際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
Dr. Emmanuel Garcia and Rebekah Chojnacki, M.A. University of
Texas at Arlington
October 21, 2016
Beyond Retention, Helping Build Resilience
 A focus on retention leads to a focus on students in
academic peril
 Students who are in good standing may need
support, but dont get it because its not a high need
 We want to fill in gap
High Achievers and the Storms They Face
 Not having to study much/at all before college
 Little experience with failure/academic obstacles
 Different standardsif a student has never had a B
or C before, it can be traumatizing
Perfectionism
 Help students find balancetheres a fine line
between burnout and engagement
 Seen in the US and in other countriesall high
achievers deal with this worldwide
 Sources of pressure
 External (family, peers, etc.)
 Internal (wanting to compete)
Invisible Challengers
 A common challenge  invisible disabilities
 High achievers may have invisible disabilities  e.g.
General Anxiety Disorder, etc.
How Can the Advisor Help?
 Literature is really lacking for advisor rolemostly
student based.
 Help us start the conversation and generate ideas!
 All students need our helpsome just need us to
listen more than anything else.
Setback vs. Failure
 What did you learn from this experience?
 Show that bumps in the road are okay, you can still get
to your destination
 Look at the overall pictureone bad grade will not bar
you from all future opportunities
Sometimes Life Does Not Go as Expected
 Calm down with math  show them they will still
graduate
 Show what they have accomplished so far  AP, dual
credit, etc.
 High-achievers like to see a plan written down
 Re-assure plans can change
College is a Whole New World AP/Dual/IB Is Not the Same as
College Level
 AP  to claim or not to claim
 Discuss the cost/benefits of not claiming AP credit to
be more prepared for other classes
 Dealing with stress when realization hits
We instead of You
 Use collaborative language
 Use empathy
Discussion
 What have you seen when working with high-
achievers?
 Discuss
Dealing with Family Pressure
 Family Pressure
 Planning to confront parents
 Give major some more effort/mentors/research/tutoring
 Let parents know that youve triedshow them
 Dont jump ship right away
 Send student to career center (strengths quest & career
planning)
 Knowing what they are good at vs. passion
 Hobbies vs. career
How to be Supportive
 Be supportive and listen
 What makes it important to the student
 Let the student talk it through to help guide them to a
solution
 Help the student see the bigger picture
 Let them have support to have venting time
 Know when to send them to counseling
 Help students build strategies for success
I want more
 Achievers have internal drive
 Introducing: University College Scholars
References
 Salanova, M., Schaufeli, W., Mart鱈nez, I., & Bres坦, E. (2010). How obstacles and
facilitators predict academic performance: The mediating role of study
burnout and engagement. Anxiety, Stress & Coping, 23(1), 53-70.
 Dickinson, M. J., & Dickinson, D. A. (2014). Practically perfect in every way: can
reframing perfectionism for high-achieving undergraduates impact academic
resilience?. Studies in Higher Education, (ahead-of-print), 1-15.
 Rice, K. G., Leever, B. A., Christopher, J., & Porter, J. D. (2006). Perfectionism,
stress, and social (dis) connection: A short-term study of hopelessness,
depression, and academic adjustment among honors students. Journal of
Counseling Psychology, 53(4), 524.
 Siegle, D., Rubenstein, L. D., Pollard, E., & Romey, E. (2009). Exploring the
relationship of college freshmen honors students effort and ability attribution,
interest, and implicit theory of intelligence with perceived ability. Gifted Child
Quarterly.
 Neumeister, K. L. S. (2004). Understanding the relationship between
perfectionism and achievement motivation in gifted college students. Gifted
child quarterly, 48(3), 219-231.

More Related Content

What's hot (18)

