ݺߣ

ݺߣShare a Scribd company logo
Approach
(Basic Science)
Scott G. Filler, M.D.
Lundquist Institute for Biomedical Innovation
at Harbor-UCLA Medical Center
sfiller@ucla.edu
Approach
• Are the overall strategy, methodology, and analyses well-
reasoned and appropriate to accomplish the specific aims
of the project?
• Have the investigators included plans to address
weaknesses in the rigor of prior research that serves as
the key support for the proposed project?
• Have the investigators presented strategies to ensure a
robust and unbiased approach, as appropriate for the
work proposed?
Approach
• Are potential problems, alternative strategies, and
benchmarks for success presented?
• If the project is in the early stages of development, will the
strategy establish feasibility and will particularly risky
aspects be managed?
• Have the investigators presented adequate plans to
address relevant biological variables, such as sex, for
studies in vertebrate animals or human subjects?
Approach--Overall Layout
• Preliminary data
• Aim 1
o Rationale and overall approach
o Experimental methods
o Anticipated results
o Alternative outcomes (potential pitfalls)
o Future directions
• Aim 2
o Rationale and overall approach
o Experimental methods
o Anticipated results
o Alternative outcomes (potential pitfalls)
o Future directions
Approach--Alternate Layout
• Aim 1
o Preliminary data
o Rationale and overall approach
o Experimental methods
o Anticipated results
o Alternative outcomes (potential pitfalls)
o Future directions
• Aim 2
o Preliminary data
o Rationale and overall approach
o Experimental methods
o Anticipated results
o Alternative outcomes (potential pitfalls)
o Future directions
Preliminary Data
• Present compelling preliminary data
o Supports premise of the work
o Demonstrates feasibility
o Sparks interest, but leaves reviewer wanting to learn more
• Potential pitfalls in preliminary data
o Clear weaknesses
o No statistical analysis
o Support alternative hypothesis
Approach
• Describe overall approach and the controls
• Only mention key details
• Need power calculations for animal studies
o Many details of animal studies can be move to Vertebrate
Animals section
• Address sex as a biological variable
Approach
• Potential pitfalls
o One aim depend on another *
o Excessive detail
• Detracts from overall message
• Target for criticism
o Densely written prose
“If reading a grant gives the reviewer a headache, that grant is
unlikely to receive a good score”
Anticipated Results and
Potential Pitfalls
• What do you think the results will be?
• Creativity and flexible thinking very important
• Interesting alternative outcomes—make a bug into a
feature
Anticipated Results and
Potential Pitfalls—Key Points
• What will you do if hypothesis is not supported?
• Never present a potential pitfall for which you don’t
have a good solution
• Don’t say, “The investigative team has substantial
experience with this work and thus do not anticipate
any technical problems.”
Future Directions
• Where is your research going?
• What will be its impact?
• How can the specific information learn be
applied to a broader question?

More Related Content

Similar to How to Structure the “Approach” Section (Basic Science) (20)

PSYA4 - Research methods
PSYA4 - Research methodsPSYA4 - Research methods
PSYA4 - Research methods
Nicky Burt
Research
ResearchResearch
Research
BP KOIRALA INSTITUTE OF HELATH SCIENCS,, NEPAL
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" - 2023
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation"  - 2023How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation"  - 2023
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" - 2023
UCLA CTSI
Writing the NIH K Award: Research Plan - May 2024
Writing the NIH K Award: Research Plan - May 2024Writing the NIH K Award: Research Plan - May 2024
Writing the NIH K Award: Research Plan - May 2024
UCLA CTSI
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...
UCLA CTSI
Evaluating published research-research publication
Evaluating published research-research publicationEvaluating published research-research publication
Evaluating published research-research publication
rehabonehealthcare
Critiquing and evaluating health literature and manuscripts
Critiquing and evaluating health literature and manuscriptsCritiquing and evaluating health literature and manuscripts
Critiquing and evaluating health literature and manuscripts
Kern Rocke
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...
UCLA CTSI
COM 302- THE FUNDAMENTALS OF SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH.pptx
COM 302- THE FUNDAMENTALS OF SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH.pptxCOM 302- THE FUNDAMENTALS OF SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH.pptx
COM 302- THE FUNDAMENTALS OF SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH.pptx
seekerhub1
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...
