
Save by SharingSave by Sharing
Save by Sharing
Goteo / Platoniq
DeGrowth & Conservation; Lessons from Pre-Industrial Societies
DeGrowth & Conservation; Lessons from Pre-Industrial SocietiesDeGrowth & Conservation; Lessons from Pre-Industrial Societies
DeGrowth & Conservation; Lessons from Pre-Industrial Societies
Goteo / Platoniq
Climate Change and the Economic Crisis; Is prosperity possible without growth?
Climate Change and the Economic Crisis; Is prosperity possible without growth?Climate Change and the Economic Crisis; Is prosperity possible without growth?
Climate Change and the Economic Crisis; Is prosperity possible without growth?
Goteo / Platoniq
Implementing Degrowth; Evolutionary Economic Perspectives
Implementing Degrowth; Evolutionary Economic PerspectivesImplementing Degrowth; Evolutionary Economic Perspectives
Implementing Degrowth; Evolutionary Economic Perspectives
Goteo / Platoniq
Help! Six types of degrowth
Help! Six types of degrowthHelp! Six types of degrowth
Help! Six types of degrowth
Goteo / Platoniq
Degrowth with an aging population
Degrowth with an aging populationDegrowth with an aging population
Degrowth with an aging population
Goteo / Platoniq
The Chicken/Egg Spiral
The Chicken/Egg SpiralThe Chicken/Egg Spiral
The Chicken/Egg Spiral
Goteo / Platoniq
Happy Degrowth vs Unhappy Growth
Happy Degrowth vs Unhappy GrowthHappy Degrowth vs Unhappy Growth
Happy Degrowth vs Unhappy Growth
Goteo / Platoniq
Collapse and stabilisation instead of degrowth?
Collapse and stabilisation  instead of degrowth?Collapse and stabilisation  instead of degrowth?
Collapse and stabilisation instead of degrowth?
Goteo / Platoniq
2010 Norgard Amateur Econ Barcelona
2010 Norgard Amateur Econ  Barcelona2010 Norgard Amateur Econ  Barcelona
2010 Norgard Amateur Econ Barcelona
Goteo / Platoniq
Growth, Degrowth, and Justice
Growth, Degrowth, and JusticeGrowth, Degrowth, and Justice
Growth, Degrowth, and Justice
Goteo / Platoniq
Sociology and de-growth; social change, entropy and evolution in a way-down era
Sociology and de-growth; social change, entropy and evolution in a way-down eraSociology and de-growth; social change, entropy and evolution in a way-down era
Sociology and de-growth; social change, entropy and evolution in a way-down era
Goteo / Platoniq
Degrowth; Proposals and Questions
Degrowth; Proposals and QuestionsDegrowth; Proposals and Questions
Degrowth; Proposals and Questions
Goteo / Platoniq
Pathways to Sustainable Development; Co-optimizing Economic Welfare, Employme...
Pathways to Sustainable Development; Co-optimizing Economic Welfare, Employme...Pathways to Sustainable Development; Co-optimizing Economic Welfare, Employme...
Pathways to Sustainable Development; Co-optimizing Economic Welfare, Employme...
Goteo / Platoniq
Entropy, evolution, and the way-down
Entropy, evolution, and the way-downEntropy, evolution, and the way-down
Entropy, evolution, and the way-down
Goteo / Platoniq
Degrowth and unemployment; Guaranteed jobs?
Degrowth and unemployment; Guaranteed jobs?Degrowth and unemployment; Guaranteed jobs?
Degrowth and unemployment; Guaranteed jobs?
Goteo / Platoniq
Measuring progress towards a steady state economy
Measuring progress towards a steady state economyMeasuring progress towards a steady state economy
Measuring progress towards a steady state economy
Goteo / Platoniq
DeGrowth & Conservation; Lessons from Pre-Industrial Societies
DeGrowth & Conservation; Lessons from Pre-Industrial SocietiesDeGrowth & Conservation; Lessons from Pre-Industrial Societies
DeGrowth & Conservation; Lessons from Pre-Industrial Societies
Goteo / Platoniq
Climate Change and the Economic Crisis; Is prosperity possible without growth?