Social Awareness Programme
Social Awareness ProgrammeSocial Awareness Programme
Social Awareness Programme
Ankit Ranjan
Adult mentors 20120725_141558_10
Adult mentors 20120725_141558_10Adult mentors 20120725_141558_10
Adult mentors 20120725_141558_10
Lisa Stack
High expectations for learners 3
High expectations for learners 3High expectations for learners 3
High expectations for learners 3
fathima rishana
Interventions for at risk students power point
Interventions for at risk students power pointInterventions for at risk students power point
Interventions for at risk students power point
Denise C Barnes
CGCA: Transition to Home School
CGCA: Transition to Home SchoolCGCA: Transition to Home School
CGCA: Transition to Home School
eeniarrol
Transitionofgnetsstudents1
Transitionofgnetsstudents1Transitionofgnetsstudents1
Transitionofgnetsstudents1
eeniarrol
Underachievers
UnderachieversUnderachievers
Underachievers
Sanika Sathe
Teaching with poverty in mind by eric jensen
Teaching with poverty in mind by eric jensenTeaching with poverty in mind by eric jensen
Teaching with poverty in mind by eric jensen
robinlstewart
Ev681 session3 planning
Ev681 session3 planningEv681 session3 planning
Ev681 session3 planning
Pippa Totraku
Underachievement
UnderachievementUnderachievement
Underachievement
Jessica Barrington
Gifted children
Gifted childrenGifted children
Gifted children
Diaa Srahin
Teaching_Poverty_in_Mind
Teaching_Poverty_in_MindTeaching_Poverty_in_Mind
Teaching_Poverty_in_Mind
WestcottJ
Teaching with Poverty (The Impact and Strategies) (July 2014)
Teaching with Poverty (The Impact and Strategies) (July 2014)Teaching with Poverty (The Impact and Strategies) (July 2014)
Teaching with Poverty (The Impact and Strategies) (July 2014)
Matt Bergman
Working with difficult learning situations
Working with difficult learning situationsWorking with difficult learning situations
Working with difficult learning situations
Deirdre Bonnycastle
Teaching with poverty in mind
Teaching with poverty in mindTeaching with poverty in mind
Teaching with poverty in mind
mmcneffnd
Teaching Gifted and Talented Pupils at Primary Level
Teaching Gifted and Talented Pupils at Primary LevelTeaching Gifted and Talented Pupils at Primary Level
Teaching Gifted and Talented Pupils at Primary Level
LKMco
Classroom disruption
Classroom disruptionClassroom disruption
Classroom disruption
Ahmed Hussein
Disruptive behavior
Disruptive behaviorDisruptive behavior
Disruptive behavior
Ahmed Hussein
Social Awareness Programme
Social Awareness ProgrammeSocial Awareness Programme
Social Awareness Programme
Ankit Ranjan
Adult mentors 20120725_141558_10
Adult mentors 20120725_141558_10Adult mentors 20120725_141558_10
Adult mentors 20120725_141558_10
Lisa Stack
High expectations for learners 3
High expectations for learners 3High expectations for learners 3
High expectations for learners 3
fathima rishana
Interventions for at risk students power point
Interventions for at risk students power pointInterventions for at risk students power point
Interventions for at risk students power point
Denise C Barnes
CGCA: Transition to Home School
CGCA: Transition to Home SchoolCGCA: Transition to Home School
CGCA: Transition to Home School
eeniarrol
Transitionofgnetsstudents1
Transitionofgnetsstudents1Transitionofgnetsstudents1
Transitionofgnetsstudents1
eeniarrol
Teaching with poverty in mind by eric jensen
Teaching with poverty in mind by eric jensenTeaching with poverty in mind by eric jensen
Teaching with poverty in mind by eric jensen
robinlstewart
Ev681 session3 planning
Ev681 session3 planningEv681 session3 planning
Ev681 session3 planning
Pippa Totraku
Gifted children
Gifted childrenGifted children
Gifted children
Diaa Srahin
Teaching_Poverty_in_Mind
Teaching_Poverty_in_MindTeaching_Poverty_in_Mind
Teaching_Poverty_in_Mind
WestcottJ
Teaching with Poverty (The Impact and Strategies) (July 2014)
Teaching with Poverty (The Impact and Strategies) (July 2014)Teaching with Poverty (The Impact and Strategies) (July 2014)
Teaching with Poverty (The Impact and Strategies) (July 2014)
Matt Bergman
Working with difficult learning situations
Working with difficult learning situationsWorking with difficult learning situations
Working with difficult learning situations
Deirdre Bonnycastle
Teaching with poverty in mind
Teaching with poverty in mindTeaching with poverty in mind
Teaching with poverty in mind
mmcneffnd
Teaching Gifted and Talented Pupils at Primary Level
Teaching Gifted and Talented Pupils at Primary LevelTeaching Gifted and Talented Pupils at Primary Level
Teaching Gifted and Talented Pupils at Primary Level
LKMco
Classroom disruption
Classroom disruptionClassroom disruption
Classroom disruption
Ahmed Hussein
Disruptive behavior
Disruptive behaviorDisruptive behavior
Disruptive behavior
Ahmed Hussein

Viewers also liked (6)