UCLA CTSI
Critical appraisal-MP-2023.pptx
Critical appraisal-MP-2023.pptxCritical appraisal-MP-2023.pptx
Critical appraisal-MP-2023.pptx
AMANUELMELAKU5
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...
UCLA CTSI
Presentation how to write a research protocol
Presentation how to write a research protocolPresentation how to write a research protocol
Presentation how to write a research protocol
Sushma Sharma
How to write a research proposal
How to write a research proposalHow to write a research proposal
How to write a research proposal
DrHebatalla Mohamed
How to ace Phd/Doctoral final oral defense or viva voce'
How to ace Phd/Doctoral final oral defense or viva voce'How to ace Phd/Doctoral final oral defense or viva voce'
How to ace Phd/Doctoral final oral defense or viva voce'
DoctoralNet Limited
Research method ch04 research topic and design
Research method ch04 research topic and designResearch method ch04 research topic and design
Research method ch04 research topic and design
naranbatn
Surviving Your Viva or Dissertation Defense
Surviving Your Viva or Dissertation DefenseSurviving Your Viva or Dissertation Defense
Surviving Your Viva or Dissertation Defense
DoctoralNet Limited
Writing A Sound Proposal
Writing A Sound ProposalWriting A Sound Proposal
Writing A Sound Proposal
Mohamed Amin Embi
Research Question and Hypothesis
Research Question and HypothesisResearch Question and Hypothesis
Research Question and Hypothesis
Arvind Kushwaha
Week 10 writing research proposal
Week 10  writing research proposalWeek 10  writing research proposal
Week 10 writing research proposal
wawaaa789
PSYA4 - Research methods
PSYA4 - Research methodsPSYA4 - Research methods
PSYA4 - Research methods
Nicky Burt
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" - 2023
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation"  - 2023How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation"  - 2023
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" - 2023
UCLA CTSI
Writing the NIH K Award: Research Plan - May 2024
Writing the NIH K Award: Research Plan - May 2024Writing the NIH K Award: Research Plan - May 2024
Writing the NIH K Award: Research Plan - May 2024
UCLA CTSI
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...
UCLA CTSI
Evaluating published research-research publication
Evaluating published research-research publicationEvaluating published research-research publication
Evaluating published research-research publication
rehabonehealthcare
Critiquing and evaluating health literature and manuscripts
Critiquing and evaluating health literature and manuscriptsCritiquing and evaluating health literature and manuscripts
Critiquing and evaluating health literature and manuscripts
Kern Rocke
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...
UCLA CTSI
COM 302- THE FUNDAMENTALS OF SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH.pptx
COM 302- THE FUNDAMENTALS OF SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH.pptxCOM 302- THE FUNDAMENTALS OF SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH.pptx
COM 302- THE FUNDAMENTALS OF SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH.pptx
seekerhub1
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...
UCLA CTSI
Critical appraisal-MP-2023.pptx
Critical appraisal-MP-2023.pptxCritical appraisal-MP-2023.pptx
Critical appraisal-MP-2023.pptx
AMANUELMELAKU5
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...
How to Craft the "Significance” & "Innovation" Sections of a Grant Applicatio...
UCLA CTSI
Presentation how to write a research protocol
Presentation how to write a research protocolPresentation how to write a research protocol
Presentation how to write a research protocol
Sushma Sharma
How to ace Phd/Doctoral final oral defense or viva voce'
How to ace Phd/Doctoral final oral defense or viva voce'How to ace Phd/Doctoral final oral defense or viva voce'
How to ace Phd/Doctoral final oral defense or viva voce'
DoctoralNet Limited
Research method ch04 research topic and design
Research method ch04 research topic and designResearch method ch04 research topic and design
Research method ch04 research topic and design
naranbatn
Surviving Your Viva or Dissertation Defense
Surviving Your Viva or Dissertation DefenseSurviving Your Viva or Dissertation Defense
Surviving Your Viva or Dissertation Defense
DoctoralNet Limited
Research Question and Hypothesis
Research Question and HypothesisResearch Question and Hypothesis
Research Question and Hypothesis
Arvind Kushwaha
Week 10 writing research proposal
Week 10  writing research proposalWeek 10  writing research proposal
Week 10 writing research proposal
wawaaa789

More from UCLA CTSI (20)

Considerations in Applying for a K99 Award: the NIH "Pathway to Independence"...