Climate Change and the Economic Crisis; Is prosperity possible without growth?Climate Change and the Economic Crisis; Is prosperity possible without growth?
Climate Change and the Economic Crisis; Is prosperity possible without growth?
Goteo / Platoniq
Implementing Degrowth; Evolutionary Economic Perspectives
Implementing Degrowth; Evolutionary Economic PerspectivesImplementing Degrowth; Evolutionary Economic Perspectives
Implementing Degrowth; Evolutionary Economic Perspectives
Goteo / Platoniq
Help! Six types of degrowth
Help! Six types of degrowthHelp! Six types of degrowth
Help! Six types of degrowth
Goteo / Platoniq
Degrowth with an aging population
Degrowth with an aging populationDegrowth with an aging population
Degrowth with an aging population
Goteo / Platoniq
Happy Degrowth vs Unhappy Growth
Happy Degrowth vs Unhappy GrowthHappy Degrowth vs Unhappy Growth
Happy Degrowth vs Unhappy Growth
Goteo / Platoniq
Collapse and stabilisation instead of degrowth?
Collapse and stabilisation  instead of degrowth?Collapse and stabilisation  instead of degrowth?
Collapse and stabilisation instead of degrowth?
Goteo / Platoniq
2010 Norgard Amateur Econ Barcelona
2010 Norgard Amateur Econ  Barcelona2010 Norgard Amateur Econ  Barcelona
2010 Norgard Amateur Econ Barcelona
Goteo / Platoniq

Degrowth: tentative ideas about a research agenda

  • 1. Degrowth: tentative ideas about a research agenda Giorgos Kallis, ICREA Researcher 2nd International Conference on Degrowth, Barcelona, 28 March 2010
  • 2. This presentation Definition of degrowth. My take on the state of degrowth research. Tentative research agenda.
  • 3. 1. What is degrowth?
  • 4. Three notions Reduction of production and consumption in physical terms through downscaling (and not just efficiency improvements). Decolonization of the imaginary (a-growth) Decommodification reducing the domain of market rationality.
  • 5. The degrowth propositions Growth is unsustainable. Degrowth has environmental and social benefits (double dividend).
  • 6. 2. State of degrowth research
  • 7. Strengths Plurality of approaches. Creative mix of different approaches and ideas.
  • 8. Contributions Unsustainability of eco-modernization (rebound effect, Jevon卒s paradox, etc) Political, cultural and anthropological cricisims of development, economism, technocentrism and utilitarianism. (Re)emerging fresh proposals (basic income, reduced working hours, resource sanctuaries, moratoria, etc) and practical examples.
  • 9. Weaknesses Programmatic laundry lists. Lack of solid theoretical grounding or theoretical development. We do not engage enough with our own contradictions. Empirical works on alternatives are often methodologically and theoretically weak.
  • 11. Tentative research agenda Strengthen propositions. Engage with contradictions. Develop theory.
  • 12. Strengthen propositions Unsustainability of growth Sustainability of degrowth How to? The process of transition. Characterize the end state.
  • 13. Unsustainability of growth Strengthen theoretically and empirically the case against the possibility of dematerializing growth.
  • 14. Sustainability of degrowth Hypothesize/model impacts on Population. Renewable Energies. Employment and Social Security. Social infrastructures, etc. Metabolic scenarios (e.g. how many people can be fed by oil-free agriculture and at what levels?). Psychological effects under different scenarios vis--vis human behavior.
  • 15. How to? The process of transition Structural barriers. Can capitalism degrow sustainably? Political processes and transformation.
  • 16. The end state The degrowth economy. The degrowth democracy. International relations.
  • 17. Contradictions Degrowth vs. a-growth. Ecotaxation vs. Decommodification. Imperative vs. Political proposal. Well-being vs. Anti-utilitarianism. Community Democracy vs. degrow this, but grow that.
  • 18. Theory Can we build a coherent theory/ies? Do we have to?
  • 19. What is a theory How and why things work the way they do? Why x is happening and not y or z? Agents of change. Central problem. Value theory. Marxists have a theory. Neoliberal economists have a theory. We dont.
  • 20. Tentative research agenda Strengthen propositions. Engage with contradictions. Develop theory.