Df China 3Df China 3
Df China 3
Mireia Buchaca
Resume
ResumeResume
Resume
vemula ramya teja
Metallographic Analysis (theory)
Metallographic Analysis (theory)Metallographic Analysis (theory)
Metallographic Analysis (theory)
Nurul Nurdiyana Rusdi
Hotel Digital Marketing Trends Presentation - Best Stay Croatia 2015
Hotel Digital Marketing Trends Presentation - Best Stay Croatia 2015 Hotel Digital Marketing Trends Presentation - Best Stay Croatia 2015
Hotel Digital Marketing Trends Presentation - Best Stay Croatia 2015
Carmelon Digital Marketing
HfS Webinar 際際滷s: Smart Process Automation in Enterprise Business
HfS Webinar 際際滷s: Smart Process Automation in Enterprise BusinessHfS Webinar 際際滷s: Smart Process Automation in Enterprise Business
HfS Webinar 際際滷s: Smart Process Automation in Enterprise Business
HfS Research
Df China 3Df China 3
Df China 3
Mireia Buchaca
Hotel Digital Marketing Trends Presentation - Best Stay Croatia 2015
Hotel Digital Marketing Trends Presentation - Best Stay Croatia 2015 Hotel Digital Marketing Trends Presentation - Best Stay Croatia 2015
Hotel Digital Marketing Trends Presentation - Best Stay Croatia 2015
Carmelon Digital Marketing
HfS Webinar 際際滷s: Smart Process Automation in Enterprise Business
HfS Webinar 際際滷s: Smart Process Automation in Enterprise BusinessHfS Webinar 際際滷s: Smart Process Automation in Enterprise Business
HfS Webinar 際際滷s: Smart Process Automation in Enterprise Business
HfS Research

Similar to Helping High Achievers Find the Magic Within (20)

Mentoring Diverse Students, Winter 2012
Mentoring Diverse Students, Winter 2012Mentoring Diverse Students, Winter 2012
Mentoring Diverse Students, Winter 2012
utepgrad
What Successful College Students Do Differently
What Successful College Students Do DifferentlyWhat Successful College Students Do Differently
What Successful College Students Do Differently
JC Cruz
The grade-8-parent-presentation-2-23-11
The grade-8-parent-presentation-2-23-11The grade-8-parent-presentation-2-23-11
The grade-8-parent-presentation-2-23-11
Universal American School of Dubai
8th-9th Grade Parent Presentation
8th-9th Grade Parent Presentation8th-9th Grade Parent Presentation
8th-9th Grade Parent Presentation
jonathanchambers
Relationship building and_hope
Relationship building and_hopeRelationship building and_hope
Relationship building and_hope
weshall217
Motivating disengaged students w solution tree symbol taping
Motivating disengaged students w solution tree symbol tapingMotivating disengaged students w solution tree symbol taping
Motivating disengaged students w solution tree symbol taping
Ali Ahsan
Coastal Georgia Comprehensive Academy: Transition to Home School
Coastal Georgia Comprehensive Academy: Transition to Home SchoolCoastal Georgia Comprehensive Academy: Transition to Home School
Coastal Georgia Comprehensive Academy: Transition to Home School
eeniarrol
Coastal Georgia Academy: Transition to General Education
Coastal Georgia Academy: Transition to General EducationCoastal Georgia Academy: Transition to General Education
Coastal Georgia Academy: Transition to General Education
eeniarrol
September 2009 P A Day
September 2009 P A  DaySeptember 2009 P A  Day
September 2009 P A Day
CathGal
From GNETS to Home School
From GNETS to Home SchoolFrom GNETS to Home School
From GNETS to Home School
eeniarrol
CGCA
CGCACGCA
CGCA
eeniarrol
Conflicts In The Home
Conflicts In The HomeConflicts In The Home
Conflicts In The Home
CassieFeldman
Conflicts In The Home
Conflicts In The HomeConflicts In The Home
Conflicts In The Home
CassieFeldman
Ut students millenials learning preferences
Ut students millenials learning preferencesUt students millenials learning preferences
Ut students millenials learning preferences
Tennessee Teaching and Learning Center
Gurnam Singh MoRKSS at SHU 7/11/12
Gurnam Singh MoRKSS at SHU 7/11/12Gurnam Singh MoRKSS at SHU 7/11/12
Gurnam Singh MoRKSS at SHU 7/11/12
viscabarca
The wellbeing classroom
The wellbeing classroomThe wellbeing classroom
The wellbeing classroom
Daniela Falecki
Working with International Students: 2017 Edition
Working with International Students: 2017 EditionWorking with International Students: 2017 Edition
Working with International Students: 2017 Edition
Emma Kennedy
Building Confidence and Student Retention Rates Among Non-Traditional Students
Building Confidence and Student Retention Rates Among Non-Traditional StudentsBuilding Confidence and Student Retention Rates Among Non-Traditional Students
Building Confidence and Student Retention Rates Among Non-Traditional Students
Georgia Libraries Conference (formerly Ga COMO).
JALT Presentation
JALT PresentationJALT Presentation
JALT Presentation
Arnold Arao
The red coler with file are very importantAttached Files油Fixedv.docx
The red coler with file are very importantAttached Files油Fixedv.docxThe red coler with file are very importantAttached Files油Fixedv.docx
The red coler with file are very importantAttached Files油Fixedv.docx
helen23456789
Mentoring Diverse Students, Winter 2012
Mentoring Diverse Students, Winter 2012Mentoring Diverse Students, Winter 2012
Mentoring Diverse Students, Winter 2012
utepgrad
What Successful College Students Do Differently
What Successful College Students Do DifferentlyWhat Successful College Students Do Differently
What Successful College Students Do Differently
JC Cruz
8th-9th Grade Parent Presentation
8th-9th Grade Parent Presentation8th-9th Grade Parent Presentation
8th-9th Grade Parent Presentation
jonathanchambers
Relationship building and_hope
Relationship building and_hopeRelationship building and_hope
Relationship building and_hope
weshall217
Motivating disengaged students w solution tree symbol taping
Motivating disengaged students w solution tree symbol tapingMotivating disengaged students w solution tree symbol taping
Motivating disengaged students w solution tree symbol taping
Ali Ahsan
Coastal Georgia Comprehensive Academy: Transition to Home School
Coastal Georgia Comprehensive Academy: Transition to Home SchoolCoastal Georgia Comprehensive Academy: Transition to Home School
Coastal Georgia Comprehensive Academy: Transition to Home School
eeniarrol
Coastal Georgia Academy: Transition to General Education
Coastal Georgia Academy: Transition to General EducationCoastal Georgia Academy: Transition to General Education
Coastal Georgia Academy: Transition to General Education
eeniarrol
September 2009 P A Day
September 2009 P A  DaySeptember 2009 P A  Day
September 2009 P A Day
CathGal
From GNETS to Home School
From GNETS to Home SchoolFrom GNETS to Home School
From GNETS to Home School
eeniarrol
Conflicts In The Home
Conflicts In The HomeConflicts In The Home
Conflicts In The Home
CassieFeldman
Conflicts In The Home
Conflicts In The HomeConflicts In The Home
Conflicts In The Home
CassieFeldman
Gurnam Singh MoRKSS at SHU 7/11/12
Gurnam Singh MoRKSS at SHU 7/11/12Gurnam Singh MoRKSS at SHU 7/11/12
Gurnam Singh MoRKSS at SHU 7/11/12
viscabarca
The wellbeing classroom
The wellbeing classroomThe wellbeing classroom
The wellbeing classroom
Daniela Falecki
Working with International Students: 2017 Edition
Working with International Students: 2017 EditionWorking with International Students: 2017 Edition
Working with International Students: 2017 Edition
Emma Kennedy
JALT Presentation
JALT PresentationJALT Presentation
JALT Presentation
Arnold Arao
The red coler with file are very importantAttached Files油Fixedv.docx
The red coler with file are very importantAttached Files油Fixedv.docxThe red coler with file are very importantAttached Files油Fixedv.docx
The red coler with file are very importantAttached Files油Fixedv.docx
helen23456789