Considerations in Applying for a K99 Award: the NIH "Pathway to Independence"...Considerations in Applying for a K99 Award: the NIH "Pathway to Independence"...
Considerations in Applying for a K99 Award: the NIH "Pathway to Independence"...
UCLA CTSI
Navigating the NIH K Award Process: Choosing Your Mentorship Team
Navigating the NIH K Award Process: Choosing Your Mentorship TeamNavigating the NIH K Award Process: Choosing Your Mentorship Team
Navigating the NIH K Award Process: Choosing Your Mentorship Team
UCLA CTSI
K Awards – Common Pitfalls and UCLA CTSI KL2 Resources
K Awards – Common Pitfalls and UCLA CTSI KL2 ResourcesK Awards – Common Pitfalls and UCLA CTSI KL2 Resources
K Awards – Common Pitfalls and UCLA CTSI KL2 Resources
UCLA CTSI
What Next: When You are not Funded on the First Round - 2023
What Next: When You are not Funded on the First Round - 2023What Next: When You are not Funded on the First Round - 2023
What Next: When You are not Funded on the First Round - 2023
UCLA CTSI
How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section - 2023
How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section - 2023How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section - 2023
How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section - 2023
UCLA CTSI
A Tactical Approach to Writing Your Grant Application (HSR) - 2023
A Tactical Approach to Writing Your Grant Application (HSR) - 2023A Tactical Approach to Writing Your Grant Application (HSR) - 2023
A Tactical Approach to Writing Your Grant Application (HSR) - 2023
UCLA CTSI
A Tactical Approach to Writing Your Grant Application - 2023
A Tactical Approach to Writing Your Grant Application - 2023A Tactical Approach to Writing Your Grant Application - 2023
A Tactical Approach to Writing Your Grant Application - 2023
UCLA CTSI
How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section of a Grant Application (Basic Scienc...
How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section of a Grant Application (Basic Scienc...How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section of a Grant Application (Basic Scienc...
How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section of a Grant Application (Basic Scienc...
UCLA CTSI
How to Anticipate and Plan for an R Grant Application - 2023
How to Anticipate and Plan for an R Grant Application - 2023How to Anticipate and Plan for an R Grant Application - 2023
How to Anticipate and Plan for an R Grant Application - 2023
UCLA CTSI
NIH Loan Repayment Program (LRP) Info Session - 9/26/23
NIH Loan Repayment Program (LRP) Info Session - 9/26/23NIH Loan Repayment Program (LRP) Info Session - 9/26/23
NIH Loan Repayment Program (LRP) Info Session - 9/26/23
UCLA CTSI
Writing the NIH K Award – Research Plan
Writing the NIH K Award – Research PlanWriting the NIH K Award – Research Plan
Writing the NIH K Award – Research Plan
UCLA CTSI
Considerations in Applying for a K99 Award: the NIH "Pathway to Independence"...
Considerations in Applying for a K99 Award: the NIH "Pathway to Independence"...Considerations in Applying for a K99 Award: the NIH "Pathway to Independence"...
Considerations in Applying for a K99 Award: the NIH "Pathway to Independence"...
UCLA CTSI
Navigating the NIH K Award Process and Choosing Your Mentorship Team (2023)
Navigating the NIH K Award Process  and Choosing Your Mentorship Team (2023)Navigating the NIH K Award Process  and Choosing Your Mentorship Team (2023)
Navigating the NIH K Award Process and Choosing Your Mentorship Team (2023)
UCLA CTSI
K Awards – Common Pitfalls and UCLA CTSI KL2 Resources (2023)
K Awards – Common Pitfalls and UCLA CTSI KL2 Resources (2023)K Awards – Common Pitfalls and UCLA CTSI KL2 Resources (2023)
K Awards – Common Pitfalls and UCLA CTSI KL2 Resources (2023)
UCLA CTSI
Writing the NIH K Award – Candidate Information and Career Development Plan, ...
Writing the NIH K Award – Candidate Information and Career Development Plan, ...Writing the NIH K Award – Candidate Information and Career Development Plan, ...
Writing the NIH K Award – Candidate Information and Career Development Plan, ...
UCLA CTSI
How to Anticipate and Plan for an R Grant Application. (2022)
How to Anticipate and Plan for an R Grant Application. (2022)How to Anticipate and Plan for an R Grant Application. (2022)
How to Anticipate and Plan for an R Grant Application. (2022)
UCLA CTSI
A Tactical Approach to Writing Your Grant Application. (Moin, 2022)
A Tactical Approach to Writing Your Grant Application. (Moin, 2022)A Tactical Approach to Writing Your Grant Application. (Moin, 2022)
A Tactical Approach to Writing Your Grant Application. (Moin, 2022)
UCLA CTSI
How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section of a Grant Application. (Moin, 2022)
How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section of a Grant Application. (Moin, 2022)How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section of a Grant Application. (Moin, 2022)
How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section of a Grant Application. (Moin, 2022)
UCLA CTSI
K99 Award: the NIH "Pathway to Independence"
K99 Award: the NIH "Pathway to Independence"K99 Award: the NIH "Pathway to Independence"
K99 Award: the NIH "Pathway to Independence"
UCLA CTSI
Navigating the NIH K Award Process - Carol Mangione, MD, MSPH (2022)
Navigating the NIH K Award Process - Carol Mangione, MD, MSPH (2022)Navigating the NIH K Award Process - Carol Mangione, MD, MSPH (2022)
Navigating the NIH K Award Process - Carol Mangione, MD, MSPH (2022)
UCLA CTSI
Considerations in Applying for a K99 Award: the NIH "Pathway to Independence"...
Considerations in Applying for a K99 Award: the NIH "Pathway to Independence"...Considerations in Applying for a K99 Award: the NIH "Pathway to Independence"...
Considerations in Applying for a K99 Award: the NIH "Pathway to Independence"...
UCLA CTSI
Navigating the NIH K Award Process: Choosing Your Mentorship Team
Navigating the NIH K Award Process: Choosing Your Mentorship TeamNavigating the NIH K Award Process: Choosing Your Mentorship Team
Navigating the NIH K Award Process: Choosing Your Mentorship Team
UCLA CTSI
K Awards – Common Pitfalls and UCLA CTSI KL2 Resources
K Awards – Common Pitfalls and UCLA CTSI KL2 ResourcesK Awards – Common Pitfalls and UCLA CTSI KL2 Resources
K Awards – Common Pitfalls and UCLA CTSI KL2 Resources
UCLA CTSI
What Next: When You are not Funded on the First Round - 2023
What Next: When You are not Funded on the First Round - 2023What Next: When You are not Funded on the First Round - 2023
What Next: When You are not Funded on the First Round - 2023
UCLA CTSI
How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section - 2023
How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section - 2023How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section - 2023
How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section - 2023
UCLA CTSI
A Tactical Approach to Writing Your Grant Application (HSR) - 2023
A Tactical Approach to Writing Your Grant Application (HSR) - 2023A Tactical Approach to Writing Your Grant Application (HSR) - 2023
A Tactical Approach to Writing Your Grant Application (HSR) - 2023
UCLA CTSI
A Tactical Approach to Writing Your Grant Application - 2023
A Tactical Approach to Writing Your Grant Application - 2023A Tactical Approach to Writing Your Grant Application - 2023
A Tactical Approach to Writing Your Grant Application - 2023
UCLA CTSI
How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section of a Grant Application (Basic Scienc...
How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section of a Grant Application (Basic Scienc...How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section of a Grant Application (Basic Scienc...
How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section of a Grant Application (Basic Scienc...
UCLA CTSI
How to Anticipate and Plan for an R Grant Application - 2023
How to Anticipate and Plan for an R Grant Application - 2023How to Anticipate and Plan for an R Grant Application - 2023
How to Anticipate and Plan for an R Grant Application - 2023
UCLA CTSI
NIH Loan Repayment Program (LRP) Info Session - 9/26/23
NIH Loan Repayment Program (LRP) Info Session - 9/26/23NIH Loan Repayment Program (LRP) Info Session - 9/26/23
NIH Loan Repayment Program (LRP) Info Session - 9/26/23
UCLA CTSI
Writing the NIH K Award – Research Plan
Writing the NIH K Award – Research PlanWriting the NIH K Award – Research Plan
Writing the NIH K Award – Research Plan
UCLA CTSI
Considerations in Applying for a K99 Award: the NIH "Pathway to Independence"...