More from Rebekah Black (8)

Empowering Student Workers to be Leaders
Empowering Student Workers to be LeadersEmpowering Student Workers to be Leaders
Empowering Student Workers to be Leaders
Rebekah Black
Honors Senior Project Crisis Planning revised for Wigley
Honors Senior Project Crisis Planning revised for WigleyHonors Senior Project Crisis Planning revised for Wigley
Honors Senior Project Crisis Planning revised for Wigley
Rebekah Black
UTAAA 2016 Certificate
UTAAA 2016 CertificateUTAAA 2016 Certificate
UTAAA 2016 Certificate
Rebekah Black
The Importance of Good Followers
The Importance of Good FollowersThe Importance of Good Followers
The Importance of Good Followers
Rebekah Black
Co-Curricular Involvement
Co-Curricular InvolvementCo-Curricular Involvement
Co-Curricular Involvement
Rebekah Black
How to Make Advising Work for You
How to Make Advising Work for YouHow to Make Advising Work for You
How to Make Advising Work for You
Rebekah Black
2010 Census PR Plan
2010 Census PR Plan2010 Census PR Plan
2010 Census PR Plan
Rebekah Black
Encouraging Other Women to Lead
Encouraging Other Women to LeadEncouraging Other Women to Lead
Encouraging Other Women to Lead
Rebekah Black
Empowering Student Workers to be Leaders
Empowering Student Workers to be LeadersEmpowering Student Workers to be Leaders
Empowering Student Workers to be Leaders
Rebekah Black
Honors Senior Project Crisis Planning revised for Wigley
Honors Senior Project Crisis Planning revised for WigleyHonors Senior Project Crisis Planning revised for Wigley
Honors Senior Project Crisis Planning revised for Wigley
Rebekah Black
UTAAA 2016 Certificate
UTAAA 2016 CertificateUTAAA 2016 Certificate
UTAAA 2016 Certificate
Rebekah Black
The Importance of Good Followers
The Importance of Good FollowersThe Importance of Good Followers
The Importance of Good Followers
Rebekah Black
Co-Curricular Involvement
Co-Curricular InvolvementCo-Curricular Involvement
Co-Curricular Involvement
Rebekah Black
How to Make Advising Work for You
How to Make Advising Work for YouHow to Make Advising Work for You
How to Make Advising Work for You
Rebekah Black
2010 Census PR Plan
2010 Census PR Plan2010 Census PR Plan
2010 Census PR Plan
Rebekah Black
Encouraging Other Women to Lead
Encouraging Other Women to LeadEncouraging Other Women to Lead
Encouraging Other Women to Lead
Rebekah Black