Considerations in Applying for a K99 Award: the NIH "Pathway to Independence"...Considerations in Applying for a K99 Award: the NIH "Pathway to Independence"...
Considerations in Applying for a K99 Award: the NIH "Pathway to Independence"...
UCLA CTSI
Navigating the NIH K Award Process and Choosing Your Mentorship Team (2023)
Navigating the NIH K Award Process  and Choosing Your Mentorship Team (2023)Navigating the NIH K Award Process  and Choosing Your Mentorship Team (2023)
Navigating the NIH K Award Process and Choosing Your Mentorship Team (2023)
UCLA CTSI
K Awards – Common Pitfalls and UCLA CTSI KL2 Resources (2023)
K Awards – Common Pitfalls and UCLA CTSI KL2 Resources (2023)K Awards – Common Pitfalls and UCLA CTSI KL2 Resources (2023)
K Awards – Common Pitfalls and UCLA CTSI KL2 Resources (2023)
UCLA CTSI
Writing the NIH K Award – Candidate Information and Career Development Plan, ...
Writing the NIH K Award – Candidate Information and Career Development Plan, ...Writing the NIH K Award – Candidate Information and Career Development Plan, ...
Writing the NIH K Award – Candidate Information and Career Development Plan, ...
UCLA CTSI
How to Anticipate and Plan for an R Grant Application. (2022)
How to Anticipate and Plan for an R Grant Application. (2022)How to Anticipate and Plan for an R Grant Application. (2022)
How to Anticipate and Plan for an R Grant Application. (2022)
UCLA CTSI
A Tactical Approach to Writing Your Grant Application. (Moin, 2022)
A Tactical Approach to Writing Your Grant Application. (Moin, 2022)A Tactical Approach to Writing Your Grant Application. (Moin, 2022)
A Tactical Approach to Writing Your Grant Application. (Moin, 2022)
UCLA CTSI
How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section of a Grant Application. (Moin, 2022)
How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section of a Grant Application. (Moin, 2022)How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section of a Grant Application. (Moin, 2022)
How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section of a Grant Application. (Moin, 2022)
UCLA CTSI
K99 Award: the NIH "Pathway to Independence"
K99 Award: the NIH "Pathway to Independence"K99 Award: the NIH "Pathway to Independence"
K99 Award: the NIH "Pathway to Independence"
UCLA CTSI
Navigating the NIH K Award Process - Carol Mangione, MD, MSPH (2022)
Navigating the NIH K Award Process - Carol Mangione, MD, MSPH (2022)Navigating the NIH K Award Process - Carol Mangione, MD, MSPH (2022)
Navigating the NIH K Award Process - Carol Mangione, MD, MSPH (2022)
UCLA CTSI

Recently uploaded (20)

Rass MELAI : an Internet MELA Quiz Finals - El Dorado 2025
Rass MELAI : an Internet MELA Quiz Finals - El Dorado 2025Rass MELAI : an Internet MELA Quiz Finals - El Dorado 2025
Rass MELAI : an Internet MELA Quiz Finals - El Dorado 2025
Conquiztadors- the Quiz Society of Sri Venkateswara College
Research & Research Methods: Basic Concepts and Types.pptx
Research & Research Methods: Basic Concepts and Types.pptxResearch & Research Methods: Basic Concepts and Types.pptx
Research & Research Methods: Basic Concepts and Types.pptx
Dr. Sarita Anand
Rass MELAI : an Internet MELA Quiz Prelims - El Dorado 2025
Rass MELAI : an Internet MELA Quiz Prelims - El Dorado 2025Rass MELAI : an Internet MELA Quiz Prelims - El Dorado 2025
Rass MELAI : an Internet MELA Quiz Prelims - El Dorado 2025
Conquiztadors- the Quiz Society of Sri Venkateswara College
APM People Interest Network Conference - Oliver Randall & David Bovis - Own Y...
APM People Interest Network Conference - Oliver Randall & David Bovis - Own Y...APM People Interest Network Conference - Oliver Randall & David Bovis - Own Y...
APM People Interest Network Conference - Oliver Randall & David Bovis - Own Y...
Association for Project Management
Blind Spots in AI and Formulation Science Knowledge Pyramid (Updated Perspect...
Blind Spots in AI and Formulation Science Knowledge Pyramid (Updated Perspect...Blind Spots in AI and Formulation Science Knowledge Pyramid (Updated Perspect...
Blind Spots in AI and Formulation Science Knowledge Pyramid (Updated Perspect...
Ajaz Hussain
Blind spots in AI and Formulation Science, IFPAC 2025.pdf
Blind spots in AI and Formulation Science, IFPAC 2025.pdfBlind spots in AI and Formulation Science, IFPAC 2025.pdf
Blind spots in AI and Formulation Science, IFPAC 2025.pdf
Ajaz Hussain
Kaun TALHA quiz Finals -- El Dorado 2025
Kaun TALHA quiz Finals -- El Dorado 2025Kaun TALHA quiz Finals -- El Dorado 2025
Kaun TALHA quiz Finals -- El Dorado 2025
Conquiztadors- the Quiz Society of Sri Venkateswara College
QuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online How to Make the Move
QuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online  How to Make the MoveQuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online  How to Make the Move
QuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online How to Make the Move
TechSoup
CRITICAL THINKING AND NURSING JUDGEMENT.pptx
CRITICAL THINKING AND NURSING JUDGEMENT.pptxCRITICAL THINKING AND NURSING JUDGEMENT.pptx
CRITICAL THINKING AND NURSING JUDGEMENT.pptx
PoojaSen20
Modeling-Simple-Equation-Using-Bar-Models.pptx
Modeling-Simple-Equation-Using-Bar-Models.pptxModeling-Simple-Equation-Using-Bar-Models.pptx
Modeling-Simple-Equation-Using-Bar-Models.pptx
maribethlacno2
Lesson Plan M1 2024 Lesson Plan M1 2024 Lesson Plan M1 2024 Lesson Plan M1...
Lesson Plan M1 2024  Lesson Plan M1 2024  Lesson Plan M1 2024  Lesson Plan M1...Lesson Plan M1 2024  Lesson Plan M1 2024  Lesson Plan M1 2024  Lesson Plan M1...
Lesson Plan M1 2024 Lesson Plan M1 2024 Lesson Plan M1 2024 Lesson Plan M1...
pinkdvil200
How to Configure Restaurants in Odoo 17 Point of Sale
How to Configure Restaurants in Odoo 17 Point of SaleHow to Configure Restaurants in Odoo 17 Point of Sale
How to Configure Restaurants in Odoo 17 Point of Sale
Celine George
How to use Init Hooks in Odoo 18 - Odoo ݺߣs
How to use Init Hooks in Odoo 18 - Odoo ݺߣsHow to use Init Hooks in Odoo 18 - Odoo ݺߣs
How to use Init Hooks in Odoo 18 - Odoo ݺߣs
Celine George
Kaun TALHA quiz Prelims - El Dorado 2025
Kaun TALHA quiz Prelims - El Dorado 2025Kaun TALHA quiz Prelims - El Dorado 2025
Kaun TALHA quiz Prelims - El Dorado 2025
Conquiztadors- the Quiz Society of Sri Venkateswara College
TRANSFER OF PATIENTS IN HOSPITAL SETTING.pptx
TRANSFER OF PATIENTS IN HOSPITAL SETTING.pptxTRANSFER OF PATIENTS IN HOSPITAL SETTING.pptx
TRANSFER OF PATIENTS IN HOSPITAL SETTING.pptx
PoojaSen20
TPR Data strategy 2025 (1).pdf Data strategy
TPR Data strategy 2025 (1).pdf Data strategyTPR Data strategy 2025 (1).pdf Data strategy
TPR Data strategy 2025 (1).pdf Data strategy
Henry Tapper
Adventure Activities Final By H R Gohil Sir
Adventure Activities Final By H R Gohil SirAdventure Activities Final By H R Gohil Sir
Adventure Activities Final By H R Gohil Sir
GUJARATCOMMERCECOLLE
How to Setup WhatsApp in Odoo 17 - Odoo ݺߣs
How to Setup WhatsApp in Odoo 17 - Odoo ݺߣsHow to Setup WhatsApp in Odoo 17 - Odoo ݺߣs
How to Setup WhatsApp in Odoo 17 - Odoo ݺߣs
Celine George
A PPT on the First Three chapters of Wings of Fire
A PPT on the First Three chapters of Wings of FireA PPT on the First Three chapters of Wings of Fire
A PPT on the First Three chapters of Wings of Fire
Beena E S
A PPT Presentation on The Princess and the God: A tale of ancient India by A...