Helping High Achievers Find the Magic Within

  • 1. Dr. Emmanuel Garcia and Rebekah Chojnacki, M.A. University of Texas at Arlington October 21, 2016
  • 2. Beyond Retention, Helping Build Resilience A focus on retention leads to a focus on students in academic peril Students who are in good standing may need support, but dont get it because its not a high need We want to fill in gap
  • 3. High Achievers and the Storms They Face Not having to study much/at all before college Little experience with failure/academic obstacles Different standardsif a student has never had a B or C before, it can be traumatizing
  • 4. Perfectionism Help students find balancetheres a fine line between burnout and engagement Seen in the US and in other countriesall high achievers deal with this worldwide Sources of pressure External (family, peers, etc.) Internal (wanting to compete)
  • 5. Invisible Challengers A common challenge invisible disabilities High achievers may have invisible disabilities e.g. General Anxiety Disorder, etc.
  • 6. How Can the Advisor Help? Literature is really lacking for advisor rolemostly student based. Help us start the conversation and generate ideas! All students need our helpsome just need us to listen more than anything else.
  • 7. Setback vs. Failure What did you learn from this experience? Show that bumps in the road are okay, you can still get to your destination Look at the overall pictureone bad grade will not bar you from all future opportunities
  • 8. Sometimes Life Does Not Go as Expected Calm down with math show them they will still graduate Show what they have accomplished so far AP, dual credit, etc. High-achievers like to see a plan written down Re-assure plans can change
  • 9. College is a Whole New World AP/Dual/IB Is Not the Same as College Level AP to claim or not to claim Discuss the cost/benefits of not claiming AP credit to be more prepared for other classes Dealing with stress when realization hits
  • 10. We instead of You Use collaborative language Use empathy
  • 11. Discussion What have you seen when working with high- achievers? Discuss
  • 12. Dealing with Family Pressure Family Pressure Planning to confront parents Give major some more effort/mentors/research/tutoring Let parents know that youve triedshow them Dont jump ship right away Send student to career center (strengths quest & career planning) Knowing what they are good at vs. passion Hobbies vs. career
  • 13. How to be Supportive Be supportive and listen What makes it important to the student Let the student talk it through to help guide them to a solution Help the student see the bigger picture Let them have support to have venting time Know when to send them to counseling Help students build strategies for success
  • 14. I want more Achievers have internal drive Introducing: University College Scholars
  • 15. References Salanova, M., Schaufeli, W., Mart鱈nez, I., & Bres坦, E. (2010). How obstacles and facilitators predict academic performance: The mediating role of study burnout and engagement. Anxiety, Stress & Coping, 23(1), 53-70. Dickinson, M. J., & Dickinson, D. A. (2014). Practically perfect in every way: can reframing perfectionism for high-achieving undergraduates impact academic resilience?. Studies in Higher Education, (ahead-of-print), 1-15. Rice, K. G., Leever, B. A., Christopher, J., & Porter, J. D. (2006). Perfectionism, stress, and social (dis) connection: A short-term study of hopelessness, depression, and academic adjustment among honors students. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 53(4), 524. Siegle, D., Rubenstein, L. D., Pollard, E., & Romey, E. (2009). Exploring the relationship of college freshmen honors students effort and ability attribution, interest, and implicit theory of intelligence with perceived ability. Gifted Child Quarterly. Neumeister, K. L. S. (2004). Understanding the relationship between perfectionism and achievement motivation in gifted college students. Gifted child quarterly, 48(3), 219-231.