A PPT Presentation on The Princess and the God: A tale of ancient India  by A...A PPT Presentation on The Princess and the God: A tale of ancient India  by A...
A PPT Presentation on The Princess and the God: A tale of ancient India by A...
Beena E S
Research & Research Methods: Basic Concepts and Types.pptx
Research & Research Methods: Basic Concepts and Types.pptxResearch & Research Methods: Basic Concepts and Types.pptx
Research & Research Methods: Basic Concepts and Types.pptx
Dr. Sarita Anand
APM People Interest Network Conference - Oliver Randall & David Bovis - Own Y...
APM People Interest Network Conference - Oliver Randall & David Bovis - Own Y...APM People Interest Network Conference - Oliver Randall & David Bovis - Own Y...
APM People Interest Network Conference - Oliver Randall & David Bovis - Own Y...
Association for Project Management
Blind Spots in AI and Formulation Science Knowledge Pyramid (Updated Perspect...
Blind Spots in AI and Formulation Science Knowledge Pyramid (Updated Perspect...Blind Spots in AI and Formulation Science Knowledge Pyramid (Updated Perspect...
Blind Spots in AI and Formulation Science Knowledge Pyramid (Updated Perspect...
Ajaz Hussain
Blind spots in AI and Formulation Science, IFPAC 2025.pdf
Blind spots in AI and Formulation Science, IFPAC 2025.pdfBlind spots in AI and Formulation Science, IFPAC 2025.pdf
Blind spots in AI and Formulation Science, IFPAC 2025.pdf
Ajaz Hussain
QuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online How to Make the Move
QuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online  How to Make the MoveQuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online  How to Make the Move
QuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online How to Make the Move
TechSoup
CRITICAL THINKING AND NURSING JUDGEMENT.pptx
CRITICAL THINKING AND NURSING JUDGEMENT.pptxCRITICAL THINKING AND NURSING JUDGEMENT.pptx
CRITICAL THINKING AND NURSING JUDGEMENT.pptx
PoojaSen20
Modeling-Simple-Equation-Using-Bar-Models.pptx
Modeling-Simple-Equation-Using-Bar-Models.pptxModeling-Simple-Equation-Using-Bar-Models.pptx
Modeling-Simple-Equation-Using-Bar-Models.pptx
maribethlacno2
Lesson Plan M1 2024 Lesson Plan M1 2024 Lesson Plan M1 2024 Lesson Plan M1...
Lesson Plan M1 2024  Lesson Plan M1 2024  Lesson Plan M1 2024  Lesson Plan M1...Lesson Plan M1 2024  Lesson Plan M1 2024  Lesson Plan M1 2024  Lesson Plan M1...
Lesson Plan M1 2024 Lesson Plan M1 2024 Lesson Plan M1 2024 Lesson Plan M1...
pinkdvil200
How to Configure Restaurants in Odoo 17 Point of Sale
How to Configure Restaurants in Odoo 17 Point of SaleHow to Configure Restaurants in Odoo 17 Point of Sale
How to Configure Restaurants in Odoo 17 Point of Sale
Celine George
How to use Init Hooks in Odoo 18 - Odoo ݺߣs
How to use Init Hooks in Odoo 18 - Odoo ݺߣsHow to use Init Hooks in Odoo 18 - Odoo ݺߣs
How to use Init Hooks in Odoo 18 - Odoo ݺߣs
Celine George
TRANSFER OF PATIENTS IN HOSPITAL SETTING.pptx
TRANSFER OF PATIENTS IN HOSPITAL SETTING.pptxTRANSFER OF PATIENTS IN HOSPITAL SETTING.pptx
TRANSFER OF PATIENTS IN HOSPITAL SETTING.pptx
PoojaSen20
TPR Data strategy 2025 (1).pdf Data strategy
TPR Data strategy 2025 (1).pdf Data strategyTPR Data strategy 2025 (1).pdf Data strategy
TPR Data strategy 2025 (1).pdf Data strategy
Henry Tapper
Adventure Activities Final By H R Gohil Sir
Adventure Activities Final By H R Gohil SirAdventure Activities Final By H R Gohil Sir
Adventure Activities Final By H R Gohil Sir
GUJARATCOMMERCECOLLE
How to Setup WhatsApp in Odoo 17 - Odoo ݺߣs
How to Setup WhatsApp in Odoo 17 - Odoo ݺߣsHow to Setup WhatsApp in Odoo 17 - Odoo ݺߣs
How to Setup WhatsApp in Odoo 17 - Odoo ݺߣs
Celine George
A PPT on the First Three chapters of Wings of Fire
A PPT on the First Three chapters of Wings of FireA PPT on the First Three chapters of Wings of Fire
A PPT on the First Three chapters of Wings of Fire
Beena E S
A PPT Presentation on The Princess and the God: A tale of ancient India by A...
A PPT Presentation on The Princess and the God: A tale of ancient India  by A...A PPT Presentation on The Princess and the God: A tale of ancient India  by A...
A PPT Presentation on The Princess and the God: A tale of ancient India by A...
Beena E S

How to Structure the “Approach” Section (Basic Science)

  • 1. Approach (Basic Science) Scott G. Filler, M.D. Lundquist Institute for Biomedical Innovation at Harbor-UCLA Medical Center sfiller@ucla.edu
  • 2. Approach • Are the overall strategy, methodology, and analyses well- reasoned and appropriate to accomplish the specific aims of the project? • Have the investigators included plans to address weaknesses in the rigor of prior research that serves as the key support for the proposed project? • Have the investigators presented strategies to ensure a robust and unbiased approach, as appropriate for the work proposed?
  • 3. Approach • Are potential problems, alternative strategies, and benchmarks for success presented? • If the project is in the early stages of development, will the strategy establish feasibility and will particularly risky aspects be managed? • Have the investigators presented adequate plans to address relevant biological variables, such as sex, for studies in vertebrate animals or human subjects?
  • 4. Approach--Overall Layout • Preliminary data • Aim 1 o Rationale and overall approach o Experimental methods o Anticipated results o Alternative outcomes (potential pitfalls) o Future directions • Aim 2 o Rationale and overall approach o Experimental methods o Anticipated results o Alternative outcomes (potential pitfalls) o Future directions
  • 5. Approach--Alternate Layout • Aim 1 o Preliminary data o Rationale and overall approach o Experimental methods o Anticipated results o Alternative outcomes (potential pitfalls) o Future directions • Aim 2 o Preliminary data o Rationale and overall approach o Experimental methods o Anticipated results o Alternative outcomes (potential pitfalls) o Future directions
  • 6. Preliminary Data • Present compelling preliminary data o Supports premise of the work o Demonstrates feasibility o Sparks interest, but leaves reviewer wanting to learn more • Potential pitfalls in preliminary data o Clear weaknesses o No statistical analysis o Support alternative hypothesis
  • 7. Approach • Describe overall approach and the controls • Only mention key details • Need power calculations for animal studies o Many details of animal studies can be move to Vertebrate Animals section • Address sex as a biological variable
  • 8. Approach • Potential pitfalls o One aim depend on another * o Excessive detail • Detracts from overall message • Target for criticism o Densely written prose “If reading a grant gives the reviewer a headache, that grant is unlikely to receive a good score”
  • 9. Anticipated Results and Potential Pitfalls • What do you think the results will be? • Creativity and flexible thinking very important • Interesting alternative outcomes—make a bug into a feature
  • 10. Anticipated Results and Potential Pitfalls—Key Points • What will you do if hypothesis is not supported? • Never present a potential pitfall for which you don’t have a good solution • Don’t say, “The investigative team has substantial experience with this work and thus do not anticipate any technical problems.”
  • 11. Future Directions • Where is your research going? • What will be its impact? • How can the specific information learn be applied to a broader question?